Chapter XLVII: Ecclesiastical Discord.—Part VI. 第四十七章 教会的纷争——第六节
¶
A more important conquest still remained, of the patriarch, the oracle and leader of the Egyptian church. Theodosius had resisted the threats and promises of Justinian with the spirit of an apostle or an enthusiast. “Such,” replied the patriarch, “were the offers of the tempter when he showed the kingdoms of the earth. But my soul is far dearer to me than life or dominion. The churches are in the hands of a prince who can kill the body; but my conscience is my own; and in exile, poverty, or chains, I will steadfastly adhere to the faith of my holy predecessors, Athanasius, Cyril, and Dioscorus. Anathema to the tome of Leo and the synod of Chalcedon! Anathema to all who embrace their creed! Anathema to them now and forevermore! Naked came I out of my mother’s womb, naked shall I descend into the grave. Let those who love God follow me and seek their salvation.” After comforting his brethren, he embarked for Constantinople, and sustained, in six successive interviews, the almost irresistible weight of the royal presence. His opinions were favorably entertained in the palace and the city; the influence of Theodora assured him a safe conduct and honorable dismission; and he ended his days, though not on the throne, yet in the bosom, of his native country. On the news of his death, Apollinaris indecently feasted the nobles and the clergy; but his joy was checked by the intelligence of a new election; and while he enjoyed the wealth of Alexandria, his rivals reigned in the monasteries of Thebais, and were maintained by the voluntary oblations of the people. A perpetual succession of patriarchs arose from the ashes of Theodosius; and the Monophysite churches of Syria and Egypt were united by the name of Jacobites and the communion of the faith. But the same faith, which has been confined to a narrow sect of the Syrians, was diffused over the mass of the Egyptian or Coptic nation; who, almost unanimously, rejected the decrees of the synod of Chalcedon. A thousand years were now elapsed since Egypt had ceased to be a kingdom, since the conquerors of Asia and Europe had trampled on the ready necks of a people, whose ancient wisdom and power ascend beyond the records of history. The conflict of zeal and persecution rekindled some sparks of their national spirit. They abjured, with a foreign heresy, the manners and language of the Greeks: every Melchite, in their eyes, was a stranger, every Jacobite a citizen; the alliance of marriage, the offices of humanity, were condemned as a deadly sin; the natives renounced all allegiance to the emperor; and his orders, at a distance from Alexandria, were obeyed only under the pressure of military force. A generous effort might have redeemed the religion and liberty of Egypt, and her six hundred monasteries might have poured forth their myriads of holy warriors, for whom death should have no terrors, since life had no comfort or delight. But experience has proved the distinction of active and passive courage; the fanatic who endures without a groan the torture of the rack or the stake, would tremble and fly before the face of an armed enemy. The pusillanimous temper of the Egyptians could only hope for a change of masters; the arms of Chosroes depopulated the land, yet under his reign the Jacobites enjoyed a short and precarious respite. The victory of Heraclius renewed and aggravated the persecution, and the patriarch again escaped from Alexandria to the desert. In his flight, Benjamin was encouraged by a voice, which bade him expect, at the end of ten years, the aid of a foreign nation, marked, like the Egyptians themselves, with the ancient rite of circumcision. The character of these deliverers, and the nature of the deliverance, will be hereafter explained; and I shall step over the interval of eleven centuries to observe the present misery of the Jacobites of Egypt. The populous city of Cairo affords a residence, or rather a shelter, for their indigent patriarch, and a remnant of ten bishops; forty monasteries have survived the inroads of the Arabs; and the progress of servitude and apostasy has reduced the Coptic nation to the despicable number of twenty-five or thirty thousand families; 148 a race of illiterate beggars, whose only consolation is derived from the superior wretchedness of the Greek patriarch and his diminutive congregation. 149
然而,还有一位更重要的人物有待收服:埃及教会的牧首——那位被奉为神谕、众望所归的领袖。狄奥多西以使徒或狂热信徒般的气概,抵挡住了查士丁尼的威逼利诱。这位牧首答道:“昔日试探者把世上万国指与人看时,开出的也正是这样的条件。可在我心里,我的灵魂远比性命或权位珍贵。各教会如今落在一位能杀身体的君主手里,但我的良心归我自己所有;无论流放、贫困还是身陷囹圄,我都要坚守历代圣师——阿塔纳修斯、西里尔与迪奥斯科鲁斯——所传的信仰。诅咒利奥的《大卷》,诅咒卡尔西顿会议!诅咒一切信奉其信条的人!此刻诅咒他们,直到永永远远!我赤身出于母胎,也必赤身入土。凡爱上帝的人,都跟我来,去寻求自己的得救吧。”他安慰过教中弟兄之后,便乘船前往君士坦丁堡,在接连六次的会见中,顶住了君主亲临所带来的巨大威压——那威压之重,几乎无人能挡。他的主张在宫廷和都城都颇受欢迎;狄奥多拉的势力保他一路平安,并以礼送归;他虽未能重登教座,终究得以在故国的怀抱里安度余生。他的死讯一传来,阿波利纳里斯便大摆筵席宴请显贵与教士,实在有失体统;但一听说对方已另选新牧首,他的欢喜顿时凉了半截;他虽坐享亚历山大里亚的财富,对手们却在底比斯地区的修道院里执掌教权,靠信众自愿的奉献维持生计。狄奥多西虽死,牧首之位却从他的灰烬中一代代传续不绝;叙利亚与埃及的基督一性论派教会,因同一信仰的团契、共戴“雅各派”之名而联为一体。不过,这同一信仰在叙利亚人中只局促于一个狭小的教派,在埃及人(即科普特人)中却传遍了举国上下;他们几乎众口一词,拒不接受卡尔西顿会议的教令。自埃及不复为独立王国,如今已过去了一千年;亚洲与欧洲的历代征服者,一个接一个地踏过这个民族早已驯顺伸出的颈项——论其古老的智慧与武功,其渊源之久远,已远在信史所能记载之外。狂热与迫害的冲突,重新点燃了他们民族精神里的几点火星。他们既弃绝了那外来的异端,也一并抛开了希腊人的风俗与语言:在他们眼里,凡麦尔基派都是外人,凡雅各派才是同胞;与麦尔基派通婚联姻、乃至以寻常人情相待,都被斥为不可饶恕的死罪;本地人不再向皇帝效忠,皇帝的政令一出亚历山大里亚,除非有武力弹压,便无人肯从。只要奋力一搏,本可挽回埃及的信仰与自由;她那六百座修道院,本可涌出成千上万的圣战之士——对这些人来说,生既无欢乐可言,死又何足畏惧。然而事实证明,勇气有主动与被动之分:那能一声不吭忍受拉肢刑架或火刑柱的狂信者,一旦面对全副武装的敌人,却会浑身发抖、掉头就逃。埃及人生性怯懦,所能指望的不过是换个主子;库思老的大军使这片土地人烟凋敝,然而在他统治下,雅各派却得了一段短暂而朝不保夕的喘息。希拉克略得胜之后,迫害重起,且变本加厉,牧首只得又一次从亚历山大里亚逃入荒漠。逃亡途中,本雅明听见一个声音在耳边勉励,叫他等上十年,届时必有一个外邦相助;那外邦与埃及人一样,也保有古老的割礼之俗。这些拯救者究竟是何等人物、这场拯救又是怎么回事,我将留待日后交代;此刻我且跨过十一个世纪的漫长间隔,来看一看埃及雅各派眼下的凄凉境况。人口稠密的开罗,为他们那位穷困的牧首和仅存的十位主教提供了一处栖身之所——与其说是居所,不如说是避难之地;有四十座修道院熬过阿拉伯人的一次次侵扰而幸存下来;而奴役与叛教日甚一日,已使科普特民族凋零到区区两万五千或三万户人家的可怜地步;148 这是一群目不识丁的乞丐,他们唯一的慰藉,便是看到希腊牧首和他那寥寥无几的会众比自己更加不堪。149
¶
VI. The Coptic patriarch, a rebel to the Caesars, or a slave to the khalifs, still gloried in the filial obedience of the kings of Nubia and Aethiopia. He repaid their homage by magnifying their greatness; and it was boldly asserted that they could bring into the field a hundred thousand horse, with an equal number of camels; 150 that their hand could pour out or restrain the waters of the Nile; 151 and the peace and plenty of Egypt was obtained, even in this world, by the intercession of the patriarch. In exile at Constantinople, Theodosius recommended to his patroness the conversion of the black nations of Nubia, from the tropic of Cancer to the confines of Abyssinia. 152 Her design was suspected and emulated by the more orthodox emperor. The rival missionaries, a Melchite and a Jacobite, embarked at the same time; but the empress, from a motive of love or fear, was more effectually obeyed; and the Catholic priest was detained by the president of Thebais, while the king of Nubia and his court were hastily baptized in the faith of Dioscorus. The tardy envoy of Justinian was received and dismissed with honor: but when he accused the heresy and treason of the Egyptians, the negro convert was instructed to reply that he would never abandon his brethren, the true believers, to the persecuting ministers of the synod of Chalcedon. 153 During several ages, the bishops of Nubia were named and consecrated by the Jacobite patriarch of Alexandria: as late as the twelfth century, Christianity prevailed; and some rites, some ruins, are still visible in the savage towns of Sennaar and Dongola. 154 But the Nubians at length executed their threats of returning to the worship of idols; the climate required the indulgence of polygamy, and they have finally preferred the triumph of the Koran to the abasement of the Cross. A metaphysical religion may appear too refined for the capacity of the negro race: yet a black or a parrot might be taught to repeat the words of the Chalcedonian or Monophysite creed.
六、科普特牧首,对恺撒诸帝而言是叛逆,对哈里发而言是奴仆,却始终以努比亚和埃塞俄比亚两国之王对他俯首帖耳、恭顺如子为荣。为报答他们的尊崇,他也极力夸耀这两国的强盛;据大言宣称,这两国能出动十万骑兵,外加同等数目的骆驼;150 又说他们一举手便能放泄或截断尼罗河的水流;151 甚至埃及现世的太平与丰饶,也全靠这位牧首从中代祷才得以保全。狄奥多西流亡君士坦丁堡期间,向他的女庇护人进言,力主使努比亚的黑人诸族皈依——其地北起北回归线,南抵阿比西尼亚边界。152 更为正统的皇帝察觉了她的图谋,也存心与她一较高下、抢占先机。两拨针锋相对的传教士——一个麦尔基派,一个雅各派——同时启程;但皇后的吩咐,无论出于爱戴还是畏惧,总归执行得更为得力:大公教会那位教士被底比斯地区的省长扣住,而努比亚国王及其满朝上下,早已匆匆按迪奥斯科鲁斯的信仰受了洗。查士丁尼那位姗姗来迟的使者,来时以礼相迎,去时以礼相送;可当他指控埃及人的异端与叛逆时,那位皈依的黑人国王却按人授意答道:他绝不会把自己的弟兄——那些真正的信徒——交到卡尔西顿会议那帮专事迫害的教士手中。153 一连数百年间,努比亚的主教都由亚历山大里亚的雅各派牧首任命并祝圣;直到十二世纪,基督教在那里仍占上风,至今在森纳尔与栋古拉那些荒蛮的城镇里,还能见到一些残存的仪礼和废墟。154 但努比亚人终究把重归偶像崇拜的威胁付诸实行;当地的气候需要一夫多妻的宽纵,到头来,他们宁取《古兰经》的凯旋,也不甘受十字架的屈辱。一门形而上的宗教,对黑人一族的悟性来说,或许显得过于精微;然而,无论是一个黑人还是一只鹦鹉,都一样可以教其背诵卡尔西顿派或基督一性论派的信条。
¶
Christianity was more deeply rooted in the Abyssinian empire; and, although the correspondence has been sometimes interrupted above seventy or a hundred years, the mother-church of Alexandria retains her colony in a state of perpetual pupilage. Seven bishops once composed the Aethiopic synod: had their number amounted to ten, they might have elected an independent primate; and one of their kings was ambitious of promoting his brother to the ecclesiastical throne. But the event was foreseen, the increase was denied: the episcopal office has been gradually confined to the abuna, 155 the head and author of the Abyssinian priesthood; the patriarch supplies each vacancy with an Egyptian monk; and the character of a stranger appears more venerable in the eyes of the people, less dangerous in those of the monarch. In the sixth century, when the schism of Egypt was confirmed, the rival chiefs, with their patrons, Justinian and Theodora, strove to outstrip each other in the conquest of a remote and independent province. The industry of the empress was again victorious, and the pious Theodora has established in that sequestered church the faith and discipline of the Jacobites. 156 Encompassed on all sides by the enemies of their religion, the Aethiopians slept near a thousand years, forgetful of the world, by whom they were forgotten. They were awakened by the Portuguese, who, turning the southern promontory of Africa, appeared in India and the Red Sea, as if they had descended through the air from a distant planet. In the first moments of their interview, the subjects of Rome and Alexandria observed the resemblance, rather than the difference, of their faith; and each nation expected the most important benefits from an alliance with their Christian brethren. In their lonely situation, the Aethiopians had almost relapsed into the savage life. Their vessels, which had traded to Ceylon, scarcely presumed to navigate the rivers of Africa; the ruins of Axume were deserted, the nation was scattered in villages, and the emperor, a pompous name, was content, both in peace and war, with the immovable residence of a camp. Conscious of their own indigence, the Abyssinians had formed the rational project of importing the arts and ingenuity of Europe; 157 and their ambassadors at Rome and Lisbon were instructed to solicit a colony of smiths, carpenters, tilers, masons, printers, surgeons, and physicians, for the use of their country. But the public danger soon called for the instant and effectual aid of arms and soldiers, to defend an unwarlike people from the Barbarians who ravaged the inland country and the Turks and Arabs who advanced from the sea-coast in more formidable array. Aethiopia was saved by four hundred and fifty Portuguese, who displayed in the field the native valor of Europeans, and the artificial power of the musket and cannon. In a moment of terror, the emperor had promised to reconcile himself and his subjects to the Catholic faith; a Latin patriarch represented the supremacy of the pope: 158 the empire, enlarged in a tenfold proportion, was supposed to contain more gold than the mines of America; and the wildest hopes of avarice and zeal were built on the willing submission of the Christians of Africa.
基督教在阿比西尼亚帝国扎根更深;尽管两地的往来有时中断七八十年乃至上百年,亚历山大里亚这座母教会仍始终把这个属地当作长不大的孩童牢牢管束,使之永处于受人监护的门徒地位。埃塞俄比亚的主教会议一度由七名主教组成;若这数目凑足十人,他们本可自行推选一位独立的首席主教;他们还有一位国王,曾野心勃勃地想把自己的兄弟扶上这教座的尊位。但此事早被料到,增额之请遂遭拒绝:于是主教之职渐渐缩减,只剩一位“阿布纳”,155 即阿比西尼亚教士团的首领兼开山之人;每逢此位出缺,牧首便从埃及派一名修士补上;而由一个外乡人充任此职,在百姓眼中反倒更显尊贵可敬,在君主看来也少些威胁。到六世纪,埃及的教会分裂已成定局,敌对的两派首领,各自背靠查士丁尼与狄奥多拉,争相抢先去征服这块遥远而独立的属地。皇后的经营再度获胜,虔诚的狄奥多拉遂在这座与世隔绝的教会里,立定了雅各派的信仰与规制。156 埃塞俄比亚人四面受本教仇敌的围困,就这样沉睡了近千年之久,既把世界忘得干净,也早被世界所遗忘。直到葡萄牙人绕过非洲南端的海岬,出现在印度和红海一带,才把他们唤醒——那模样,仿佛是从某个遥远的星球凌空降下的一般。初次会面的头几刻,罗马的臣民与亚历山大里亚的臣民都只留意到彼此信仰的相似,而非分歧;两个民族都指望着,与这些基督徒弟兄结盟能带来莫大的好处。长久孤处一隅,埃塞俄比亚人几乎已重新堕回蒙昧的生活。他们的船只从前曾远航锡兰通商,如今却连本土非洲的河流都几乎不敢行驶;阿克苏姆已成废墟,无人问津,整个民族散居在一座座村落里;至于那位“皇帝”,徒有堂皇之名,无论平时还是战时,都安于以一座固定不动的营帐为居所。阿比西尼亚人自知贫弱,倒也拟定了一个明智的方略:从欧洲引进各种技艺与巧思;157 他们派驻罗马和里斯本的使节奉命去招募一批工匠移民——铁匠、木匠、瓦匠、泥水匠、印刷工、外科医生与内科大夫,好为本国所用。但国难当头,眼下更急需的是刀枪与兵员的即时救援,好保护这个不善征战的民族,去抵御那些在内陆四处劫掠的蛮族,以及从海岸一侧以更凶悍阵势步步进逼的土耳其人和阿拉伯人。埃塞俄比亚终由四百五十名葡萄牙人挽救;他们在战场上既展现了欧洲人与生俱来的骁勇,也施展了火枪与火炮这种人为的威力。皇帝曾在惊惧之中许诺,要率领自己和臣民归顺天主教信仰;一位拉丁宗主教便代表着教宗的至高权柄;158 这个帝国的疆域被夸大了十倍,据说藏金之多胜过美洲的矿藏;贪婪与狂热由此生出种种痴心妄想,全都寄托在非洲这些基督徒的甘心归顺之上。
¶
But the vows which pain had extorted were forsworn on the return of health. The Abyssinians still adhered with unshaken constancy to the Monophysite faith; their languid belief was inflamed by the exercise of dispute; they branded the Latins with the names of Arians and Nestorians, and imputed the adoration of four gods to those who separated the two natures of Christ. Fremona, a place of worship, or rather of exile, was assigned to the Jesuit missionaries. Their skill in the liberal and mechanic arts, their theological learning, and the decency of their manners, inspired a barren esteem; but they were not endowed with the gift of miracles, 159 and they vainly solicited a reenforcement of European troops. The patience and dexterity of forty years at length obtained a more favorable audience, and two emperors of Abyssinia were persuaded that Rome could insure the temporal and everlasting happiness of her votaries. The first of these royal converts lost his crown and his life; and the rebel army was sanctified by the abuna, who hurled an anathema at the apostate, and absolved his subjects from their oath of fidelity. The fate of Zadenghel was revenged by the courage and fortune of Susneus, who ascended the throne under the name of Segued, and more vigorously prosecuted the pious enterprise of his kinsman. After the amusement of some unequal combats between the Jesuits and his illiterate priests, the emperor declared himself a proselyte to the synod of Chalcedon, presuming that his clergy and people would embrace without delay the religion of their prince. The liberty of choice was succeeded by a law, which imposed, under pain of death, the belief of the two natures of Christ: the Abyssinians were enjoined to work and to play on the Sabbath; and Segued, in the face of Europe and Africa, renounced his connection with the Alexandrian church. A Jesuit, Alphonso Mendez, the Catholic patriarch of Aethiopia, accepted, in the name of Urban VIII., the homage and abjuration of the penitent. “I confess,” said the emperor on his knees, “I confess that the pope is the vicar of Christ, the successor of St. Peter, and the sovereign of the world. To him I swear true obedience, and at his feet I offer my person and kingdom.” A similar oath was repeated by his son, his brother, the clergy, the nobles, and even the ladies of the court: the Latin patriarch was invested with honors and wealth; and his missionaries erected their churches or citadels in the most convenient stations of the empire. The Jesuits themselves deplore the fatal indiscretion of their chief, who forgot the mildness of the gospel and the policy of his order, to introduce with hasty violence the liturgy of Rome and the inquisition of Portugal. He condemned the ancient practice of circumcision, which health, rather than superstition, had first invented in the climate of Aethiopia. 160 A new baptism, a new ordination, was inflicted on the natives; and they trembled with horror when the most holy of the dead were torn from their graves, when the most illustrious of the living were excommunicated by a foreign priest. In the defense of their religion and liberty, the Abyssinians rose in arms, with desperate but unsuccessful zeal. Five rebellions were extinguished in the blood of the insurgents: two abunas were slain in battle, whole legions were slaughtered in the field, or suffocated in their caverns; and neither merit, nor rank, nor sex, could save from an ignominious death the enemies of Rome. But the victorious monarch was finally subdued by the constancy of the nation, of his mother, of his son, and of his most faithful friends. Segued listened to the voice of pity, of reason, perhaps of fear: and his edict of liberty of conscience instantly revealed the tyranny and weakness of the Jesuits. On the death of his father, Basilides expelled the Latin patriarch, and restored to the wishes of the nation the faith and the discipline of Egypt. The Monophysite churches resounded with a song of triumph, “that the sheep of Aethiopia were now delivered from the hyaenas of the West;” and the gates of that solitary realm were forever shut against the arts, the science, and the fanaticism of Europe. 161
然而,这些在痛苦逼迫下许下的誓愿,一等安泰复原便被弃如敝屣。阿比西尼亚人依旧坚定不移地固守基督一性论的信仰;他们原本淡漠的信念,反倒在反复争辩中愈燃愈炽;他们给拉丁人扣上“阿里乌斯派”和“聂斯脱利派”的帽子,并指斥那些把基督二性分开的人是在崇拜四位神明。当局把弗雷莫纳指给耶稣会传教士,名为供其礼拜之地,实则形同流放之所。这些传教士精通文理与工技,兼有神学造诣,举止又端庄得体,赢得了一份敬意——却是有敬无实、于事无补;只是他们并未获赐行神迹的本领,159 几番恳求增派欧洲援军,也是徒劳无功。凭着四十年的耐心与巧于周旋,他们终于博得了较为有利的听众:先后有两位阿比西尼亚皇帝被说动,相信罗马能为归顺者担保今生与永世的福乐。这两位皈依的君王中,头一位丢了王冠、也丢了性命;叛军则由阿布纳加以圣化——这位阿布纳向变节者掷出绝罚,并解除了臣民效忠于他的誓约。扎登盖尔的下场,后来靠苏斯内乌斯的勇武与好运得了报偿:此人以“塞格德”之名登上王位,比他这位亲族更为强悍地推行那桩虔诚的事业。耶稣会士与他手下那些不通文墨的教士较量过几场实力悬殊、聊供消遣的论战之后,皇帝便自称皈依了卡尔西顿会议,满以为教士和百姓会毫不迟疑地接受君主的宗教。起初还许人自择信仰,随后便颁下一道法令,以死刑相胁,强令众人信奉基督二性之说;又勒令阿比西尼亚人在安息日照常劳作、照常玩乐;塞格德更当着欧洲与非洲的面,宣布断绝与亚历山大里亚教会的一切关系。耶稣会士阿方索·门德斯,身为埃塞俄比亚的天主教宗主教,代表教宗乌尔班八世,接受了这位悔改者的效忠宣誓与弃教声明。“我承认,”皇帝跪伏在地说道,“我承认教宗乃是基督的代理人、圣彼得的继承人、普世的君主。我向他宣誓永矢忠顺,并将我这个人连同我的王国,一并奉献于他脚前。”类似的誓言,又由他的儿子、他的兄弟、众教士、群臣,乃至宫中的贵妇一一重述了一遍;那位拉丁宗主教受封以荣衔与财富,他手下的传教士则在帝国各处最便利的据点,建起了一座座教堂——或者说是一座座堡垒。就连耶稣会自己也痛惜其首领那致命的鲁莽:此人竟忘了福音的温和、也忘了本会一贯的谋略,一味操之过急、强行推行罗马的礼拜仪式和葡萄牙的宗教裁判所。他还斥责割礼这一古老习俗——其实这习俗最初在埃塞俄比亚的气候下兴起,为的是健康,而非迷信。160 当地人被迫重新受洗、重新授职;而当至圣的先人被从坟中掘出、当在世的显贵被一个外来教士逐出教门时,他们无不惊怖战栗。为捍卫本教与自由,阿比西尼亚人揭竿而起,虽满腔狂热、拼死相搏,终归无功。先后五次起事,都在义军的血泊中被扑灭;两任阿布纳阵亡沙场,整队整队的人马或被杀于旷野,或被闷死在藏身的洞窟之中;凡与罗马为敌者,无论功勋、地位还是性别,都难逃一场屈辱的死。但这位屡战屡胜的君主,终究抵不过举国上下的执拗,也抵不过他的母亲、他的儿子和他那些最忠实的友人的坚持。塞格德终于听从了怜悯之声、理性之声,或许还有几分畏惧之声:他那道准许信仰自由的敕令一出,立时暴露了耶稣会既暴虐又虚弱的真相。父亲一死,巴西里德斯便驱逐了拉丁宗主教,顺应举国的心愿,恢复了埃及教会的信仰与规制。基督一性论派的各教会里回荡起一片凯歌:“埃塞俄比亚的羊群,如今总算从西方的鬣狗口中脱险了!”从此,这个孤悬一隅的王国便永远关上了大门,把欧洲的技艺、科学连同它的宗教狂热一概拒之门外。161
Notes 注释
148
↩
This number is taken from the curious Recherches sur les Egyptiens et les Chinois, (tom. ii. p. 192, 193,) and appears more probable than the 600,000 ancient, or 15,000 modern, Copts of Gemelli Carreri Cyril Lucar, the Protestant patriarch of Constantinople, laments that those heretics were ten times more numerous than his orthodox Greeks, ingeniously applying Homer, (Iliad, ii. 128,) the most perfect expression of contempt, (Fabric. Lux Evangelii, 740.)
此数取自那部奇特的著作 Recherches sur les Egyptiens et les Chinois(tom. ii. p. 192, 193),比杰梅利·卡雷里所记的科普特人数——古时六十万、今时一万五千——似乎更为可信。君士坦丁堡的新教牧首西里尔·卢卡里斯曾慨叹,这些异端的人数竟是他麾下正统希腊人的十倍之多,还巧妙地援引荷马(《伊利亚特》ii. 128)那句最能表达轻蔑之意的诗句来讥讽(Fabric. Lux Evangelii, 740)。
149
↩
The history of the Copts, their religion, manners, &c., may be found in the Abbe Renaudot’s motley work, neither a translation nor an original; the Chronicon Orientale of Peter, a Jacobite; in the two versions of Abraham Ecchellensis, Paris, 1651; and John Simon Asseman, Venet. 1729. These annals descend no lower than the xiiith century. The more recent accounts must be searched for in the travellers into Egypt and the Nouveaux Memoires des Missions du Levant. In the last century, Joseph Abudacnus, a native of Cairo, published at Oxford, in thirty pages, a slight Historia Jacobitarum, 147, post p.150
关于科普特人的历史、宗教、风俗等等,可参见勒诺多神父那部不伦不类的著作——它既非翻译,也非原创;还可参见雅各派的彼得所撰 Chronicon Orientale,以及亚伯拉罕·埃凯伦西斯(Paris, 1651)与约翰·西蒙·阿塞马尼(Venet. 1729)的两种译本。这些编年史所记年代,最晚不过十三世纪。若要查阅较晚近的记载,则须求诸游历埃及者的著述,以及 Nouveaux Memoires des Missions du Levant。上个世纪,开罗人约瑟夫·阿布达克努斯曾在牛津刊行一部单薄的 Historia Jacobitarum,仅三十页(147, post p.150)。
150
↩
About the year 737. See Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex p. 221, 222. Elmacin, Hist. Saracen. p. 99.
约在公元 737 年。参见 Renaudot, Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 221, 222;Elmacin, Hist. Saracen. p. 99。
151
↩
Ludolph. Hist. Aethiopic. et Comment. l. i. c. 8. Renaudot Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 480, &c. This opinion, introduced into Egypt and Europe by the artifice of the Copts, the pride of the Abyssinians, the fear and ignorance of the Turks and Arabs, has not even the semblance of truth. The rains of Aethiopia do not, in the increase of the Nile, consult the will of the monarch. If the river approaches at Napata within three days’ journey of the Red Sea (see D’Anville’s Maps,) a canal that should divert its course would demand, and most probably surpass, the power of the Caesars.
Ludolph. Hist. Aethiopic. et Comment. l. i. c. 8;Renaudot Hist. Patriarch. Alex. p. 480, &c.。这一说法是靠科普特人的伎俩、阿比西尼亚人的自负,以及土耳其人和阿拉伯人的畏惧与无知,才传入埃及和欧洲的,实则连一点真实的影子都没有。尼罗河的泛涨源于埃塞俄比亚的降雨,而这雨水涨落,从不请示那位君主的意旨。尼罗河在纳帕塔一带虽流至离红海仅三日路程之处(见当维尔绘制的地图),但若想开一条运河把河水引开,所需之力足以耗尽——多半还要超出——历代恺撒的国力。
152
↩
The Abyssinians, who still preserve the features and olive complexion of the Arabs, afford a proof that two thousand years are not sufficient to change the color of the human race. The Nubians, an African race, are pure negroes, as black as those of Senegal or Congo, with flat noses, thick lips, and woolly hair, (Buffon, Hist. Naturelle, tom. v. p. 117, 143, 144, 166, 219, edit. in 12mo., Paris, 1769.) The ancients beheld, without much attention, the extraordinary phenomenon which has exercised the philosophers and theologians of modern times
阿比西尼亚人至今仍保有阿拉伯人的相貌与橄榄色的肤色,这恰好证明:区区两千年,不足以改变一个人种的肤色。努比亚人属非洲人种,是纯粹的黑人,肤色黑得如同塞内加尔或刚果一带的黑人,扁鼻、厚唇、卷发(Buffon, Hist. Naturelle, tom. v. p. 117, 143, 144, 166, 219, edit. in 12mo., Paris, 1769)。这一奇异的现象,古人看在眼里却不甚留意,却让近代的哲学家与神学家大费思量。
153
↩
Asseman. Bibliot. Orient. tom. i. p. 329.
Asseman. Bibliot. Orient. tom. i. p. 329。
154
↩
The Christianity of the Nubians (A.D. 1153) is attested by the sheriff al Edrisi, falsely described under the name of the Nubian geographer, (p. 18,) who represents them as a nation of Jacobites. The rays of historical light that twinkle in the history of Ranaudot (p. 178, 220—224, 281—286, 405, 434, 451, 464) are all previous to this aera. See the modern state in the Lettres Edifiantes (Recueil, iv.) and Busching, (tom. ix. p. 152—139, par Berenger.)
努比亚人信奉基督教(公元 1153 年)一事,有谢里夫·伊德里西为证——此人被世人误称为“努比亚地理学家”(p. 18)——他把努比亚人描述为一个雅各派民族。勒诺多的著作中闪烁着的那几缕史光(p. 178, 220—224, 281—286, 405, 434, 451, 464),所照见的都在这一年代之前。至于其近世状况,可参见 Lettres Edifiantes(Recueil, iv.)与 Busching(tom. ix. p. 152—139, par Berenger)。
155
↩
The abuna is improperly dignified by the Latins with the title of patriarch. The Abyssinians acknowledge only the four patriarchs, and their chief is no more than a metropolitan or national primate, (Ludolph. Hist. Aethiopic. et Comment. l. iii. c. 7.) The seven bishops of Renaudot, (p. 511,) who existed A.D. 1131, are unknown to the historian.
拉丁人抬举“阿布纳”,僭称之为牧首,实属不当。阿比西尼亚人只承认四位牧首,而他们这位首领充其量不过是一名都主教,或曰全国的首席主教(Ludolph. Hist. Aethiopic. et Comment. l. iii. c. 7)。勒诺多所说那七名主教(p. 511),据称存在于公元 1131 年,却为那位史家(卢多尔夫)所不知。
156
↩
I know not why Assemannus (Bibliot. Orient. tom. ii. p. 384) should call in question these probable missions of Theodora into Nubia and Aethiopia. The slight notices of Abyssinia till the year 1500 are supplied by Renaudot (p. 336-341, 381, 382, 405, 443, &c., 452, 456, 463, 475, 480, 511, 525, 559—564) from the Coptic writers. The mind of Ludolphus was a perfect blank.
我不明白阿塞马尼(Bibliot. Orient. tom. ii. p. 384)何以要质疑狄奥多拉派人赴努比亚和埃塞俄比亚传教这件很可能属实的事。有关阿比西尼亚直至 1500 年的零星记载,都是勒诺多(p. 336-341, 381, 382, 405, 443, &c., 452, 456, 463, 475, 480, 511, 525, 559—564)从科普特作者那里辑录来的。至于卢多尔夫,他脑中对此则是一片空白。
157
↩
Ludolph. Hist. Aethiop. l. iv. c. 5. The most necessary arts are now exercised by the Jews, and the foreign trade is in the hands of the Armenians. What Gregory principally admired and envied was the industry of Europe—artes et opificia.
Ludolph. Hist. Aethiop. l. iv. c. 5。如今,那些最不可或缺的手艺都由犹太人操持,对外贸易则掌握在亚美尼亚人手中。格列高利最为艳羡的,是欧洲的百工——artes et opificia(技艺与工造)。
158
↩
John Bermudez, whose relation, printed at Lisbon, 1569, was translated into English by Purchas, (Pilgrims, l. vii. c. 7, p. 1149, &c.,) and from thence into French by La Croze, (Christianisme d’Ethiopie, p. 92—265.) The piece is curious; but the author may be suspected of deceiving Abyssinia, Rome, and Portugal. His title to the rank of patriarch is dark and doubtful, (Ludolph. Comment. No. 101, p. 473.)
约翰·贝尔穆德斯的记述,1569 年在里斯本印行,后由珀切斯译成英文(Pilgrims, l. vii. c. 7, p. 1149, &c.),再由拉克罗兹从英文转译为法文(Christianisme d’Ethiopie, p. 92—265)。这部作品颇为奇特,但其作者恐怕对阿比西尼亚、罗马和葡萄牙三方都有所欺瞒。至于他自称的宗主教头衔,则来路不明、大可存疑(Ludolph. Comment. No. 101, p. 473)。
159
↩
Religio Romana...nec precibus patrum nec miraculis ab ipsis editis suffulciebatur, is the uncontradicted assurance of the devout emperor Susneus to his patriarch Mendez, (Ludolph. Comment. No. 126, p. 529;) and such assurances should be preciously kept, as an antidote against any marvellous legends.
“Religio Romana...nec precibus patrum nec miraculis ab ipsis editis suffulciebatur”(罗马的宗教……既无教父的祈祷、也无他们所行的神迹为其撑腰)——这是虔诚的皇帝苏斯内乌斯对其宗主教门德斯所作的、无人反驳的保证(Ludolph. Comment. No. 126, p. 529);这类保证理当珍而重之地保存下来,好用作解毒剂,以抵御一切神乎其神的传说。
160
↩
I am aware how tender is the question of circumcision. Yet I will affirm, 1. That the Aethiopians have a physical reason for the circumcision of males, and even of females, (Recherches Philosophiques sur les Americains, tom. ii.) 2. That it was practised in Aethiopia long before the introduction of Judaism or Christianity, (Herodot. l. ii. c. 104. Marsham, Canon. Chron. p. 72, 73.) “Infantes circumcidunt ob consuetudinemn, non ob Judaismum,” says Gregory the Abyssinian priest, (apud Fabric. Lux Christiana, p. 720.) Yet in the heat of dispute, the Portuguese were sometimes branded with the name of uncircumcised, (La Croze, p. 90. Ludolph. Hist. and Comment. l. iii. c. l.)
我深知割礼是个何等敏感的话题,但我仍要断言:其一,埃塞俄比亚人为男子、甚至为女子行割礼,自有其生理上的缘由(Recherches Philosophiques sur les Americains, tom. ii);其二,早在犹太教或基督教传入之前很久,割礼就已在埃塞俄比亚通行(Herodot. l. ii. c. 104;Marsham, Canon. Chron. p. 72, 73)。阿比西尼亚教士格列高利说:“Infantes circumcidunt ob consuetudinem, non ob Judaismum”(他们为婴儿行割礼,是出于习俗,而非出于犹太教)(apud Fabric. Lux Christiana, p. 720)。然而在争论白热之际,葡萄牙人有时反倒被人扣上“未受割礼者”的骂名(La Croze, p. 90;Ludolph. Hist. and Comment. l. iii. c. l)。
161
↩
The three Protestant historians, Ludolphus, (Hist. Aethiopica, Francofurt. 1681; Commentarius, 1691; Relatio Nova, &c., 1693, in folio,) Geddes, (Church History of Aethiopia, London, 1696, in 8vo..) and La Croze, (Hist. du Christianisme d’Ethiopie et d’Armenie, La Haye, 1739, in 12mo.,) have drawn their principal materials from the Jesuits, especially from the General History of Tellez, published in Portuguese at Coimbra, 1660. We might be surprised at their frankness; but their most flagitious vice, the spirit of persecution, was in their eyes the most meritorious virtue. Ludolphus possessed some, though a slight, advantage from the Aethiopic language, and the personal conversation of Gregory, a free-spirited Abyssinian priest, whom he invited from Rome to the court of Saxe-Gotha. See the Theologia Aethiopica of Gregory, in (Fabric. Lux Evangelii, p. 716—734.) * Note: The travels of Bruce, illustrated by those of Mr. Salt, and the narrative of Nathaniel Pearce, have brought us again acquainted with this remote region. Whatever may be their speculative opinions the barbarous manners of the Ethiopians seem to be gaining more and more the ascendency over the practice of Christianity.—M.
三位新教史家——卢多尔夫(Hist. Aethiopica, Francofurt. 1681;Commentarius, 1691;Relatio Nova, &c., 1693, in folio)、格迪斯(Church History of Aethiopia, London, 1696, in 8vo.)与拉克罗兹(Hist. du Christianisme d’Ethiopie et d’Armenie, La Haye, 1739, in 12mo.)——其主要材料都取自耶稣会士,尤其取自特列斯那部于 1660 年在科英布拉以葡萄牙文刊行的《通史》。他们如此坦率,或许会令我们惊讶;但在他们眼中,迫害的精神——这桩最伤天害理的恶德——反倒是最值得称道的美德。卢多尔夫略占了一点便宜(虽然有限):他懂些埃塞俄比亚语,又曾与格列高利当面交谈——此人是位思想自由的阿比西尼亚教士,卢多尔夫特意把他从罗马请到萨克森-哥达的宫廷。格列高利的《埃塞俄比亚神学》,见 Fabric. Lux Evangelii, p. 716—734。* 编者按:布鲁斯的游记,加上索尔特先生游记的印证,以及纳撒尼尔·皮尔斯的记述,使我们重新认识了这个偏远的地区。无论他们抱持何种思辨观点,埃塞俄比亚人那野蛮的习俗,似乎正日益压倒基督教的践行、占据上风。—M