Chapter XXX: Revolt Of The Goths.—Part IV. 第三十章 哥特人的反叛——第四节

The correspondence of nations was, in that age, so imperfect and precarious, that the revolutions of the North might escape the knowledge of the court of Ravenna; till the dark cloud, which was collected along the coast of the Baltic, burst in thunder upon the banks of the Upper Danube. The emperor of the West, if his ministers disturbed his amusements by the news of the impending danger, was satisfied with being the occasion, and the spectator, of the war. 70 The safety of Rome was intrusted to the counsels, and the sword, of Stilicho; but such was the feeble and exhausted state of the empire, that it was impossible to restore the fortifications of the Danube, or to prevent, by a vigorous effort, the invasion of the Germans. 71 The hopes of the vigilant minister of Honorius were confined to the defence of Italy. He once more abandoned the provinces, recalled the troops, pressed the new levies, which were rigorously exacted, and pusillanimously eluded; employed the most efficacious means to arrest, or allure, the deserters; and offered the gift of freedom, and of two pieces of gold, to all the slaves who would enlist. 72 By these efforts he painfully collected, from the subjects of a great empire, an army of thirty or forty thousand men, which, in the days of Scipio or Camillus, would have been instantly furnished by the free citizens of the territory of Rome. 73 The thirty legions of Stilicho were reenforced by a large body of Barbarian auxiliaries; the faithful Alani were personally attached to his service; and the troops of Huns and of Goths, who marched under the banners of their native princes, Huldin and Sarus, were animated by interest and resentment to oppose the ambition of Radagaisus. The king of the confederate Germans passed, without resistance, the Alps, the Po, and the Apennine; leaving on one hand the inaccessible palace of Honorius, securely buried among the marshes of Ravenna; and, on the other, the camp of Stilicho, who had fixed his head-quarters at Ticinum, or Pavia, but who seems to have avoided a decisive battle, till he had assembled his distant forces. Many cities of Italy were pillaged, or destroyed; and the siege of Florence, 74 by Radagaisus, is one of the earliest events in the history of that celebrated republic; whose firmness checked and delayed the unskillful fury of the Barbarians. The senate and people trembled at their approach within a hundred and eighty miles of Rome; and anxiously compared the danger which they had escaped, with the new perils to which they were exposed. Alaric was a Christian and a soldier, the leader of a disciplined army; who understood the laws of war, who respected the sanctity of treaties, and who had familiarly conversed with the subjects of the empire in the same camps, and the same churches. The savage Radagaisus was a stranger to the manners, the religion, and even the language, of the civilized nations of the South. The fierceness of his temper was exasperated by cruel superstition; and it was universally believed, that he had bound himself, by a solemn vow, to reduce the city into a heap of stones and ashes, and to sacrifice the most illustrious of the Roman senators on the altars of those gods who were appeased by human blood. The public danger, which should have reconciled all domestic animosities, displayed the incurable madness of religious faction. The oppressed votaries of Jupiter and Mercury respected, in the implacable enemy of Rome, the character of a devout Pagan; loudly declared, that they were more apprehensive of the sacrifices, than of the arms, of Radagaisus; and secretly rejoiced in the calamities of their country, which condemned the faith of their Christian adversaries. 75 7511
那个时代,各国之间音讯难通,往来既稀且不足凭恃,因此北方的种种变乱,拉文纳的宫廷竟可能全然无从知晓;直到那片沿波罗的海岸边聚拢起来的乌云挟雷霆之势,在多瑙河上游倾泻而下。西部皇帝若被大臣们以危机将临的消息扰了兴致,也不过安然做一场战争的缘由与看客罢了。70罗马的安危,全托付给了斯提利科的谋略与刀剑;然而帝国衰弱枯竭到如此地步,既无力重修多瑙河的防御工事,也难以奋力一举,遏止日耳曼人的入侵。71霍诺留麾下这位警觉的大臣,所存的指望仅限于守住意大利。他再度放弃各行省,召回驻军,加紧征募新兵——征令虽严苛催逼,应征者却怯懦逃避;他又想尽一切有效的手段,或缉拿、或利诱逃亡者归伍;并许诺凡愿入伍的奴隶,皆赐以自由之身与金币两枚。72费尽如此气力,他才从一个泱泱大国的臣民中,勉强凑起三四万人的一支军队——而在西庇阿或卡米卢斯的时代,单是罗马近郊的自由公民便能立时提供这许多兵员。73斯提利科的三十个军团另有大批蛮族辅军增援:忠诚的阿兰人亲附于他麾下;匈人与哥特人的队伍则各随本族君长胡尔丁与萨鲁斯的旗号进军,出于利害与宿怨,同心要挫败拉达盖苏斯的野心。这位日耳曼联军之王一路未遇抵抗,越过阿尔卑斯山、波河与亚平宁山脉;一侧撇下霍诺留那座深藏于拉文纳沼泽、无从攻入的宫殿,另一侧撇下斯提利科的营垒——斯提利科已把大本营设在提基努姆(即帕维亚),却似乎有意避战,要等远方各路兵马会齐,方肯决一死战。意大利许多城市遭劫掠或焚毁;拉达盖苏斯围攻佛罗伦萨74一役,则是这座日后名震一时的共和城邦史上最早的大事之一——全城坚守不屈,挫阻并迟滞了蛮族那不谙章法的凶焰。敌军逼近至距罗马一百八十英里之处,元老院与民众为之战栗,忧心忡忡地把方才躲过的旧祸与眼下临头的新危两相权量。阿拉里克既是基督徒,又是军人,统领着一支纪律严明的军队;他深谙战争的法则,尊重条约的神圣,且曾与帝国的臣民同营共处、同堂礼拜,相与款洽。而野蛮的拉达盖苏斯,对南方文明诸族的风习、宗教乃至语言,全然陌生。他生性凶暴,又为残忍的迷信所激,愈发狠戾;人人都相信,他曾立下庄严的誓愿,要把罗马城夷为一片瓦砾灰烬,并将最显赫的罗马元老献祭于那些唯以人血方得平息的神明祭坛之上。这场共同的危难,本该化解一切内部的仇隙,却反倒暴露出宗教派系那不可救药的疯狂。那些备受压制的朱庇特与墨丘利的信徒,竟在罗马这不共戴天的仇敌身上,看重起一位虔诚异教徒的品格;他们高声宣称,比起拉达盖苏斯的刀兵,他们更惧怕他的献祭;暗地里却为祖国的灾祸窃喜,只因这灾祸仿佛正给他们那些基督徒对头的信仰判了罪。75 7511
Florence was reduced to the last extremity; and the fainting courage of the citizens was supported only by the authority of St. Ambrose; who had communicated, in a dream, the promise of a speedy deliverance. 76 On a sudden, they beheld, from their walls, the banners of Stilicho, who advanced, with his united force, to the relief of the faithful city; and who soon marked that fatal spot for the grave of the Barbarian host. The apparent contradictions of those writers who variously relate the defeat of Radagaisus, may be reconciled without offering much violence to their respective testimonies. Orosius and Augustin, who were intimately connected by friendship and religion, ascribed this miraculous victory to the providence of God, rather than to the valor of man. 77 They strictly exclude every idea of chance, or even of bloodshed; and positively affirm, that the Romans, whose camp was the scene of plenty and idleness, enjoyed the distress of the Barbarians, slowly expiring on the sharp and barren ridge of the hills of Faesulae, which rise above the city of Florence. Their extravagant assertion that not a single soldier of the Christian army was killed, or even wounded, may be dismissed with silent contempt; but the rest of the narrative of Augustin and Orosius is consistent with the state of the war, and the character of Stilicho. Conscious that he commanded the last army of the republic, his prudence would not expose it, in the open field, to the headstrong fury of the Germans. The method of surrounding the enemy with strong lines of circumvallation, which he had twice employed against the Gothic king, was repeated on a larger scale, and with more considerable effect. The examples of Caesar must have been familiar to the most illiterate of the Roman warriors; and the fortifications of Dyrrachium, which connected twenty-four castles, by a perpetual ditch and rampart of fifteen miles, afforded the model of an intrenchment which might confine, and starve, the most numerous host of Barbarians. 78 The Roman troops had less degenerated from the industry, than from the valor, of their ancestors; and if their servile and laborious work offended the pride of the soldiers, Tuscany could supply many thousand peasants, who would labor, though, perhaps, they would not fight, for the salvation of their native country. The imprisoned multitude of horses and men 79 was gradually destroyed, by famine rather than by the sword; but the Romans were exposed, during the progress of such an extensive work, to the frequent attacks of an impatient enemy. The despair of the hungry Barbarians would precipitate them against the fortifications of Stilicho; the general might sometimes indulge the ardor of his brave auxiliaries, who eagerly pressed to assault the camp of the Germans; and these various incidents might produce the sharp and bloody conflicts which dignify the narrative of Zosimus, and the Chronicles of Prosper and Marcellinus. 80 A seasonable supply of men and provisions had been introduced into the walls of Florence, and the famished host of Radagaisus was in its turn besieged. The proud monarch of so many warlike nations, after the loss of his bravest warriors, was reduced to confide either in the faith of a capitulation, or in the clemency of Stilicho. 81 But the death of the royal captive, who was ignominiously beheaded, disgraced the triumph of Rome and of Christianity; and the short delay of his execution was sufficient to brand the conqueror with the guilt of cool and deliberate cruelty. 82 The famished Germans, who escaped the fury of the auxiliaries, were sold as slaves, at the contemptible price of as many single pieces of gold; but the difference of food and climate swept away great numbers of those unhappy strangers; and it was observed, that the inhuman purchasers, instead of reaping the fruits of their labor were soon obliged to provide the expense of their interment. Stilicho informed the emperor and the senate of his success; and deserved, a second time, the glorious title of Deliverer of Italy. 83
佛罗伦萨已被逼到山穷水尽的绝境;城中居民勇气将尽,全靠圣安布罗斯的威望支撑——这位圣徒曾在一场梦中传示了不久便将获救的应许。76忽然间,他们从城墙上望见了斯提利科的旌旗——他正率会合的大军前来解救这座忠贞的城市,且不久便择定此地,作为埋葬蛮族大军的坟场。诸家史笔对拉达盖苏斯败亡一事记载不一,表面看似互相牴牾,其实不必怎样牵强,便可将各家的说法调和起来。奥罗修斯与奥古斯丁二人,因友谊与信仰而交谊甚笃,都把这场奇迹般的胜利归功于上帝的眷佑,而非人的勇武。77他们断然排除一切侥幸乃至流血的成分,一口咬定:罗马人这一方军营里丰足安闲,只管坐观蛮族的困苦——那些蛮人正困在俯瞰佛罗伦萨城的法伊苏莱丘陵、在嶙峋荒瘠的山脊上慢慢等死。他们夸口说基督徒军中竟无一兵一卒阵亡、甚至无一人负伤,这等说法尽可付之默然的鄙夷;但奥古斯丁与奥罗修斯叙述的其余部分,倒与战事的实情、斯提利科的为人相吻合。他深知自己所统率的是共和国最后一支军队,出于审慎,断不肯把它摆到旷野之上,去硬撼日耳曼人那一往无前的凶悍。以坚固的围城壁垒把敌人团团圈住,这一战法他先前对付哥特王时已两度施用,如今又照搬过来,规模更大,收效也更著。恺撒的战例,即便是罗马军中最不通文墨的兵士也必耳熟能详;当年迪拉基乌姆的工事,以一道绵延十五英里、不曾中断的壕沟与壁垒把二十四座堡垒连成一气,正为这样一种围垒提供了范本——足以困住并饿垮蛮族最庞大的军队。78罗马军队较之先祖,勤勉上的退化尚不及勇武上那般厉害;若说这般卑贱而繁重的苦役有伤兵士的自尊,托斯卡纳尽可提供成千上万的农夫——他们为拯救故土,或许不肯上阵厮杀,出力流汗却是甘愿的。被围困的人马79成群成群地渐次覆灭,多半死于饥馑而非刀兵;然而这般浩大的工程施工期间,罗马人也不免屡遭焦躁难耐之敌的攻击。饥饿的蛮族出于绝望,会不顾一切地扑向斯提利科的壁垒;这位主帅有时也会纵容麾下勇悍辅军的热望,任他们争先恐后地去猛攻日耳曼人的营寨;这样种种插曲,或许便酿成了佐西莫斯笔下、以及普罗斯佩尔与马尔切利努斯编年史中那些为之增色的激烈血战。80其时一批兵员与粮秣及时运入佛罗伦萨城内,饥饿的拉达盖苏斯大军反过来倒被围困了。这位统辖着如许多善战部族的骄傲君王,折损了麾下最勇猛的战士之后,落到了这般田地:要么寄望于受降条款的信誉,要么指望斯提利科的宽仁。81然而这位被俘之王终遭斩首,死得屈辱,玷污了罗马与基督教的凯旋;处决之前那短短的一段拖延,已足以给胜利者烙上蓄意行凶、冷酷残忍的罪名。82那些侥幸躲过辅军凶焰的饥饿日耳曼人,被当作奴隶卖掉,每人不过区区一枚金币,贱得可怜;然而饮食与气候的悬殊,还是把这些不幸的异乡人成批成批地夺去了性命;据人所见,那些狠心的买主非但没能坐享其劳役之利,反倒不久便得掏钱替他们料理丧葬。斯提利科将捷报奏闻皇帝与元老院;他第二次无愧于“意大利拯救者”这一光荣的称号。83
Faesulae: under the hills above Florence the besieger was besieged 法伊苏莱:佛罗伦萨城外的山岭之下,围城者反被围困 THE BESIEGER BESIEGED 围城者反被围困 THE LAST ARMY OF THE REPUBLIC 共和国最后一支军队 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 AN ARMY OF THIRTY OR FORTY THOUSAND MEN 三四万人的一支军队 He once more abandoned the provinces, recalled the troops, pressed the new levies, which were rigorously exacted and pusillanimously eluded, and offered the gift of freedom, and of two pieces of gold, to all the slaves who would enlist. 他再度放弃各行省,召回驻军,加紧 征募新兵——征令虽严苛催逼,应征 者却怯懦逃避;他还许诺凡愿入伍的 奴隶,皆赐以自由之身与金币两枚。 THE AUXILIARIES 蛮族辅军 the faithful ALANI; the HUNS and GOTHS who marched under their native princes HULDIN and SARUS 忠诚的阿兰人;随本族君长胡尔丁 与萨鲁斯的旗号进军的匈人与哥特人 FLORENCE 佛罗伦萨 THE LINES OF CIRCUMVALLATION 围城壁垒 THE RIDGE OF FAESULAE 法伊苏莱丘陵 THE HOST OF RADAGAISUS 拉达盖苏斯的大军 STILICHO fixed his head-quarters at Ticinum, or Pavia, and seems to have avoided a decisive battle till he had assembled his distant forces. 斯提利科把大本营设在提基努姆 (即帕维亚),似乎有意避战,要等 远方各路兵马会齐,方肯决一死战。 A seasonable supply of men and provisions had been introduced into the walls of Florence, whose fainting courage was supported by the authority of St. Ambrose — who had communicated, in a dream, the promise of a speedy deliverance. 一批兵员与粮秣及时运入佛罗伦萨 城内;城中居民勇气将尽,全靠圣 安布罗斯的威望支撑——这位圣徒 曾在一场梦中传示了不久便将获救 的应许。 The despair of the hungry Barbarians would precipitate them against the fortifications of Stilicho: the imprisoned multitude of horses and men was gradually destroyed, by famine rather than by the sword. 饥饿的蛮族出于绝望,会不顾一切 地扑向斯提利科的壁垒;被围困的 人马成群成群地渐次覆灭,多半死 于饥馑而非刀兵。 THE MODEL: CAESAR AT DYRRACHIUM 范本:恺撒在迪拉基乌姆 the fortifications of Dyrrachium, which connected twenty-four castles by a perpetual ditch and rampart of fifteen miles, afforded the model of an intrenchment which might confine, and starve, the most numerous host of Barbarians 迪拉基乌姆的工事以一道绵延十五英里、不曾中断的壕沟与壁垒把二 十四座堡垒连成一气,正为这样一种围垒提供了范本——足以困住并 饿垮蛮族最庞大的军队 fn 30.79 — Faesulae, only three miles from Florence, might afford space for the head-quarters of Radagaisus, and would be comprehended within the circuit of the Roman lines. The rhetorical expressions of Orosius are not very suitable to the encampment of a great army. 注30.79——法伊苏莱离佛罗伦萨仅三英里,或可容得下拉达盖苏 斯的大本营,且当在罗马围垒的圈围之内。奥罗修斯那些辞藻华丽的说 法,用来形容一支大军的驻扎,并不十分贴切。 “Their extravagant assertion that not a single soldier of the Christian army was killed, or even wounded, may be dismissed with silent contempt.” 「他们夸口说基督徒军中竟无一兵一卒阵亡、甚至无一人负伤,这等说 法尽可付之默然的鄙夷。」 The senate and people trembled at their approach within a hundred and eighty miles of Rome; and it was universally believed that Radagaisus had bound himself, by a solemn vow, to reduce the city into a heap of stones and ashes. 敌军逼近至距罗马一百八十英里之处,元老院与民众 为之战栗;人人都相信,拉达盖苏斯曾立下庄严的誓 愿,要把罗马城夷为一片瓦砾灰烬。 TOWARD ROME 朝罗马而去 “the famished host of Radagaisus was in its turn besieged.” 「饥饿的拉达盖苏斯大军反过来倒被围困了。」 TWO PIECES OF GOLD — freedom, and the bounty of enlisting a slave in the army of the republic 金币两枚——自由之身,外加招一名奴隶入共和国军中的赏格 A SINGLE PIECE OF GOLD — the contemptible price at which the famished Germans were sold as slaves 一枚金币——饥饿的日耳曼人被当作奴隶卖掉时那贱得可怜的身价 The inhuman purchasers, instead of reaping the fruits of their labor, were soon obliged to provide the expense of their interment. 那些狠心的买主非但没能坐享其劳役之利,反倒不 久便得掏钱替他们料理丧葬。 The proud monarch of so many warlike nations was reduced to confide either in the faith of a capitulation, or in the clemency of Stilicho; but the death of the royal captive, who was ignominiously beheaded, disgraced the triumph of Rome and of Christianity, and the short delay of his execution was sufficient to brand the conqueror with the guilt of cool and deliberate cruelty. 这位统辖着如许多善战部族的骄傲君王,落到了这般田地:要么寄望于受降条款的信誉,要么指望斯提利科的宽 仁;然而这位被俘之王终遭斩首,死得屈辱,玷污了罗马与基督教的凯旋;处决之前那短短的一段拖延,已足以 给胜利者烙上蓄意行凶、冷酷残忍的罪名。 Stilicho deserved, a second time, the glorious title of DELIVERER OF ITALY. 斯提利科第二次无愧于「意大利拯救者」这一光荣的称号。
Fig. 30.6 — Under the hills above Florence the besieger was besieged: Stilicho repeated, on the model of Caesar’s lines at Dyrrachium, the method he had twice employed against Alaric, and famine, rather than the sword, destroyed the imprisoned multitude; the royal captive was ignominiously beheaded, and the survivors were sold at the contemptible price of as many single pieces of gold — their purchasers soon obliged to provide the expense of their interment. 图30.6——佛罗伦萨城外的山岭之下,围城者反被围困:斯提利科依照恺撒在迪拉基乌姆筑垒的范本,把先前两度用于阿拉里克的战法重施一遍、规模更大;被困的人马多半死于饥馑而非刀兵;这位被俘之王终遭斩首,死得屈辱,幸存者则被当作奴隶卖掉,每人不过区区一枚金币,贱得可怜——那些买主不久反倒得掏钱替他们料理丧葬。
The fame of the victory, and more especially of the miracle, has encouraged a vain persuasion, that the whole army, or rather nation, of Germans, who migrated from the shores of the Baltic, miserably perished under the walls of Florence. Such indeed was the fate of Radagaisus himself, of his brave and faithful companions, and of more than one third of the various multitude of Sueves and Vandals, of Alani and Burgundians, who adhered to the standard of their general. 84 The union of such an army might excite our surprise, but the causes of separation are obvious and forcible; the pride of birth, the insolence of valor, the jealousy of command, the impatience of subordination, and the obstinate conflict of opinions, of interests, and of passions, among so many kings and warriors, who were untaught to yield, or to obey. After the defeat of Radagaisus, two parts of the German host, which must have exceeded the number of one hundred thousand men, still remained in arms, between the Apennine and the Alps, or between the Alps and the Danube. It is uncertain whether they attempted to revenge the death of their general; but their irregular fury was soon diverted by the prudence and firmness of Stilicho, who opposed their march, and facilitated their retreat; who considered the safety of Rome and Italy as the great object of his care, and who sacrificed, with too much indifference, the wealth and tranquillity of the distant provinces. 85 The Barbarians acquired, from the junction of some Pannonian deserters, the knowledge of the country, and of the roads; and the invasion of Gaul, which Alaric had designed, was executed by the remains of the great army of Radagaisus. 86
这场胜利、尤其那桩奇迹的名声,助长了一种虚妄的臆断,以为从波罗的海岸迁徙而来的整支日耳曼大军——毋宁说整个日耳曼民族——都惨死在佛罗伦萨城下了。拉达盖苏斯本人、他那些勇敢忠诚的伙伴,以及追随其主帅旗号的苏维汇人、汪达尔人、阿兰人和勃艮第人这一支杂色大军中三分之一以上的人,确实落得了这般下场。84这样一支大军竟能拧成一股,或许令我们诧异;但它分崩离析的缘由却是明摆着的,且势所必然:门第的骄矜、勇力的骄横、争权的猜忌、居下位者的不耐,再加上如许多君长战士之间意见、利害与意气那顽固难解的冲突——而这些人生来就不曾学过退让或服从。拉达盖苏斯败亡之后,日耳曼大军中另有两部——人数必在十万以上——仍旧执戈未散,或盘桓于亚平宁与阿尔卑斯之间,或往来于阿尔卑斯与多瑙河之间。他们是否曾图谋为主帅复仇,已不得而知;但他们那漫无章法的凶焰,不久便被斯提利科的审慎与坚定引开了去——他一面阻其进路,一面为其退路大开方便;他心目中头等要务,是罗马与意大利的安危,至于远方各行省的富庶与安宁,他牺牲起来未免太过漠然。85几名潘诺尼亚逃兵前来投奔,蛮族这才摸清了地形与道路;于是,阿拉里克原先谋划的那场入侵高卢之举,竟由拉达盖苏斯大军的残部付诸实行了。86
Yet if they expected to derive any assistance from the tribes of Germany, who inhabited the banks of the Rhine, their hopes were disappointed. The Alemanni preserved a state of inactive neutrality; and the Franks distinguished their zeal and courage in the defence of the of the empire. In the rapid progress down the Rhine, which was the first act of the administration of Stilicho, he had applied himself, with peculiar attention, to secure the alliance of the warlike Franks, and to remove the irreconcilable enemies of peace and of the republic. Marcomir, one of their kings, was publicly convicted, before the tribunal of the Roman magistrate, of violating the faith of treaties. He was sentenced to a mild, but distant exile, in the province of Tuscany; and this degradation of the regal dignity was so far from exciting the resentment of his subjects, that they punished with death the turbulent Sunno, who attempted to revenge his brother; and maintained a dutiful allegiance to the princes, who were established on the throne by the choice of Stilicho. 87 When the limits of Gaul and Germany were shaken by the northern emigration, the Franks bravely encountered the single force of the Vandals; who, regardless of the lessons of adversity, had again separated their troops from the standard of their Barbarian allies. They paid the penalty of their rashness; and twenty thousand Vandals, with their king Godigisclus, were slain in the field of battle. The whole people must have been extirpated, if the squadrons of the Alani, advancing to their relief, had not trampled down the infantry of the Franks; who, after an honorable resistance, were compelled to relinquish the unequal contest. The victorious confederates pursued their march, and on the last day of the year, in a season when the waters of the Rhine were most probably frozen, they entered, without opposition, the defenceless provinces of Gaul. This memorable passage of the Suevi, the Vandals, the Alani, and the Burgundians, who never afterwards retreated, may be considered as the fall of the Roman empire in the countries beyond the Alps; and the barriers, which had so long separated the savage and the civilized nations of the earth, were from that fatal moment levelled with the ground. 88
然而,他们若指望从莱茵河两岸的日耳曼诸部族那里得到什么助力,那便是要失望了。阿勒曼尼人按兵不动,守着中立;法兰克人则在保卫帝国一事上显出了非凡的热忱与勇气。当年斯提利科执政伊始的头一桩举措,便是沿莱茵河疾驰而下;其间他格外用心,力求牢牢结好骁勇善战的法兰克人,并铲除那些与和平、与国家势不两立的死敌。法兰克诸王之一马科米尔,因背弃条约的信义,在罗马官员的法庭上当众定了罪。判处他流放,发落虽不严苛,去处却颇遥远——放逐到托斯卡纳行省。王者尊严受此贬抑,非但未激起臣民的怨愤,反倒是:当桀骜的苏诺意图为其兄复仇时,众人竟将他处死;而对斯提利科所选立、扶上王座的君长,他们始终恪守臣节,忠顺不二。87及至北方民族的大迁徙撼动了高卢与日耳曼的边界,法兰克人挺身独战汪达尔人一军——那汪达尔人不记前番患难的教训,又一次把自家队伍从蛮族盟友的旗号下拆分了出来。他们为自己的鲁莽付出了代价:两万汪达尔人连同其王戈迪吉斯克鲁斯,尽数战死沙场。汪达尔全族本已濒于灭绝,幸得阿兰骑兵驰援赶到,踏破了法兰克人的步阵;法兰克人奋力抵抗,虽不失体面,终究众寡悬殊,只得放弃这场角逐。获胜的联军继续进军,就在这一年的最后一天——其时莱茵河水多半已然封冻——他们不遇任何抵抗,长驱进入了无险可守的高卢诸行省。苏维汇人、汪达尔人、阿兰人与勃艮第人这一次可纪念的渡河,此后再未回头——它足可视为罗马帝国在阿尔卑斯山以外诸地的覆亡;那道长久以来把大地上蛮荒之族与文明之族隔开的屏障,自这一注定的时刻起,便被夷为平地了。88
While the peace of Germany was secured by the attachment of the Franks, and the neutrality of the Alemanni, the subjects of Rome, unconscious of their approaching calamities, enjoyed the state of quiet and prosperity, which had seldom blessed the frontiers of Gaul. Their flocks and herds were permitted to graze in the pastures of the Barbarians; their huntsmen penetrated, without fear or danger, into the darkest recesses of the Hercynian wood. 89 The banks of the Rhine were crowned, like those of the Tyber, with elegant houses, and well-cultivated farms; and if a poet descended the river, he might express his doubt, on which side was situated the territory of the Romans. 90 This scene of peace and plenty was suddenly changed into a desert; and the prospect of the smoking ruins could alone distinguish the solitude of nature from the desolation of man. The flourishing city of Mentz was surprised and destroyed; and many thousand Christians were inhumanly massacred in the church. Worms perished after a long and obstinate siege; Strasburgh, Spires, Rheims, Tournay, Arras, Amiens, experienced the cruel oppression of the German yoke; and the consuming flames of war spread from the banks of the Rhine over the greatest part of the seventeen provinces of Gaul. That rich and extensive country, as far as the ocean, the Alps, and the Pyrenees, was delivered to the Barbarians, who drove before them, in a promiscuous crowd, the bishop, the senator, and the virgin, laden with the spoils of their houses and altars. 91 The ecclesiastics, to whom we are indebted for this vague description of the public calamities, embraced the opportunity of exhorting the Christians to repent of the sins which had provoked the Divine Justice, and to renounce the perishable goods of a wretched and deceitful world. But as the Pelagian controversy, 92 which attempts to sound the abyss of grace and predestination, soon became the serious employment of the Latin clergy, the Providence which had decreed, or foreseen, or permitted, such a train of moral and natural evils, was rashly weighed in the imperfect and fallacious balance of reason. The crimes, and the misfortunes, of the suffering people, were presumptuously compared with those of their ancestors; and they arraigned the Divine Justice, which did not exempt from the common destruction the feeble, the guiltless, the infant portion of the human species. These idle disputants overlooked the invariable laws of nature, which have connected peace with innocence, plenty with industry, and safety with valor. The timid and selfish policy of the court of Ravenna might recall the Palatine legions for the protection of Italy; the remains of the stationary troops might be unequal to the arduous task; and the Barbarian auxiliaries might prefer the unbounded license of spoil to the benefits of a moderate and regular stipend. But the provinces of Gaul were filled with a numerous race of hardy and robust youth, who, in the defence of their houses, their families, and their altars, if they had dared to die, would have deserved to vanquish. The knowledge of their native country would have enabled them to oppose continual and insuperable obstacles to the progress of an invader; and the deficiency of the Barbarians, in arms, as well as in discipline, removed the only pretence which excuses the submission of a populous country to the inferior numbers of a veteran army. When France was invaded by Charles V., he inquired of a prisoner, how many days Paris might be distant from the frontier; “Perhaps twelve, but they will be days of battle:” 93 such was the gallant answer which checked the arrogance of that ambitious prince. The subjects of Honorius, and those of Francis I., were animated by a very different spirit; and in less than two years, the divided troops of the savages of the Baltic, whose numbers, were they fairly stated, would appear contemptible, advanced, without a combat, to the foot of the Pyrenean Mountains.
法兰克人既已归心、阿勒曼尼人又守中立,日耳曼一带的和平因而得以保全;罗马的臣民浑然不觉大祸将至,尽享着一派安宁富庶——这般景象,高卢边境素来是难得一见的。他们的牛羊获准到蛮族的牧场上放牧;他们的猎人也能毫无惧色、毫无风险地深入赫尔基尼亚密林最幽深的角落。89莱茵河两岸,一如台伯河畔,处处点缀着精雅的宅第与耕作齐整的田庄;诗人若泛舟顺流而下,恐怕会一时犯疑:究竟哪一岸才是罗马人的疆土。90这一派太平丰足的景象,骤然化作一片荒芜;唯有那犹自冒烟的废墟,才能让人分辨出何处是天然的旷寂、何处是人为的荒凉。繁华的美因茨城遭突袭而毁;成千上万的基督徒在教堂里惨遭屠戮。沃尔姆斯苦守良久,终告陷落;斯特拉斯堡、施派尔、兰斯、图尔内、阿拉斯、亚眠,一一尝到了日耳曼枷锁的残酷压迫;战火愈烧愈炽,自莱茵河两岸蔓延开来,席卷了高卢十七个行省的绝大部分。这片富庶辽阔的国土,远至大洋、阿尔卑斯山与比利牛斯山,全都落入了蛮族之手;他们把主教、元老与贞女不分贵贱地成群驱赶在前,自己则满载着从这些人家宅与圣坛上劫来的财物。91关于这场公共灾难,我们所得的这番笼统描述,全赖教会中人留下;他们趁机劝勉基督徒悔改那些触怒了上帝公义的罪愆,并舍弃这可悲而虚妄的尘世中一切转瞬即逝的财货。然而,佩拉纠派之争92——它力图探测恩典与预定这一深渊的底蕴——不久便成了拉丁教士们郑重其事的功课;于是,那位注定了、或预见了、或听任了这一连串道德之恶与自然之灾的天意,竟被人轻率地放到理性那架残缺而靠不住的天平上去称量。受难民众的罪孽与不幸,被人狂妄地拿来与他们祖先的相比较;他们还诘责上帝的公义,责问它为何不让柔弱者、无辜者以及尚在襁褓的婴孩免于这场共同的毁灭。这些空谈之辈,却忽略了自然界那些亘古不变的法则:和平系于清白,丰足系于勤劳,安全系于勇武。拉文纳宫廷的政策既怯懦又自私,为守护意大利,或许会把帕拉丁诸军团调回;留驻边地的残兵或许难当这艰巨的重任;而蛮族辅军或许宁取那放纵无度、任意劫掠的快意,也看不上一份不多不少、按时发放的饷银。然而,高卢诸行省本不乏众多剽悍强健的青年;他们若肯为保卫自家的宅院、家眷与神坛而拼死一战,原是配得上一场胜利的。凭着对故土地理的熟稔,他们本可给入侵者的推进设下重重难以逾越的障碍;何况蛮族无论在兵器还是纪律上都远逊一筹;一个人烟稠密之国向一支人数虽寡却身经百战的军队俯首,本还有这唯一一点可作托辞,如今连这点借口也荡然无存了。当年查理五世入侵法兰西时,曾问一名俘虏,从边境到巴黎约需几日行程;“或许十二日,可这十二日,日日都是恶战。”93——这一句豪迈的回答,煞住了那位野心勃勃的君主的骄气。霍诺留的臣民与弗朗索瓦一世的臣民,胸中所怀的气概却大不相同;于是不到两年,那些来自波罗的海的野蛮人——他们分成数股,其人数若据实道来,原少得不足挂齿——竟未经一战,便一路推进到了比利牛斯山脚下。
The last day of the year: the barrier of the Rhine broken, and Gaul overrun 这一年的最后一天:莱茵河这道屏障被冲破,高卢遭长驱蹂躏 THE LAST DAY OF THE YEAR 这一年的最后一天 “the barriers, which had so long separated the savage and the civilized nations of the earth, were from that fatal moment levelled with the ground.” 「那道长久以来把大地上蛮荒之族与文明之族隔开的屏障,自这一注定的时刻起,便被夷为平地了。」 GAUL 高卢 GERMANY 日耳曼 BRITAIN 不列颠 THE OCEAN 大洋 THE ALPS 阿尔卑斯山 THE PYRENEAN MOUNTAINS 比利牛斯山 THE RHINE 莱茵河 ELEGANT HOUSES ON BOTH BANKS 两岸精雅的宅第 MENTZ 美因茨 WORMS 沃尔姆斯 SPIRES 施派尔 STRASBURGH 斯特拉斯堡 RHEIMS 兰斯 TOURNAY 图尔内 ARRAS 阿拉斯 AMIENS 亚眠 ON THE LAST DAY OF THE YEAR 就在这一年的最后一天 the waters most probably frozen 其时莱茵河水多半已然封冻 SUEVI · VANDALS · ALANI · BURGUNDIANS 苏维汇人·汪达尔人·阿兰人·勃艮第人 who never afterwards retreated 此后再未回头 THE FRANKS AND THE VANDALS 法兰克人与汪达尔人 TO THE FOOT OF THE PYRENEES 直抵比利牛斯山脚下 in less than two years, and without a combat — their numbers, were they fairly stated, contemptible 不到两年,未经一战——其人数若据实道来, 原少得不足挂齿 THE SEVENTEEN PROVINCES 十七个行省 1 THE FRANKS AND THE VANDALS 法兰克人与汪达尔人 The Alemanni preserved a state of inactive neutrality, and the Franks distinguished their zeal and courage in the defence of the empire. When the limits of Gaul and Germany were shaken by the northern emigration, the Franks bravely encountered the single force of the Vandals: twenty thousand Vandals, with their king Godigisclus, were slain in the field of battle. The whole people must have been extirpated, if the squadrons of the Alani had not trampled down the infantry of the Franks. 阿勒曼尼人按兵不动,守着中立;法兰克人则在保卫帝国一事上显出了 非凡的热忱与勇气。及至北方民族的大迁徙撼动了高卢与日耳曼的边界, 法兰克人挺身独战汪达尔人一军:两万汪达尔人连同其王戈迪吉斯克 鲁斯,尽数战死沙场。汪达尔全族本已濒于灭绝,幸得阿兰骑兵驰援赶 到,踏破了法兰克人的步阵。 2 THE BANKS BEFORE THE PASSAGE 渡河之前的两岸 The subjects of Rome, unconscious of their approaching calamities, enjoyed a state of quiet and prosperity which had seldom blessed the frontiers of Gaul. The banks of the Rhine were crowned, like those of the Tyber, with elegant houses and well-cultivated farms; and if a poet descended the river, he might express his doubt, on which side was situated the territory of the Romans. This scene of peace and plenty was suddenly changed into a desert. 罗马的臣民浑然不觉大祸将至,尽享着一派安宁富庶——这般景象,高 卢边境素来是难得一见的。莱茵河两岸,一如台伯河畔,处处点缀着精 雅的宅第与耕作齐整的田庄;诗人若泛舟顺流而下,恐怕会一时犯疑: 究竟哪一岸才是罗马人的疆土。这一派太平丰足的景象,骤然化作一片 荒芜。 3 THE CONSUMING FLAMES 愈烧愈炽的战火 DESTROYED — MENTZ, surprised and destroyed, and many thousand Christians inhumanly massacred in the church; WORMS, which perished after a long and obstinate siege. UNDER THE GERMAN YOKE — STRASBURGH, SPIRES, RHEIMS, TOURNAY, ARRAS, AMIENS. The flames spread over the greatest part of the seventeen provinces of Gaul; and the Barbarians drove before them, in a promiscuous crowd, the bishop, the senator, and the virgin. 毁于兵燹——美因茨遭突袭而毁,成千上万的基督徒在教堂里惨遭屠戮; 沃尔姆斯苦守良久,终告陷落。尝到日耳曼枷锁压迫的——斯特拉斯 堡、施派尔、兰斯、图尔内、阿拉斯、亚眠。战火席卷了高卢十七个行 省的绝大部分;蛮族把主教、元老与贞女不分贵贱地成群驱赶在前。 “This memorable passage of the Suevi, the Vandals, the Alani, and the Burgundians, who never afterwards retreated, may be considered as the fall of the Roman empire in the countries beyond the Alps.” 「苏维汇人、汪达尔人、阿兰人与勃艮第人这一次可纪念的渡河,此后再未回头——它足可视为罗马帝国在阿尔卑斯山以外诸地的覆亡。」
Fig. 30.7 — On the last day of the year, in a season when the waters of the Rhine were most probably frozen, the Suevi, the Vandals, the Alani, and the Burgundians — fresh from the slaughter of twenty thousand Vandals and their king by the Franks — entered the defenceless provinces of Gaul without opposition: a passage which may be considered as the fall of the Roman empire in the countries beyond the Alps. 图30.7——就在这一年的最后一天,其时莱茵河水多半已然封冻,苏维汇人、汪达尔人、阿兰人与勃艮第人——不久前两万汪达尔人连同其王刚丧于法兰克人之手——不遇任何抵抗,长驱进入了无险可守的高卢诸行省:这一次渡河,足可视为罗马帝国在阿尔卑斯山以外诸地的覆亡。
In the early part of the reign of Honorius, the vigilance of Stilicho had successfully guarded the remote island of Britain from her incessant enemies of the ocean, the mountains, and the Irish coast. 94 But those restless Barbarians could not neglect the fair opportunity of the Gothic war, when the walls and stations of the province were stripped of the Roman troops. If any of the legionaries were permitted to return from the Italian expedition, their faithful report of the court and character of Honorius must have tended to dissolve the bonds of allegiance, and to exasperate the seditious temper of the British army. The spirit of revolt, which had formerly disturbed the age of Gallienus, was revived by the capricious violence of the soldiers; and the unfortunate, perhaps the ambitious, candidates, who were the objects of their choice, were the instruments, and at length the victims, of their passion. 95 Marcus was the first whom they placed on the throne, as the lawful emperor of Britain and of the West. They violated, by the hasty murder of Marcus, the oath of fidelity which they had imposed on themselves; and their disapprobation of his manners may seem to inscribe an honorable epitaph on his tomb. Gratian was the next whom they adorned with the diadem and the purple; and, at the end of four months, Gratian experienced the fate of his predecessor. The memory of the great Constantine, whom the British legions had given to the church and to the empire, suggested the singular motive of their third choice. They discovered in the ranks a private soldier of the name of Constantine, and their impetuous levity had already seated him on the throne, before they perceived his incapacity to sustain the weight of that glorious appellation. 96 Yet the authority of Constantine was less precarious, and his government was more successful, than the transient reigns of Marcus and of Gratian. The danger of leaving his inactive troops in those camps, which had been twice polluted with blood and sedition, urged him to attempt the reduction of the Western provinces. He landed at Boulogne with an inconsiderable force; and after he had reposed himself some days, he summoned the cities of Gaul, which had escaped the yoke of the Barbarians, to acknowledge their lawful sovereign. They obeyed the summons without reluctance. The neglect of the court of Ravenna had absolved a deserted people from the duty of allegiance; their actual distress encouraged them to accept any circumstances of change, without apprehension, and, perhaps, with some degree of hope; and they might flatter themselves, that the troops, the authority, and even the name of a Roman emperor, who fixed his residence in Gaul, would protect the unhappy country from the rage of the Barbarians. The first successes of Constantine against the detached parties of the Germans, were magnified by the voice of adulation into splendid and decisive victories; which the reunion and insolence of the enemy soon reduced to their just value. His negotiations procured a short and precarious truce; and if some tribes of the Barbarians were engaged, by the liberality of his gifts and promises, to undertake the defence of the Rhine, these expensive and uncertain treaties, instead of restoring the pristine vigor of the Gallic frontier, served only to disgrace the majesty of the prince, and to exhaust what yet remained of the treasures of the republic. Elated, however, with this imaginary triumph, the vain deliverer of Gaul advanced into the provinces of the South, to encounter a more pressing and personal danger. Sarus the Goth was ordered to lay the head of the rebel at the feet of the emperor Honorius; and the forces of Britain and Italy were unworthily consumed in this domestic quarrel. After the loss of his two bravest generals, Justinian and Nevigastes, the former of whom was slain in the field of battle, the latter in a peaceful but treacherous interview, Constantine fortified himself within the walls of Vienna. The place was ineffectually attacked seven days; and the Imperial army supported, in a precipitate retreat, the ignominy of purchasing a secure passage from the freebooters and outlaws of the Alps. 97 Those mountains now separated the dominions of two rival monarchs; and the fortifications of the double frontier were guarded by the troops of the empire, whose arms would have been more usefully employed to maintain the Roman limits against the Barbarians of Germany and Scythia.
霍诺留在位的头些年里,斯提利科警觉戒备,成功地守护着不列颠这座偏远的海岛,使它免遭来自海上、山地与爱尔兰海岸那些无休无止之敌的侵扰。94但当哥特战争一起,该行省城墙戍所里的罗马驻军被抽调一空之际,那些不肯安分的蛮族,自然不会放过这一大好时机。倘有军团士兵获准从意大利远征归来,他们据实讲述的宫廷内情与霍诺留的为人,势必会松动效忠的纽带,激起不列颠军队本就好乱的脾性。昔日曾搅乱加里恩努斯一朝的叛乱之风,如今又因士兵们反复无常的暴戾而死灰复燃;那几个被他们拥立的倒霉鬼——或许也是野心家——先是充当了他们狂热情绪的工具,到头来又成了这股狂热的牺牲品。95他们最先扶上宝座、奉为不列颠与西部合法皇帝的,是马库斯。他们草草弑杀了马库斯,背弃了自己立下的效忠誓言;而他们之所以不满于他的作风,倒仿佛为他的墓碑刻下了一句光彩的碑铭。接着被他们加冕披紫、奉为皇帝的是格拉提安;才过四个月,格拉提安便重蹈了前任的覆辙。伟大的君士坦丁当年正是不列颠军团奉献给教会与帝国的;对他的追念,促成了他们第三次拥立时那个离奇的动机。他们在行伍之中发现了一个名叫君士坦丁的小兵;一时轻率冲动,早已把他扶上了帝位,却还没看出他压根担不起这一光荣名号的分量。96不过,比起马库斯与格拉提安那昙花一现的短命之治,这位君士坦丁的权位倒还稳固些,治绩也更可观些。那几座军营已两度被血腥与叛乱所玷污,把无所事事的部队继续留在那里终究危险;这就促使他动手去谋取西部各行省。他带着一支为数不多的兵力在布洛涅登陆;歇息数日之后,便传令高卢那些尚未落入蛮族枷锁的城市,要它们承认自己这位合法的君主。各城毫不迟疑,欣然从命。拉文纳宫廷的不闻不问,早已把这群被遗弃的子民从效忠的义务中解脱了出来;眼下的困厄,又促使他们愿意接受任何形式的变动,毫无疑惧,甚至还怀着几分指望;他们或许还自我宽慰地想:一位罗马皇帝把居所定在高卢,那么他的军队、他的权威,乃至他这“罗马皇帝”的名号,总能保这片苦难的国土免受蛮族的暴虐吧。君士坦丁起初对付日耳曼人几支零散队伍所取得的小胜,被阿谀之声吹嘘成辉煌而决定性的大捷;可敌人重新集结、气焰复炽,转眼便把这些“大捷”还原到了它们本来的分量。他几番交涉,换来一纸短暂而靠不住的休战;纵然凭着慷慨的馈赠与许诺,笼络了几个蛮族部落去担负守卫莱茵河之责,这些既费钱又不牢靠的条约,非但没能恢复高卢边境昔日的锐气,反倒只是折损了君主的威严,并把国库中所剩无几的资财也耗尽了。然而,这位徒有虚名的高卢拯救者却因这场想象中的凯旋而洋洋自得,遂挥师南下,进入南方诸行省,去迎接一桩更为迫近、更关乎自身的凶险。哥特人萨鲁斯奉命去把这叛贼的首级献到霍诺留皇帝脚下;于是不列颠与意大利的兵力,都白白虚耗在了这场内讧之中。君士坦丁麾下两员最勇猛的大将查士丁尼与内维加斯特斯先后折损——前者战死沙场,后者则丧命于一场表面和平、实则暗藏杀机的会晤——此后,他便退守维埃纳城墙之内,据险自固。围攻此城七日,无功而返;帝国军队仓皇撤退,途中竟不得不忍辱花钱,向阿尔卑斯山中那些强盗匪徒买一条安稳的退路。97如今,这道山脉把两位敌对君主的领土隔了开来;这一双重边界上的工事,由帝国的军队把守——而这些军队的刀兵,本该更有用地去防守罗马疆界,抵御来自日耳曼与斯基泰的蛮族才是。

Notes 注释

70
Cujus agendi
Spectator vel causa fui,
—-(Claudian, vi. Cons. Hon. 439,)
is the modest language of Honorius, in speaking of the Gothic war, which he had seen somewhat nearer.
Cujus agendi Spectator vel causa fui(“此番举事,我或为看客,或为缘由”,克劳狄安 vi. Cons. Hon. 439)——霍诺留谈起这场他就近看得稍真切些的哥特战争时,所用的正是这般自谦之语。
71
Zosimus (l. v. p. 331) transports the war, and the victory of Stilisho, beyond the Danube. A strange error, which is awkwardly and imperfectly cured (Tillemont, Hist. des Emp. tom. v. p. 807.) In good policy, we must use the service of Zosimus, without esteeming or trusting him.
佐西莫斯(l. v. p. 331)把这场战争连同斯提利科的胜利,都搬到了多瑙河的彼岸。这是个离奇的错误,虽经蒂耶蒙(Hist. des Emp. tom. v. p. 807)勉强弥缝,终究不能圆满。说到取舍之道,我们对佐西莫斯,只可利用其记述,却不必敬重、也不必轻信其人。
72
Codex Theodos. l. vii. tit. xiii. leg. 16. The date of this law A.D. 406. May 18 satisfies me, as it had done Godefroy, (tom. ii. p. 387,) of the true year of the invasion of Radagaisus. Tillemont, Pagi, and Muratori, prefer the preceding year; but they are bound, by certain obligations of civility and respect, to St. Paulinus of Nola.
《狄奥多西法典》l. vii. tit. xiii. leg. 16。此项法令的日期为公元406年5月18日,这一日期使我确信——正如它当年使戈德弗鲁瓦(tom. ii. p. 387)确信的那样——拉达盖苏斯入侵的确切年份即在此时。蒂耶蒙、帕吉与穆拉托里都倾向于取前一年;但他们碍于对诺拉的圣保利努斯所负的某种礼敬与情面,才不得不如此。
73
Soon after Rome had been taken by the Gauls, the senate, on a sudden emergency, armed ten legions, 3000 horse, and 42,000 foot; a force which the city could not have sent forth under Augustus, (Livy, xi. 25.) This declaration may puzzle an antiquary, but it is clearly explained by Montesquieu.
罗马被高卢人攻陷后不久,元老院因猝然临危,武装起十个军团,计骑兵三千、步兵四万二千;这样一支兵力,即便到了奥古斯都治下,罗马城也未必调得出来(李维,xi. 25)。这番话或许会叫考据家困惑不解,孟德斯鸠却把它解释得清清楚楚。
74
Machiavel has explained, at least as a philosopher, the origin of Florence, which insensibly descended, for the benefit of trade, from the rock of Faesulae to the banks of the Arno, (Istoria Fiorentina, tom. i. p. 36. Londra, 1747.) The triumvirs sent a colony to Florence, which, under Tiberius, (Tacit. Annal. i. 79,) deserved the reputation and name of a flourishing city. See Cluver. Ital. Antiq. tom. i. p. 507, &c.
马基雅维利(至少是以哲人的眼光)解说过佛罗伦萨的由来:为便于通商,它不知不觉地从法伊苏莱的山岩迁下,移到了阿尔诺河畔(《佛罗伦萨史》tom. i. p. 36,伦敦,1747年)。三头执政曾向佛罗伦萨派遣过一批殖民;到提比略在位时(塔西佗《编年史》i. 79),这座城市已足当“繁荣都会”之名。参看克吕韦里乌斯《意大利古志》tom. i. p. 507 等。
75
Yet the Jupiter of Radagaisus, who worshipped Thor and Woden, was very different from the Olympic or Capitoline Jove. The accommodating temper of Polytheism might unite those various and remote deities; but the genuine Romans ahhorred the human sacrifices of Gaul and Germany.
不过,拉达盖苏斯崇奉的乃是托尔与沃登,他心目中的那位“朱庇特”,与奥林匹斯或卡皮托利山上的朱庇特实在大相径庭。多神教那副兼容并蓄的脾性,或许能把这些形形色色、相距辽远的神明捏合到一处;但真正的罗马人,对高卢与日耳曼以活人为祭的做法,是深恶痛绝的。
7511
Gibbon has rather softened the language of Augustine as to this threatened insurrection of the Pagans, in order to restore the prohibited rites and ceremonies of Paganism; and their treasonable hopes that the success of Radagaisus would be the triumph of idolatry. Compare ii. 25—M.
吉本在此把奥古斯丁的措辞冲淡了些:奥古斯丁本是说,异教徒扬言要发动叛乱,以恢复被禁的异教仪典,并怀着大逆不道的指望,盼拉达盖苏斯得胜便是偶像崇拜的凯旋。参较 ii. 25。—M
76
Paulinus (in Vit. Ambros c. 50) relates this story, which he received from the mouth of Pansophia herself, a religious matron of Florence. Yet the archbishop soon ceased to take an active part in the business of the world, and never became a popular saint.
保利努斯(《安布罗斯传》c. 50)记述了这段故事,说是亲耳听佛罗伦萨一位虔诚的主妇潘索菲娅本人讲的。不过这位大主教不久便不再插手尘世的事务,也从未成为广受崇奉的圣徒。
77
Augustin de Civitat. Dei, v. 23. Orosius, l. vii. c. 37, p. 567-571. The two friends wrote in Africa, ten or twelve years after the victory; and their authority is implicitly followed by Isidore of Seville, (in Chron. p. 713, edit. Grot.) How many interesting facts might Orosius have inserted in the vacant space which is devoted to pious nonsense!
奥古斯丁《上帝之城》v. 23。奥罗修斯,l. vii. c. 37, p. 567-571。这两位友人都是在此役过后十年或十二年间于非洲写成其书的;塞维利亚的伊西多尔(in Chron. p. 713,格劳秀斯校订本)也一味沿袭他们的说法。奥罗修斯把那么多篇幅拿去写虔诚的胡话,其间本可插叙多少有趣的史实啊!
78
Franguntur montes, planumque per ardua Caesar
Ducit opus: pandit fossas, turritaque summis
Disponit castella jugis, magnoque necessu
Amplexus fines, saltus, memorosaque tesqua
Et silvas, vastaque feras indagine claudit.!
Yet the simplicity of truth (Caesar, de Bell. Civ. iii. 44) is far greater than the amplifications of Lucan, (Pharsal. l. vi. 29-63.)
Franguntur montes, planumque per ardua Caesar Ducit opus: pandit fossas, turritaque summis Disponit castella jugis, magnoque necessu Amplexus fines, saltus, memorosaque tesqua Et silvas, vastaque feras indagine claudit.!(大意为:群山被劈开,恺撒把平坦的工事一路修上险峻的高地:他挖开一道道壕沟,又沿着一处处山脊的顶端布置起带箭塔的堡垒;他以浩大的围墙把整片地界都环抱起来,将林间的空地、长满草木的荒僻角落连同大片森林一齐圈入其中,更像张开一面广阔的围猎大网,把里面的野兽也统统困死在内。)然而,恺撒本人(《内战记》de Bell. Civ. iii. 44)那种质朴无华、直陈其事的叙述,其分量远远胜过卢坎(《法尔萨利亚》Pharsal. l. vi. 29-63)这一番词藻铺张的渲染。
79
The rhetorical expressions of Orosius, “in arido et aspero montis jugo;” “in unum ac parvum verticem,” are not very suitable to the encampment of a great army. But Faesulae, only three miles from Florence, might afford space for the head-quarters of Radagaisus, and would be comprehended within the circuit of the Roman lines.
奥罗修斯那些辞藻华丽的说法——“in arido et aspero montis jugo”(在干旱嶙峋的山脊上)、“in unum ac parvum verticem”(挤在一处窄小的峰顶)——用来形容一支大军的驻扎,并不十分贴切。不过法伊苏莱离佛罗伦萨仅三英里,或可容得下拉达盖苏斯的大本营,且当在罗马围垒的圈围之内。
80
See Zosimus, l. v. p. 331, and the Chronicles of Prosper and Marcellinus.
参看佐西莫斯,l. v. p. 331,以及普罗斯佩尔与马尔切利努斯的编年史。
81
Olympiodorus (apud Photium, p. 180) uses an expression which would denote a strict and friendly alliance, and render Stilicho still more criminal. The paulisper detentus, deinde interfectus, of Orosius, is sufficiently odious. * Note: Gibbon, by translating this passage of Olympiodorus, as if it had been good Greek, has probably fallen into an error. The natural order of the words is as Gibbon translates it; but it is almost clear, refers to the Gothic chiefs, “whom Stilicho, after he had defeated Radagaisus, attached to his army.” So in the version corrected by Classen for Niebuhr’s edition of the Byzantines, p. 450.—M.
奥林匹奥多罗斯(辑于佛提乌书中,p. 180)所用的措辞,意味着一种严密而友好的结盟,这就使斯提利科更显罪咎深重。奥罗修斯所谓“paulisper detentus, deinde interfectus”(先羁留些时,随即处死),已够可憎的了。* 编者按:吉本把奥林匹奥多罗斯这段文字当作通顺的希腊文来翻译,多半是弄错了。照吉本的译法,词序固然自然;然而这段话几乎可以肯定指的是那些哥特首领——“斯提利科击败拉达盖苏斯之后,把他们收编入自己的军中”。克拉森为尼布尔版《拜占庭史家丛书》所校订的本子(p. 450)便是如此。—M
82
Orosius, piously inhuman, sacrifices the king and people, Agag and the Amalekites, without a symptom of compassion. The bloody actor is less detestable than the cool, unfeeling historian.——Note: Considering the vow, which he was universally believed to have made, to destroy Rome, and to sacrifice the senators on the altars, and that he is said to have immolated his prisoners to his gods, the execution of Radagaisus, if, as it appears, he was taken in arms, cannot deserve Gibbon’s severe condemnation. Mr. Herbert (notes to his poem of Attila, p. 317) justly observes, that “Stilicho had probably authority for hanging him on the first tree.” Marcellinus, adds Mr. Herbert, attributes the execution to the Gothic chiefs Sarus.—M.
奥罗修斯怀着一副虔诚而不近人情的心肠,把国王连同他的子民一并当作亚甲与亚玛力人来献祭,竟无半点怜悯之意。那嗜血的行凶者,倒还不如这位冷酷无情的史家可憎。——编者按:拉达盖苏斯据说曾发誓要毁灭罗马、把元老们献祭于祭坛,且相传他确曾把俘虏杀献给自己的诸神;有鉴于此,倘若他果真是被擒于阵前(看来正是如此),那么处死他一事,实在当不起吉本这般严厉的谴责。赫伯特先生(其长诗《阿提拉》注释,p. 317)说得公道:“斯提利科多半有权把他吊死在头一棵树上。”赫伯特先生又补充道,马尔切利努斯把这次处决归于哥特首领萨鲁斯。—M
83
And Claudian’s muse, was she asleep? had she been ill paid! Methinks the seventh consulship of Honorius (A.D. 407) would have furnished the subject of a noble poem. Before it was discovered that the state could no longer be saved, Stilicho (after Romulus, Camillus and Marius) might have been worthily surnamed the fourth founder of Rome.
克劳狄安的缪斯,莫非睡着了?还是酬劳给得太薄了!我看,霍诺留第七度执政那一年(公元407年),本大可作一首堂皇诗篇的题材。在世人尚未看清国家已无可挽救之前,斯提利科(继罗慕路斯、卡米卢斯与马略之后)原可当之无愧地被尊为“罗马的第四位奠基者”。
84
A luminous passage of Prosper’s Chronicle, “In tres partes, pes diversos principes, diversus exercitus,” reduces the miracle of Florence and connects the history of Italy, Gaul, and Germany.
普罗斯佩尔编年史中有一段话说得明白:“In tres partes, pes diversos principes, diversus exercitus”(大军分作三部,各随不同的君长),它把佛罗伦萨那桩“奇迹”的分量削减了下来,并将意大利、高卢与日耳曼三地的历史贯通起来。
85
Orosius and Jerom positively charge him with instigating the in vasion. “Excitatae a Stilichone gentes,” &c. They must mean a directly. He saved Italy at the expense of Gaul
奥罗修斯与哲罗姆都一口咬定,是他挑动了这场入侵。“Excitatae a Stilichone gentes”(诸族乃斯提利科所煽动)云云。他们所指的,想必是间接的怂恿。他是牺牲了高卢,才保全了意大利。
86
The Count de Buat is satisfied, that the Germans who invaded Gaul were the two thirds that yet remained of the army of Radagaisus. See the Histoire Ancienne des Peuples de l’Europe, (tom. vii. p. 87, 121. Paris, 1772;) an elaborate work, which I had not the advantage of perusing till the year 1777. As early as 1771, I find the same idea expressed in a rough draught of the present History. I have since observed a similar intimation in Mascou, (viii. 15.) Such agreement, without mutual communication, may add some weight to our common sentiment.
布阿伯爵确信,入侵高卢的那些日耳曼人,正是拉达盖苏斯军中残存下来的那三分之二。参看《欧洲诸民族古代史》(tom. vii. p. 87, 121,巴黎,1772年)——这是一部精心结撰的著作,我却迟至1777年才有幸读到。早在1771年,我便在本书的一份草稿里表达过同样的看法。后来我又发现马斯科夫(viii. 15)也有类似的暗示。彼此并无往来,见解却不谋而合,这或许能为我们共同的看法平添几分分量。
87
Provincia missos
Expellet citius fasces, quam Francia reges
Quos dederis.
Claudian (i. Cons. Stil. l. i. 235, &c.) is clear and satisfactory. These kings of France are unknown to Gregory of Tours; but the author of the Gesta Francorum mentions both Sunno and Marcomir, and names the latter as the father of Pharamond, (in tom. ii. p. 543.) He seems to write from good materials, which he did not understand.
Provincia missos Expellet citius fasces, quam Francia reges Quos dederis.——克劳狄安(i. Cons. Stil. l. i. 235 等)这几句写得明白而令人信服。这几位法兰克国王,图尔的格雷戈里并不知晓;但《法兰克人事迹》的作者却同时提到了苏诺与马科米尔,并称后者为法拉蒙德之父(tom. ii. p. 543)。看来他手上握有上好的材料,只是自己并不明白其中的含义。
88
See Zosimus, (l. vi. p. 373,) Orosius, (l. vii. c. 40, p. 576,) and the Chronicles. Gregory of Tours (l. ii. c. 9, p. 165, in the second volume of the Historians of France) has preserved a valuable fragment of Renatus Profuturus Frigeridus, whose three names denote a Christian, a Roman subject, and a Semi-Barbarian.
参看佐西莫斯(l. vi. p. 373)、奥罗修斯(l. vii. c. 40, p. 576)以及诸编年史。图尔的格雷戈里(l. ii. c. 9, p. 165,见《法兰西史家》第二卷)保存了雷纳图斯·普罗弗图鲁斯·弗里格里杜斯的一段珍贵残篇——此人的三个名字,恰好分别标示出一位基督徒、一名罗马臣民与一个半开化的蛮族。
89
Claudian (i. Cons. Stil. l. i. 221, &c., l. ii. 186) describes the peace and prosperity of the Gallic frontier. The Abbe Dubos (Hist. Critique, &c., tom. i. p. 174) would read Alba (a nameless rivulet of the Ardennes) instead of Albis; and expatiates on the danger of the Gallic cattle grazing beyond the Elbe. Foolish enough! In poetical geography, the Elbe, and the Hercynian, signify any river, or any wood, in Germany. Claudian is not prepared for the strict examination of our antiquaries.
克劳狄安(i. Cons. Stil. l. i. 221 等,l. ii. 186)描绘了高卢边境的和平与繁荣。杜博神父(Hist. Critique 等,tom. i. p. 174)主张把“Albis”(易北河)读作“Alba”(阿登地区一条无名小溪),并且大发议论,说什么高卢的牲口跑到易北河那一边去吃草有多危险。真够蠢的!在诗人的地理里,“易北河”也罢,“赫尔基尼亚”也罢,无非泛指日耳曼境内的某条河、某片林罢了。克劳狄安可没打算经受我们这些考据家的严格盘查。
90
—Germinasque viator Cum videat ripas, quae sit Romana requirat.
Germinasque viator Cum videat ripas, quae sit Romana requirat.(“行人望见两岸风光相似,竟要问何处方是罗马的疆土。”)
91
Jerom, tom. i. p. 93. See in the 1st vol. of the Historians of France, p. 777, 782, the proper extracts from the Carmen de Providentil Divina, and Salvian. The anonymous poet was himself a captive, with his bishop and fellow-citizens.
哲罗姆,tom. i. p. 93。相关的摘录见《法兰西史家》第一卷 p. 777、782,出自《论神意》(Carmen de Providentia Divina)与萨尔维安。那位佚名诗人本人也曾沦为俘虏,与他的主教及同乡一道被掳。
92
The Pelagian doctrine, which was first agitated A.D. 405, was condemned, in the space of ten years, at Rome and Carthage. St Augustin fought and conquered; but the Greek church was favorable to his adversaries; and (what is singular enough) the people did not take any part in a dispute which they could not understand.
佩拉纠派的教义最初于公元405年掀起争论,不出十年,便先后在罗马与迦太基遭到谴责。圣奥古斯丁挺身论战,终获全胜;但希腊教会却偏袒他的对手;而且(说来也够稀奇)民众对这场他们根本弄不懂的争论,竟毫不参与。
93
See the Mémoires de Guillaume du Bellay, l. vi. In French, the original reproof is less obvious, and more pointed, from the double sense of the word journee, which alike signifies, a day’s travel, or a battle.
参看《吉约姆·杜贝莱回忆录》l. vi。在法文原文里,这句反唇相讥不那么直白,却更为尖刻,因为“journée”一词一语双关,既指一天的路程,也指一场战役。
94
Claudian, (i. Cons. Stil. l. ii. 250.) It is supposed that the Scots of Ireland invaded, by sea, the whole western coast of Britain: and some slight credit may be given even to Nennius and the Irish traditions, (Carte’s Hist. of England, vol. i. p. 169.) Whitaker’s Genuine History of the Britons, p. 199. The sixty-six lives of St. Patrick, which were extant in the ninth century, must have contained as many thousand lies; yet we may believe, that, in one of these Irish inroads the future apostle was led away captive, (Usher, Antiquit. Eccles Britann. p. 431, and Tillemont, Mem. Eccles. tom. xvi. p. 45 782, &c.)
克劳狄安(i. Cons. Stil. l. ii. 250)。据推测,爱尔兰的苏格兰人曾从海路侵袭不列颠的整个西海岸;就连内尼乌斯与爱尔兰的种种传说,也不妨略予采信(卡特《英格兰史》vol. i. p. 169)。参看惠特克《不列颠人真史》p. 199。九世纪时尚存的六十六种《圣帕特里克传》,内中所载的谎言想必也有成千上万;不过我们尽可相信,在爱尔兰人某一次的入寇中,这位未来的使徒确曾被掳为奴(厄谢尔《不列颠教会古志》p. 431,及蒂耶蒙《教会史论集》tom. xvi. p. 45、782 等)。
95
The British usurpers are taken from Zosimus, (l. vi. p. 371-375,) Orosius, (l. vii. c. 40, p. 576, 577,) Olympiodorus, (apud Photium, p. 180, 181,) the ecclesiastical historians, and the Chronicles. The Latins are ignorant of Marcus.
不列颠这几位僭位者的事迹,取材于佐西莫斯(l. vi. p. 371-375)、奥罗修斯(l. vii. c. 40, p. 576, 577)、奥林匹奥多罗斯(辑于佛提乌书中,p. 180, 181)、诸教会史家以及各编年史。至于马库斯,拉丁语的作家们则一无所知。
96
Cum in Constantino inconstantiam... execrarentur, (Sidonius Apollinaris, l. v. epist. 9, p. 139, edit. secund. Sirmond.) Yet Sidonius might be tempted, by so fair a pun, to stigmatize a prince who had disgraced his grandfather.
“Cum in Constantino inconstantiam... execrarentur”(他们厌恶君士坦丁之名所含的“反复无常”之意——西多尼乌斯·阿波利纳里斯,l. v. epist. 9, p. 139,西尔蒙校订第二版)。不过,西多尼乌斯之所以如此下笔,也许是抵挡不住这一妙绝双关的诱惑,才要借它去贬损那位曾令自己祖父蒙羞的君主。
97
Bagaudoe is the name which Zosimus applies to them; perhaps they deserved a less odious character, (see Dubos, Hist. Critique, tom. i. p. 203, and this History, vol. i. p. 407.) We shall hear of them again.
佐西莫斯管他们叫“Bagaudae”(巴高达);或许他们并不该得这样一个可憎的名声(参看杜博,Hist. Critique, tom. i. p. 203,以及本书 vol. i. p. 407)。此辈以后还会再提到。