Chapter LI: Conquests By The Arabs.—Part VII. 第五十一章 阿拉伯人的征服——第七节

On the intelligence of this rapid success, the applause of Musa degenerated into envy; and he began, not to complain, but to fear, that Tarik would leave him nothing to subdue. At the head of ten thousand Arabs and eight thousand Africans, he passed over in person from Mauritania to Spain: the first of his companions were the noblest of the Koreish; his eldest son was left in the command of Africa; the three younger brethren were of an age and spirit to second the boldest enterprises of their father. At his landing in Algezire, he was respectfully entertained by Count Julian, who stifled his inward remorse, and testified, both in words and actions, that the victory of the Arabs had not impaired his attachment to their cause. Some enemies yet remained for the sword of Musa. The tardy repentance of the Goths had compared their own numbers and those of the invaders; the cities from which the march of Tarik had declined considered themselves as impregnable; and the bravest patriots defended the fortifications of Seville and Merida. They were successively besieged and reduced by the labor of Musa, who transported his camp from the Boetis to the Anas, from the Guadalquivir to the Guadiana. When he beheld the works of Roman magnificence, the bridge, the aqueducts, the triumphal arches, and the theatre, of the ancient metropolis of Lusitania, “I should imagine,” said he to his four companions, “that the human race must have united their art and power in the foundation of this city: happy is the man who shall become its master!” He aspired to that happiness, but the Emeritans sustained on this occasion the honor of their descent from the veteran legionaries of Augustus 183 Disdaining the confinement of their walls, they gave battle to the Arabs on the plain; but an ambuscade rising from the shelter of a quarry, or a ruin, chastised their indiscretion, and intercepted their return.
塔里克如此迅速的捷报传来,穆萨的赞许渐渐化作妒忌;他所忧惧的,不是别的,只怕塔里克把可征之地尽数收服,不给自己留下用武之处。于是他亲率一万阿拉伯人、八千非洲人,从毛里塔尼亚渡海进入西班牙:随行的头等人物,皆是古莱什族中最尊贵者;长子留下统辖阿非利加;三个弟弟正当壮年,意气风发,足以襄助父亲的种种壮举。他在阿尔赫西拉斯登陆时,尤利安伯爵以厚礼相待——伯爵强压心底的悔恨,言语行事之间处处表明:阿拉伯人的胜利,丝毫未曾动摇他效忠于阿拉伯事业之心。穆萨的刀锋之下,尚有几处敌人未平。哥特人悔之已晚,这才把自己的兵力与入侵者的兵力两相比较;当初塔里克进军时绕道而过的城池,守御者自以为固若金汤;最勇武的爱国志士则据守塞维利亚与梅里达的城防。穆萨苦心经营,将两城次第围攻、逐一攻克,营帐由贝提斯河移至阿纳斯河,也就是从瓜达尔基维尔河移到瓜迪亚纳河。当他目睹卢西塔尼亚这座古都罗马式的宏伟遗构——那桥梁、引水渠、凯旋门与剧场——不禁对四名随从叹道:“依我看,营建此城,人类想必是把全部的技艺与力量都倾注在了一处:谁能做它的主人,谁便是有福之人!”他一心想得此福,然而梅里达人这一回却不负奥古斯都麾下老兵的血脉之名183。他们不屑困守城墙,出城在平原与阿拉伯人交战;不料一支伏兵从采石场或废墟的掩蔽中突起,教训了他们的鲁莽,断绝了他们的归路。
The wooden turrets of assault were rolled forwards to the foot of the rampart; but the defence of Merida was obstinate and long; and the castle of the martyrs was a perpetual testimony of the losses of the Moslems. The constancy of the besieged was at length subdued by famine and despair; and the prudent victor disguised his impatience under the names of clemency and esteem. The alternative of exile or tribute was allowed; the churches were divided between the two religions; and the wealth of those who had fallen in the siege, or retired to Gallicia, was confiscated as the reward of the faithful. In the midway between Merida and Toledo, the lieutenant of Musa saluted the vicegerent of the caliph, and conducted him to the palace of the Gothic kings. Their first interview was cold and formal: a rigid account was exacted of the treasures of Spain: the character of Tarik was exposed to suspicion and obloquy; and the hero was imprisoned, reviled, and ignominiously scourged by the hand, or the command, of Musa. Yet so strict was the discipline, so pure the zeal, or so tame the spirit, of the primitive Moslems, that, after this public indignity, Tarik could serve and be trusted in the reduction of the Tarragonest province. A mosch was erected at Saragossa, by the liberality of the Koreish: the port of Barcelona was opened to the vessels of Syria; and the Goths were pursued beyond the Pyrenaean mountains into their Gallic province of Septimania or Languedoc. 184 In the church of St. Mary at Carcassone, Musa found, but it is improbable that he left, seven equestrian statues of massy silver; and from his term or column of Narbonne, he returned on his footsteps to the Gallician and Lusitanian shores of the ocean. During the absence of the father, his son Abdelaziz chastised the insurgents of Seville, and reduced, from Malaga to Valentia, the sea-coast of the Mediterranean: his original treaty with the discreet and valiant Theodemir 185 will represent the manners and policy of the times. “The conditions of peace agreed and sworn between Abdelaziz, the son of Musa, the son of Nassir, and Theodemir prince of the Goths. In the name of the most merciful God, Abdelaziz makes peace on these conditions: that Theodemir shall not be disturbed in his principality; nor any injury be offered to the life or property, the wives and children, the religion and temples, of the Christians: that Theodemir shall freely deliver his seven 1851 cities, Orihuela, Valentola, Alicanti Mola, Vacasora, Bigerra, (now Bejar,) Ora, (or Opta,) and Lorca: that he shall not assist or entertain the enemies of the caliph, but shall faithfully communicate his knowledge of their hostile designs: that himself, and each of the Gothic nobles, shall annually pay one piece of gold, four measures of wheat, as many of barley, with a certain proportion of honey, oil, and vinegar; and that each of their vassals shall be taxed at one moiety of the said imposition. Given the fourth of Regeb, in the year of the Hegira ninety-four, and subscribed with the names of four Mussulman witnesses.” 186 Theodemir and his subjects were treated with uncommon lenity; but the rate of tribute appears to have fluctuated from a tenth to a fifth, according to the submission or obstinacy of the Christians. 187 In this revolution, many partial calamities were inflicted by the carnal or religious passions of the enthusiasts: some churches were profaned by the new worship: some relics or images were confounded with idols: the rebels were put to the sword; and one town (an obscure place between Cordova and Seville) was razed to its foundations. Yet if we compare the invasion of Spain by the Goths, or its recovery by the kings of Castile and Arragon, we must applaud the moderation and discipline of the Arabian conquerors.
攻城的木塔被推到城墙脚下;然而梅里达守御顽强,历时甚久,那座“殉道者堡”便长久见证着穆斯林的伤亡。被围者的坚忍,终究为饥饿与绝望所磨折;老谋深算的胜利者,则把自己的焦躁掩饰在宽仁与礼遇的名义之下。他准许守军在流亡与纳贡之间择一而从;城中教堂由两教分用;至于在围城中阵亡者、或退往加利西亚者的财产,则一概没收,用作犒赏信徒之资。在梅里达与托莱多之间的中途,穆萨的副将迎候这位哈里发的代理人,引他前往哥特列王的宫殿。二人初次会面,冷淡而拘礼:穆萨严词追究西班牙财宝的下落,对塔里克的为人横加猜忌与诋毁;这位英雄竟被囚禁、辱骂,还遭穆萨亲手(或奉其命)施以可耻的鞭笞。然而早期穆斯林纪律之严、热忱之纯、又或性情之驯顺,竟至如此地步:塔里克蒙受这般当众羞辱之后,仍能受命效力、受人信任,参与征服塔拉戈纳行省。古莱什人慷慨解囊,在萨拉戈萨建起一座清真寺;巴塞罗那港向叙利亚的船只敞开;哥特人则被一路追击,越过比利牛斯山,直入他们在高卢的行省塞普提马尼亚,即朗格多克。184 在卡尔卡松的圣马利亚教堂里,穆萨见到七尊纯银的骑马雕像——不过他多半没有把它们留下。他在纳博讷立下界标(或界柱),到此为止,随即循原路折返,回到加利西亚与卢西塔尼亚濒海之滨。父亲远征在外之际,其子阿卜杜勒·阿齐兹平定了塞维利亚的叛乱,又征服了自马拉加至瓦伦提亚一线的地中海沿岸:他与那位审慎而英勇的狄奥德米尔185所订的原始和约,恰可反映当时的风气与政策。“兹立此约,为穆萨之子、纳西尔之孙阿卜杜勒·阿齐兹与哥特君主狄奥德米尔双方议定并立誓之和平条款。奉至仁真主之名,阿卜杜勒·阿齐兹依下列条件缔结和约:狄奥德米尔于其领地之内不受侵扰;基督徒之生命财产、妻室子女、宗教庙堂,皆不得加害;狄奥德米尔须无偿交出所辖七1851城,即奥里韦拉、瓦伦托拉、阿利坎蒂·莫拉、瓦卡索拉、比赫拉(今贝哈尔)、奥拉(或称奥普塔)、洛尔卡;他不得资助或收容哈里发之敌,且须将所知敌方图谋如实通报;他本人及每一位哥特贵族,每年须缴纳金币一枚、小麦四斗、大麦四斗,另附蜂蜜、油、醋若干;其属下臣民,则按上述税额之半征收。立约于希吉拉94年赖哲卜月4日,并有四名穆斯林见证人具名于后。”186 狄奥德米尔及其臣民所受待遇格外宽厚;不过贡赋的税率似乎在十分之一到五分之一之间浮动,视基督徒顺服或顽抗而定。187 在这场变局中,狂热之徒或纵情肉欲、或激于教义,造成了种种局部的祸患:有些教堂被新的信仰亵渎;有些圣物或圣像被当作偶像;叛乱者遭刀剑处决;还有一座市镇(科尔多瓦与塞维利亚之间一处无名小地)被夷为平地。然而,若把当年哥特人入侵西班牙、或后来卡斯蒂利亚与阿拉贡诸王收复西班牙的情形拿来相比,我们就不得不称赞阿拉伯征服者的节制与纪律了。
The exploits of Musa were performed in the evening of life, though he affected to disguise his age by coloring with a red powder the whiteness of his beard. But in the love of action and glory, his breast was still fired with the ardor of youth; and the possession of Spain was considered only as the first step to the monarchy of Europe. With a powerful armament by sea and land, he was preparing to repass the Pyrenees, to extinguish in Gaul and Italy the declining kingdoms of the Franks and Lombards, and to preach the unity of God on the altar of the Vatican. From thence, subduing the Barbarians of Germany, he proposed to follow the course of the Danube from its source to the Euxine Sea, to overthrow the Greek or Roman empire of Constantinople, and returning from Europe to Asia, to unite his new acquisitions with Antioch and the provinces of Syria. 188 But his vast enterprise, perhaps of easy execution, must have seemed extravagant to vulgar minds; and the visionary conqueror was soon reminded of his dependence and servitude. The friends of Tarik had effectually stated his services and wrongs: at the court of Damascus, the proceedings of Musa were blamed, his intentions were suspected, and his delay in complying with the first invitation was chastised by a harsher and more peremptory summons. An intrepid messenger of the caliph entered his camp at Lugo in Gallicia, and in the presence of the Saracens and Christians arrested the bridle of his horse. His own loyalty, or that of his troops, inculcated the duty of obedience: and his disgrace was alleviated by the recall of his rival, and the permission of investing with his two governments his two sons, Abdallah and Abdelaziz. His long triumph from Ceuta to Damascus displayed the spoils of Africa and the treasures of Spain: four hundred Gothic nobles, with gold coronets and girdles, were distinguished in his train; and the number of male and female captives, selected for their birth or beauty, was computed at eighteen, or even at thirty, thousand persons. As soon as he reached Tiberias in Palestine, he was apprised of the sickness and danger of the caliph, by a private message from Soliman, his brother and presumptive heir; who wished to reserve for his own reign the spectacle of victory.
穆萨这些功业,都成就于暮年——尽管他惯用红粉染须,遮掩花白,佯装未老。然而论及对事功与荣耀的渴慕,他胸中仍燃着少年人的热望;在他看来,据有西班牙不过是称霸欧洲的第一步。他海陆并举,整备大军,正欲再度翻越比利牛斯山,在高卢与意大利扑灭日渐衰微的法兰克与伦巴第两国,并要在梵蒂冈的祭坛上宣讲真主独一之道。他还打算由此制服日耳曼的蛮族,沿多瑙河顺流而下,从源头直抵黑海,倾覆君士坦丁堡的希腊(或曰罗马)帝国,然后自欧洲折返亚洲,把新征之地与安条克及叙利亚各行省连成一片。188 这宏图或许并不难实现,但在庸常之辈眼中,终归是狂妄之想;而这位耽于幻梦的征服者,很快便有人提醒他:他不过是仰人鼻息、供人驱使之臣。塔里克的党羽已把他的功劳与所受的委屈申说得淋漓尽致:在大马士革的朝廷上,穆萨的所作所为受到指责,其居心遭人猜疑;他接到头一道召令却迟迟不应,于是又有一道更严厉、更不容违抗的诏书下来申斥。哈里发一名无所畏惧的使者闯入他在加利西亚卢戈的营地,当着萨拉森人与基督徒之面,一把勒住了他坐骑的缰绳。或出于他本人的忠诚,或碍于部众的忠诚,服从的本分终究不容违背;所幸他的政敌也一并被召回,朝廷又准他将自己所辖的两处总督之职分授两子阿卜杜拉与阿卜杜勒·阿齐兹,这才稍减他的耻辱。从休达到大马士革,他一路凯旋,沿途炫示着阿非利加的战利品与西班牙的珍宝:随行队列中,尤为醒目的是四百名头戴金冠、腰束金带的哥特贵族;至于因出身或美貌而遴选出来的男女俘虏,据计约有一万八千人,甚或多达三万。他一抵达巴勒斯坦的提比里亚,便从苏莱曼的密信中得知:哈里发已然病重垂危。苏莱曼是哈里发之弟,又是储位所属,他有意把这场献捷的盛况留待自己登基之后再行上演。
Had Walid recovered, the delay of Musa would have been criminal: he pursued his march, and found an enemy on the throne. In his trial before a partial judge against a popular antagonist, he was convicted of vanity and falsehood; and a fine of two hundred thousand pieces of gold either exhausted his poverty or proved his rapaciousness. The unworthy treatment of Tarik was revenged by a similar indignity; and the veteran commander, after a public whipping, stood a whole day in the sun before the palace gate, till he obtained a decent exile, under the pious name of a pilgrimage to Mecca. The resentment of the caliph might have been satiated with the ruin of Musa; but his fears demanded the extirpation of a potent and injured family. A sentence of death was intimated with secrecy and speed to the trusty servants of the throne both in Africa and Spain; and the forms, if not the substance, of justice were superseded in this bloody execution. In the mosch or palace of Cordova, Abdelaziz was slain by the swords of the conspirators; they accused their governor of claiming the honors of royalty; and his scandalous marriage with Egilona, the widow of Roderic, offended the prejudices both of the Christians and Moslems. By a refinement of cruelty, the head of the son was presented to the father, with an insulting question, whether he acknowledged the features of the rebel? “I know his features,” he exclaimed with indignation: “I assert his innocence; and I imprecate the same, a juster fate, against the authors of his death.” The age and despair of Musa raised him above the power of kings; and he expired at Mecca of the anguish of a broken heart. His rival was more favorably treated: his services were forgiven; and Tarik was permitted to mingle with the crowd of slaves. 189 I am ignorant whether Count Julian was rewarded with the death which he deserved indeed, though not from the hands of the Saracens; but the tale of their ingratitude to the sons of Witiza is disproved by the most unquestionable evidence. The two royal youths were reinstated in the private patrimony of their father; but on the decease of Eba, the elder, his daughter was unjustly despoiled of her portion by the violence of her uncle Sigebut. The Gothic maid pleaded her cause before the caliph Hashem, and obtained the restitution of her inheritance; but she was given in marriage to a noble Arabian, and their two sons, Isaac and Ibrahim, were received in Spain with the consideration that was due to their origin and riches.
倘若瓦利德痊愈,穆萨这番耽搁便要坐实死罪;然而他继续赶路,等到抵京,宝座上坐着的却已是一个仇敌。审判他的法官偏袒一方,与他对簿的又是个深得人心的对头;结果他被判犯有虚夸与欺妄之罪,罚金高达二十万枚金币——这要么榨干了他本已窘迫的家底,要么反倒证实了他确曾贪得无厌。当年他慢待塔里克,如今也以同样的羞辱得了报应:这位久经沙场的老将当众挨了一顿鞭子,又在宫门前烈日下整整罚站一天,最后才得以体面地放逐——借口则是虔诚的麦加朝觐。哈里发的怨愤,本可因穆萨的败落而消解;然而他的恐惧,却要将这个势力雄厚、又蒙冤受辱的家族斩草除根。一道死刑密令火速下达阿非利加与西班牙两地忠于王室的心腹;而这场血腥的处决,即便说不上背弃了司法的实质,至少连司法的外在形式也一概略去了。在科尔多瓦的清真寺(或曰宫殿)中,阿卜杜勒·阿齐兹死于密谋者的刀下;他们指控这位总督僭图王者的尊荣,而他与罗德里克的遗孀埃吉洛娜那桩不体面的婚姻,又同时触犯了基督徒与穆斯林双方的成见。他们更以一种精巧的残忍,把儿子的首级送到父亲面前,出言羞辱地问他:可还认得出这叛贼的面目么?“我认得他的面目,”他悲愤地喊道,“我断言他无罪;我更咒愿那些害他性命之人,也遭同样的下场——只是那对他们才算公道。”穆萨年迈而绝望,反倒超脱于帝王权势之外;最终他心碎肠断,怀着满腔悲苦死在麦加。他的政敌反倒得了较宽厚的待遇:先前的一切都获宽宥,塔里克得以隐没于奴仆之群。189 尤利安伯爵是否终于领受了他确实应得的死——尽管未必死在萨拉森人手里——我便无从知晓了;不过说阿拉伯人如何忘恩负义、亏待维蒂扎诸子的那段传闻,却已为确凿无疑的证据所推翻。这两位王家少年得以重新继承父亲的私产;然而年长的埃巴一死,其女应得的那一份遗产,便被叔父西格布特恃强夺去。这位哥特少女向哈里发哈希姆申诉,终于讨回了自己的遗产;不过她被许配给一位阿拉伯贵族,二人所生的两个儿子伊萨克与易卜拉欣,在西班牙都因其出身与财富而受到应有的礼遇。
A province is assimilated to the victorious state by the introduction of strangers and the imitative spirit of the natives; and Spain, which had been successively tinctured with Punic, and Roman, and Gothic blood, imbibed, in a few generations, the name and manners of the Arabs. The first conquerors, and the twenty successive lieutenants of the caliphs, were attended by a numerous train of civil and military followers, who preferred a distant fortune to a narrow home: the private and public interest was promoted by the establishment of faithful colonies; and the cities of Spain were proud to commemorate the tribe or country of their Eastern progenitors. The victorious though motley bands of Tarik and Musa asserted, by the name of Spaniards, their original claim of conquest; yet they allowed their brethren of Egypt to share their establishments of Murcia and Lisbon. The royal legion of Damascus was planted at Cordova; that of Emesa at Seville; that of Kinnisrin or Chalcis at Jaen; that of Palestine at Algezire and Medina Sidonia. The natives of Yemen and Persia were scattered round Toledo and the inland country, and the fertile seats of Grenada were bestowed on ten thousand horsemen of Syria and Irak, the children of the purest and most noble of the Arabian tribes. 190 A spirit of emulation, sometimes beneficial, more frequently dangerous, was nourished by these hereditary factions. Ten years after the conquest, a map of the province was presented to the caliph: the seas, the rivers, and the harbors, the inhabitants and cities, the climate, the soil, and the mineral productions of the earth. 191 In the space of two centuries, the gifts of nature were improved by the agriculture, 192 the manufactures, and the commerce, of an industrious people; and the effects of their diligence have been magnified by the idleness of their fancy. The first of the Ommiades who reigned in Spain solicited the support of the Christians; and in his edict of peace and protection, he contents himself with a modest imposition of ten thousand ounces of gold, ten thousand pounds of silver, ten thousand horses, as many mules, one thousand cuirasses, with an equal number of helmets and lances. 193 The most powerful of his successors derived from the same kingdom the annual tribute of twelve millions and forty-five thousand dinars or pieces of gold, about six millions of sterling money; 194 a sum which, in the tenth century, most probably surpassed the united revenues of the Christians monarchs. His royal seat of Cordova contained six hundred moschs, nine hundred baths, and two hundred thousand houses; he gave laws to eighty cities of the first, to three hundred of the second and third order; and the fertile banks of the Guadalquivir were adorned with twelve thousand villages and hamlets. The Arabs might exaggerate the truth, but they created and they describe the most prosperous aera of the riches, the cultivation, and the populousness of Spain. 195
一个行省之所以与征服它的国家渐趋同化,一靠外来者的迁入,二靠本地人的仿效之心;西班牙先后浸染过布匿、罗马与哥特的血脉,如今不出数代,又把阿拉伯人的名号与风习吸纳于身。最初的征服者,以及历任二十位哈里发的代理人,身边都跟着大批文武随员——这些人宁肯远赴他乡求取功名,也不愿困守家中那一亩三分地:忠诚移民的落户,既成全了私利,也增进了公益;西班牙各城更以能纪念其东方祖先所属的部族或故国为荣。塔里克与穆萨麾下那支虽杂而胜的队伍,以“西班牙人”之名,宣示着他们凭征服而来的原始权利;不过他们也允许来自埃及的同胞,分享穆尔西亚与里斯本的产业。大马士革的皇家军团安置在科尔多瓦;埃梅萨的军团安置在塞维利亚;金奈斯林(即卡尔基斯)的军团安置在哈恩;巴勒斯坦的军团则安置在阿尔赫西拉斯与梅迪纳西多尼亚。也门与波斯的居民散布在托莱多一带及内陆各地;格拉纳达那片沃土,则赐给了来自叙利亚与伊拉克的一万骑兵——他们都是阿拉伯诸部中血统最纯、门第最尊者的子弟。190 这些世代相承的派系,滋长出一种彼此争胜的风气,偶尔于世有益,却更多地暗藏祸机。征服之后十年,一幅行省舆图呈献到哈里发面前:海洋、河流、港口,居民与城邑,气候、土壤,乃至地下的矿产,无不备载其上。191 两百年间,这片土地天赋的物产,经一个勤勉民族的耕作192、工艺与商贸而愈发丰饶;而他们辛勤所致的成果,又被后人闲逸的想象夸大了几分。在西班牙称王的第一位倭马亚君主,曾力求争取基督徒的拥护;他在颁布的和平保护敕令中,只满足于课取一笔不算苛重的贡赋:黄金一万盎司、白银一万磅、战马一万匹、骡子亦一万头、胸甲一千副,另有头盔与长矛各一千。193 他历代继承者中最强盛的一位,则从同一个王国岁收贡赋一千二百零四万五千第纳尔(即金币),约合六百万英镑194;这笔数目,在十世纪多半已超过基督教诸王岁入的总和。他的王都科尔多瓦,有清真寺六百座、浴场九百处、房舍二十万间;他号令着头等城市八十座、二三等城市三百座;瓜达尔基维尔河两岸沃野之上,更点缀着一万二千个村庄与聚落。阿拉伯人所述或有夸大,但西班牙财富最盛、垦殖最广、人烟最稠的那个时代,毕竟是他们亲手缔造、又亲笔描绘的。195
The wars of the Moslems were sanctified by the prophet; but among the various precepts and examples of his life, the caliphs selected the lessons of toleration that might tend to disarm the resistance of the unbelievers. Arabia was the temple and patrimony of the God of Mahomet; but he beheld with less jealousy and affection the nations of the earth. The polytheists and idolaters, who were ignorant of his name, might be lawfully extirpated by his votaries; 196 but a wise policy supplied the obligation of justice; and after some acts of intolerant zeal, the Mahometan conquerors of Hindostan have spared the pagodas of that devout and populous country. The disciples of Abraham, of Moses, and of Jesus, were solemnly invited to accept the more perfect revelation of Mahomet; but if they preferred the payment of a moderate tribute, they were entitled to the freedom of conscience and religious worship. 197 In a field of battle the forfeit lives of the prisoners were redeemed by the profession of Islam; the females were bound to embrace the religion of their masters, and a race of sincere proselytes was gradually multiplied by the education of the infant captives. But the millions of African and Asiatic converts, who swelled the native band of the faithful Arabs, must have been allured, rather than constrained, to declare their belief in one God and the apostle of God. By the repetition of a sentence and the loss of a foreskin, the subject or the slave, the captive or the criminal, arose in a moment the free and equal companion of the victorious Moslems. Every sin was expiated, every engagement was dissolved: the vow of celibacy was superseded by the indulgence of nature; the active spirits who slept in the cloister were awakened by the trumpet of the Saracens; and in the convulsion of the world, every member of a new society ascended to the natural level of his capacity and courage. The minds of the multitude were tempted by the invisible as well as temporal blessings of the Arabian prophet; and charity will hope that many of his proselytes entertained a serious conviction of the truth and sanctity of his revelation. In the eyes of an inquisitive polytheist, it must appear worthy of the human and the divine nature. More pure than the system of Zoroaster, more liberal than the law of Moses, the religion of Mahomet might seem less inconsistent with reason than the creed of mystery and superstition, which, in the seventh century, disgraced the simplicity of the gospel.
穆斯林的征战,都由先知加以神圣的名义;不过在先知一生留下的种种训诫与言行之中,历代哈里发偏偏选取那些讲宽容的教诲,好借此消解异教徒的抵抗之志。阿拉伯半岛是穆罕默德之真主的圣殿与产业;至于世间其余的民族,真主看待起来,猜忌既少,眷爱亦浅。那些不知真主之名的多神教徒与拜偶像者,依教法本可由真主的信徒尽行剿灭196;然而明智的权谋补足了公义所未及之处:在几番不容异己的狂热举动之后,征服印度斯坦的穆斯林终究还是放过了那个虔信而人稠之国的众多庙宇。亚伯拉罕、摩西与耶稣的信徒,都受到郑重的劝请,去接受穆罕默德那更为完备的启示;但他们若宁愿缴纳一笔不重的贡金,也就有权保有信仰与礼拜的自由。197 在战场上,俘虏原本该偿的性命,可凭皈依伊斯兰而赎回;被俘的妇女则必须信奉主人的宗教;至于年幼的俘虏,则经调教而渐渐繁衍出一代诚心的皈依者。然而那千百万非洲与亚洲的皈依者,使阿拉伯本土的信众队伍日益壮大——他们之所以宣称信奉独一真主及真主的使者,多半是受了利诱,而非出于强迫。只消念一句证词、割去一片包皮,无论是臣民还是奴隶、俘虏还是罪犯,转眼之间便成了胜利的穆斯林那自由而平等的同伴。一切罪愆就此涤清,一切旧约就此解除:守贞的誓愿,为顺乎天性的放纵所取代;那些本在修道院中沉睡的活跃心灵,被萨拉森人的号角唤醒;而在这天翻地覆的动荡之中,这新社会的每一分子,都攀升到与自身才干和勇气相称的天然地位。这位阿拉伯先知既许下无形的福报,又许下现世的好处,芸芸众生的心便为之所动;而怀着善意去揣度,我们也愿相信:他的皈依者中,确有许多人真心笃信其启示的真实与神圣。在一个好探究的多神教徒看来,这宗教想必既配得上人性,也配得上神性。它比琐罗亚斯德的体系更为纯净,比摩西的律法更为宽宏;较之七世纪时那套神秘而迷信、玷污了福音本有质朴的教条,穆罕默德的宗教与理性倒似乎没那么相悖。
In the extensive provinces of Persia and Africa, the national religion has been eradicated by the Mahometan faith. The ambiguous theology of the Magi stood alone among the sects of the East; but the profane writings of Zoroaster 198 might, under the reverend name of Abraham, be dexterously connected with the chain of divine revelation. Their evil principle, the daemon Ahriman, might be represented as the rival, or as the creature, of the God of light. The temples of Persia were devoid of images; but the worship of the sun and of fire might be stigmatized as a gross and criminal idolatry. 199 The milder sentiment was consecrated by the practice of Mahomet 200 and the prudence of the caliphs; the Magians or Ghebers were ranked with the Jews and Christians among the people of the written law; 201 and as late as the third century of the Hegira, the city of Herat will afford a lively contrast of private zeal and public toleration. 202 Under the payment of an annual tribute, the Mahometan law secured to the Ghebers of Herat their civil and religious liberties: but the recent and humble mosch was overshadowed by the antique splendor of the adjoining temple of fire. A fanatic Imam deplored, in his sermons, the scandalous neighborhood, and accused the weakness or indifference of the faithful. Excited by his voice, the people assembled in tumult; the two houses of prayer were consumed by the flames, but the vacant ground was immediately occupied by the foundations of a new mosch. The injured Magi appealed to the sovereign of Chorasan; he promised justice and relief; when, behold! four thousand citizens of Herat, of a grave character and mature age, unanimously swore that the idolatrous fane had never existed; the inquisition was silenced and their conscience was satisfied (says the historian Mirchond 203 with this holy and meritorious perjury. 204 But the greatest part of the temples of Persia were ruined by the insensible and general desertion of their votaries.
在波斯与阿非利加那两片辽阔的行省里,本土的宗教已被穆斯林信仰连根拔除。麻葛的神学暧昧含混,在东方诸教派中自成一格;不过琐罗亚斯德那些世俗的著述198,倒也能假借亚伯拉罕的尊名,巧妙地接上神启相传的一脉。他们所奉的恶之本原——魔君阿里曼——则可说成是光明之神的对头,或是光明之神所造之物。波斯的神庙里并无偶像;然而对日与火的崇拜,仍可被斥为一种粗鄙而有罪的偶像崇拜。199 较为温和的看法,则因穆罕默德的先例200与历代哈里发的审慎而得以确立:麻葛教徒(即盖伯尔人)与犹太人、基督徒一道,被列入‘有经之民’201;直到希吉拉三世纪,赫拉特城仍能鲜明地映现出民间的狂热与官方的宽容之间的反差。202 只需缴纳一笔年贡,穆斯林律法便保障赫拉特的盖伯尔人享有其民事与宗教的自由;只是那座新近落成、又颇为简陋的清真寺,为紧邻的古老火庙那份辉煌所掩。一位狂热的伊玛目在讲道时痛惜这毗邻之耻,指斥信徒们不是软弱便是冷漠。民众被他一番话煽动,纷纷聚集起来,闹作一团;两座礼拜之所都付之一炬,那空出的地基上旋即建起了一座新清真寺。受了委屈的麻葛教徒向呼罗珊的君主申诉;君主许诺主持公道、给予补救;不料——你瞧!——赫拉特竟有四千名神情庄重、年高德劭的市民众口一词地起誓,说那座偶像神庙从来不曾存在过;追查就此哑然作罢,而他们的良心(史家米尔洪德203如是说)也因这桩神圣而有功的伪誓而心安理得。204 不过波斯的神庙,大半还是因信徒于不知不觉间普遍弃之而去,才终归荒废的。
It was insensible, since it is not accompanied with any memorial of time or place, of persecution or resistance. It was general, since the whole realm, from Shiraz to Samarcand, imbibed the faith of the Koran; and the preservation of the native tongue reveals the descent of the Mahometans of Persia. 205 In the mountains and deserts, an obstinate race of unbelievers adhered to the superstition of their fathers; and a faint tradition of the Magian theology is kept alive in the province of Kirman, along the banks of the Indus, among the exiles of Surat, and in the colony which, in the last century, was planted by Shaw Abbas at the gates of Ispahan. The chief pontiff has retired to Mount Elbourz, eighteen leagues from the city of Yezd: the perpetual fire (if it continues to burn) is inaccessible to the profane; but his residence is the school, the oracle, and the pilgrimage of the Ghebers, whose hard and uniform features attest the unmingled purity of their blood. Under the jurisdiction of their elders, eighty thousand families maintain an innocent and industrious life: their subsistence is derived from some curious manufactures and mechanic trades; and they cultivate the earth with the fervor of a religious duty. Their ignorance withstood the despotism of Shaw Abbas, who demanded with threats and tortures the prophetic books of Zoroaster; and this obscure remnant of the Magians is spared by the moderation or contempt of their present sovereigns. 206
说“不知不觉”,是因为这一变迁并未留下任何关于时间地点、迫害抵抗的记载。说“普遍”,是因为从设拉子到撒马尔罕,整个国土都吸纳了《古兰经》的信仰;而波斯本土语言的留存,恰恰泄露了波斯穆斯林的血脉出身。205 在山地与荒漠之间,仍有一支顽固的不信道者,死守着祖辈的迷信;麻葛神学那一线微弱的传承,至今尚存活于克尔曼省、印度河两岸、苏拉特的流亡者中间,以及上个世纪沙阿·阿拔斯迁置于伊斯法罕城门外的那处聚居地里。他们的大祭司已隐居到厄尔布尔士山中,离亚兹德城十八里格:那长明之火(倘若仍在燃烧)外人不得亲近;然而他的居所,却是盖伯尔人的学府、神谕所与朝圣之地——这些人棱角分明、形貌一律,正见证着其血统的纯而不杂。在长老们的管辖之下,八万户人家过着无害而勤勉的日子:他们靠一些别致的手工艺与匠作营生,又怀着履行宗教义务般的热忱耕耘土地。沙阿·阿拔斯曾以威胁与酷刑索要琐罗亚斯德的先知典籍,却被他们那份蒙昧挡了回去;而麻葛教徒这一支默默无闻的孑遗,如今则因其君主的宽容——或者说不屑一顾——而得以幸存。206
The Northern coast of Africa is the only land in which the light of the gospel, after a long and perfect establishment, has been totally extinguished. The arts, which had been taught by Carthage and Rome, were involved in a cloud of ignorance; the doctrine of Cyprian and Augustin was no longer studied. Five hundred episcopal churches were overturned by the hostile fury of the Donatists, the Vandals, and the Moors. The zeal and numbers of the clergy declined; and the people, without discipline, or knowledge, or hope, submissively sunk under the yoke of the Arabian prophet. Within fifty years after the expulsion of the Greeks, a lieutenant of Africa informed the caliph that the tribute of the infidels was abolished by their conversion; 207 and, though he sought to disguise his fraud and rebellion, his specious pretence was drawn from the rapid and extensive progress of the Mahometan faith. In the next age, an extraordinary mission of five bishops was detached from Alexandria to Cairoan. They were ordained by the Jacobite patriarch to cherish and revive the dying embers of Christianity: 208 but the interposition of a foreign prelate, a stranger to the Latins, an enemy to the Catholics, supposes the decay and dissolution of the African hierarchy. It was no longer the time when the successor of St. Cyprian, at the head of a numerous synod, could maintain an equal contest with the ambition of the Roman pontiff. In the eleventh century, the unfortunate priest who was seated on the ruins of Carthage implored the arms and the protection of the Vatican; and he bitterly complains that his naked body had been scourged by the Saracens, and that his authority was disputed by the four suffragans, the tottering pillars of his throne. Two epistles of Gregory the Seventh 209 are destined to soothe the distress of the Catholics and the pride of a Moorish prince. The pope assures the sultan that they both worship the same God, and may hope to meet in the bosom of Abraham; but the complaint that three bishops could no longer be found to consecrate a brother, announces the speedy and inevitable ruin of the episcopal order. The Christians of Africa and Spain had long since submitted to the practice of circumcision and the legal abstinence from wine and pork; and the name of Mozarabes 210 (adoptive Arabs) was applied to their civil or religious conformity. 211 About the middle of the twelfth century, the worship of Christ and the succession of pastors were abolished along the coast of Barbary, and in the kingdoms of Cordova and Seville, of Valencia and Grenada. 212 The throne of the Almohades, or Unitarians, was founded on the blindest fanaticism, and their extraordinary rigor might be provoked or justified by the recent victories and intolerant zeal of the princes of Sicily and Castille, of Arragon and Portugal. The faith of the Mozarabes was occasionally revived by the papal missionaries; and, on the landing of Charles the Fifth, some families of Latin Christians were encouraged to rear their heads at Tunis and Algiers. But the seed of the gospel was quickly eradicated, and the long province from Tripoli to the Atlantic has lost all memory of the language and religion of Rome. 213
非洲北岸是唯一一片这样的土地:福音之光曾在此长久而稳固地立足,最终却被彻底熄灭。迦太基与罗马昔日传授的种种技艺,尽陷于蒙昧的迷雾之中;西普里安与奥古斯丁的教义,也再无人研习。五百座主教座堂,在多纳图斯派、汪达尔人与摩尔人的仇恨与暴怒之下倾覆殆尽。教士的热忱与人数俱衰;民众既无教规约束,又乏学识与指望,只得驯顺地俯首于阿拉伯先知的轭下。希腊人被逐出阿非利加后不出五十年,当地一位总督便禀报哈里发说:异教徒既已皈依,那份贡赋自然免除了207;他这番话虽是要掩饰自己的欺瞒与反叛,其冠冕堂皇的托词,却也确实取自穆斯林信仰那迅猛而广泛的扩张。到了下一个时代,亚历山大里亚特派了一个由五位主教组成的非常使团,前往凯鲁万。他们由雅各派的牧首祝圣,受命去守护并重燃基督教那奄奄一息的余烬208;然而竟要一位外来的高级教士出面干预——此人于拉丁教会是外人,于公教是仇敌——这本身就说明非洲的教阶体系已然朽坏瓦解。曾几何时,圣西普里安的继任者尚能统领一众与会主教,与罗马教宗的野心分庭抗礼;如今那样的岁月早已一去不返。到了十一世纪,那位困守迦太基废墟的可怜教士,只得恳求梵蒂冈出兵庇护;他痛切地诉说:自己曾被萨拉森人剥去衣衫、施以鞭笞,而他的权威还遭到四位副主教的质疑——这四人,本该是支撑其宝座的栋梁,如今却摇摇欲坠。格列高利七世有两封书信209,意在安抚公教徒的困厄,同时也安抚一位摩尔君主的骄矜。教宗向这位苏丹保证:双方所敬奉的原是同一位上帝,来日或可同归于亚伯拉罕的怀抱;然而他抱怨说,如今连凑齐三位主教为一位同僚祝圣都已办不到——这便预告了主教品级迅速而不可挽回的覆灭。非洲与西班牙的基督徒,早已顺从了割礼之俗,也依教法戒绝酒与猪肉;“莫扎拉布人”210(意即“归化的阿拉伯人”)这一称呼,便是用来指他们在民事或宗教上的这种趋同。211 约在十二世纪中叶,沿巴巴里海岸一带,以及科尔多瓦、塞维利亚、巴伦西亚与格拉纳达诸王国境内,对基督的崇拜与牧者的传承都被废除了。212 阿尔摩哈德王朝(即“一位论派”)的王座,建立在最盲目的狂热之上;他们那异乎寻常的严酷,或许正是为西西里、卡斯蒂利亚、阿拉贡与葡萄牙诸君近来的胜利及其不容异己的热忱所激起——由此看来,倒也情有可原。莫扎拉布人的信仰,偶尔也会因教宗派来的传教士而重新振作;查理五世登陆之际,还有若干拉丁基督徒家庭受到鼓舞,在突尼斯与阿尔及尔重新抬起头来。然而福音的种子很快就被铲除了;从的黎波里到大西洋这一狭长地带,对罗马的语言与宗教已尽数忘却,再无一丝记忆。213
After the revolution of eleven centuries, the Jews and Christians of the Turkish empire enjoy the liberty of conscience which was granted by the Arabian caliphs. During the first age of the conquest, they suspected the loyalty of the Catholics, whose name of Melchites betrayed their secret attachment to the Greek emperor, while the Nestorians and Jacobites, his inveterate enemies, approved themselves the sincere and voluntary friends of the Mahometan government. 214 Yet this partial jealousy was healed by time and submission; the churches of Egypt were shared with the Catholics; 215 and all the Oriental sects were included in the common benefits of toleration. The rank, the immunities, the domestic jurisdiction of the patriarchs, the bishops, and the clergy, were protected by the civil magistrate: the learning of individuals recommended them to the employments of secretaries and physicians: they were enriched by the lucrative collection of the revenue; and their merit was sometimes raised to the command of cities and provinces. A caliph of the house of Abbas was heard to declare that the Christians were most worthy of trust in the administration of Persia. “The Moslems,” said he, “will abuse their present fortune; the Magians regret their fallen greatness; and the Jews are impatient for their approaching deliverance.” 216 But the slaves of despotism are exposed to the alternatives of favor and disgrace. The captive churches of the East have been afflicted in every age by the avarice or bigotry of their rulers; and the ordinary and legal restraints must be offensive to the pride, or the zeal, of the Christians. 217 About two hundred years after Mahomet, they were separated from their fellow-subjects by a turban or girdle of a less honorable color; instead of horses or mules. they were condemned to ride on asses, in the attitude of women. Their public and private building were measured by a diminutive standard; in the streets or the baths it is their duty to give way or bow down before the meanest of the people; and their testimony is rejected, if it may tend to the prejudice of a true believer. The pomp of processions, the sound of bells or of psalmody, is interdicted in their worship; a decent reverence for the national faith is imposed on their sermons and conversations; and the sacrilegious attempt to enter a mosch, or to seduce a Mussulman, will not be suffered to escape with impunity. In a time, however, of tranquillity and justice, the Christians have never been compelled to renounce the Gospel, or to embrace the Koran; but the punishment of death is inflicted upon the apostates who have professed and deserted the law of Mahomet. The martyrs of Cordova provoked the sentence of the cadhi, by the public confession of their inconstancy, or their passionate invectives against the person and religion of the prophet. 218
十一个世纪流转而下,土耳其帝国境内的犹太人与基督徒,如今仍享有当年阿拉伯哈里发所赐予的信仰自由。在征服之初的年月里,阿拉伯人对公教徒的忠诚心存疑虑——“麦尔基派”这个名号,本就泄露了他们暗中对希腊皇帝的依恋;反倒是希腊皇帝的宿敌聂斯脱利派与雅各派,表明自己是穆斯林政权真心而自愿的盟友。214 不过这种偏颇的猜忌,终因时日流逝与臣服既久而消弭;埃及的教堂也分与公教徒共用215;东方各教派于是一并纳入了宽容政策的共同惠泽之中。牧首、主教与教士们的品级、豁免权以及内部的管辖之权,都受到世俗官府的保护:个别人凭其学识,得以充任书记与御医;他们又因经手油水丰厚的税收征缴而致富;有的更因才干出众而受拔擢,委以城邑乃至行省的治权。阿拔斯家族的一位哈里发曾公然宣称:在波斯的治理上,基督徒最是可以信托。“穆斯林嘛,”他说,“会滥用眼下的好运;麻葛教徒念念不忘他们失落的荣光;犹太人则急不可耐,盼着那行将到来的救赎。”216 然而,专制之下的奴仆,注定要在恩宠与失势之间反复起落。东方那些被征服的教会,历朝历代都饱受统治者贪婪或偏执之苦;即便是寻常而合法的种种约束,也难免要刺痛基督徒的自尊或热忱。217 穆罕默德之后约二百年,他们被勒令佩戴颜色较不体面的头巾或腰带,借此与其余臣民区别开来;他们不得骑马或骑骡,只准像妇人那样侧坐着骑驴。他们无论公私建筑,都须按一套缩小的标准建造;在街市或浴场,遇见最卑贱的平民也得让路或躬身;他们的证词,凡可能有损于一名真信者的,一概不予采信。他们礼拜之时,禁绝一切盛大的游行,也不许钟声与颂唱之声传出;他们的讲道与言谈,都须对国教保持相当的敬意;至于擅闯清真寺、或诱使穆斯林改宗这类亵渎之举,则断不容其逍遥法外。然而,在太平清明之世,基督徒却从未被强迫背弃福音或皈依《古兰经》;唯有那些曾信奉穆罕默德教法、后又背弃者,才会被处以死刑。科尔多瓦的那些殉道者,之所以招来卡迪的死刑判决,或是因为公开招认自己变节反复,或是因为激烈地辱骂先知其人及其宗教。218
At the end of the first century of the Hegira, the caliphs were the most potent and absolute monarchs of the globe. Their prerogative was not circumscribed, either in right or in fact, by the power of the nobles, the freedom of the commons, the privileges of the church, the votes of a senate, or the memory of a free constitution. The authority of the companions of Mahomet expired with their lives; and the chiefs or emirs of the Arabian tribes left behind, in the desert, the spirit of equality and independence. The regal and sacerdotal characters were united in the successors of Mahomet; and if the Koran was the rule of their actions, they were the supreme judges and interpreters of that divine book. They reigned by the right of conquest over the nations of the East, to whom the name of liberty was unknown, and who were accustomed to applaud in their tyrants the acts of violence and severity that were exercised at their own expense. Under the last of the Ommiades, the Arabian empire extended two hundred days’ journey from east to west, from the confines of Tartary and India to the shores of the Atlantic Ocean. And if we retrench the sleeve of the robe, as it is styled by their writers, the long and narrow province of Africa, the solid and compact dominion from Fargana to Aden, from Tarsus to Surat, will spread on every side to the measure of four or five months of the march of a caravan. 219 We should vainly seek the indissoluble union and easy obedience that pervaded the government of Augustus and the Antonines; but the progress of the Mahometan religion diffused over this ample space a general resemblance of manners and opinions. The language and laws of the Koran were studied with equal devotion at Samarcand and Seville: the Moor and the Indian embraced as countrymen and brothers in the pilgrimage of Mecca; and the Arabian language was adopted as the popular idiom in all the provinces to the westward of the Tigris. 220
到希吉拉第一个世纪之末,哈里发已是全世界权势最盛、最为专断的君主。他们的大权无所约束,于法于实皆然:贵族的势力、平民的自由、教会的特权、元老院的表决,乃至对昔日自由政制的追念,都不足以对它有丝毫限制。穆罕默德那些门弟子的权威,随其性命一同消逝;阿拉伯各部的酋长、埃米尔们,也把平等独立的精神一并留在了大漠之中。穆罕默德的继承者们,集君王与祭司二重身份于一身;《古兰经》固然是他们行事的准绳,可他们又正是这部神圣典籍至高的裁断者与诠释者。他们凭征服之权,统治着东方诸民族——这些民族素来不知“自由”为何物,反倒惯于为暴君喝彩,哪怕那些暴烈严酷之举,损的正是他们自己。到末代倭马亚君主治下,阿拉伯帝国东西横亘二百天的路程,从鞑靼与印度的边界,一直延伸到大西洋之滨。如果我们把他们的文人所谓“袍袖”——即阿非利加那狭长的行省——截去不算,那么这片疆土坚实而紧凑,自费尔干纳到亚丁、自塔尔苏斯到苏拉特,无论朝哪个方向,都足有一支商队四五个月的行程之广。219 若想在这里寻见奥古斯都与安敦尼诸帝治下那种牢不可破的统一、那种甘心顺从的风气,终归是徒劳;然而穆斯林宗教的传布,却使这片广袤之域在习俗与观念上大体趋于一致。《古兰经》的语言与律法,在撒马尔罕和塞维利亚受到同样虔诚的钻研;摩尔人与印度人在麦加朝觐途中,如同乡里兄弟般彼此相拥;阿拉伯语则在底格里斯河以西的所有行省,成为通行的日常用语。220

Notes 注释

183
The honorable relics of the Cantabrian war (Dion Cassius, l. liii p. 720) were planted in this metropolis of Lusitania, perhaps of Spain, (submittit cui tota suos Hispania fasces.) Nonius (Hispania, c. 31, p. 106-110) enumerates the ancient structures, but concludes with a sigh: Urbs haec olim nobilissima ad magnam incolarum infrequentiam delapsa est, et praeter priscae claritatis ruinas nihil ostendit.
坎塔布里亚战争中光荣的老兵(Dion Cassius, l. liii p. 720),便安置在卢西塔尼亚——或可说是全西班牙——的这座都会里(submittit cui tota suos Hispania fasces,意为“全西班牙俯首向它奉上权柄”)。诺尼乌斯(Nonius, Hispania, c. 31, p. 106-110)一一列举了城中的古建,却在末尾发出一声叹息:Urbs haec olim nobilissima ad magnam incolarum infrequentiam delapsa est, et praeter priscae claritatis ruinas nihil ostendit(此城昔日至为显赫,如今却人烟凋敝,除却往昔荣光的断壁残垣,别无所有)。
184
Both the interpreters of Novairi, De Guignes (Hist. des Huns, tom. i. p. 349) and Cardonne, (Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne, tom. i. p. 93, 94, 104, 135,) lead Musa into the Narbonnese Gaul. But I find no mention of this enterprise, either in Roderic of Toledo, or the Mss. of the Escurial, and the invasion of the Saracens is postponed by a French chronicle till the ixth year after the conquest of Spain, A.D. 721, (Pagi, Critica, tom. iii. p. 177, 195. Historians of France, tom. iii.) I much question whether Musa ever passed the Pyrenees.
努韦里的两位注释者——德经(De Guignes, Hist. des Huns, tom. i. p. 349)与卡尔多纳(Cardonne, Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne, tom. i. p. 93, 94, 104, 135)——都把穆萨引到了纳博讷高卢。但无论在托莱多的罗德里克笔下,还是在埃斯科里亚尔的抄本中,我都找不到这场行动的记载;而据一部法兰西编年史,萨拉森人的这次入侵要迟至征服西班牙之后第九年、即公元721年才发生(Pagi, Critica, tom. iii. p. 177, 195. Historians of France, tom. iii.)。穆萨究竟是否真的翻越过比利牛斯山,我深表怀疑。
185
Four hundred years after Theodemir, his territories of Murcia and Carthagena retain in the Nubian geographer Edrisi (p, 154, 161) the name of Tadmir, (D’Anville, Etats de l’Europe, p. 156. Pagi, tom. iii. p. 174.) In the present decay of Spanish agriculture, Mr. Swinburne (Travels into Spain, p. 119) surveyed with pleasure the delicious valley from Murcia to Orihuela, four leagues and a half of the finest corn pulse, lucerne, oranges, &c.
狄奥德米尔身后四百年,在努比亚地理学家伊德里西(p. 154, 161)的著述里,他昔日的领地穆尔西亚与卡塔赫纳仍保留着“塔德米尔”这一名称(D’Anville, Etats de l’Europe, p. 156. Pagi, tom. iii. p. 174)。当今西班牙农业虽已衰败,斯温伯恩先生(Travels into Spain, p. 119)却仍饶有兴致地踏勘了从穆尔西亚到奥里韦拉那片肥美的谷地——绵延四里格半,尽是上好的谷物、豆蔬、苜蓿、柑橘之属。
1851
Gibbon has made eight cities: in Conde’s translation Bigera does not appear.—M.
吉本列出了八座城:而在孔代的译本中,并无比赫拉一城。—M
186
See the treaty in Arabic and Latin, in the Bibliotheca Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 105, 106. It is signed the 4th of the month of Regeb, A. H. 94, the 5th of April, A.D. 713; a date which seems to prolong the resistance of Theodemir, and the government of Musa.
该和约的阿拉伯文与拉丁文本,见 Bibliotheca Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 105, 106。约上署有立约之日:希吉拉94年赖哲卜月4日,即公元713年4月5日;这一日期,似乎把狄奥德米尔的抵抗与穆萨的治理都往后延长了些。
187
From the history of Sandoval, p. 87. Fleury (Hist. Eccles. tom. ix. p. 261) has given the substance of another treaty concluded A Ae. C. 782, A.D. 734, between an Arabian chief and the Goths and Romans, of the territory of Conimbra in Portugal. The tax of the churches is fixed at twenty-five pounds of gold; of the monasteries, fifty; of the cathedrals, one hundred; the Christians are judged by their count, but in capital cases he must consult the alcaide. The church doors must be shut, and they must respect the name of Mahomet. I have not the original before me; it would confirm or destroy a dark suspicion, that the piece has been forged to introduce the immunity of a neighboring convent.
材料出自桑多瓦尔的史书(p. 87)。弗勒里(Hist. Eccles. tom. ix. p. 261)转述了另一份和约的大意:该约缔于西班牙纪元782年、即公元734年,立约双方是一位阿拉伯首领与葡萄牙科英布拉地区的哥特人及罗马人。约中规定:教堂纳税二十五磅黄金,隐修院五十磅,主教座堂一百磅;基督徒由其伯爵审断,但遇死刑案件,伯爵须征询阿尔凯德的意见。教堂大门须时时关闭,众人须敬奉穆罕默德之名。原件我手头没有;否则倒可证实或推翻一桩隐隐的疑虑:这份文书,或许是为给附近某座隐修院张目、争取豁免而伪造出来的。
188
This design, which is attested by several Arabian historians, (Cardonne, tom. i. p. 95, 96,) may be compared with that of Mithridates, to march from the Crimaea to Rome; or with that of Caesar, to conquer the East, and return home by the North; and all three are perhaps surpassed by the real and successful enterprise of Hannibal.
这一图谋,有好几位阿拉伯史家可资佐证(Cardonne, tom. i. p. 95, 96);它可与米特拉达梯从克里米亚进军罗马的计划相比,或与恺撒东征、再取道北方还师的构想相比;而这三者,或许都不及汉尼拔那桩确曾付诸实施且大获成功的壮举。
189
I much regret our loss, or my ignorance, of two Arabic works of the viiith century, a Life of Musa, and a poem on the exploits of Tarik. Of these authentic pieces, the former was composed by a grandson of Musa, who had escaped from the massacre of his kindred; the latter, by the vizier of the first Abdalrahman, caliph of Spain, who might have conversed with some of the veterans of the conqueror, (Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 36, 139.)
有两部八世纪的阿拉伯文著作——一部《穆萨传》,一部咏塔里克功业的长诗——如今或已散佚,或为我所不知,实在令我惋惜不已。这两部真作,前者出自穆萨一位孙子之手,他从家族遭屠戮中侥幸逃生;后者则出自西班牙首位哈里发阿卜杜勒·拉赫曼的维齐尔之手,此人或许曾与几位追随过那位征服者的老兵交谈过(Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 36, 139)。
190
Bibliot. Arab. Hispana, tom. ii. p. 32, 252. The former of these quotations is taken from a Biographia Hispanica, by an Arabian of Valentia, (see the copious Extracts of Casiri, tom. ii. p. 30-121;) and the latter from a general Chronology of the Caliphs, and of the African and Spanish Dynasties, with a particular History of the kingdom of Grenada, of which Casiri has given almost an entire version, (Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 177-319.) The author, Ebn Khateb, a native of Grenada, and a contemporary of Novairi and Abulfeda, (born A.D. 1313, died A.D. 1374,) was an historian, geographer, physician, poet, &c., (tom. ii. p. 71, 72.)
Bibliot. Arab. Hispana, tom. ii. p. 32, 252。上引两处,前一处出自一位瓦伦提亚阿拉伯人所著的《西班牙名人传》(Biographia Hispanica,参见卡西里所辑的大量摘录,tom. ii. p. 30-121);后一处则出自一部历代哈里发暨非洲、西班牙诸王朝的通史,其中另有格拉纳达王国专史一种,卡西里几乎全文迻译(Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 177-319)。此书作者伊本·哈提卜是格拉纳达本地人,与努韦里、阿布尔费达同时(生于公元1313年,卒于公元1374年),身兼史家、地理学家、医师、诗人等数职(tom. ii. p. 71, 72)。
191
Cardonne, Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne, tom. i. p. 116, 117.
Cardonne, Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne, tom. i. p. 116, 117.
192
A copious treatise of husbandry, by an Arabian of Seville, in the xiith century, is in the Escurial library, and Casiri had some thoughts of translating it. He gives a list of the authors quoted, Arabs as well as Greeks, Latins, &c.; but it is much if the Andalusian saw these strangers through the medium of his countryman Columella, (Casiri, Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. i. p. 323-338.)
埃斯科里亚尔图书馆藏有一部内容详赡的农事论著,出自十二世纪一位塞维利亚阿拉伯人之手,卡西里一度有意将它译出。他开列了书中所引诸家名录,既有阿拉伯人,也有希腊人、拉丁人等等;不过,这位安达卢西亚人多半只是隔着其同乡科卢梅拉这一层,才得以窥见那些异邦作者罢了(Casiri, Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. i. p. 323-338)。
193
Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 104. Casiri translates the original testimony of the historian Rasis, as it is alleged in the Arabic Biographia Hispanica, pars ix. But I am most exceedingly surprised at the address, Principibus caeterisque Christianis, Hispanis suis Castellae. The name of Castellae was unknown in the viiith century; the kingdom was not erected till the year 1022, a hundred years after the time of Rasis, (Bibliot. tom. ii. p. 330,) and the appellation was always expressive, not of a tributary province, but of a line of castles independent of the Moorish yoke, (D’Anville, Etats de l’Europe, p. 166-170.) Had Casiri been a critic, he would have cleared a difficulty, perhaps of his own making.
Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 104。卡西里译出了史家拉齐斯的原始记述——据称此说见于阿拉伯文《西班牙名人传》第九卷。但其中一句称呼——Principibus caeterisque Christianis, Hispanis suis Castellae(致卡斯蒂利亚的诸君侯及其余基督徒、西班牙臣民)——却令我大为惊讶。“卡斯蒂利亚”(Castellae)之名,在八世纪根本无人知晓;该王国迟至1022年才建立,比拉齐斯在世之时晚了整整一百年(Bibliot. tom. ii. p. 330),而且这个称谓所指的,从来不是什么纳贡的行省,而是一列不受摩尔人羁轭的城堡(D’Anville, Etats de l’Europe, p. 166-170)。卡西里若是个有考订眼光的人,本可澄清这一难点——何况这难点,或许正是他自己造出来的。
194
Cardonne, tom. i. p. 337, 338. He computes the revenue at 130,000,000 of French livres. The entire picture of peace and prosperity relieves the bloody uniformity of the Moorish annals.
Cardonne, tom. i. p. 337, 338。他把这笔岁入折算为一亿三千万法国里弗尔。这样一幅太平繁盛的全景,多少冲淡了摩尔人编年史里那一味的血腥单调。
195
I am happy enough to possess a splendid and interesting work which has only been distributed in presents by the court of Madrid Bibliotheca Arabico-Hispana Escurialensis, opera et studio Michaelis Casiri, Syro Maronitoe. Matriti, in folio, tomus prior, 1760, tomus posterior, 1770. The execution of this work does honor to the Spanish press; the Mss., to the number of MDCCCLI., are judiciously classed by the editor, and his copious extracts throw some light on the Mahometan literature and history of Spain. These relics are now secure, but the task has been supinely delayed, till, in the year 1671, a fire consumed the greatest part of the Escurial library, rich in the spoils of Grenada and Morocco. * Note: Compare the valuable work of Conde, Historia de la Dominacion de las Arabes en Espana. Madrid, 1820.—M.
我很幸运地藏有一部华美而饶有趣味的著作,它此前只作为马德里宫廷的赠礼分发过——Bibliotheca Arabico-Hispana Escurialensis, opera et studio Michaelis Casiri, Syro Maronitoe. Matriti, in folio, tomus prior, 1760, tomus posterior, 1770(即《埃斯科里亚尔藏阿拉伯-西班牙文库》,叙利亚马龙派人卡西里编纂,马德里对开本,上卷1760年、下卷1770年出版)。此书的制作为西班牙印刷业增光;所收抄本多达1851种,经编者审慎分类,其大量摘录亦为西班牙的穆斯林文学与历史投下了些许光亮。这批珍藏如今虽已无虞,整理之事却被慵懒地一再拖延,直到1671年,一场大火烧毁了埃斯科里亚尔图书馆的大半藏书——那里本收藏着从格拉纳达和摩洛哥掠来的大批珍籍。* 注:可与孔代的力作相参看,Historia de la Dominacion de las Arabes en Espana(《阿拉伯人在西班牙的统治史》),马德里,1820年。—M
196
The Harbii, as they are styled, qui tolerari nequeunt, are, 1. Those who, besides God, worship the sun, moon, or idols. 2. Atheists, Utrique, quamdiu princeps aliquis inter Mohammedanos superest, oppugnari debent donec religionem amplectantur, nec requies iis concedenda est, nec pretium acceptandum pro obtinenda conscientiae libertate, (Reland, Dissertat. x. de Jure Militari Mohammedan. tom. iii. p. 14;) a rigid theory!
所谓“哈尔比”(Harbii,qui tolerari nequeunt,意即“不可容忍者”)分两类:一、除真主之外,还崇拜日、月或偶像者;二、无神论者。Utrique, quamdiu princeps aliquis inter Mohammedanos superest, oppugnari debent donec religionem amplectantur, nec requies iis concedenda est, nec pretium acceptandum pro obtinenda conscientiae libertate(对这两类人,只要穆斯林中尚有一位君主在位,就应对其征讨,直至他们皈依为止;不得给他们以喘息,也不得收取任何赎金以让他们换取信仰自由)(Reland, Dissertat. x. de Jure Militari Mohammedan. tom. iii. p. 14)——好一套严酷的理论!
197
The distinction between a proscribed and a tolerated sect, between the Harbii and the people of the Book, the believers in some divine revelation, is correctly defined in the conversation of the caliph Al Mamum with the idolaters or Sabaeans of Charrae, (Hottinger, Hist. Orient. p. 107, 108.)
被取缔的教派与获容忍的教派之间、即“哈尔比”与“有经之民”(亦即某种神启的信奉者)之间的分野,在哈里发马蒙同哈兰的拜偶像者(或曰萨巴人)的一番对话里,界定得十分准确(Hottinger, Hist. Orient. p. 107, 108)。
198
The Zend or Pazend, the bible of the Ghebers, is reckoned by themselves, or at least by the Mahometans, among the ten books which Abraham received from heaven; and their religion is honorably styled the religion of Abraham, (D’Herblot, Bibliot. Orient. p. 701; Hyde, de Religione veterum Persarum, c, iii. p. 27, 28, &c.) I much fear that we do not possess any pure and free description of the system of Zoroaster. 1981 Dr. Prideaux (Connection, vol. i. p. 300, octavo) adopts the opinion, that he had been the slave and scholar of some Jewish prophet in the captivity of Babylon. Perhaps the Persians, who have been the masters of the Jews, would assert the honor, a poor honor, of being their masters.
《曾德》(Zend)或《帕赞德》(Pazend)——盖伯尔人的圣典——据他们自己、或至少据穆斯林的说法,位列亚伯拉罕自天上领受的十部经书之中;他们的宗教也因此被尊称为“亚伯拉罕的宗教”(D’Herblot, Bibliot. Orient. p. 701; Hyde, de Religione veterum Persarum, c. iii. p. 27, 28, &c.)。我很担心,我们手头并无任何一部纯正而不受拘束地记述琐罗亚斯德体系的文献。1981 普里多博士(Connection, vol. i. p. 300, octavo)采信这样一种看法:琐罗亚斯德曾是巴比伦之囚期间某位犹太先知的奴仆兼门徒。也许,曾经做过犹太人主子的波斯人,倒愿意来争这个当他们主子的荣耀——一份可怜的荣耀。
1981
Whatever the real age of the Zendavesta, published by Anquetil du Perron, whether of the time of Ardeschir Babeghan, according to Mr. Erskine, or of much higher antiquity, it may be considered, I conceive, both a “pure and a free,” though imperfect, description of Zoroastrianism; particularly with the illustrations of the original translator, and of the German Kleuker—M.
昂克蒂尔·迪佩龙刊布的《阿维斯塔》,其真实年代究竟属于何时——照厄斯金先生的说法是阿尔达希尔·巴贝甘之世,抑或远为古老——姑且不论,我以为都可视作对琐罗亚斯德教一份‘纯正而不受拘束’、尽管并不完备的记述;尤其若参照那位原译者以及德国人克洛伊克的注疏,便更是如此。—M
199
The Arabian Nights, a faithful and amusing picture of the Oriental world, represent in the most odious colors of the Magians, or worshippers of fire, to whom they attribute the annual sacrifice of a Mussulman. The religion of Zoroaster has not the least affinity with that of the Hindoos, yet they are often confounded by the Mahometans; and the sword of Timour was sharpened by this mistake, (Hist. de Timour Bec, par Cherefeddin Ali Yezdi, l. v.)
《一千零一夜》既真实又有趣地描绘了东方世界,其中把麻葛教徒(即拜火者)刻画得极其可憎,说他们每年都要拿一名穆斯林作牺牲献祭。琐罗亚斯德的宗教与印度人的宗教毫无半点渊源,穆斯林却常把二者混为一谈;帖木儿的刀锋,正是因这一误解而愈发锋利(Hist. de Timour Bec, par Cherefeddin Ali Yezdi, l. v.)。
200
Vie de Mahomet, par Gagnier, (tom. iii. p. 114, 115.)
Vie de Mahomet, par Gagnier, (tom. iii. p. 114, 115.)
201
Hae tres sectae, Judaei, Christiani, et qui inter Persas Magorum institutis addicti sunt, populi libri dicuntur, (Reland, Dissertat. tom. iii. p. 15.) The caliph Al Mamun confirms this honorable distinction in favor of the three sects, with the vague and equivocal religion of the Sabaeans, under which the ancient polytheists of Charrae were allowed to shelter their idolatrous worship, (Hottinger, Hist. Orient p. 167, 168.)
Hae tres sectae, Judaei, Christiani, et qui inter Persas Magorum institutis addicti sunt, populi libri dicuntur(此三派——犹太人、基督徒,以及波斯人中信奉麻葛教规者——皆称为“有经之民”)(Reland, Dissertat. tom. iii. p. 15)。哈里发马蒙确认了对这三派的荣誉性区别待遇,并将萨巴人那含糊暧昧的宗教也一并纳入——哈兰的古代多神教徒,便得以借这层名义遮掩其偶像崇拜(Hottinger, Hist. Orient p. 167, 168)。
202
This singular story is related by D’Herbelot, (Bibliot. Orient. p 448, 449,) on the faith of Khondemir, and by Mirchond himself, (Hist priorum Regum Persarum, &c., p. 9, 10, not. p. 88, 89.)
这个奇特的故事,由埃尔布洛转述(D’Herbelot, Bibliot. Orient. p. 448, 449),所据是洪德米尔的说法;米尔洪德本人也有记载(Hist priorum Regum Persarum, &c., p. 9, 10, not. p. 88, 89)。
203
Mirchond, (Mohammed Emir Khoondah Shah,) a native of Herat, composed in the Persian language a general history of the East, from the creation to the year of the Hegira 875, (A.D. 1471.) In the year 904 (A.D. 1498) the historian obtained the command of a princely library, and his applauded work, in seven or twelve parts, was abbreviated in three volumes by his son Khondemir, A. H. 927, A.D. 1520. The two writers, most accurately distinguished by Petit de la Croix, (Hist. de Genghizcan, p.537, 538, 544, 545,) are loosely confounded by D’Herbelot, (p. 358, 410, 994, 995: ) but his numerous extracts, under the improper name of Khondemir, belong to the father rather than the son. The historian of Genghizcan refers to a Ms. of Mirchond, which he received from the hands of his friend D’Herbelot himself. A curious fragment (the Taherian and Soffarian Dynasties) has been lately published in Persic and Latin, (Viennae, 1782, in 4to., cum notis Bernard de Jenisch;) and the editor allows us to hope for a continuation of Mirchond.
米尔洪德(Mohammed Emir Khoondah Shah,穆罕默德·埃米尔·洪达·沙)是赫拉特本地人,曾用波斯语撰写一部东方通史,起自创世,讫于希吉拉875年(公元1471年)。904年(公元1498年),这位史家获准执掌一座王室图书馆;他那部广受赞誉的著作,共七卷或十二卷,后由其子洪德米尔缩编为三卷,成于希吉拉927年、即公元1520年。这两位作者,佩蒂·德拉克鲁瓦(Hist. de Genghizcan, p. 537, 538, 544, 545)区分得最为精确,埃尔布洛(p. 358, 410, 994, 995)却把二人含混地混为一谈;不过埃尔布洛冠以“洪德米尔”这一不确切名号所辑的大量摘录,其实多半属于父亲而非儿子。那位《成吉思汗史》的作者提到过一部米尔洪德的抄本,是他从好友埃尔布洛本人手中得来的。近来又有一份耐人寻味的残篇(记塔希尔王朝与萨法尔王朝)以波斯文和拉丁文刊行(Viennae, 1782, in 4to., cum notis Bernard de Jenisch);编者还让我们有望读到米尔洪德著作的续篇。
204
Quo testimonio boni se quidpiam praestitisse opinabantur. Yet Mirchond must have condemned their zeal, since he approved the legal toleration of the Magi, cui (the fire temple) peracto singulis annis censu uti sacra Mohammedis lege cautum, ab omnibus molestiis ac oneribus libero esse licuit.
Quo testimonio boni se quidpiam praestitisse opinabantur(他们自以为凭这番作证做成了一桩善举)。然而米尔洪德想必是谴责他们这份狂热的,因为他赞同律法对麻葛的容忍:cui (the fire temple) peracto singulis annis censu uti sacra Mohammedis lege cautum, ab omnibus molestiis ac oneribus libero esse licuit(依穆罕默德的神圣律法,那座火庙只要每年缴纳规定的赋税,便获准免受一切滋扰与负担)。
205
The last Magian of name and power appears to be Mardavige the Dilemite, who, in the beginning of the 10th century, reigned in the northern provinces of Persia, near the Caspian Sea, (D’Herbelot, Bibliot. Orient. p. 355.) But his soldiers and successors, the Bowides either professed or embraced the Mahometan faith; and under their dynasty (A.D. 933-1020) I should say the fall of the religion of Zoroaster.
最后一位有名望、有权势的麻葛教徒,似乎当属德莱木人马尔达维杰;十世纪初,他统治着波斯北部、里海一带的诸行省(D’Herbelot, Bibliot. Orient. p. 355)。但他的部众与继承者布韦希人,却或是本就信奉、或是转而皈依了穆斯林信仰;我以为,琐罗亚斯德宗教的覆亡,正当其王朝之世(公元933至1020年)。
206
The present state of the Ghebers in Persia is taken from Sir John Chardin, not indeed the most learned, but the most judicious and inquisitive of our modern travellers, (Voyages en Perse, tom. ii. p. 109, 179-187, in 4to.) His brethren, Pietro della Valle, Olearius, Thevenot, Tavernier, &c., whom I have fruitlessly searched, had neither eyes nor attention for this interesting people.
盖伯尔人在波斯的现状,取自约翰·夏尔丹爵士的记述——在我们这些近代旅行家中,他虽算不上最博学,却是最有见识、最富探究之心的一位(Voyages en Perse, tom. ii. p. 109, 179-187, in 4to.)。至于他的同侪彼得罗·德拉·瓦莱、奥莱亚里乌斯、泰夫诺、塔韦尼耶等人,我遍查其著作却一无所获——他们对这个有趣的民族既无眼力,也无心留意。
207
The letter of Abdoulrahman, governor or tyrant of Africa, to the caliph Aboul Abbas, the first of the Abbassides, is dated A. H. 132 Cardonne, (Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne, tom. i. p. 168.)
阿卜杜勒·拉赫曼——阿非利加的总督(或曰僭主)——写给阿拔斯王朝首位哈里发艾布·阿拔斯的那封信,注明的日期是希吉拉132年(Cardonne, Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne, tom. i. p. 168)。
208
Bibliotheque Orientale, p. 66. Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 287, 288.
Bibliotheque Orientale, p. 66. Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 287, 288.
209
Among the Epistles of the Popes, see Leo IX. epist. 3; Gregor. VII. l. i. epist. 22, 23, l. iii. epist. 19, 20, 21; and the criticisms of Pagi, (tom. iv. A.D. 1053, No. 14, A.D. 1073, No. 13,) who investigates the name and family of the Moorish prince, with whom the proudest of the Roman pontiffs so politely corresponds.
在历代教宗的书信集中,可参看 Leo IX. epist. 3;Gregor. VII. l. i. epist. 22, 23, l. iii. epist. 19, 20, 21;以及帕吉的评述(tom. iv. A.D. 1053, No. 14, A.D. 1073, No. 13)——帕吉考究了那位摩尔君主的名号与家世,而罗马历代教宗中最为高傲的一位,竟与此君如此彬彬有礼地通信往来。
210
Mozarabes, or Mostarabes, adscititii, as it is interpreted in Latin, (Pocock, Specimen Hist. Arabum, p. 39, 40. Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 18.) The Mozarabic liturgy, the ancient ritual of the church of Toledo, has been attacked by the popes, and exposed to the doubtful trials of the sword and of fire, (Marian. Hist. Hispan. tom. i. l. ix. c. 18, p. 378.) It was, or rather it is, in the Latin tongue; yet in the xith century it was found necessary (A. Ae. C. 1687, A.D. 1039) to transcribe an Arabic version of the canons of the councils of Spain, (Bibliot. Arab. Hisp. tom. i. p. 547,) for the use of the bishops and clergy in the Moorish kingdoms.
“莫扎拉布人”(Mozarabes,或作 Mostarabes),拉丁文释作 adscititii(意为“外来归附者”)(Pocock, Specimen Hist. Arabum, p. 39, 40. Bibliot. Arabico-Hispana, tom. ii. p. 18)。莫扎拉布礼仪,即托莱多教会的古老仪轨,曾屡遭历代教宗攻讦,还被交付刀与火那种难凭定断的神判来试炼(Marian. Hist. Hispan. tom. i. l. ix. c. 18, p. 378)。这套礼仪从前——不如说至今——都用拉丁文;然而到十一世纪,人们却觉得有必要(西班牙纪元1687年、即公元1039年)另抄一份阿拉伯文的西班牙历次公会议教规译本(Bibliot. Arab. Hisp. tom. i. p. 547),以供摩尔诸王国境内的主教与教士使用。
211
About the middle of the xth century, the clergy of Cordova was reproached with this criminal compliance, by the intrepid envoy of the Emperor Otho I., (Vit. Johan. Gorz, in Secul. Benedict. V. No. 115, apud Fleury, Hist. Eccles. tom. xii. p. 91.)
约在十世纪中叶,皇帝奥托一世那位无所畏惧的使节,曾指责科尔多瓦的教士这种有罪的迁就顺从(Vit. Johan. Gorz, in Secul. Benedict. V. No. 115, apud Fleury, Hist. Eccles. tom. xii. p. 91)。
212
Pagi, Critica, tom. iv. A.D. 1149, No. 8, 9. He justly observes, that when Seville, &c., were retaken by Ferdinand of Castille, no Christians, except captives, were found in the place; and that the Mozarabic churches of Africa and Spain, described by James a Vitriaco, A.D. 1218, (Hist. Hierosol. c. 80, p. 1095, in Gest. Dei per Francos,) are copied from some older book. I shall add, that the date of the Hegira 677 (A.D. 1278) must apply to the copy, not the composition, of a treatise of a jurisprudence, which states the civil rights of the Christians of Cordova, (Bibliot. Arab. Hisp. tom. i. p. 471;) and that the Jews were the only dissenters whom Abul Waled, king of Grenada, (A.D. 1313,) could either discountenance or tolerate, (tom. ii. p. 288.)
Pagi, Critica, tom. iv. A.D. 1149, No. 8, 9。他的观察颇为中肯:当塞维利亚等城被卡斯蒂利亚的斐迪南收复时,城中除俘虏外,已找不到一个基督徒;而雅克·德维特里于公元1218年所记述的非洲与西班牙的莫扎拉布教会(Hist. Hierosol. c. 80, p. 1095, in Gest. Dei per Francos),也不过是从某部更早的书里抄来的。我还要补充一点:希吉拉677年(公元1278年)这个日期,只能指一部法学论著的抄写年代,而非其撰著年代——该论著载明了科尔多瓦基督徒的民事权利(Bibliot. Arab. Hisp. tom. i. p. 471);此外,犹太人是格拉纳达国王阿布·瓦利德(公元1313年)唯一可加冷遇或加以容忍的异见者(tom. ii. p. 288)。
213
Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 288. Leo Africanus would have flattered his Roman masters, could he have discovered any latent relics of the Christianity of Africa.
Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 288。利奥·阿非利卡努斯若真能发现非洲基督教尚存的一丝隐微遗迹,本会借此讨好他那些罗马主子的。
214
Absit (said the Catholic to the vizier of Bagdad) ut pari loco habeas Nestorianos, quorum praeter Arabas nullus alius rex est, et Graecos quorum reges amovendo Arabibus bello non desistunt, &c. See in the Collections of Assemannus (Bibliot. Orient. tom. iv. p. 94-101) the state of the Nestorians under the caliphs. That of the Jacobites is more concisely exposed in the Preliminary Dissertation of the second volume of Assemannus.
Absit (said the Catholic to the vizier of Bagdad) ut pari loco habeas Nestorianos, quorum praeter Arabas nullus alius rex est, et Graecos quorum reges amovendo Arabibus bello non desistunt, &c.(聂斯脱利派的大公牧首对巴格达的维齐尔说:“万不可将聂斯脱利派与希腊人等量齐观——聂斯脱利派除阿拉伯人外别无他王,而希腊人的历代君主却对阿拉伯人征战不休”云云。)聂斯脱利派在历代哈里发治下的境况,可参见阿塞马尼所辑文集(Bibliot. Orient. tom. iv. p. 94-101)。雅各派的情形,则在阿塞马尼第二卷的绪论中有较简要的叙述。
215
Eutych. Annal. tom. ii. p. 384, 387, 388. Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 205, 206, 257, 332. A taint of the Monothelite heresy might render the first of these Greek patriarchs less loyal to the emperors and less obnoxious to the Arabs.
Eutych. Annal. tom. ii. p. 384, 387, 388. Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 205, 206, 257, 332。这几位希腊牧首中的头一位,或许因沾染了一志论异端的气味,才对历代皇帝不那么忠顺,也不那么招阿拉伯人的忌恨。
216
Motadhed, who reigned from A.D. 892 to 902. The Magians still held their name and rank among the religions of the empire, (Assemanni, Bibliot. Orient. tom. iv. p. 97.)
穆耳台迪德在位于公元892年至902年。麻葛教徒在帝国诸教之中,仍保有其名号与地位(Assemanni, Bibliot. Orient. tom. iv. p. 97)。
217
Reland explains the general restraints of the Mahometan policy and jurisprudence, (Dissertat. tom. iii. p. 16-20.) The oppressive edicts of the caliph Motawakkel, (A.D. 847-861,) which are still in force, are noticed by Eutychius, (Annal. tom. ii. p. 448,) and D’Herbelot, (Bibliot. Orient. p. 640.) A persecution of the caliph Omar II. is related, and most probably magnified, by the Greek Theophanes (Chron p. 334.)
雷兰对穆斯林政策与法理中普遍存在的种种约束作了阐释(Dissertat. tom. iii. p. 16-20)。哈里发穆塔瓦基勒(公元847至861年在位)那些苛酷的敕令至今仍然有效,欧提基乌斯(Annal. tom. ii. p. 448)与埃尔布洛(Bibliot. Orient. p. 640)都提到过。哈里发欧麦尔二世发动过的一场迫害,则由希腊人塞奥法尼斯(Chron. p. 334)记载下来——多半还被他添油加醋,夸大了几分。
218
The martyrs of Cordova (A.D. 850, &c.) are commemorated and justified by St. Eulogius, who at length fell a victim himself. A synod, convened by the caliph, ambiguously censured their rashness. The moderate Fleury cannot reconcile their conduct with the discipline of antiquity, toutefois l’autorite de l’eglise, &c. (Fleury, Hist. Eccles. tom. x. p. 415-522, particularly p. 451, 508, 509.) Their authentic acts throw a strong, though transient, light on the Spanish church in the ixth century.
科尔多瓦的殉道者(公元850年前后),由圣尤洛吉乌斯加以纪念并为之申辩,而尤洛吉乌斯本人最终也成了牺牲者。哈里发召集的一次主教会议,含糊其辞地责备了他们的鲁莽。温和的弗勒里无法把他们的行径同古教会的规矩相调和,toutefois l’autorite de l’eglise, &c.(然而教会之权威云云)(Fleury, Hist. Eccles. tom. x. p. 415-522, particularly p. 451, 508, 509)。这些殉道者真确的行传,为九世纪的西班牙教会投下了一道虽短暂却强烈的光亮。
219
See the article Eslamiah, (as we say Christendom,) in the Bibliotheque Orientale, (p. 325.) This chart of the Mahometan world is suited by the author, Ebn Alwardi, to the year of the Hegira 385 (A.D. 995.) Since that time, the losses in Spain have been overbalanced by the conquests in India, Tartary, and the European Turkey.
可参看《东方文库》中“Eslamiah”(意即“伊斯兰世界”,正如我们说“基督教世界”一般)一条(p. 325)。这幅穆斯林世界的舆图,作者伊本·阿尔瓦尔迪把它定在希吉拉385年(公元995年)的情形。此后,西班牙一带虽有失地,却已由印度、鞑靼与欧洲境内土耳其属地的征服所抵偿而有余。
220
The Arabic of the Koran is taught as a dead language in the college of Mecca. By the Danish traveller, this ancient idiom is compared to the Latin; the vulgar tongue of Hejaz and Yemen to the Italian; and the Arabian dialects of Syria, Egypt, Africa, &c., to the Provencal, Spanish, and Portuguese, (Niebuhr, Description de l’Arabie, p. 74, &c.)
《古兰经》所用的阿拉伯语,在麦加的学院里被当作一种已死的语言来教授。那位丹麦旅行家把这种古老的语言比作拉丁语;把希贾兹与也门的俗语比作意大利语;又把叙利亚、埃及、非洲等地的阿拉伯方言,比作普罗旺斯语、西班牙语与葡萄牙语(Niebuhr, Description de l’Arabie, p. 74, &c.)。