Chapter LIII: Fate Of The Eastern Empire.—Part II. 第五十三章 东罗马帝国的命运——第二节

I must repeat the complaint that the vague and scanty memorials of the times will not afford any just estimate of the taxes, the revenue, and the resources of the Greek empire. From every province of Europe and Asia the rivulets of gold and silver discharged into the Imperial reservoir a copious and perennial stream. The separation of the branches from the trunk increased the relative magnitude of Constantinople; and the maxims of despotism contracted the state to the capital, the capital to the palace, and the palace to the royal person. A Jewish traveller, who visited the East in the twelfth century, is lost in his admiration of the Byzantine riches. “It is here,” says Benjamin of Tudela, “in the queen of cities, that the tributes of the Greek empire are annually deposited and the lofty towers are filled with precious magazines of silk, purple, and gold. It is said, that Constantinople pays each day to her sovereign twenty thousand pieces of gold; which are levied on the shops, taverns, and markets, on the merchants of Persia and Egypt, of Russia and Hungary, of Italy and Spain, who frequent the capital by sea and land.” 28 In all pecuniary matters, the authority of a Jew is doubtless respectable; but as the three hundred and sixty-five days would produce a yearly income exceeding seven millions sterling, I am tempted to retrench at least the numerous festivals of the Greek calendar. The mass of treasure that was saved by Theodora and Basil the Second will suggest a splendid, though indefinite, idea of their supplies and resources. The mother of Michael, before she retired to a cloister, attempted to check or expose the prodigality of her ungrateful son, by a free and faithful account of the wealth which he inherited; one hundred and nine thousand pounds of gold, and three hundred thousand of silver, the fruits of her own economy and that of her deceased husband. 29 The avarice of Basil is not less renowned than his valor and fortune: his victorious armies were paid and rewarded without breaking into the mass of two hundred thousand pounds of gold, (about eight millions sterling,) which he had buried in the subterraneous vaults of the palace. 30 Such accumulation of treasure is rejected by the theory and practice of modern policy; and we are more apt to compute the national riches by the use and abuse of the public credit. Yet the maxims of antiquity are still embraced by a monarch formidable to his enemies; by a republic respectable to her allies; and both have attained their respective ends of military power and domestic tranquillity.
我不得不再度慨叹:那个时代留下的史料既含混又稀少,无从据以准确估算希腊帝国的赋税、岁入与国力。欧亚两洲的各行省,金银如涓涓细流汇聚而来,注入帝国的府库,源源不绝,终年不竭。帝国的枝叶纷纷脱离主干,反倒使君士坦丁堡在这残躯之中显得愈发庞大;而专制之道又层层收束——国家收束于都城,都城收束于宫廷,宫廷收束于君主一身。十二世纪时,有一位犹太旅行家游历东方,对拜占庭的富庶叹为观止。图德拉的本雅明写道:“正是在这里,在这座冠绝众城的都会之中,希腊帝国每年的贡赋悉数汇集;那些高耸的塔楼里,堆满了丝绸、紫袍与黄金,尽是珍宝。据说,君士坦丁堡每日向君主进献黄金两万枚;这些钱取自城中的店铺、酒肆与市集,也取自那些经由水陆络绎往来于都城的商人——波斯人、埃及人、罗斯人、匈牙利人、意大利人和西班牙人。”28 在钱财一事上,犹太人的说法自然值得敬重;不过,若照此每日之数乘以三百六十五天,全年岁入竟逾七百万英镑,未免太多,我倒想至少把希腊历上那些名目繁多的节庆日子扣除掉。狄奥多拉与巴西尔二世所积攒的财富,虽难以确指其数,却足以让人遥想帝国财源之丰。米海尔之母在遁入修道院之前,曾想遏制或揭穿这忘恩之子的挥霍无度,便如实而坦率地列出了他所继承的家产:黄金十万九千磅,白银三十万磅——这全是她与亡夫俭省积攒的成果。29 巴西尔的贪吝,与他的武勇和好运一样为人所知:他麾下的常胜之师,粮饷犒赏一应发放,却始终未曾动用他埋藏在宫廷地窖中的那二十万磅黄金(约合八百万英镑)。30 如此囤积财货,为近世的理财之道所不取,无论理论还是实践皆然;今人衡量国家的富庶,更倾向于看公共信用如何运用、又如何滥用。然而,古人的这套准则,至今仍为某位令敌人生畏的君主所奉行,也为某个受盟邦敬重的共和国所遵守;而二者也各遂所愿,一者成就了军事强权,一者赢得了国内的安宁。
Whatever might be consumed for the present wants, or reserved for the future use, of the state, the first and most sacred demand was for the pomp and pleasure of the emperor, and his discretion only could define the measure of his private expense. The princes of Constantinople were far removed from the simplicity of nature; yet, with the revolving seasons, they were led by taste or fashion to withdraw to a purer air, from the smoke and tumult of the capital. They enjoyed, or affected to enjoy, the rustic festival of the vintage: their leisure was amused by the exercise of the chase and the calmer occupation of fishing, and in the summer heats, they were shaded from the sun, and refreshed by the cooling breezes from the sea. The coasts and islands of Asia and Europe were covered with their magnificent villas; but, instead of the modest art which secretly strives to hide itself and to decorate the scenery of nature, the marble structure of their gardens served only to expose the riches of the lord, and the labors of the architect. The successive casualties of inheritance and forfeiture had rendered the sovereign proprietor of many stately houses in the city and suburbs, of which twelve were appropriated to the ministers of state; but the great palace, 31 the centre of the Imperial residence, was fixed during eleven centuries to the same position, between the hippodrome, the cathedral of St. Sophia, and the gardens, which descended by many a terrace to the shores of the Propontis. The primitive edifice of the first Constantine was a copy, or rival, of ancient Rome; the gradual improvements of his successors aspired to emulate the wonders of the old world, 32 and in the tenth century, the Byzantine palace excited the admiration, at least of the Latins, by an unquestionable preeminence of strength, size, and magnificence. 33 But the toil and treasure of so many ages had produced a vast and irregular pile: each separate building was marked with the character of the times and of the founder; and the want of space might excuse the reigning monarch, who demolished, perhaps with secret satisfaction, the works of his predecessors. The economy of the emperor Theophilus allowed a more free and ample scope for his domestic luxury and splendor. A favorite ambassador, who had astonished the Abbassides themselves by his pride and liberality, presented on his return the model of a palace, which the caliph of Bagdad had recently constructed on the banks of the Tigris. The model was instantly copied and surpassed: the new buildings of Theophilus 34 were accompanied with gardens, and with five churches, one of which was conspicuous for size and beauty: it was crowned with three domes, the roof of gilt brass reposed on columns of Italian marble, and the walls were incrusted with marbles of various colors. In the face of the church, a semicircular portico, of the figure and name of the Greek sigma, was supported by fifteen columns of Phrygian marble, and the subterraneous vaults were of a similar construction. The square before the sigma was decorated with a fountain, and the margin of the basin was lined and encompassed with plates of silver. In the beginning of each season, the basin, instead of water, was replenished with the most exquisite fruits, which were abandoned to the populace for the entertainment of the prince. He enjoyed this tumultuous spectacle from a throne resplendent with gold and gems, which was raised by a marble staircase to the height of a lofty terrace. Below the throne were seated the officers of his guards, the magistrates, the chiefs of the factions of the circus; the inferior steps were occupied by the people, and the place below was covered with troops of dancers, singers, and pantomimes. The square was surrounded by the hall of justice, the arsenal, and the various offices of business and pleasure; and the purple chamber was named from the annual distribution of robes of scarlet and purple by the hand of the empress herself. The long series of the apartments was adapted to the seasons, and decorated with marble and porphyry, with painting, sculpture, and mosaics, with a profusion of gold, silver, and precious stones. His fanciful magnificence employed the skill and patience of such artists as the times could afford: but the taste of Athens would have despised their frivolous and costly labors; a golden tree, with its leaves and branches, which sheltered a multitude of birds warbling their artificial notes, and two lions of massy gold, and of natural size, who looked and roared like their brethren of the forest. The successors of Theophilus, of the Basilian and Comnenian dynasties, were not less ambitious of leaving some memorial of their residence; and the portion of the palace most splendid and august was dignified with the title of the golden triclinium. 35 With becoming modesty, the rich and noble Greeks aspired to imitate their sovereign, and when they passed through the streets on horseback, in their robes of silk and embroidery, they were mistaken by the children for kings. 36 A matron of Peloponnesus, 37 who had cherished the infant fortunes of Basil the Macedonian, was excited by tenderness or vanity to visit the greatness of her adopted son. In a journey of five hundred miles from Patras to Constantinople, her age or indolence declined the fatigue of a horse or carriage: the soft litter or bed of Danielis was transported on the shoulders of ten robust slaves; and as they were relieved at easy distances, a band of three hundred were selected for the performance of this service. She was entertained in the Byzantine palace with filial reverence, and the honors of a queen; and whatever might be the origin of her wealth, her gifts were not unworthy of the regal dignity. I have already described the fine and curious manufactures of Peloponnesus, of linen, silk, and woollen; but the most acceptable of her presents consisted in three hundred beautiful youths, of whom one hundred were eunuchs; 38 “for she was not ignorant,” says the historian, “that the air of the palace is more congenial to such insects, than a shepherd’s dairy to the flies of the summer.” During her lifetime, she bestowed the greater part of her estates in Peloponnesus, and her testament instituted Leo, the son of Basil, her universal heir. After the payment of the legacies, fourscore villas or farms were added to the Imperial domain; and three thousand slaves of Danielis were enfranchised by their new lord, and transplanted as a colony to the Italian coast. From this example of a private matron, we may estimate the wealth and magnificence of the emperors. Yet our enjoyments are confined by a narrow circle; and, whatsoever may be its value, the luxury of life is possessed with more innocence and safety by the master of his own, than by the steward of the public, fortune.
国库开支,无论是充作眼前的国用,还是留备日后的需要,其中首要而最不可侵犯的一项,总是皇帝的排场与享乐;而这份私人用度究竟有多大,全凭他一人的意愿裁定。君士坦丁堡的历代君主早已远离质朴的天性;然而随着四时更迭,或出于雅趣,或迫于风尚,他们仍不时避开都城的烟尘与喧嚣,退往空气清新之地。他们乐于——或佯装乐于——参加乡间的采葡萄庆典;闲暇时,或纵情田猎以自娱,或垂钓以怡情;炎夏酷暑之际,则有绿荫为他们遮蔽烈日,有海上凉风为他们送爽。亚欧两洲的海岸与岛屿上,遍布着他们华美的别墅;然而这些园林里的大理石建筑,非但没有那种含蓄的巧思——即暗自藏拙、只为点缀天然景致——反倒一味炫耀主人的豪富和建筑师的手艺。历年来或因继承、或因籍没,种种变故使君主名下积攒了城内与近郊许多华屋,其中十二座拨归朝廷大臣使用;但那座大皇宫,31 作为帝室居所的中枢,十一个世纪里始终坐落在同一处:它介于竞技场、圣索菲亚大教堂与御苑之间,而御苑顺着一级级台地层层下延,直抵普罗庞提斯的岸边。第一代君士坦丁所建的最初殿宇,仿的是古罗马,也意在与之争辉;历代继任者又逐步增修,一心想媲美古代世界的种种奇观,32 到了十世纪,这座拜占庭皇宫以其无可争辩的坚固、宏大与华丽,至少令拉丁人叹服。33 只是历代耗费的人力与钱财,堆砌出的却是一片庞大而杂乱的建筑群:每一栋各自成形,都打着其时代与营造者的烙印;倘若在位的君主以地方局促为由,把前人的手笔拆毁——心底或许还暗自得意——这倒也情有可原。塞奥菲鲁斯皇帝善于理财,因而在宫廷的奢华与排场上,能更加放手铺张。他有一位宠信的使臣,此人的高傲与阔绰连阿拔斯王朝的君臣都为之咋舌;使臣归来时,献上了一座宫殿的图样——那是巴格达的哈里发新近在底格里斯河畔建成的。图样一到手,便照样仿造,还要更胜一筹:塞奥菲鲁斯的新建筑群 34 附有园林,还配有五座教堂,其中一座因规模宏大、美轮美奂而格外醒目:顶上冠以三座穹顶,鎏金铜瓦的屋顶托在意大利大理石的柱子上,墙壁则镶嵌着五色斑斓的大理石。教堂正面有一道半圆形的柱廊,其形状与名称皆取自希腊字母西格玛(sigma),由十五根弗里吉亚大理石柱撑起,地下的拱室也是同样的构造。西格玛柱廊前的广场上装点着一座喷泉,池沿内外都包镶着银板。每逢时节之初,池中盛的不是清水,而是最精美的鲜果,任由百姓争抢,以供君主取乐。他则高踞在一座金光宝气的御座上观赏这番喧闹景象;御座由一道大理石台阶托起,直抵一处高台之顶。御座之下,坐着他的卫队军官、各级官吏,以及竞技场各党派的头目;再往下的台阶上是庶民百姓;最下方的场地则挤满了成群的舞者、歌者与哑剧优伶。广场四周环绕着审判厅、军械库,以及办理政务和供人取乐的种种馆舍;至于那间紫室,则因每年由皇后亲手颁赐绯红与紫色袍服而得名。一长列的殿室依四时之宜而设,饰以大理石与斑岩,绘以图画、雕以塑像、嵌以镶画,更缀满了金银珠宝,不计其数。他这份异想天开的豪奢,把当时所能延揽的匠人都用上了,穷尽其技艺与耐心;然而以雅典的眼光看来,这些劳作既浮华又靡费,只会为人所不齿——譬如一棵黄金铸成的树,枝繁叶茂,荫庇着满树飞鸟,鸟儿啁啾作声,唱的却是机巧的假嗓;又有两头纯金铸就的狮子,大小与真狮无异,其顾盼与吼声,竟同林间的同类一般无二。塞奥菲鲁斯的继任者,无论是巴西尔王朝还是科穆宁王朝,都同样一心想在其居所留下些许纪念;宫中最富丽、最庄严的一处,便冠以“黄金三榻厅”(golden triclinium)之名。35 希腊的豪门贵胄,也颇知分寸地想效法他们的君主;当他们身着绫罗绣袍、骑马穿街而过时,孩童们竟错把他们当成了国王。36 伯罗奔尼撒有一位贵妇,37 当年曾扶助过马其顿人巴西尔尚在微时的家业;如今她或出于慈爱,或出于虚荣,动了念头,要去看看这位义子如今何等显赫。从帕特雷到君士坦丁堡这五百英里的路程,她因年迈或慵懒,不愿受骑马乘车之苦:达尼埃利斯那张软榻卧床,由十名壮奴扛在肩上抬行;为了每隔不远便可换班,特地挑选了三百名奴仆来充任此役。在拜占庭皇宫里,人们以子侄之礼相待,又以王后之尊款待她;且不论她的财富从何而来,单看她所献的礼物,便无愧于王家的体面。我先前已述及伯罗奔尼撒精巧奇丽的织造之业——亚麻、丝绸与毛料;但她所献诸礼中最受欢迎的,却是三百名俊美的少年,其中一百名是阉人;38 史家称:“她心里清楚,宫廷的气息对这类虫豸而言,比牧人的乳酪坊对夏日的苍蝇还要相宜。”她在世时,便已将自己在伯罗奔尼撒的大部分产业施赠出去;临终立下遗嘱,又指定巴西尔之子利奥为她全部遗产的继承人。各项遗赠清偿之后,尚有八十座庄园田产并入了帝室的领地;达尼埃利斯名下的三千名奴隶,也获新主人开释为自由民,并作为一批移民,迁往意大利海岸安置。单凭这样一位民间贵妇的事例,我们便可推想历代皇帝何等富有豪奢了。然而人之享乐终究局限在一个狭小的范围之内;无论这份奢华值几何,享用自家产业者,总比支配公家财货者更为清白,也更为稳妥。
In an absolute government, which levels the distinctions of noble and plebeian birth, the sovereign is the sole fountain of honor; and the rank, both in the palace and the empire, depends on the titles and offices which are bestowed and resumed by his arbitrary will. Above a thousand years, from Vespasian to Alexius Comnenus, 39 the Caesar was the second person, or at least the second degree, after the supreme title of Augustus was more freely communicated to the sons and brothers of the reigning monarch. To elude without violating his promise to a powerful associate, the husband of his sister, and, without giving himself an equal, to reward the piety of his brother Isaac, the crafty Alexius interposed a new and supereminent dignity. The happy flexibility of the Greek tongue allowed him to compound the names of Augustus and Emperor (Sebastos and Autocrator,) and the union produces the sonorous title of Sebastocrator. He was exalted above the Caesar on the first step of the throne: the public acclamations repeated his name; and he was only distinguished from the sovereign by some peculiar ornaments of the head and feet. The emperor alone could assume the purple or red buskins, and the close diadem or tiara, which imitated the fashion of the Persian kings. 40 It was a high pyramidal cap of cloth or silk, almost concealed by a profusion of pearls and jewels: the crown was formed by a horizontal circle and two arches of gold: at the summit, the point of their intersection, was placed a globe or cross, and two strings or lappets of pearl depended on either cheek. Instead of red, the buskins of the Sebastocrator and Caesar were green; and on their open coronets or crowns, the precious gems were more sparingly distributed. Beside and below the Caesar the fancy of Alexius created the Panhypersebastos and the Protosebastos, whose sound and signification will satisfy a Grecian ear. They imply a superiority and a priority above the simple name of Augustus; and this sacred and primitive title of the Roman prince was degraded to the kinsmen and servants of the Byzantine court. The daughter of Alexius applauds, with fond complacency, this artful gradation of hopes and honors; but the science of words is accessible to the meanest capacity; and this vain dictionary was easily enriched by the pride of his successors. To their favorite sons or brothers, they imparted the more lofty appellation of Lord or Despot, which was illustrated with new ornaments, and prerogatives, and placed immediately after the person of the emperor himself. The five titles of, 1. Despot; 2. Sebastocrator; 3. Caesar; 4. Panhypersebastos; and, 5. Protosebastos; were usually confined to the princes of his blood: they were the emanations of his majesty; but as they exercised no regular functions, their existence was useless, and their authority precarious.
在专制政体之下,贵族与平民的出身之别被夷为平地,君主成了唯一的荣誉源泉;无论在宫中还是在帝国里,一个人的品秩高低,全系于种种头衔与官职,而这些皆由君主一意予夺。一千多年间,从韦帕芗直到阿历克塞·科穆宁,39 自“奥古斯都”这一至尊称号开始较为随意地分授给在位君主的子嗣与兄弟之后,“恺撒”一衔便退居次位,至少也是第二等。阿历克塞诡计多端:他曾许给一位举足轻重的盟友——即自己的姐夫——一个高位,如今既要设法回避这诺言,又不愿公然背弃;同时还想褒奖胞兄伊萨克的忠敬,却又不肯抬举出一个与自己平起平坐的人来。于是他别出心裁,凭空插进了一个崭新而超卓的尊号。希腊语生来灵活,正好任他随意拼合:他把“奥古斯都”与“皇帝”两词(希腊语作 Sebastos 与 Autocrator)合而为一,铸成了“塞巴斯托克拉托尔”这个铿锵响亮的头衔。此人位在恺撒之上,仅低御座一级;朝野的欢呼声中屡屡念及他的名字;他与君主之别,唯在头饰足饰的几处特异而已。唯有皇帝一人可以穿紫色或红色的高筒靴,戴那仿波斯诸王式样的紧扣冠冕或高冠。40 那是一顶高高的锥形软帽,以布或丝制成,几乎被密密匝匝的珍珠宝石遮得看不见帽身;冠身由一道水平的金环与两道金拱构成:金拱顶端交会之处,安着一枚金球或十字架,两串珍珠或珠饰垂在两颊两侧。塞巴斯托克拉托尔与恺撒的高筒靴不用红色,而用绿色;他们那开口的冠冕上,珠宝的缀饰也稀疏得多。阿历克塞又异想天开,在恺撒之旁、之下增设了“潘许佩塞巴斯托斯”与“普罗托塞巴斯托斯”两衔,其音其义都足以令希腊人的耳朵称心。这两个名号,都寓有尊于、先于区区一个“奥古斯都”之意;于是罗马君主这一神圣而古老的称号,竟沦落到拜占庭朝廷的宗亲与仆从头上。阿历克塞的女儿提起这套精心排定的希望与荣衔的等级时,满心得意,赞不绝口;然而玩弄字眼这门学问,纵是最平庸的才智也做得来;他的后继者凭着一腔骄矜,便轻而易举地把这部虚浮的名号辞典续写得愈发丰富。他们把“主上”即“德斯波特斯”这个更为尊崇的称号,赐给宠爱的子嗣或兄弟,又为之增添新的服饰与特权,位次紧随皇帝本人之后。这五种头衔——一、德斯波特斯;二、塞巴斯托克拉托尔;三、恺撒;四、潘许佩塞巴斯托斯;五、普罗托塞巴斯托斯——通常只限于皇族的宗室子弟:它们不过是君主威权的流溢;然而既不担负任何常设的职司,其存在便形同虚设,其权柄也岌岌可危。
But in every monarchy the substantial powers of government must be divided and exercised by the ministers of the palace and treasury, the fleet and army. The titles alone can differ; and in the revolution of ages, the counts and praefects, the praetor and quaestor, insensibly descended, while their servants rose above their heads to the first honors of the state. 1. In a monarchy, which refers every object to the person of the prince, the care and ceremonies of the palace form the most respectable department. The Curopalata, 41 so illustrious in the age of Justinian, was supplanted by the Protovestiare, whose primitive functions were limited to the custody of the wardrobe. From thence his jurisdiction was extended over the numerous menials of pomp and luxury; and he presided with his silver wand at the public and private audience. 2. In the ancient system of Constantine, the name of Logothete, or accountant, was applied to the receivers of the finances: the principal officers were distinguished as the Logothetes of the domain, of the posts, the army, the private and public treasure; and the great Logothete, the supreme guardian of the laws and revenues, is compared with the chancellor of the Latin monarchies. 42 His discerning eye pervaded the civil administration; and he was assisted, in due subordination, by the eparch or praefect of the city, the first secretary, and the keepers of the privy seal, the archives, and the red or purple ink which was reserved for the sacred signature of the emperor alone. 43 The introductor and interpreter of foreign ambassadors were the great Chiauss 44 and the Dragoman, 45 two names of Turkish origin, and which are still familiar to the Sublime Porte. 3. From the humble style and service of guards, the Domestics insensibly rose to the station of generals; the military themes of the East and West, the legions of Europe and Asia, were often divided, till the great Domestic was finally invested with the universal and absolute command of the land forces. The Protostrator, in his original functions, was the assistant of the emperor when he mounted on horseback: he gradually became the lieutenant of the great Domestic in the field; and his jurisdiction extended over the stables, the cavalry, and the royal train of hunting and hawking. The Stratopedarch was the great judge of the camp: the Protospathaire commanded the guards; the Constable, 46 the great Aeteriarch, and the Acolyth, were the separate chiefs of the Franks, the Barbarians, and the Varangi, or English, the mercenary strangers, who, at the decay of the national spirit, formed the nerve of the Byzantine armies. 4. The naval powers were under the command of the great Duke; in his absence they obeyed the great Drungaire of the fleet; and, in his place, the Emir, or Admiral, a name of Saracen extraction, 47 but which has been naturalized in all the modern languages of Europe. Of these officers, and of many more whom it would be useless to enumerate, the civil and military hierarchy was framed. Their honors and emoluments, their dress and titles, their mutual salutations and respective preeminence, were balanced with more exquisite labor than would have fixed the constitution of a free people; and the code was almost perfect when this baseless fabric, the monument of pride and servitude, was forever buried in the ruins of the empire. 48
然而在任何君主国里,治理国家的实权终须分派下去,交由宫廷、财库、水师与陆军的各位大臣分而掌之。所异者唯名号而已;而随着世代更迭,昔日的伯爵与长官、大法官与财务官,不知不觉间地位日降,他们的属吏却越过其头顶,攀上了国中的头等尊位。一、在一个凡事都以君主一身为归依的君主国里,宫廷的照料与礼仪自成一个最受敬重的部门。在查士丁尼时代显赫一时的库罗帕拉塔斯(Curopalata,宫廷总管),41 后来被普罗托维斯提亚里乌斯(Protovestiare,御衣总管)所取代——此职起初不过掌管御用衣橱,其后职权渐渐扩展,把宫中众多侍奉排场与享乐的仆役都归其统辖;每逢公私觐见,他都手执银杖,居中主持。二、在君士坦丁所立的旧制中,度支官(Logothete,即会计之意)一名,用来称呼掌管财赋收纳的官员:其中主要的几位,分别称为掌领地的、掌驿传的、掌军费的、掌私库与公库的度支官;而那位总揽法律与岁入的大度支官,则相当于拉丁诸国的宰相(chancellor)。42 他明察秋毫的目光遍及整个民政;在他之下,各依品级辅佐他的,有都城的市长官(eparch,即城市长官)、首席秘书,还有分掌机要玉玺、档案与御墨的诸位掌事——那御墨作红紫之色,专供皇帝御笔亲署。43 负责引荐与传译外国使节的,是大恰乌什(Chiauss)44 与通译官(Dragoman,德拉戈曼);45 这两个名号都源出土耳其语,至今仍为“高门”(即奥斯曼朝廷)所惯用。三、多梅斯提科斯(Domestic,禁卫统领)本是卑微的卫士名号与职守,日久竟悄然跃升为将军之位;东西两方的各军区、欧亚两洲的各军团,起初常分归数人统领,直到那大多梅斯提科斯一职最终总揽全部陆军,独掌统一而绝对的指挥大权。普罗托斯特拉托尔(Protostrator)一职,本来的职守是在皇帝上马时从旁侍奉,后来渐渐成了大多梅斯提科斯在战阵上的副手,职权也扩及马厩、骑兵,以及君王田猎放鹰的整套扈从班子。斯特拉托佩达尔克(Stratopedarch)是军营中的大判官;普罗托斯帕塔里乌斯(Protospathaire)统领禁卫;康斯塔布尔(Constable)46、大埃泰里阿尔克(Aeteriarch)与阿科吕特(Acolyth),则分别统率法兰克人、蛮族与瓦兰吉人(即英格兰人)——这些受雇的异邦人,在帝国民族血性衰颓之际,构成了拜占庭军队的中坚。四、水师归大督军统辖;大督军不在时,则听命于舰队的大德隆加里乌斯(Drungaire);再往下,还有埃米尔(Emir,即水师提督 Admiral)——此名源出萨拉森,47 却已在近代欧洲的各种语言里落地生根。文武两班的品级序列,便是由这些官员,以及其他许多不必一一列举的职位,共同构成的。他们的荣衔与俸禄、服色与名号、彼此间的揖让礼数与各自的尊卑位次,无不反复斟酌、细加权衡,那份精细,比起为一个自由民族厘定宪制所费的心力还要多;而正当这套典章将臻于完备之际,这座毫无根基的楼阁——这座矜夸与奴性的纪念碑——却随着帝国的倾覆,永远埋进了废墟之中。48

Notes 注释

28
Voyage de Benjamin de Tudele, tom. i. c. 5, p. 44-52. The Hebrew text has been translated into French by that marvellous child Baratier, who has added a volume of crude learning. The errors and fictions of the Jewish rabbi are not a sufficient ground to deny the reality of his travels. * Note: I am inclined, with Buegnot (Les Juifs d’Occident, part iii. p. 101 et seqq.) and Jost (Geschichte der Israeliter, vol. vi. anhang. p. 376) to consider this work a mere compilation, and to doubt the reality of the travels.—M.
Voyage de Benjamin de Tudele, tom. i. c. 5, p. 44-52。这部希伯来文本,由那位神童巴拉蒂耶译成法文,他还附加了整整一卷生涩的学问。这位犹太拉比虽有种种谬误与虚构,却不足以据此否认他确曾有过这趟旅行。* 按:我倾向于赞同伯尼奥(Les Juifs d'Occident, part iii. p. 101 及以下诸页)与约斯特(Geschichte der Israeliter, vol. vi. anhang. p. 376)的看法,认为此书不过是一部辑录之作,并怀疑这趟旅行是否真有其事。—M
29
See the continuator of Theophanes, (l. iv. p. 107,) Cedremis, (p. 544,) and Zonaras, (tom. ii. l. xvi. p. 157.)
参见塞奥法尼斯的续修者(l. iv. p. 107)、塞德雷努斯(Cedrenus,p. 544)与佐纳拉斯(tom. ii. l. xvi. p. 157)。
30
Zonaras, (tom. ii. l. xvii. p. 225,) instead of pounds, uses the more classic appellation of talents, which, in a literal sense and strict computation, would multiply sixty fold the treasure of Basil.
佐纳拉斯(tom. ii. l. xvii. p. 225)不用“磅”,而用更为古典的名目“塔兰特”;若照字面严格计算,巴西尔的这笔财富便要放大六十倍。
31
For a copious and minute description of the Imperial palace, see the Constantinop. Christiana (l. ii. c. 4, p. 113-123) of Ducange, the Tillemont of the middle ages. Never has laborious Germany produced two antiquarians more laborious and accurate than these two natives of lively France.
关于帝国皇宫详尽入微的描述,可参见杜康热的 Constantinop. Christiana(l. ii. c. 4, p. 113-123)——他堪称中世纪研究领域的蒂耶蒙。勤勉的德意志,也从未产出过比这两位生于活泼法兰西的古物学家更为勤勉、更为精确的人物。
32
The Byzantine palace surpasses the Capitol, the palace of Pergamus, the Rufinian wood, the temple of Adrian at Cyzicus, the pyramids, the Pharus, &c., according to an epigram (Antholog. Graec. l. iv. p. 488, 489. Brodaei, apud Wechel) ascribed to Julian, ex-praefect of Egypt. Seventy-one of his epigrams, some lively, are collected in Brunck, (Analect. Graec. tom. ii. p. 493-510; but this is wanting.
据一首归于尤利安(曾任埃及长官)名下的铭辞(Antholog. Graec. l. iv. p. 488, 489. Brodaei, apud Wechel)所称,拜占庭皇宫胜过卡皮托利乌姆、帕加马的宫殿、鲁菲尼安努斯的林苑、基齐库斯的阿德里安神庙、金字塔、法罗斯灯塔等等。他的铭辞有七十一首收在 Brunck 的 Analect. Graec. tom. ii. p. 493-510 中,其中不乏生动之作;唯独这一首缺载。
33
Constantinopolitanum Palatium non pulchritudine solum, verum stiam fortitudine, omnibus quas unquam videram munitionibus praestat, (Liutprand, Hist. l. v. c. 9, p. 465.)
Constantinopolitanum Palatium non pulchritudine solum, verum etiam fortitudine, omnibus quas unquam videram munitionibus praestat(“君士坦丁堡的皇宫,不仅论华美,即便论坚固,也胜过我平生所见的一切工事”——柳特普兰德,Hist. l. v. c. 9, p. 465)。
34
See the anonymous continuator of Theophanes, (p. 59, 61, 86,) whom I have followed in the neat and concise abstract of Le Beau, (Hint. du Bas Empire, tom. xiv. p. 436, 438.)
参见塞奥法尼斯的佚名续修者(p. 59, 61, 86);我所依据的,是勒博(Hist. du Bas Empire, tom. xiv. p. 436, 438)那份简洁明快的摘述。
35
In aureo triclinio quae praestantior est pars potentissimus (the usurper Romanus) degens caeteras partes (filiis) distribuerat, (Liutprand. Hist. l. v. c. 9, p. 469.) For this last signification of Triclinium see Ducange (Gloss. Graec. et Observations sur Joinville, p. 240) and Reiske, (ad Constantinum de Ceremoniis, p. 7.)
In aureo triclinio quae praestantior est pars potentissimus(指篡位者罗曼努斯)degens caeteras partes(filiis)distribuerat(“那位最有权势者〔篡位者罗曼努斯〕自居于黄金三榻厅中最尊贵的一部分,把其余各部分分给了诸子”——柳特普兰德,Hist. l. v. c. 9, p. 469)。关于 Triclinium 一词这一后起的含义,参见杜康热(Gloss. Graec. et Observations sur Joinville, p. 240)与赖斯克(ad Constantinum de Ceremoniis, p. 7)。
36
In equis vecti (says Benjamin of Tudela) regum filiis videntur persimiles. I prefer the Latin version of Constantine l’Empereur (p. 46) to the French of Baratier, (tom. i. p. 49.)
In equis vecti(图德拉的本雅明说)regum filiis videntur persimiles(“他们骑在马上,看来极像王子”)。相较于巴拉蒂耶的法译本(tom. i. p. 49),我更取君士坦丁·勒姆佩勒尔(Constantine l'Empereur)的拉丁译本(p. 46)。
37
See the account of her journey, munificence, and testament, in the life of Basil, by his grandson Constantine, (p. 74, 75, 76, p. 195-197.)
关于她此行、她的慷慨施赠及其遗嘱,可参见其孙君士坦丁所撰的《巴西尔传》(p. 74, 75, 76, p. 195-197)。
38
Carsamatium. Graeci vocant, amputatis virilibus et virga, puerum eunuchum quos Verdunenses mercatores obinmensum lucrum facere solent et in Hispaniam ducere, (Liutprand, l. vi. c. 3, p. 470.)—The last abomination of the abominable slave-trade! Yet I am surprised to find, in the xth century, such active speculations of commerce in Lorraine.
Carsamatium Graeci vocant, amputatis virilibus et virga, puerum eunuchum quos Verdunenses mercatores ob immensum lucrum facere solent et in Hispaniam ducere(“希腊人把割去了阴茎与睾丸的男童阉奴称作 Carsamatium;凡尔登的商人惯于制造这种阉奴以牟取暴利,再贩往西班牙”——柳特普兰德,l. vi. c. 3, p. 470)。——这可是那可憎的奴隶买卖里最可憎的一桩勾当!然而令我惊讶的是,早在十世纪,洛林一带竟已有如此活跃的此类商贩投机。
39
See the Alexiad (l. iii. p. 78, 79) of Anna Comnena, who, except in filial piety, may be compared to Mademoiselle de Montpensier. In her awful reverence for titles and forms, she styles her father, the inventor of this royal art.
参见安娜·科穆宁娜的《阿莱克修斯传》(l. iii. p. 78, 79);此人除却那份孝心之外,几可与德·蒙庞西耶小姐相提并论。她对名号与礼仪怀着极度的敬畏,竟称她父亲为这门帝王之术的发明者。
40
See Reiske, and Ceremoniale, p. 14, 15. Ducange has given a learned dissertation on the crowns of Constantinople, Rome, France, &c., (sur Joinville, xxv. p. 289-303;) but of his thirty-four models, none exactly tally with Anne’s description.
参见赖斯克及 Ceremoniale, p. 14, 15。杜康热就君士坦丁堡、罗马、法国等地的冠冕写过一篇渊博的专论(sur Joinville, xxv. p. 289-303);但在他所列的三十四种式样中,没有一种与安娜的描述完全吻合。
41
Par exstans curis, solo diademate dispar, Ordine pro rerum vocitatus Cura-Palati, says the African Corippus, (de Laudibus Justini, l. i. 136,) and in the same century (the vith) Cassiodorus represents him, who, virga aurea decoratus, inter numerosa obsequia primus ante pedes regis incederet (Variar. vii. 5.) But this great officer, (unknown,) exercising no function, was cast down by the modern Greeks to the xvth rank, (Codin. c. 5, p. 65.)
Par exstans curis, solo diademate dispar, / Ordine pro rerum vocitatus Cura-Palati(“他与君主分忧相埒,唯独没有那顶冠冕;因职掌之序,得名‘宫廷总管’”)——非洲人科里普斯如是说(de Laudibus Justini, l. i. 136);同一世纪(即六世纪)里,卡西奥多鲁斯也这样描绘他:virga aurea decoratus, inter numerosa obsequia primus ante pedes regis incederet(“手执金杖,在众多随侍之中率先行于君王足前”,Variar. vii. 5)。不过这位显赫的大员(其名不详)既不担负实际职司,后来竟被后世的希腊人贬到了第十五等(Codin. c. 5, p. 65)。
42
Nicetas (in Manuel, l. vii. c. 1) defines him. Yet the epithet was added by the elder Andronicus, (Ducange, tom. i. p. 822, 823.)
尼基塔斯(in Manuel, l. vii. c. 1)对他有所界定。不过“大”这个称号,是老安德罗尼库斯所加(Ducange, tom. i. p. 822, 823)。
43
From Leo I. (A.D. 470) the Imperial ink, which is still visible on some original acts, was a mixture of vermilion and cinnabar, or purple. The emperor’s guardians, who shared in this prerogative, always marked in green ink the indiction and the month. See the Dictionnaire Diplomatique, (tom. i. p. 511-513) a valuable abridgment.
自利奥一世(公元 470 年)以降,帝国的御墨便是朱砂与丹砂的混合,或作紫色,至今在若干原始文书上仍可看到。皇帝的监护者也分享这项特权,他们总是用绿墨来标注纪年(indiction)与月份。参见 Dictionnaire Diplomatique(tom. i. p. 511-513),那是一部很有价值的节本。
44
The sultan sent to Alexius, (Anna Comnena, l. vi. p. 170. Ducange ad loc.;) and Pachymer often speaks, (l. vii. c. 1, l. xii. c. 30, l. xiii. c. 22.) The Chiaoush basha is now at the head of 700 officers, (Rycaut’s Ottoman Empire, p. 349, octavo edition.)
苏丹曾遣恰乌什往见阿历克塞(安娜·科穆宁娜,l. vi. p. 170;杜康热注此处);帕希梅雷斯也屡屡提及(l. vii. c. 1, l. xii. c. 30, l. xiii. c. 22)。如今的恰乌什巴夏(Chiaoush basha)统领着七百名官员(里科《奥斯曼帝国》,p. 349,八开本)。
45
Tagerman is the Arabic name of an interpreter, (D’Herbelot, p. 854, 855;), says Codinus, (c. v. No. 70, p. 67.) See Villehardouin, (No. 96,) Bus, (Epist. iv. p. 338,) and Ducange, (Observations sur Villehardouin, and Gloss. Graec. et Latin)
Tagerman 是阿拉伯语中“译员”一词(埃尔布洛,p. 854, 855),科迪努斯如是说(c. v. No. 70, p. 67)。另见维尔阿杜安(No. 96)、Bus(Epist. iv. p. 338)与杜康热(Observations sur Villehardouin, and Gloss. Graec. et Latin)。
46
A corruption from the Latin Comes stabuli, or the French Connetable. In a military sense, it was used by the Greeks in the eleventh century, at least as early as in France.
此名是拉丁语 Comes stabuli(马厩伯)或法语 Connetable(统帅)的讹变。就其军事含义而言,希腊人在十一世纪便已使用,至少与法国用它同样早。
47
It was directly borrowed from the Normans. In the xiith century, Giannone reckons the admiral of Sicily among the great officers.
这个词是直接从诺曼人那里借来的。到了十二世纪,詹诺内已把西西里的水师提督列入显要大员之列。
48
This sketch of honors and offices is drawn from George Cordinus Curopalata, who survived the taking of Constantinople by the Turks: his elaborate, though trifling, work (de Officiis Ecclesiae et Aulae C. P.) has been illustrated by the notes of Goar, and the three books of Gretser, a learned Jesuit.
这份关于荣衔与官职的概述,取材于乔治·科迪努斯·库罗帕拉塔——此人在土耳其人攻陷君士坦丁堡之后仍幸存于世;他那部虽琐碎却颇为繁详的著作(de Officiis Ecclesiae et Aulae C. P.),经戈阿尔的注释、以及博学的耶稣会士格雷策的三卷本加以阐发。