Chapter LVI: The Saracens, The Franks And The Normans.—Part V. 第五十六章 萨拉森人、法兰克人与诺曼人——第五节

A prince of such a temper could not be satisfied with having repelled the insolence of a Barbarian. It was the right and duty, it might be the interest and glory, of Manuel to restore the ancient majesty of the empire, to recover the provinces of Italy and Sicily, and to chastise this pretended king, the grandson of a Norman vassal. 112 The natives of Calabria were still attached to the Greek language and worship, which had been inexorably proscribed by the Latin clergy: after the loss of her dukes, Apulia was chained as a servile appendage to the crown of Sicily; the founder of the monarchy had ruled by the sword; and his death had abated the fear, without healing the discontent, of his subjects: the feudal government was always pregnant with the seeds of rebellion; and a nephew of Roger himself invited the enemies of his family and nation. The majesty of the purple, and a series of Hungarian and Turkish wars, prevented Manuel from embarking his person in the Italian expedition. To the brave and noble Palaeologus, his lieutenant, the Greek monarch intrusted a fleet and army: the siege of Bari was his first exploit; and, in every operation, gold as well as steel was the instrument of victory. Salerno, and some places along the western coast, maintained their fidelity to the Norman king; but he lost in two campaigns the greater part of his continental possessions; and the modest emperor, disdaining all flattery and falsehood, was content with the reduction of three hundred cities or villages of Apulia and Calabria, whose names and titles were inscribed on all the walls of the palace. The prejudices of the Latins were gratified by a genuine or fictitious donation under the seal of the German Caesars; 113 but the successor of Constantine soon renounced this ignominious pretence, claimed the indefeasible dominion of Italy, and professed his design of chasing the Barbarians beyond the Alps. By the artful speeches, liberal gifts, and unbounded promises, of their Eastern ally, the free cities were encouraged to persevere in their generous struggle against the despotism of Frederic Barbarossa: the walls of Milan were rebuilt by the contributions of Manuel; and he poured, says the historian, a river of gold into the bosom of Ancona, whose attachment to the Greeks was fortified by the jealous enmity of the Venetians. 114 The situation and trade of Ancona rendered it an important garrison in the heart of Italy: it was twice besieged by the arms of Frederic; the imperial forces were twice repulsed by the spirit of freedom; that spirit was animated by the ambassador of Constantinople; and the most intrepid patriots, the most faithful servants, were rewarded by the wealth and honors of the Byzantine court. 115 The pride of Manuel disdained and rejected a Barbarian colleague; his ambition was excited by the hope of stripping the purple from the German usurpers, and of establishing, in the West, as in the East, his lawful title of sole emperor of the Romans. With this view, he solicited the alliance of the people and the bishop of Rome. Several of the nobles embraced the cause of the Greek monarch; the splendid nuptials of his niece with Odo Frangipani secured the support of that powerful family, 116 and his royal standard or image was entertained with due reverence in the ancient metropolis. 117 During the quarrel between Frederic and Alexander the Third, the pope twice received in the Vatican the ambassadors of Constantinople. They flattered his piety by the long-promised union of the two churches, tempted the avarice of his venal court, and exhorted the Roman pontiff to seize the just provocation, the favorable moment, to humble the savage insolence of the Alemanni and to acknowledge the true representative of Constantine and Augustus. 118
像曼努埃尔这样心性的君主,仅仅挫退一个蛮族的骄横,是断不会心满意足的。在他看来,重振帝国昔日的威严、收复意大利与西西里各行省、惩治这个自封为王、不过是诺曼封臣之孙的家伙,112既是他的权利与责任,或许也关乎他的利益与荣耀。卡拉布里亚的土著居民仍眷恋希腊的语言与礼拜,而这两者早已被拉丁教士无情地严加禁绝;阿普利亚自失去自己的诸公爵后,便被锁在西西里的王冠之下,充作卑屈的附庸;这个王国的开创者向以刀剑统御臣民,他一死,臣民的畏惧固然减了几分,心中的不满却丝毫未曾平复;封建的政体本就时时孕育着叛乱的种子,就连罗杰本人的一个侄儿,也出面招引他家族与民族的仇敌。帝王之尊,加上一连串对匈牙利人和土耳其人的战事,使曼努埃尔无法亲自出征意大利。希腊君主便把一支舰队和军队,托付给他麾下那位英勇而高贵的副帅帕莱奥洛戈斯;围攻巴里是他的首功,而在每一次军事行动中,制胜的凭借除了刀兵,还有黄金。萨莱诺以及西海岸的若干地方,仍效忠于诺曼国王;但两场战役下来,他在大陆上的领地已丧失大半。这位谦抑的皇帝不屑于一切阿谀与虚饰,只满足于将阿普利亚和卡拉布里亚的三百座城镇村庄收归治下,并把这些地方的名称与封号一一镌刻在王宫的四壁之上。一纸盖有日耳曼诸恺撒印玺的赠与文书——真伪且不论——满足了拉丁人的成见;113但这位君士坦丁的继承者不久便弃绝了这个可耻的借口,转而宣称自己对意大利拥有不可剥夺的主权,并公开申明要把蛮族逐往阿尔卑斯山以外。这位东方盟友巧言游说、慷慨馈赠,又许下无穷的允诺,鼓舞着各自由城邦坚持那场豪迈的斗争,去反抗腓特烈·巴巴罗萨的专制;米兰的城墙靠曼努埃尔的捐助得以重建;据史家记载,他还把黄金如江河般灌入安科纳的怀抱——而安科纳对希腊人的依附,又因威尼斯人出于猜忌的敌意而愈发牢固。114安科纳凭其地利与商贸,成为意大利腹心的一处军事重镇:腓特烈的军队曾两度围攻此城,皇帝的大军也两度为自由的精神所击退;而这份精神,正是君士坦丁堡的使臣所鼓动的;那些最无畏的爱国者、最忠诚的效力者,都得到拜占庭宫廷以财富与荣誉相酬。115曼努埃尔生性高傲,不屑与一个蛮族同列为帝,断然拒绝这样的并称;而激起他野心的,是这样一个指望:从日耳曼篡位者身上剥下那袭紫袍,好让自己“罗马人唯一皇帝”的合法名号,如在东方一般,也确立于西方。抱着这一图谋,他向罗马的人民和罗马主教寻求结盟。好几位贵族都投向了这位希腊君主的旗下;他的侄女与奥多·弗兰吉帕尼盛大联姻,为他赢得了那个豪门望族的支持,116而他的王旗(或王者画像)也在这座古老的都城中受到应有的礼敬。117在腓特烈与亚历山大三世交恶期间,教宗曾两度在梵蒂冈接见君士坦丁堡的使节。使节们以久已许诺的两教会合一之说,投合教宗的虔敬之心;又以财货挑动他那贪墨成风的教廷;并力劝这位罗马教宗抓住这一正当的由头、这一有利的时机,去挫一挫阿勒曼尼人的野蛮气焰,转而承认谁才是君士坦丁与奥古斯都的真正传人。118
But these Italian conquests, this universal reign, soon escaped from the hand of the Greek emperor. His first demands were eluded by the prudence of Alexander the Third, who paused on this deep and momentous revolution; 119 nor could the pope be seduced by a personal dispute to renounce the perpetual inheritance of the Latin name. After the reunion with Frederic, he spoke a more peremptory language, confirmed the acts of his predecessors, excommunicated the adherents of Manuel, and pronounced the final separation of the churches, or at least the empires, of Constantinople and Rome. 120 The free cities of Lombardy no longer remembered their foreign benefactor, and without preserving the friendship of Ancona, he soon incurred the enmity of Venice. 121 By his own avarice, or the complaints of his subjects, the Greek emperor was provoked to arrest the persons, and confiscate the effects, of the Venetian merchants. This violation of the public faith exasperated a free and commercial people: one hundred galleys were launched and armed in as many days; they swept the coasts of Dalmatia and Greece: but after some mutual wounds, the war was terminated by an agreement, inglorious to the empire, insufficient for the republic; and a complete vengeance of these and of fresh injuries was reserved for the succeeding generation. The lieutenant of Manuel had informed his sovereign that he was strong enough to quell any domestic revolt of Apulia and Calabria; but that his forces were inadequate to resist the impending attack of the king of Sicily. His prophecy was soon verified: the death of Palaeologus devolved the command on several chiefs, alike eminent in rank, alike defective in military talents; the Greeks were oppressed by land and sea; and a captive remnant that escaped the swords of the Normans and Saracens, abjured all future hostility against the person or dominions of their conqueror. 122 Yet the king of Sicily esteemed the courage and constancy of Manuel, who had landed a second army on the Italian shore; he respectfully addressed the new Justinian; solicited a peace or truce of thirty years, accepted as a gift the regal title; and acknowledged himself the military vassal of the Roman empire. 123 The Byzantine Caesars acquiesced in this shadow of dominion, without expecting, perhaps without desiring, the service of a Norman army; and the truce of thirty years was not disturbed by any hostilities between Sicily and Constantinople. About the end of that period, the throne of Manuel was usurped by an inhuman tyrant, who had deserved the abhorrence of his country and mankind: the sword of William the Second, the grandson of Roger, was drawn by a fugitive of the Comnenian race; and the subjects of Andronicus might salute the strangers as friends, since they detested their sovereign as the worst of enemies. The Latin historians 124 expatiate on the rapid progress of the four counts who invaded Romania with a fleet and army, and reduced many castles and cities to the obedience of the king of Sicily. The Greeks 125 accuse and magnify the wanton and sacrilegious cruelties that were perpetrated in the sack of Thessalonica, the second city of the empire. The former deplore the fate of those invincible but unsuspecting warriors who were destroyed by the arts of a vanquished foe. The latter applaud, in songs of triumph, the repeated victories of their countrymen on the Sea of Marmora or Propontis, on the banks of the Strymon, and under the walls of Durazzo. A revolution which punished the crimes of Andronicus, had united against the Franks the zeal and courage of the successful insurgents: ten thousand were slain in battle, and Isaac Angelus, the new emperor, might indulge his vanity or vengeance in the treatment of four thousand captives. Such was the event of the last contest between the Greeks and Normans: before the expiration of twenty years, the rival nations were lost or degraded in foreign servitude; and the successors of Constantine did not long survive to insult the fall of the Sicilian monarchy.
然而,这些在意大利取得的征服、这份普天下共主的威权,很快便从这位希腊皇帝手中溜走了。他最初的种种要求,亚历山大三世都谨慎地回避了;教宗对这样一场深远而重大的变局踌躇不前,119更不肯为了一桩私人的争执,就断送拉丁名号那份世代相承的基业。待到与腓特烈重归于好,教宗的口气便强硬了许多:他确认前任诸教宗的成命,将曼努埃尔的党羽逐出教门,并宣告君士坦丁堡与罗马两教会——至少是两帝国——从此彻底分道扬镳。120伦巴第的各自由城邦,早把这位异邦的恩主抛诸脑后;曼努埃尔既没能保住安科纳的情谊,不久又招来了威尼斯的仇视。121不知是出于自己的贪婪,还是听信了臣民的抱怨,这位希腊皇帝竟悍然下令逮捕威尼斯商人、抄没他们的财货。这般背弃公信之举,激怒了这个自由而重商的民族:百艘战船在百日之内相继下水、备齐兵甲,横扫达尔马提亚与希腊的沿海;然而双方各有折损之后,这场战争终以一纸和约收场——对帝国而言不甚光彩,对共和国而言又远不解恨;至于这笔旧账连同日后新添的仇怨,那彻底的报复,便留待下一代人去了结了。曼努埃尔的副帅早已禀报君主:以他的兵力,平定阿普利亚和卡拉布里亚境内任何叛乱都绰绰有余,可要抵挡西西里国王迫在眉睫的进攻,却力有不逮。他这番预言很快应验:帕莱奥洛戈斯一死,兵权便落到好几位将领手中,这些人品秩同样显赫,将才却同样欠缺;希腊人于是水陆两面俱受压制;侥幸逃过诺曼人和萨拉森人刀锋的残兵成了俘虏,只得立誓:从此再不与征服他们的人为敌,也不再侵犯其领土。122不过,西西里国王倒也敬重曼努埃尔的勇气与坚忍——后者已在意大利海岸登陆了第二支军队;国王恭敬地致书这位“当世查士丁尼”,请求缔结一份为期三十年的和约或休战,并把自己的王号当作一份恩赐领受,还自认是罗马帝国的军事封臣。123拜占庭的诸位恺撒对这种有名无实的宗主权也就默然受用,既不指望、或许也并不真想要一支诺曼军队来为自己效力;于是这三十年的休战期间,西西里与君士坦丁堡之间再无兵戈相扰。临近这段时期的末尾,曼努埃尔的皇位被一个残暴不仁的僭主篡夺,此人早已为自己的国人乃至全人类所憎恶;罗杰之孙威廉二世之所以拔剑而起,是受了科穆宁王室一名逃亡者的怂恿;而安德罗尼库斯的臣民,尽可把这些外来者当作朋友来迎接,因为他们早已把自己的君主视同最可恨的仇敌。拉丁史家们124详述了那四位伯爵如何势如破竹:他们率舰队和大军侵入罗马尼亚(时人对罗马帝国疆土的称呼),迫使众多城堡与城市俯首听命于西西里国王。希腊史家125则控诉并极力渲染塞萨洛尼卡——帝国的第二大城——陷落之际那些恣意妄为、亵渎神圣的暴行。前者痛惜那些所向无敌却疏于防备的勇士,竟为手下败将用诡计所歼灭;后者则以凯歌颂扬同胞屡屡奏捷——无论在马尔马拉海(即普罗庞提斯)之上、斯特里蒙河两岸,还是在都拉佐的城下。一场惩治了安德罗尼库斯罪行的革命,把起事得手者的热忱与勇气拧成一股,共同对付法兰克人:一万人阵亡疆场,而新皇帝伊萨克·安格洛斯,则大可在处置那四千名俘虏时,尽情满足自己的虚荣或报复之心。希腊人与诺曼人之间最后一场较量,结局便是如此:不到二十年,这两个昔日的对手便双双沦亡,或屈身于异族的奴役之下;而君士坦丁的后继者,也没能多活几年去讥笑西西里王国的覆灭。
The sceptre of Roger successively devolved to his son and grandson: they might be confounded under the name of William: they are strongly discriminated by the epithets of the bad and the good; but these epithets, which appear to describe the perfection of vice and virtue, cannot strictly be applied to either of the Norman princes. When he was roused to arms by danger and shame, the first William did not degenerate from the valor of his race; but his temper was slothful; his manners were dissolute; his passions headstrong and mischievous; and the monarch is responsible, not only for his personal vices, but for those of Majo, the great admiral, who abused the confidence, and conspired against the life, of his benefactor. From the Arabian conquest, Sicily had imbibed a deep tincture of Oriental manners; the despotism, the pomp, and even the harem, of a sultan; and a Christian people was oppressed and insulted by the ascendant of the eunuchs, who openly professed, or secretly cherished, the religion of Mahomet. An eloquent historian of the times 126 has delineated the misfortunes of his country: 127 the ambition and fall of the ungrateful Majo; the revolt and punishment of his assassins; the imprisonment and deliverance of the king himself; the private feuds that arose from the public confusion; and the various forms of calamity and discord which afflicted Palermo, the island, and the continent, during the reign of William the First, and the minority of his son. The youth, innocence, and beauty of William the Second, 128 endeared him to the nation: the factions were reconciled; the laws were revived; and from the manhood to the premature death of that amiable prince, Sicily enjoyed a short season of peace, justice, and happiness, whose value was enhanced by the remembrance of the past and the dread of futurity. The legitimate male posterity of Tancred of Hauteville was extinct in the person of the second William; but his aunt, the daughter of Roger, had married the most powerful prince of the age; and Henry the Sixth, the son of Frederic Barbarossa, descended from the Alps to claim the Imperial crown and the inheritance of his wife. Against the unanimous wish of a free people, this inheritance could only be acquired by arms; and I am pleased to transcribe the style and sense of the historian Falcandus, who writes at the moment, and on the spot, with the feelings of a patriot, and the prophetic eye of a statesman. “Constantia, the daughter of Sicily, nursed from her cradle in the pleasures and plenty, and educated in the arts and manners, of this fortunate isle, departed long since to enrich the Barbarians with our treasures, and now returns, with her savage allies, to contaminate the beauties of her venerable parent. Already I behold the swarms of angry Barbarians: our opulent cities, the places flourishing in a long peace, are shaken with fear, desolated by slaughter, consumed by rapine, and polluted by intemperance and lust. I see the massacre or captivity of our citizens, the rapes of our virgins and matrons. 129 In this extremity (he interrogates a friend) how must the Sicilians act? By the unanimous election of a king of valor and experience, Sicily and Calabria might yet be preserved; 130 for in the levity of the Apulians, ever eager for new revolutions, I can repose neither confidence nor hope. 131 Should Calabria be lost, the lofty towers, the numerous youth, and the naval strength, of Messina, 132 might guard the passage against a foreign invader. If the savage Germans coalesce with the pirates of Messina; if they destroy with fire the fruitful region, so often wasted by the fires of Mount Aetna, 133 what resource will be left for the interior parts of the island, these noble cities which should never be violated by the hostile footsteps of a Barbarian? 134 Catana has again been overwhelmed by an earthquake: the ancient virtue of Syracuse expires in poverty and solitude; 135 but Palermo is still crowned with a diadem, and her triple walls enclose the active multitudes of Christians and Saracens. If the two nations, under one king, can unite for their common safety, they may rush on the Barbarians with invincible arms. But if the Saracens, fatigued by a repetition of injuries, should now retire and rebel; if they should occupy the castles of the mountains and sea-coast, the unfortunate Christians, exposed to a double attack, and placed as it were between the hammer and the anvil, must resign themselves to hopeless and inevitable servitude.” 136 We must not forget, that a priest here prefers his country to his religion; and that the Moslems, whose alliance he seeks, were still numerous and powerful in the state of Sicily.
罗杰的王笏,先后传到他的儿子和孙子手中:二人同名为威廉,容易混为一谈;然而“恶”与“善”两个绰号,却把他们截然分开——只是这两个绰号,看似要形容恶之极与善之至,严格说来,却没有一个真正贴合这两位诺曼君主。每当危难与耻辱把他激上战场,第一位威廉倒也不曾辱没本族的勇武;无奈他生性怠惰,行止放荡,情欲又执拗而好肇祸;这位君主要担的罪责,不单是他一己的恶行,还包括大海军统帅马约的种种劣迹——马约辜负了恩主的信任,甚至图谋加害其性命。自阿拉伯人征服以来,西西里便深深沾染了东方的习气——苏丹式的专制、排场,乃至后宫;而一群宦官得势擅权,压迫并欺凌着这个基督徒的民族——这些宦官,有的公然信奉、有的暗中笃信穆罕默德的宗教。当时一位文采斐然的史家,126曾描摹过祖国的种种不幸:127忘恩负义的马约如何野心勃勃、又如何败亡;行刺他的凶手如何起事、又如何伏法;国王本人如何被囚、又如何获释;国中大乱之际滋生的种种私仇宿怨;以及威廉一世在位期间、及其子年幼当国之时,巴勒莫、西西里全岛乃至大陆各地所遭受的形形色色的灾祸与纷争。威廉二世128年少、纯真而俊美,深得举国的爱戴:各派系握手言和,法度重获伸张;从这位可亲君主成年,到他英年早逝,西西里享有了一段短暂的太平、公道与安乐——而这份安乐,又因回想往昔的苦难、忧惧来日的祸患,而愈显珍贵。欧特维尔的坦克雷德那一支合法的男嗣,到第二位威廉这里便断绝了;但他的姑母、罗杰的女儿,早已嫁给当世最强大的君主;于是腓特烈·巴巴罗萨之子亨利六世,翻越阿尔卑斯山南下,来索取那顶皇帝的冠冕,以及他妻子应得的那份继承。面对一个自由民族众口一词的反对,这份遗产便只能靠武力去攫取;在此,我很乐意把史家法尔坎杜斯的文辞与意旨照录下来——他身临其境、就在事发之时执笔,怀着爱国者的一腔赤忱,又有政治家那双预见未来的慧眼。“君士坦提娅是西西里之女,自摇篮时起便在这座福岛的安逸与丰饶中长养,又受它的技艺与风习熏陶;她早已远嫁而去,把我们的珍宝拿去充实蛮族,如今却带着她那些野蛮的盟友回来,要玷污她那可敬母亲的秀美。我仿佛已经望见成群结队、气势汹汹的蛮族:我们那些富庶的城邑、那些在长久太平中繁荣起来的地方,正因恐惧而战栗,遭屠戮而夷为废墟,被劫掠而蚕食殆尽,更为荒淫纵欲所玷污。我看见我们的市民惨遭屠戮或被掳为奴,处女与妇人横遭奸污。129(他向一位友人发问:)值此危急存亡之际,西西里人该当如何?若能同心推选一位勇武而老练的国王,西西里与卡拉布里亚或许尚可保全;130至于阿普利亚人,轻浮善变、一味热衷于生乱图新,我对他们既不能寄予信任,也不敢抱以指望。131万一卡拉布里亚失守,墨西拿凭其巍峨的塔楼、众多的青壮,以及海上的实力,132或还能扼守海道,抵御外来的入侵者。可万一那些凶蛮的日耳曼人与墨西拿的海盗沆瀣一气,万一他们纵火焚毁这片肥沃的土地——它本就屡遭埃特纳火山烈焰的荼毒——133那么,这岛屿的腹地,这些本不该遭蛮族铁蹄践踏的高贵城邑,134又还剩下什么可以凭恃的呢?卡塔纳再一次毁于地震;叙拉古昔日的英风,如今在贫困与孤寂中奄奄一息;135唯有巴勒莫仍头戴王冠,三重城垣之内,还拥聚着熙熙攘攘、生气勃勃的基督徒和萨拉森人。倘若这两个民族能在同一位国王麾下,为共同的安危而联手,便能以无坚不摧之势扑向蛮族。可万一萨拉森人不堪一再受辱,就此退避、揭竿而反;万一他们占据了山间与海岸的城堡,那么那些不幸的基督徒便将腹背受敌,恰如置身于铁锤与铁砧之间,只得听天由命,去承受那无可挽回、在劫难逃的奴役了。”136我们不可忘记:此处这位教士,把祖国看得重于自己的宗教;而他所要引为奥援的穆斯林,在西西里国中仍然人多势众。
The hopes, or at least the wishes, of Falcandus were at first gratified by the free and unanimous election of Tancred, the grandson of the first king, whose birth was illegitimate, but whose civil and military virtues shone without a blemish. During four years, the term of his life and reign, he stood in arms on the farthest verge of the Apulian frontier, against the powers of Germany; and the restitution of a royal captive, of Constantia herself, without injury or ransom, may appear to surpass the most liberal measure of policy or reason. After his decease, the kingdom of his widow and infant son fell without a struggle; and Henry pursued his victorious march from Capua to Palermo. The political balance of Italy was destroyed by his success; and if the pope and the free cities had consulted their obvious and real interest, they would have combined the powers of earth and heaven to prevent the dangerous union of the German empire with the kingdom of Sicily. But the subtle policy, for which the Vatican has so often been praised or arraigned, was on this occasion blind and inactive; and if it were true that Celestine the Third had kicked away the Imperial crown from the head of the prostrate Henry, 137 such an act of impotent pride could serve only to cancel an obligation and provoke an enemy. The Genoese, who enjoyed a beneficial trade and establishment in Sicily, listened to the promise of his boundless gratitude and speedy departure: 138 their fleet commanded the straits of Messina, and opened the harbor of Palermo; and the first act of his government was to abolish the privileges, and to seize the property, of these imprudent allies. The last hope of Falcandus was defeated by the discord of the Christians and Mahometans: they fought in the capital; several thousands of the latter were slain; but their surviving brethren fortified the mountains, and disturbed above thirty years the peace of the island. By the policy of Frederic the Second, sixty thousand Saracens were transplanted to Nocera in Apulia. In their wars against the Roman church, the emperor and his son Mainfroy were strengthened and disgraced by the service of the enemies of Christ; and this national colony maintained their religion and manners in the heart of Italy, till they were extirpated, at the end of the thirteenth century, by the zeal and revenge of the house of Anjou. 139 All the calamities which the prophetic orator had deplored were surpassed by the cruelty and avarice of the German conqueror. He violated the royal sepulchres, 1391 and explored the secret treasures of the palace, Palermo, and the whole kingdom: the pearls and jewels, however precious, might be easily removed; but one hundred and sixty horses were laden with the gold and silver of Sicily. 140 The young king, his mother and sisters, and the nobles of both sexes, were separately confined in the fortresses of the Alps; and, on the slightest rumor of rebellion, the captives were deprived of life, of their eyes, or of the hope of posterity. Constantia herself was touched with sympathy for the miseries of her country; and the heiress of the Norman line might struggle to check her despotic husband, and to save the patrimony of her new-born son, of an emperor so famous in the next age under the name of Frederic the Second. Ten years after this revolution, the French monarchs annexed to their crown the duchy of Normandy: the sceptre of her ancient dukes had been transmitted, by a granddaughter of William the Conqueror, to the house of Plantagenet; and the adventurous Normans, who had raised so many trophies in France, England, and Ireland, in Apulia, Sicily, and the East, were lost, either in victory or servitude, among the vanquished nations.
法尔坎杜斯的指望——至少是他的心愿——起初倒也如愿:众人自由而一致地推选了坦克雷德,即第一位国王之孙。此人虽属庶出,其文治武功却光彩照人、无可挑剔。在他为王、也是他余生的这四年里,始终披坚执锐,屹立在阿普利亚边境最远的一端,迎战日耳曼的大军;而他把一位落入囹圄的王家俘虏——正是君士坦提娅本人——毫发无伤地送还,且不取分文赎金;此举之宽宏,恐怕已超出任何权谋或情理所能有的最大限度。他一去世,遗孀与幼子的王国便不战而溃;亨利遂长驱直入,从卡普亚一路凯歌,直抵巴勒莫。他的得手,打破了意大利的政治均势;倘若教宗和各自由城邦当真顾及那显而易见的切身利害,本该动员天上人间的一切力量,去阻止日耳曼帝国与西西里王国这一危险的合并。然而,梵蒂冈那份屡屡令它或受褒扬、或遭责难的深谋远虑,这一回却既盲目又迟钝,毫无作为;即便塞莱斯廷三世当真曾一脚把皇冠从俯身跪伏的亨利头上踢开,137这种色厉内荏的傲慢之举,也只能一笔勾销一份恩义、平白招惹一个仇敌罢了。热那亚人在西西里享有获利丰厚的商贸与据点,听信了亨利那番话:许诺日后感恩不尽、且会尽快撤离;138于是他们的舰队为他控扼了墨西拿海峡,又打开了巴勒莫的港口;可他执政后的头一件事,便是取缔这些轻信盟友的种种特权,并夺占他们的财产。法尔坎杜斯最后的一线指望,也因基督徒与穆斯林的自相纷争而破灭:两派在都城中厮杀,穆斯林一方被杀数千;然而幸存的教众退守山中、据险自固,扰乱全岛的安宁达三十余年。后来腓特烈二世出于策略考量,把六万萨拉森人迁往阿普利亚的诺切拉。在与罗马教会交战之际,这位皇帝和他的儿子曼弗雷德,因役使这些基督之敌而兵力大增,却也因此蒙羞;而这个自成一族的聚居地,就在意大利腹心保持着自己的宗教与习俗,直到十三世纪末,才被安茹王室以宗教的狂热和复仇的怒火斩草除根。139那位有先见之明的雄辩家所痛陈的种种灾祸,比起这位日耳曼征服者的残暴与贪婪,竟还是有所不及。他掘开王家的陵寝,1391搜刮王宫、巴勒莫乃至整个王国秘藏的财宝:珍珠宝石纵然贵重,倒还便于搬运;单是西西里的金银,就用了一百六十匹马来驮运。140那位年幼的国王,连同他的母亲、姐妹,以及男女贵族,都被分别囚禁在阿尔卑斯山的各处城堡里;稍有叛乱的风声,这些囚徒便或被夺去性命,或被剜去双眼,或被断绝后嗣之望。连君士坦提娅本人,也为祖国的苦难所动,心生怜悯;这位诺曼王系的女继承人,或曾力图约束她那专横的丈夫,好为自己刚出生的儿子保住那份世袭的基业——这孩子,便是下一个时代以“腓特烈二世”之名声名显赫的那位皇帝。这场变局十年之后,法国的君主把诺曼底公国并入了自己的王冠之下;诺曼底历代古老公爵的权柄,早已由征服者威廉的一位孙女之手,传到了金雀花王朝;而那些勇于冒险的诺曼人,曾在法兰西、英格兰、爱尔兰,又在阿普利亚、西西里以及东方竖起无数丰碑,最终却或在胜利之中、或在奴役之下,湮没消融于他们所征服的各民族之间了。

Notes 注释

112
For the invasion of Italy, which is almost overlooked by Nicetas see the more polite history of Cinnamus, (l. iv. c. 1-15, p. 78-101,) who introduces a diffuse narrative by a lofty profession, iii. 5.
关于这场对意大利的入侵,尼基塔斯几乎略而不提;欲知其详,可参看钦纳穆斯那部文笔较为雅致的史书(第四卷第1—15章,第78—101页)——他以一番冠冕堂皇的自诩,引出了一段冗长的叙述(见第三卷第5章)。
113
The Latin, Otho, (de Gestis Frederici I. l. ii. c. 30, p. 734,) attests the forgery; the Greek, Cinnamus, (l. iv. c. 1, p. 78,) claims a promise of restitution from Conrad and Frederic. An act of fraud is always credible when it is told of the Greeks.
拉丁史家奥托(《腓特烈一世事迹》de Gestis Frederici I. 第二卷第30章,第734页)证实此系伪造;希腊史家钦纳穆斯(第四卷第1章,第78页)则声称康拉德和腓特烈曾许诺归还。凡是关于希腊人的诈伪之说,人们向来总是深信不疑的。
114
Quod Ancontiani Graecum imperium nimis diligerent ... Veneti speciali odio Anconam oderunt. The cause of love, perhaps of envy, were the beneficia, flumen aureum of the emperor; and the Latin narrative is confirmed by Cinnamus, (l. iv. c. 14, p. 98.)
Quod Ancontiani Graecum imperium nimis diligerent ... Veneti speciali odio Anconam oderunt.(大意:安科纳人对希腊帝国过于亲昵爱戴……威尼斯人则怀着特别的仇恨憎恶安科纳。)这份爱意——或许还夹着几分嫉妒——的缘由,正是皇帝的种种恩惠,那“黄金之河”(flumen aureum);而这段拉丁记载又得到钦纳穆斯的印证(第四卷第14章,第98页)。
115
Muratori mentions the two sieges of Ancona; the first, in 1167, against Frederic I. in person (Annali, tom. x. p. 39, &c.;) the second, in 1173, against his lieutenant Christian, archbishop of Mentz, a man unworthy of his name and office, (p. 76, &c.) It is of the second siege that we possess an original narrative, which he has published in his great collection, (tom. vi. p. 921-946.)
穆拉托里提到安科纳曾两度被围:头一次在1167年,对手是御驾亲征的腓特烈一世(《意大利编年史》Annali 第十卷第39页等);第二次在1173年,对手是他的副帅、美因茨大主教克里斯蒂安——此人有负其名号与圣职(第76页等)。我们如今所拥有的一份原始记述,正是关于这第二次围城的;穆拉托里已把它收入他那部宏富的汇编(第六卷第921—946页)。
116
We derive this anecdote from an anonymous chronicle of Fossa Nova, published by Muratori, (Script. Ital. tom. vii. p. 874.)
这则轶事,我们取自一部佚名的福萨诺瓦《编年史》,由穆拉托里刊布(《意大利史料集成》Script. Ital. 第七卷第874页)。
117
Cinnamus (l. iv. c. 14, p. 99) is susceptible of this double sense. A standard is more Latin, an image more Greek.
钦纳穆斯的措辞(第四卷第14章,第99页)可作这样两种解释:若指旗帜,则更合拉丁人的习惯;若指画像,则更合希腊人的做派。
118
Nihilominus quoque petebat, ut quia occasio justa et tempos opportunum et acceptabile se obtulerant, Romani corona imperii a sancto apostolo sibi redderetur; quoniam non ad Frederici Alemanni, sed ad suum jus asseruit pertinere, (Vit. Alexandri III. a Cardinal. Arragoniae, in Script. Rerum Ital. tom. iii. par. i. p. 458.) His second embassy was accompanied cum immensa multitudine pecuniarum.
Nihilominus quoque petebat, ut quia occasio justa et tempos opportunum et acceptabile se obtulerant, Romani corona imperii a sancto apostolo sibi redderetur; quoniam non ad Frederici Alemanni, sed ad suum jus asseruit pertinere.(大意:他还进而请求:既然正当的机缘、有利而恰当的时机已然呈现,就该由圣使徒把罗马帝国的皇冠归还于他;因为他申明,这皇冠的权利不属于日耳曼人腓特烈,而属于他自己。)(《亚历山大三世传》Vit. Alexandri III.,出自阿拉贡枢机之手,见《意大利史料集成》第三卷第一分册第458页。)他的第二次遣使,还“带着数目庞大的钱财”(cum immensa multitudine pecuniarum)同行。
119
Nimis alta et perplexa sunt, (Vit. Alexandri III. p. 460, 461,) says the cautious pope.
“兹事体大,错综难解”(Nimis alta et perplexa sunt)——这位谨慎的教宗如是说(《亚历山大三世传》第460、461页)。
120
(Cinnamus, l. iv. c. 14, p. 99.)
(钦纳穆斯,第四卷第14章,第99页。)
121
In his vith book, Cinnamus describes the Venetian war, which Nicetas has not thought worthy of his attention. The Italian accounts, which do not satisfy our curiosity, are reported by the annalist Muratori, under the years 1171, &c.
钦纳穆斯在其著作第六卷中记述了这场对威尼斯的战争,尼基塔斯却不屑一顾。至于意大利方面的记载,虽不足以满足我们的好奇,编年史家穆拉托里已系于1171年等条目之下加以载录。
122
This victory is mentioned by Romuald of Salerno, (in Muratori, Script. Ital. tom. vii. p. 198.) It is whimsical enough, that in the praise of the king of Sicily, Cinnamus (l. iv. c. 13, p. 97, 98) is much warmer and copious than Falcandus, (p. 268, 270.) But the Greek is fond of description, and the Latin historian is not fond of William the Bad.
萨莱诺的罗慕阿尔德提到过这场胜利(见穆拉托里《意大利史料集成》第七卷第198页)。说来颇为可笑:在颂扬西西里国王一事上,钦纳穆斯(第四卷第13章,第97、98页)竟比法尔坎杜斯(第268、270页)还要热忱、还要不惜笔墨。不过话说回来,希腊人本就喜好铺陈描摹,而这位拉丁史家又向来不喜欢恶人威廉。
123
For the epistle of William I. see Cinnamus (l. iv. c. 15, p. 101, 102) and Nicetas, (l. ii. c. 8.) It is difficult to affirm, whether these Greeks deceived themselves, or the public, in these flattering portraits of the grandeur of the empire.
威廉一世的这封书信,可参看钦纳穆斯(第四卷第15章,第101、102页)和尼基塔斯(第二卷第8章)。这些希腊人对帝国之煊赫大加溢美,究竟是自欺,还是欺人,实在难下定论。
124
I can only quote, of original evidence, the poor chronicles of Sicard of Cremona, (p. 603,) and of Fossa Nova, (p. 875,) as they are published in the viith tome of Muratori’s historians. The king of Sicily sent his troops contra nequitiam Andronici.... ad acquirendum imperium C. P. They were.... decepti captique, by Isaac.
说到原始证据,我所能援引的,不过是克雷莫纳的西卡尔(第603页)和福萨诺瓦(第875页)那两部粗陋的《编年史》,均见穆拉托里所辑史家丛书第七卷。西西里国王派出军队,“去讨伐安德罗尼库斯的暴虐”(contra nequitiam Andronici)……“以夺取君士坦丁堡的帝位”(ad acquirendum imperium C. P.)。结果他们却被伊萨克“诱骗并俘获”(decepti captique)。
125
By the failure of Cinnamus to Nicetas (in Andronico, l.. c. 7, 8, 9, l. ii. c. 1, in Isaac Angelo, l. i. c. 1-4,) who now becomes a respectable contemporary. As he survived the emperor and the empire, he is above flattery; but the fall of Constantinople exasperated his prejudices against the Latins. For the honor of learning I shall observe that Homer’s great commentator, Eustathias archbishop of Thessalonica, refused to desert his flock.
钦纳穆斯的记载中断之后,便要转看尼基塔斯(《安德罗尼库斯传》第7、8、9章,第二卷第1章;《伊萨克·安格洛斯传》第一卷第1—4章);此人此时已成为一位值得敬重的当代见证者。由于他比皇帝和帝国都活得更久,故其笔下无须谄媚;只是君士坦丁堡的陷落,加深了他对拉丁人的成见。为学术界的荣誉计,我要特别指出:荷马那位了不起的注疏家、塞萨洛尼卡大主教欧斯塔提乌斯,曾拒绝弃自己的羊群于不顾。
126
The Historia Sicula of Hugo Falcandus, which properly extends from 1154 to 1169, is inserted in the viiith volume of Muratori’s Collection, (tom. vii. p. 259-344,) and preceded by a eloquent preface or epistle, (p. 251-258, de Calamitatibus Siciliae.) Falcandus has been styled the Tacitus of Sicily; and, after a just, but immense, abatement, from the ist to the xiith century, from a senator to a monk, I would not strip him of his title: his narrative is rapid and perspicuous, his style bold and elegant, his observation keen; he had studied mankind, and feels like a man. I can only regret the narrow and barren field on which his labors have been cast.
胡果·法尔坎杜斯的《西西里史》(Historia Sicula)严格说来所述始于1154年、止于1169年,收入穆拉托里汇编第八卷(第七卷第259—344页),卷首冠有一篇文采斐然的序言或书信(第251—258页,题为《论西西里的灾难》de Calamitatibus Siciliae)。法尔坎杜斯素有“西西里的塔西佗”之誉;诚然,从一世纪到十二世纪、从元老院议员到修道士,这中间要作一番公允而巨大的折扣,但即便如此,我也不忍剥夺他这一称号:他叙事明快晓畅,文笔遒劲雅致,观察锐利入微;他阅尽世情人事,感受一如常人。我唯一惋惜的,是他一身才力所施展的天地,未免过于狭小而贫瘠。
127
The laborious Benedictines (l’Art de verifier les Dates, p. 896) are of opinion, that the true name of Falcandus is Fulcandus, or Foucault. According to them, Hugues Foucalt, a Frenchman by birth, and at length abbot of St. Denys, had followed into Sicily his patron Stephen de la Perche, uncle to the mother of William II., archbishop of Palermo, and great chancellor of the kingdom. Yet Falcandus has all the feelings of a Sicilian; and the title of Alumnus (which he bestows on himself) appears to indicate that he was born, or at least educated, in the island.
勤勉的本笃会士们(《核定纪年之法》l'Art de verifier les Dates,第896页)认为,法尔坎杜斯(Falcandus)的真名其实是富尔坎杜斯(Fulcandus),或作富科(Foucault)。据他们说,于格·富科(Hugues Foucalt)本是法兰西人,后来官至圣但尼修道院院长;他曾追随其恩主斯蒂芬·德拉佩尔什(Stephen de la Perche)来到西西里——此人是威廉二世之母的舅父,官居巴勒莫大主教兼王国大掌玺官。然而法尔坎杜斯通篇流露的,全然是一个西西里人的情怀;而他自封的“阿卢姆努斯”(Alumnus,意即土生子弟)这一称号,似乎表明他即便不是生于此岛,至少也是在此岛受的教养。
128
Falcand. p. 303. Richard de St. Germano begins his history from the death and praises of William II. After some unmeaning epithets, he thus continues: Legis et justitiae cultus tempore suo vigebat in regno; sua erat quilibet sorte contentus; (were they mortals?) abique pax, ubique securitas, nec latronum metuebat viator insidias, nec maris nauta offendicula piratarum, (Script. Rerum Ital. tom. vii p 939.)
法尔坎杜斯,第303页。圣杰尔马诺的理查,其史书正是从威廉二世的去世与颂词写起。他先用了几句空泛的溢美之词,接着写道:Legis et justitiae cultus tempore suo vigebat in regno; sua erat quilibet sorte contentus;(大意:他在位之时,国中崇法尚义,蔚然成风;人人各安其分——难道他们竟都不是凡人吗?)abique pax, ubique securitas, nec latronum metuebat viator insidias, nec maris nauta offendicula piratarum.(大意:处处太平,处处安宁,行路人不必再担心盗匪的埋伏,航海者也不必再顾虑海盗的侵扰。)(《意大利史料集成》第七卷第939页。)
129
Constantia, primis a cunabulis in deliciarun tuarum affluentia diutius educata, tuisque institutis, doctrinus et moribus informata, tandem opibus tuis Barbaros delatura discessit: et nunc cum imgentibus copiis revertitur, ut pulcherrima nutricis ornamenta barbarica foeditate contaminet .... Intuari mihi jam videor turbulentas bar barorum acies.... civitates opulentas et loca diuturna pace florentia, metu concutere, caede vastare, rapinis atterere, et foedare luxuria hinc cives aut gladiis intercepti, aut servitute depressi, virgines constupratae, matronae, &c.
Constantia, primis a cunabulis in deliciarun tuarum affluentia diutius educata, tuisque institutis, doctrinus et moribus informata, tandem opibus tuis Barbaros delatura discessit: et nunc cum imgentibus copiis revertitur, ut pulcherrima nutricis ornamenta barbarica foeditate contaminet .... Intuari mihi jam videor turbulentas bar barorum acies.... civitates opulentas et loca diuturna pace florentia, metu concutere, caede vastare, rapinis atterere, et foedare luxuria hinc cives aut gladiis intercepti, aut servitute depressi, virgines constupratae, matronae, &c.(此系正文所引君士坦提娅一段哀辞的拉丁原文。)
130
Certe si regem non dubiae virtutis elegerint, nec a Saracenis Christiani dissentiant, poterit rex creatus rebus licet quasi desperatis et perditis subvenire, et incursus hostium, si prudenter egerit, propulsare.
Certe si regem non dubiae virtutis elegerint, nec a Saracenis Christiani dissentiant, poterit rex creatus rebus licet quasi desperatis et perditis subvenire, et incursus hostium, si prudenter egerit, propulsare.(大意:只要他们推选出一位德才无可置疑的国王,且基督徒与萨拉森人不生龃龉,那么新立的国王纵然面对近乎绝望、几近崩坏的局面,也仍能有所匡救;处置得当,便能击退敌人的进犯。)
131
In Apulis, qui, semper novitate gaudentes, novarum rerum studiis aguntur, nihil arbitror spei aut fiduciae reponendum.
In Apulis, qui, semper novitate gaudentes, novarum rerum studiis aguntur, nihil arbitror spei aut fiduciae reponendum.(大意:阿普利亚人素来喜新好变,一心热衷于生乱图新,我以为对他们不可寄托丝毫的指望或信任。)
132
Si civium tuorum virtutem et audaciam attendas, .... muriorum etiam ambitum densis turribus circumseptum.
Si civium tuorum virtutem et audaciam attendas, .... muriorum etiam ambitum densis turribus circumseptum.(大意:你若留意你城中市民的勇武与胆气……还有那绕城一周、密布着重重塔楼的城垣。)
133
Cum erudelitate piratica Theutonum confligat atrocitas, et inter aucbustos lapides, et Aethnae flagrant’s incendia, &c.
Cum erudelitate piratica Theutonum confligat atrocitas, et inter aucbustos lapides, et Aethnae flagrant's incendia, &c.(大意:当日耳曼人的凶暴与海盗的残忍相勾结,在灼热的岩石之间、在埃特纳喷涌的烈焰之中,云云。)
134
Eam partem, quam nobilissimarum civitatum fulgor illustrat, quae et toti regno singulari meruit privilegio praeminere, nefarium esset.... vel barbarorum ingressu pollui. I wish to transcribe his florid, but curious, description, of the palace, city, and luxuriant plain of Palermo.
Eam partem, quam nobilissimarum civitatum fulgor illustrat, quae et toti regno singulari meruit privilegio praeminere, nefarium esset.... vel barbarorum ingressu pollui.(大意:那一片为最高贵的城邑之光辉所映照、且以独一无二的殊荣冠绝全国的地方,若竟被蛮族的踏入所玷污,实属大逆不道。)我很想把他那段辞藻华丽却又别具意趣的文字——关于巴勒莫的宫殿、城市及其丰饶平原的描写——一并照录下来。
135
Vires non suppetunt, et conatus tuos tam inopia civium, quam paucitas bellatorum elidunt.
Vires non suppetunt, et conatus tuos tam inopia civium, quam paucitas bellatorum elidunt.(大意:气力已然不济,无论是市民的匮乏,还是战士的稀少,都足以使你的种种努力归于徒劳。)
136
The Normans and Sicilians appear to be confounded.
诺曼人与西西里人在此处似乎被混为一谈了。
137
The testimony of an Englishman, of Roger de Hoveden, (p. 689,) will lightly weigh against the silence of German and Italian history, (Muratori, Annali d’ Italia, tom. x. p. 156.) The priests and pilgrims, who returned from Rome, exalted, by every tale, the omnipotence of the holy father.
一个英格兰人——罗杰·德·霍夫登(第689页)——的这番证词,在日耳曼与意大利史书的一片沉默面前,实在分量甚轻(穆拉托里《意大利编年史》第十卷第156页)。那些从罗马归来的教士与朝圣者,则借着一个又一个传闻,把圣父(教宗)的全能渲染得神乎其神。
138
Ego enim in eo cum Teutonicis manere non debeo, (Caffari, Annal. Genuenses, in Muratori, Script. Rerum Italicarum, tom vi. p. 367, 368.)
Ego enim in eo cum Teutonicis manere non debeo.(大意:至于此事,我断不该与那些日耳曼人同流合污、久留其间。)(卡法罗《热那亚编年史》Annal. Genuenses,见穆拉托里《意大利史料集成》第六卷第367、368页。)
139
For the Saracens of Sicily and Nocera, see the Annals of Muratori, (tom. x. p. 149, and A.D. 1223, 1247,) Giannone, (tom ii. p. 385,) and of the originals, in Muratori’s Collection, Richard de St. Germano, (tom. vii. p. 996,) Matteo Spinelli de Giovenazzo, (tom. vii. p. 1064,) Nicholas de Jamsilla, (tom. x. p. 494,) and Matreo Villani, (tom. xiv l. vii. p. 103.) The last of these insinuates that, in reducing the Saracens of Nocera, Charles II. of Anjou employed rather artifice than violence.
关于西西里和诺切拉的萨拉森人,可参看穆拉托里的《编年史》(第十卷第149页,及公元1223、1247年各条)、詹诺内(第二卷第385页);至于原始文献,则见穆拉托里汇编所收诸家:圣杰尔马诺的理查(第七卷第996页)、焦韦纳佐的马泰奥·斯皮内利(第七卷第1064页)、尼古拉·德·雅姆西拉(第十卷第494页),以及马泰奥·维拉尼(第十四卷,第七卷第103页)。其中最后一位暗示:安茹的查理二世在收服诺切拉的萨拉森人时,用的与其说是武力,不如说是权术。
1391
It is remarkable that at the same time the tombs of the Roman emperors, even of Constantine himself, were violated and ransacked by their degenerate successor Alexius Comnenus, in order to enable him to pay the “German” tribute exacted by the menaces of the emperor Henry. See the end of the first book of the Life of Alexius, in Nicetas, p. 632, edit.—M.
值得注意的是,几乎在同一时期,罗马历代皇帝、甚至君士坦丁本人的陵墓,也被他们那位不肖的后继者阿历克塞·科穆宁掘开洗劫,为的是筹措那笔“日耳曼”贡赋——那是亨利皇帝以武力相胁所勒索的。参看尼基塔斯《阿历克塞传》第一卷末尾,第632页(校订本)。—M
140
Muratori quotes a passage from Arnold of Lubec, (l. iv. c. 20:) Reperit thesauros absconditos, et omnem lapidum pretiosorum et gemmarum gloriam, ita ut oneratis 160 somariis, gloriose ad terram suam redierit. Roger de Hoveden, who mentions the violation of the royal tombs and corpses, computes the spoil of Salerno at 200,000 ounces of gold, (p. 746.) On these occasions, I am almost tempted to exclaim with the listening maid in La Fontaine, “Je voudrois bien avoir ce qui manque.”
穆拉托里引录了吕贝克的阿诺德(第四卷第20章)的一段话:Reperit thesauros absconditos, et omnem lapidum pretiosorum et gemmarum gloriam, ita ut oneratis 160 somariis, gloriose ad terram suam redierit.(大意:他搜得了秘藏的财宝,以及一切珍贵宝石美玉的荣华,竟满载一百六十头驮兽,风风光光地返回了自己的领地。)罗杰·德·霍夫登提到了王家陵墓与遗骸遭亵渎一事,并把在萨莱诺劫得的财物估算为二十万盎司黄金(第746页)。每逢此类记载,我几乎忍不住要学拉封丹笔下那个偷听的侍女,脱口惊叹一句:“但愿那缺的一份也归我所有。”(Je voudrois bien avoir ce qui manque.)