Chapter XXVI: Progress of The Huns.—Part IV. 第二十六章 匈人的推进——第四节
¶
One of the most dangerous inconveniences of the introduction of the Barbarians into the army and the palace, was sensibly felt in their correspondence with their hostile countrymen; to whom they imprudently, or maliciously, revealed the weakness of the Roman empire. A soldier, of the lifeguards of Gratian, was of the nation of the Alemanni, and of the tribe of the Lentienses, who dwelt beyond the Lake of Constance. Some domestic business obliged him to request a leave of absence. In a short visit to his family and friends, he was exposed to their curious inquiries: and the vanity of the loquacious soldier tempted him to display his intimate acquaintance with the secrets of the state, and the designs of his master. The intelligence, that Gratian was preparing to lead the military force of Gaul, and of the West, to the assistance of his uncle Valens, pointed out to the restless spirit of the Alemanni the moment, and the mode, of a successful invasion. The enterprise of some light detachments, who, in the month of February, passed the Rhine upon the ice, was the prelude of a more important war. The boldest hopes of rapine, perhaps of conquest, outweighed the considerations of timid prudence, or national faith. Every forest, and every village, poured forth a band of hardy adventurers; and the great army of the Alemanni, which, on their approach, was estimated at forty thousand men by the fears of the people, was afterwards magnified to the number of seventy thousand by the vain and credulous flattery of the Imperial court. The legions, which had been ordered to march into Pannonia, were immediately recalled, or detained, for the defence of Gaul; the military command was divided between Nanienus and Mellobaudes; and the youthful emperor, though he respected the long experience and sober wisdom of the former, was much more inclined to admire, and to follow, the martial ardor of his colleague; who was allowed to unite the incompatible characters of count of the domestics, and of king of the Franks. His rival Priarius, king of the Alemanni, was guided, or rather impelled, by the same headstrong valor; and as their troops were animated by the spirit of their leaders, they met, they saw, they encountered each other, near the town of Argentaria, or Colmar, 86 in the plains of Alsace. The glory of the day was justly ascribed to the missile weapons, and well-practised evolutions, of the Roman soldiers; the Alemanni, who long maintained their ground, were slaughtered with unrelenting fury; five thousand only of the Barbarians escaped to the woods and mountains; and the glorious death of their king on the field of battle saved him from the reproaches of the people, who are always disposed to accuse the justice, or policy, of an unsuccessful war. After this signal victory, which secured the peace of Gaul, and asserted the honor of the Roman arms, the emperor Gratian appeared to proceed without delay on his Eastern expedition; but as he approached the confines of the Alemanni, he suddenly inclined to the left, surprised them by his unexpected passage of the Rhine, and boldly advanced into the heart of their country. The Barbarians opposed to his progress the obstacles of nature and of courage; and still continued to retreat, from one hill to another, till they were satisfied, by repeated trials, of the power and perseverance of their enemies. Their submission was accepted as a proof, not indeed of their sincere repentance, but of their actual distress; and a select number of their brave and robust youth was exacted from the faithless nation, as the most substantial pledge of their future moderation. The subjects of the empire, who had so often experienced that the Alemanni could neither be subdued by arms, nor restrained by treaties, might not promise themselves any solid or lasting tranquillity: but they discovered, in the virtues of their young sovereign, the prospect of a long and auspicious reign. When the legions climbed the mountains, and scaled the fortifications of the Barbarians, the valor of Gratian was distinguished in the foremost ranks; and the gilt and variegated armor of his guards was pierced and shattered by the blows which they had received in their constant attachment to the person of their sovereign. At the age of nineteen, the son of Valentinian seemed to possess the talents of peace and war; and his personal success against the Alemanni was interpreted as a sure presage of his Gothic triumphs. 87
将蛮族引入军队与宫廷,此举流弊甚多,其中最危险的一桩,在他们与心怀敌意的本族同胞的通信往来中暴露无遗:这些蛮族或出于轻率,或出于恶意,把罗马帝国的虚弱一一泄露给了对方。格拉提安的卫队里有一名士兵,本是阿勒曼尼人,属伦提恩塞斯部落,其族居于康斯坦茨湖彼岸。他因家中有事,不得不请假归乡。短短几日探亲访友之间,亲友们好奇的追问纷至沓来;这个爱说话的士兵虚荣心一起,便忍不住卖弄自己对国家机密与主上意图的熟稔。他透露:格拉提安正准备率高卢与西部的全部兵力,去驰援其叔父瓦伦斯——这条消息,恰为躁动不安的阿勒曼尼人指明了一举入侵得手的时机与门径。二月里,几支轻装队伍踏着冰面渡过莱茵河,这不过是一场更大战事的前奏。劫掠——乃至征服——的狂热妄想,压倒了怯懦的审慎之心,也压倒了守约的信义。每一片森林、每一座村庄,都涌出一队剽悍的亡命之徒;阿勒曼尼大军压境之际,惊惶的民众估计其众有四万,日后帝国朝廷出于虚荣与轻信的谄媚,又把这数目夸大到七万。原奉命开赴潘诺尼亚的各军团,当即被召回或留驻,以防守高卢;军权则由纳尼埃努斯与梅洛包德斯分掌。年轻的皇帝虽敬重前者阅历深厚、见识老成,心中却更倾慕、也更乐于追随后者那股尚武的锐气——此人竟得以身兼侍卫伯与法兰克王这两个本不相容的身份。与他为敌的阿勒曼尼人之王普里阿里乌斯,也同样被那股一意孤行的勇猛所驱使——与其说是引领,不如说是驱策。两军将士皆秉承各自统帅的血性,于是狭路相逢:他们相遇、相望、相搏于阿尔萨斯平原上的阿根塔里亚(又名科尔马)城下。86这一天的荣耀,理应归功于罗马士兵的投射兵器与娴熟的阵法变换。阿勒曼尼人久久死守阵地,终究被毫不留情地屠戮殆尽,仅五千蛮族逃入山林;他们的王战死沙场,死得光荣,倒使他免遭民众的责难——世人总爱把一场败仗归咎于统帅师出无名或谋划失当。这场大捷,既保住了高卢的太平,又重振了罗马武功的声威。此后,格拉提安皇帝似要即刻启程东征;然而,当他行近阿勒曼尼人的边境时,却突然向左折进,出其不意地渡过莱茵河,大胆深入敌境腹地。蛮族既凭天险、又凭血勇,处处阻挡他的进军;他们且战且退,从一座山头撤到另一座山头,直到屡试之后,方才领教了敌人的兵力之强与意志之坚。他们终于归降;这归降固然算不得真心悔过,却也可证其眼下确已窘迫。为求日后安分守己,罗马人从这背信之族中抽调一批精挑细选的健勇青年,作为最实在的担保。帝国的臣民早已屡屡领教:阿勒曼尼人既不能凭武力慑服,也不能靠条约约束,因此本不敢指望什么牢靠而持久的安宁;然而,他们却从这位年轻君主的德行中,看到了一个长久而昌隆之治世的希望。当各军团攀山越岭、强攻蛮族工事时,格拉提安身先士卒,勇冠三军;他的卫士寸步不离地护卫在君主身旁,身上那镶金错彩的铠甲,被一次次砍击刺得千疮百孔、支离破碎。这位瓦伦提尼安之子,年方十九,便似乎兼具了治世与用兵的才干;他亲征阿勒曼尼人的战功,也被人解读为他日后战胜哥特人的确凿吉兆。87
¶
While Gratian deserved and enjoyed the applause of his subjects, the emperor Valens, who, at length, had removed his court and army from Antioch, was received by the people of Constantinople as the author of the public calamity. Before he had reposed himself ten days in the capital, he was urged by the licentious clamors of the Hippodrome to march against the Barbarians, whom he had invited into his dominions; and the citizens, who are always brave at a distance from any real danger, declared, with confidence, that, if they were supplied with arms, they alone would undertake to deliver the province from the ravages of an insulting foe. 88 The vain reproaches of an ignorant multitude hastened the downfall of the Roman empire; they provoked the desperate rashness of Valens; who did not find, either in his reputation or in his mind, any motives to support with firmness the public contempt. He was soon persuaded, by the successful achievements of his lieutenants, to despise the power of the Goths, who, by the diligence of Fritigern, were now collected in the neighborhood of Hadrianople. The march of the Taifalæ had been intercepted by the valiant Frigeric: the king of those licentious Barbarians was slain in battle; and the suppliant captives were sent into distant exile to cultivate the lands of Italy, which were assigned for their settlement in the vacant territories of Modena and Parma. 89 The exploits of Sebastian, 90 who was recently engaged in the service of Valens, and promoted to the rank of master-general of the infantry, were still more honorable to himself, and useful to the republic. He obtained the permission of selecting three hundred soldiers from each of the legions; and this separate detachment soon acquired the spirit of discipline, and the exercise of arms, which were almost forgotten under the reign of Valens. By the vigor and conduct of Sebastian, a large body of the Goths were surprised in their camp; and the immense spoil, which was recovered from their hands, filled the city of Hadrianople, and the adjacent plain. The splendid narratives, which the general transmitted of his own exploits, alarmed the Imperial court by the appearance of superior merit; and though he cautiously insisted on the difficulties of the Gothic war, his valor was praised, his advice was rejected; and Valens, who listened with pride and pleasure to the flattering suggestions of the eunuchs of the palace, was impatient to seize the glory of an easy and assured conquest. His army was strengthened by a numerous reenforcement of veterans; and his march from Constantinople to Hadrianople was conducted with so much military skill, that he prevented the activity of the Barbarians, who designed to occupy the intermediate defiles, and to intercept either the troops themselves, or their convoys of provisions. The camp of Valens, which he pitched under the walls of Hadrianople, was fortified, according to the practice of the Romans, with a ditch and rampart; and a most important council was summoned, to decide the fate of the emperor and of the empire. The party of reason and of delay was strenuously maintained by Victor, who had corrected, by the lessons of experience, the native fierceness of the Sarmatian character; while Sebastian, with the flexible and obsequious eloquence of a courtier, represented every precaution, and every measure, that implied a doubt of immediate victory, as unworthy of the courage and majesty of their invincible monarch. The ruin of Valens was precipitated by the deceitful arts of Fritigern, and the prudent admonitions of the emperor of the West. The advantages of negotiating in the midst of war were perfectly understood by the general of the Barbarians; and a Christian ecclesiastic was despatched, as the holy minister of peace, to penetrate, and to perplex, the councils of the enemy. The misfortunes, as well as the provocations, of the Gothic nation, were forcibly and truly described by their ambassador; who protested, in the name of Fritigern, that he was still disposed to lay down his arms, or to employ them only in the defence of the empire; if he could secure for his wandering countrymen a tranquil settlement on the waste lands of Thrace, and a sufficient allowance of corn and cattle. But he added, in a whisper of confidential friendship, that the exasperated Barbarians were averse to these reasonable conditions; and that Fritigern was doubtful whether he could accomplish the conclusion of the treaty, unless he found himself supported by the presence and terrors of an Imperial army. About the same time, Count Richomer returned from the West to announce the defeat and submission of the Alemanni, to inform Valens that his nephew advanced by rapid marches at the head of the veteran and victorious legions of Gaul, and to request, in the name of Gratian and of the republic, that every dangerous and decisive measure might be suspended, till the junction of the two emperors should insure the success of the Gothic war. But the feeble sovereign of the East was actuated only by the fatal illusions of pride and jealousy. He disdained the importunate advice; he rejected the humiliating aid; he secretly compared the ignominious, at least the inglorious, period of his own reign, with the fame of a beardless youth; and Valens rushed into the field, to erect his imaginary trophy, before the diligence of his colleague could usurp any share of the triumphs of the day.
正当格拉提安赢得并享受着臣民的喝彩之时,瓦伦斯皇帝终于把宫廷与军队从安条克迁出;可君士坦丁堡的民众,却把他当作这场公共灾难的祸首来迎接。他在都城还没歇够十天,竞技场上便响起放肆的鼓噪,催逼他出兵讨伐那些原是他自己引进境内的蛮族。市民们一向是在远离真正危险时才显得勇敢,此刻竟信誓旦旦地宣称:只要发给他们兵器,单凭他们自己,就能把这行省从骄横之敌的蹂躏中解救出来。88无知群氓这一番徒然的责难,加速了罗马帝国的覆亡:它激起了瓦伦斯那孤注一掷的莽撞;无论凭声望还是凭心性,此人都拿不出半分底气,去坦然承受众人的轻蔑。他麾下将领接连奏捷,很快便使他相信哥特人不足为惧——尽管此时哥特人已在弗里提格恩的悉心调度下,集结于阿德里安堡近郊。泰伐利人的行军被骁勇的弗里格里克拦截:这个放荡不羁的蛮族之王阵亡;乞降的俘虏被远远流放,去耕种意大利的田地——摩德纳与帕尔马一带的空旷之地,划归他们安置。89塞巴斯蒂安90新近投效瓦伦斯麾下,晋升为步兵统帅;他建下的功业,于己更为光彩,于国也更为有益。他获准从每个军团各挑三百名士兵;这支单独编成的队伍,很快便重新养成了严明的纪律,操练起在瓦伦斯治下几乎已被遗忘的武艺。凭着塞巴斯蒂安的干练与谋略,一大股哥特人在营中遭到突袭;从他们手中夺回的战利品不计其数,堆满了阿德里安堡城内以及城外邻近的平原。这位将军呈报自家战功时辞采飞扬,那副功盖群僚的气派反倒惊动了帝国朝廷。尽管他谨慎地一再申说哥特战争之艰难,人们却只夸他勇武,全不采纳他的进言;瓦伦斯得意而欢畅地听信宫中宦官的谄媚之词,迫不及待地要去攫取那一场唾手可得、稳操胜券的荣耀。大批老兵前来增援,壮大了他的军势;他从君士坦丁堡向阿德里安堡进发,行军调度极见章法,以致抢在蛮族动手之前便挫败了他们的图谋——蛮族本想占据途中的险隘,好截击他的部队或其粮秣辎重。瓦伦斯在阿德里安堡城墙下扎营,依照罗马人的惯例,挖壕筑垒加以设防;随后召开了一次至关紧要的军议,来裁定皇帝与帝国的命运。维克托竭力主张持重待机、审慎从事:他本是萨尔马提亚人,那与生俱来的凶悍脾性,已被阅历磨去了棱角;塞巴斯蒂安却凭着廷臣那圆滑而谄媚的口才,把凡是含有一丝迟疑、不敢立即言胜的谨慎之策,统统贬斥为有辱他们那位战无不胜的君主的勇气与威严。弗里提格恩的诡诈伎俩,加上西部皇帝那番审慎的劝诫,一并加速了瓦伦斯的败亡。在战事正酣之际展开谈判有何等好处,蛮族的统帅心中一清二楚;于是他派出一名基督教教士,充当神圣的和平使者,去刺探并搅乱敌方的决策。这位使者把哥特民族所受的种种苦难,以及他们兴兵的缘由,都描述得既有力又真切。他以弗里提格恩的名义郑重声明:只要能为流离失所的同胞,在色雷斯的荒地上求得一处安宁的定居之所,并保证足量的粮食与牲畜供给,弗里提格恩仍愿意放下武器,或只把武器用于保卫帝国。但他又压低嗓音,以推心置腹之态补充道:那些被激怒的蛮族并不情愿接受这些合情合理的条件;弗里提格恩自己也拿不准,除非有一支帝国大军压境、以其声威慑服众人,否则他能否促成这纸条约。大约与此同时,侍卫伯里科梅尔自西方归来,一面禀报阿勒曼尼人已败降,一面告知瓦伦斯:其侄正率领高卢那些身经百战、屡建奇功的军团,兼程赶来;他还以格拉提安与国家的名义请求:一切冒险的、决定性的举动,都应暂缓,须等两位皇帝会师,方可确保哥特战争必胜。然而,这位孱弱的东部君主,心中一味受骄矜与妒忌这两种致命妄念的摆布。他不屑于这聒噪不休的劝告,回绝了这令他脸上无光的援手;他暗自把自己那段即便说不上可耻、至少也毫无光彩的统治,同一个乳臭未干的少年的赫赫声名相比较。于是瓦伦斯一头冲上战场,抢在他那勤勉的同僚分去这一天胜利的丝毫功劳之前,去树立他那想象中的凯旋丰碑。
¶
On the ninth of August, a day which has deserved to be marked among the most inauspicious of the Roman Calendar, 91 the emperor Valens, leaving, under a strong guard, his baggage and military treasure, marched from Hadrianople to attack the Goths, who were encamped about twelve miles from the city. 92 By some mistake of the orders, or some ignorance of the ground, the right wing, or column of cavalry arrived in sight of the enemy, whilst the left was still at a considerable distance; the soldiers were compelled, in the sultry heat of summer, to precipitate their pace; and the line of battle was formed with tedious confusion and irregular delay. The Gothic cavalry had been detached to forage in the adjacent country; and Fritigern still continued to practise his customary arts. He despatched messengers of peace, made proposals, required hostages, and wasted the hours, till the Romans, exposed without shelter to the burning rays of the sun, were exhausted by thirst, hunger, and intolerable fatigue. The emperor was persuaded to send an ambassador to the Gothic camp; the zeal of Richomer, who alone had courage to accept the dangerous commission, was applauded; and the count of the domestics, adorned with the splendid ensigns of his dignity, had proceeded some way in the space between the two armies, when he was suddenly recalled by the alarm of battle. The hasty and imprudent attack was made by Bacurius the Iberian, who commanded a body of archers and targeteers; and as they advanced with rashness, they retreated with loss and disgrace. In the same moment, the flying squadrons of Alatheus and Saphrax, whose return was anxiously expected by the general of the Goths, descended like a whirlwind from the hills, swept across the plain, and added new terrors to the tumultuous, but irresistible charge of the Barbarian host. The event of the battle of Hadrianople, so fatal to Valens and to the empire, may be described in a few words: the Roman cavalry fled; the infantry was abandoned, surrounded, and cut in pieces. The most skilful evolutions, the firmest courage, are scarcely sufficient to extricate a body of foot, encompassed, on an open plain, by superior numbers of horse; but the troops of Valens, oppressed by the weight of the enemy and their own fears, were crowded into a narrow space, where it was impossible for them to extend their ranks, or even to use, with effect, their swords and javelins. In the midst of tumult, of slaughter, and of dismay, the emperor, deserted by his guards and wounded, as it was supposed, with an arrow, sought protection among the Lancearii and the Mattiarii, who still maintained their ground with some appearance of order and firmness. His faithful generals, Trajan and Victor, who perceived his danger, loudly exclaimed that all was lost, unless the person of the emperor could be saved. Some troops, animated by their exhortation, advanced to his relief: they found only a bloody spot, covered with a heap of broken arms and mangled bodies, without being able to discover their unfortunate prince, either among the living or the dead. Their search could not indeed be successful, if there is any truth in the circumstances with which some historians have related the death of the emperor.
八月九日——这一天理应列入罗马历上最不祥的日子之列91——瓦伦斯皇帝把辎重与军饷留下、交由重兵看守,随即率军自阿德里安堡出发,去攻打在离城约十二英里处扎营的哥特人。92也许是号令传达有误,也许是不谙地形,右翼——即骑兵纵队——已抵近敌军视野之内,左翼却还远在后方;士兵们只得在盛夏的酷热中疾行赶路,战线的布列则在拖沓的混乱与参差的迟滞中勉强成形。哥特骑兵已被派往邻近乡野征集粮草,弗里提格恩则依旧施展他惯用的伎俩。他派出求和的使者,提出种种条件,索要人质,一味拖延时光;直到罗马人在毫无遮蔽之下曝晒于炎炎烈日,被饥渴与难耐的疲惫折磨得筋疲力尽为止。有人劝皇帝派一名使节前往哥特营地;里科梅尔独具胆识,甘愿领受这桩凶险的差事,其热忱博得众人赞许。这位侍卫伯佩着彰显其尊荣的华美徽饰,已在两军之间的空地上走出了一段路,却被骤然响起的战斗警号召了回来。这场仓促而轻率的进攻,是伊比利亚人巴库里乌斯发动的,他统领着一队弓手与轻盾兵;他们冒进而上,又损兵折将、狼狈退回。就在这同一刻,阿拉特乌斯与萨弗拉克斯麾下那疾驰的骑队——哥特统帅正翘首盼其归来——如旋风般自山间俯冲而下,横扫平原,为蛮族大军那纷乱却锐不可当的冲锋,又添了几分骇人的声势。阿德里安堡这一战,对瓦伦斯、对帝国都是灭顶之祸,其结局三言两语便可道尽:罗马骑兵溃逃,步兵遭到抛弃,被团团围住,砍成肉泥。一支步兵若在开阔平原上被数量占优的骑兵合围,纵有最娴熟的阵法变换、最坚定的勇气,也难以脱身;何况瓦伦斯的部队还被敌军的压力与自身的恐惧逼迫,挤作一团,困在狭小的地面上,既无法展开队列,甚至连刀剑与标枪都施展不开。在一片喧嚣、屠戮与惊恐之中,皇帝被卫士抛弃,据说还中了一箭负伤,只得逃到兰凯亚里与马提亚里两支队伍中间求得庇护——这两支队伍仍守着阵地,多少还有几分秩序井然、镇定不乱的模样。他忠心的两位将领图拉真与维克托,察觉他身陷险境,高声疾呼:若不能救出皇帝本人,便一切都完了。一些士兵受其激励,挺身前去救援,却只找到一片血泊,那里堆满了断折的兵器与残缺的尸身,无论在生者还是死者当中,都寻不见他们那不幸的君主。倘若某些史家对这位皇帝之死所记述的种种情形当真有几分属实,那么他们这番搜寻,也就注定无功而返了。
¶
By the care of his attendants, Valens was removed from the field of battle to a neighboring cottage, where they attempted to dress his wound, and to provide for his future safety. But this humble retreat was instantly surrounded by the enemy: they tried to force the door, they were provoked by a discharge of arrows from the roof, till at length, impatient of delay, they set fire to a pile of dry magots, and consumed the cottage with the Roman emperor and his train. Valens perished in the flames; and a youth, who dropped from the window, alone escaped, to attest the melancholy tale, and to inform the Goths of the inestimable prize which they had lost by their own rashness. A great number of brave and distinguished officers perished in the battle of Hadrianople, which equalled in the actual loss, and far surpassed in the fatal consequences, the misfortune which Rome had formerly sustained in the fields of Cannæ. 93 Two master-generals of the cavalry and infantry, two great officers of the palace, and thirty-five tribunes, were found among the slain; and the death of Sebastian might satisfy the world, that he was the victim, as well as the author, of the public calamity. Above two thirds of the Roman army were destroyed: and the darkness of the night was esteemed a very favorable circumstance, as it served to conceal the flight of the multitude, and to protect the more orderly retreat of Victor and Richomer, who alone, amidst the general consternation, maintained the advantage of calm courage and regular discipline. 94
瓦伦斯的随从费尽心力,把他从战场上抬到附近一间农舍,想为他包扎伤口,并谋划日后如何脱身。可这处简陋的藏身之地转眼便被敌人围住:他们想撞开房门,屋顶上射下的一阵箭矢又激怒了他们;到最后,他们再也按捺不住性子,索性点燃一堆干柴,把这农舍连同这位罗马皇帝及其随从一并烧成灰烬。瓦伦斯葬身火海;唯有一名从窗口跳下的少年得以逃生,好为这桩凄惨的故事作证,也让哥特人得知:他们竟因自己的莽撞,白白错失了一件无价的战利品。阿德里安堡一役,众多骁勇卓著的将官殒命;这场惨败,就实际伤亡而论,可与当年罗马在坎尼平原所蒙受的灾祸相提并论,而就其致命的后果而言,则远远过之。93阵亡者当中,有骑兵统帅与步兵统帅各一名、两位宫廷显宦,以及三十五名军事保民官;塞巴斯蒂安之死,或可让世人心服:这场公共灾难,他既是始作俑者,也是牺牲品。罗马大军三分之二以上尽遭覆灭;那夜色的漆黑,倒被视为一桩极有利的情形,因为它既掩护了溃兵的奔逃,又庇护了维克托与里科梅尔那较为有序的撤退——在满营惊惶之中,唯有这两人始终不失沉着的勇气与严整的纪律。94
¶
While the impressions of grief and terror were still recent in the minds of men, the most celebrated rhetorician of the age composed the funeral oration of a vanquished army, and of an unpopular prince, whose throne was already occupied by a stranger. “There are not wanting,” says the candid Libanius, “those who arraign the prudence of the emperor, or who impute the public misfortune to the want of courage and discipline in the troops. For my own part, I reverence the memory of their former exploits: I reverence the glorious death, which they bravely received, standing, and fighting in their ranks: I reverence the field of battle, stained with their blood, and the blood of the Barbarians. Those honorable marks have been already washed away by the rains; but the lofty monuments of their bones, the bones of generals, of centurions, and of valiant warriors, claim a longer period of duration. The king himself fought and fell in the foremost ranks of the battle. His attendants presented him with the fleetest horses of the Imperial stable, that would soon have carried him beyond the pursuit of the enemy. They vainly pressed him to reserve his important life for the future service of the republic. He still declared that he was unworthy to survive so many of the bravest and most faithful of his subjects; and the monarch was nobly buried under a mountain of the slain. Let none, therefore, presume to ascribe the victory of the Barbarians to the fear, the weakness, or the imprudence, of the Roman troops. The chiefs and the soldiers were animated by the virtue of their ancestors, whom they equalled in discipline and the arts of war. Their generous emulation was supported by the love of glory, which prompted them to contend at the same time with heat and thirst, with fire and the sword; and cheerfully to embrace an honorable death, as their refuge against flight and infamy. The indignation of the gods has been the only cause of the success of our enemies.” The truth of history may disclaim some parts of this panegyric, which cannot strictly be reconciled with the character of Valens, or the circumstances of the battle: but the fairest commendation is due to the eloquence, and still more to the generosity, of the sophist of Antioch. 95
正当悲恸与恐惧的印象在人们心中尚未消退之际,当世最负盛名的修辞学家,为一支败亡的军队、一位不得人心的君主,写下了一篇悼词——而此时那君主的宝座,早已由一个外人占据。坦率的利巴尼乌斯说道:“世上不乏这样的人:他们或指摘皇帝失于审慎,或把这场公共灾难归咎于军队缺乏勇气与纪律。至于我自己,我敬重他们昔日战功的记忆;我敬重他们那光荣的死——他们巍然挺立、在行伍之中奋战而死;我敬重那片战场,那里既浸透着他们自己的鲜血,也浸透着蛮族的鲜血。那些荣耀的血痕,早已被雨水冲刷殆尽;然而由他们的枯骨堆成的巍巍丰碑——将军的、百夫长的、无数勇士的枯骨——却理当留存得更为长久。那位君王,亲自在战斗的最前列拼杀,直至倒下。他的侍从牵来御厩中最快的骏马,本可转眼间载他脱出敌人的追击。他们徒然地恳求他:为了日后报效国家,务必保全这至关重要的性命。他却始终宣称:这么多最勇敢、最忠诚的臣民都已捐躯,自己实无颜苟活于世;于是这位君主壮烈地长眠于尸山之下。故而,谁也休想把蛮族的胜利,归因于罗马军队的怯懦、软弱或轻率。无论将领还是士兵,皆以先辈的武德自励,其纪律之严、韬略之精,与先辈不相上下。他们那慷慨的竞胜之心,全凭对荣誉的热爱支撑;正是这份热爱,驱使他们同时与酷热、干渴搏斗,与烈火、刀剑搏斗,并欣然把光荣的死当作自己的归宿,以躲避逃亡与耻辱。我们的敌人之所以得胜,唯一的缘由,便是诸神的震怒。”这篇颂词中有些说法,与瓦伦斯的为人、或这场战斗的实情终究难以严丝合缝,历史的真相尽可将其否弃;但对这位安条克辩士的雄辩之才,尤其是他那份宽厚之情,实应致以最公允的赞许。95
¶
The pride of the Goths was elated by this memorable victory; but their avarice was disappointed by the mortifying discovery, that the richest part of the Imperial spoil had been within the walls of Hadrianople. They hastened to possess the reward of their valor; but they were encountered by the remains of a vanquished army, with an intrepid resolution, which was the effect of their despair, and the only hope of their safety. The walls of the city, and the ramparts of the adjacent camp, were lined with military engines, that threw stones of an enormous weight; and astonished the ignorant Barbarians by the noise, and velocity, still more than by the real effects, of the discharge. The soldiers, the citizens, the provincials, the domestics of the palace, were united in the danger, and in the defence: the furious assault of the Goths was repulsed; their secret arts of treachery and treason were discovered; and, after an obstinate conflict of many hours, they retired to their tents; convinced, by experience, that it would be far more advisable to observe the treaty, which their sagacious leader had tacitly stipulated with the fortifications of great and populous cities. After the hasty and impolitic massacre of three hundred deserters, an act of justice extremely useful to the discipline of the Roman armies, the Goths indignantly raised the siege of Hadrianople. The scene of war and tumult was instantly converted into a silent solitude: the multitude suddenly disappeared; the secret paths of the woods and mountains were marked with the footsteps of the trembling fugitives, who sought a refuge in the distant cities of Illyricum and Macedonia; and the faithful officers of the household, and the treasury, cautiously proceeded in search of the emperor, of whose death they were still ignorant. The tide of the Gothic inundation rolled from the walls of Hadrianople to the suburbs of Constantinople. The Barbarians were surprised with the splendid appearance of the capital of the East, the height and extent of the walls, the myriads of wealthy and affrighted citizens who crowded the ramparts, and the various prospect of the sea and land. While they gazed with hopeless desire on the inaccessible beauties of Constantinople, a sally was made from one of the gates by a party of Saracens, 96 who had been fortunately engaged in the service of Valens. The cavalry of Scythia was forced to yield to the admirable swiftness and spirit of the Arabian horses: their riders were skilled in the evolutions of irregular war; and the Northern Barbarians were astonished and dismayed, by the inhuman ferocity of the Barbarians of the South.
这场令人难忘的大捷,令哥特人的骄气愈发高涨;可他们的贪欲却大为扫兴,因为他们懊恼地发现:帝国财货中最丰厚的那一部分,原来一直藏在阿德里安堡城墙之内。他们急急赶去攫取这份勇武应得的酬报,迎面撞上的却是一支残军——那是败军之余,凭着一股无畏的决心严阵以待;这决心,既是绝望所激发,也是他们保全性命的唯一指望。城墙之上,以及紧邻的营垒之上,密布着抛掷巨石的军械;这些器械发射时的轰鸣与飞石的迅疾,比其实际杀伤更令懵懂无知的蛮族惊骇。士兵、市民、行省居民、宫中的仆役,都在这危难之际同心协力、共守城池:哥特人的猛攻被击退,他们暗施的背信与叛卖的诡计也被识破;激战数小时后,他们退回营帐,从亲身经历中悟出:还是遵守那纸条约为上——那是他们精明的首领与这些人烟稠密的大城的坚固工事之间,早已心照不宣地立下的默契。哥特人仓促而失策地屠杀了三百名逃兵——此举名为伸张正义,于整肃罗马军纪倒的确大有裨益——随后便愤然撤了阿德里安堡之围。方才还是战火喧嚣的场面,转眼便化作一片死寂的荒凉:人群骤然散尽;山林间隐秘的小径上,印满了瑟瑟发抖的逃亡者的足迹,他们要逃往伊利里库姆与马其顿的远方城镇去避难;而那些忠于职守的宫廷与国库官员,则小心翼翼地四处寻访皇帝,浑然不知他已经死了。哥特人这股泛滥的洪流,从阿德里安堡城下一路奔涌,直抵君士坦丁堡的近郊。这东方之都的堂皇气象,令蛮族大为惊叹:那城墙之高峻绵长,那挤满城头、既富庶又惊惶的万千市民,还有那海天陆地交织变幻的景致。正当他们怀着无望的觊觎,凝望着君士坦丁堡那可望而不可即的繁华时,一队萨拉森人96从一座城门里杀出——所幸这些人此前已投在瓦伦斯麾下效力。斯基泰的骑兵,不得不在阿拉伯战马那惊人的迅捷与骁悍面前甘拜下风:马上的骑手精于游击战的种种机变;北方蛮族见识了南方蛮族那非人的凶残,无不骇然失色、心胆俱寒。
¶
A Gothic soldier was slain by the dagger of an Arab; and the hairy, naked savage, applying his lips to the wound, expressed a horrid delight, while he sucked the blood of his vanquished enemy. 97 The army of the Goths, laden with the spoils of the wealthy suburbs and the adjacent territory, slowly moved, from the Bosphorus, to the mountains which form the western boundary of Thrace. The important pass of Succi was betrayed by the fear, or the misconduct, of Maurus; and the Barbarians, who no longer had any resistance to apprehend from the scattered and vanquished troops of the East, spread themselves over the face of a fertile and cultivated country, as far as the confines of Italy and the Hadriatic Sea. 98
¶
The Romans, who so coolly, and so concisely, mention the acts of justice which were exercised by the legions, 99 reserve their compassion, and their eloquence, for their own sufferings, when the provinces were invaded, and desolated, by the arms of the successful Barbarians. The simple circumstantial narrative (did such a narrative exist) of the ruin of a single town, of the misfortunes of a single family, 100 might exhibit an interesting and instructive picture of human manners: but the tedious repetition of vague and declamatory complaints would fatigue the attention of the most patient reader. The same censure may be applied, though not perhaps in an equal degree, to the profane, and the ecclesiastical, writers of this unhappy period; that their minds were inflamed by popular and religious animosity; and that the true size and color of every object is falsified by the exaggerations of their corrupt eloquence. The vehement Jerom 101 might justly deplore the calamities inflicted by the Goths, and their barbarous allies, on his native country of Pannonia, and the wide extent of the provinces, from the walls of Constantinople to the foot of the Julian Alps; the rapes, the massacres, the conflagrations; and, above all, the profanation of the churches, that were turned into stables, and the contemptuous treatment of the relics of holy martyrs. But the Saint is surely transported beyond the limits of nature and history, when he affirms, “that, in those desert countries, nothing was left except the sky and the earth; that, after the destruction of the cities, and the extirpation of the human race, the land was overgrown with thick forests and inextricable brambles; and that the universal desolation, announced by the prophet Zephaniah, was accomplished, in the scarcity of the beasts, the birds, and even of the fish.” These complaints were pronounced about twenty years after the death of Valens; and the Illyrian provinces, which were constantly exposed to the invasion and passage of the Barbarians, still continued, after a calamitous period of ten centuries, to supply new materials for rapine and destruction. Could it even be supposed, that a large tract of country had been left without cultivation and without inhabitants, the consequences might not have been so fatal to the inferior productions of animated nature. The useful and feeble animals, which are nourished by the hand of man, might suffer and perish, if they were deprived of his protection; but the beasts of the forest, his enemies or his victims, would multiply in the free and undisturbed possession of their solitary domain. The various tribes that people the air, or the waters, are still less connected with the fate of the human species; and it is highly probable that the fish of the Danube would have felt more terror and distress, from the approach of a voracious pike, than from the hostile inroad of a Gothic army.
罗马人提及自家军团所施行的种种“正义”之举时,何等冷淡、何等简略99;可一旦轮到自己受苦——各行省遭得胜蛮族的兵锋侵犯、蹂躏为一片荒芜——他们却把满腔的悲悯与全副的辩才都留给了自己。倘若当真有这样一篇质朴而详实的记述,专写一座城镇的毁灭、一个家庭的不幸100,那或许能为世态人情勾勒出一幅既引人入胜、又发人深省的图画;然而,那些空泛而夸饰的哀叹若一味絮絮重复,便是再有耐心的读者也会看得倦怠。对这段不幸岁月里的世俗作家与教会作家,也可施以同样的指责,尽管轻重或许有别:他们的头脑,早被民间与宗教的仇恨煽得发热;每一桩事物本来的大小与色彩,都经他们那败坏的辞采一番夸张,变得面目全非。言辞激烈的哲罗姆101大可痛惜哥特人及其蛮族盟友所造成的种种祸殃——从君士坦丁堡的城墙直到尤利安阿尔卑斯山麓,广袤诸行省,乃至他的故乡潘诺尼亚,无一幸免:奸淫、屠杀、纵火,尤其是那些教堂被亵渎、被改作马厩,圣洁殉道者的遗骨也遭到轻慢作践。不过,这位圣徒断言下面这番话时,未免逾越了自然与史实的界限:“在那些荒芜之地,除了天空与大地,别无所剩;城市尽毁、人烟灭绝之后,土地上长满了茂密的森林与纠结难分的荆棘;先知西番雅所预告的那场遍及万物的浩劫,如今果真应验了——走兽、飞禽,乃至鱼类,都稀少殆尽。”这些哀叹,是在瓦伦斯死后约二十年间发出的;而那些伊利里亚行省,长年暴露在蛮族的入侵与往来践踏之下,历经十个世纪的灾难岁月之后,竟仍能为劫掠与破坏源源不断地提供新的材料。纵然假设当真有大片土地荒废失耕、渺无人烟,其后果对生灵界中那些较为低等的物类,也未必就那样致命。那些有用而孱弱、全赖人手饲养的家畜,一旦失去人的护佑,或许会受苦乃至死绝;然而林中的野兽,无论是人的仇敌还是人的猎物,却会在无人搅扰、自由自在地独占那荒僻领地之际繁衍滋生。至于那些遍布空中与水中的形形色色的族类,与人类的命运就更不相干了;多瑙河里的鱼,多半会因一条贪婪的梭子鱼逼近而感到更大的惊恐与不安,而非因一支哥特军队的来犯。
Notes 注释
86
↩
The field of battle, Argentaria or Argentovaria, is accurately fixed by M. D’Anville (Notice de l’Ancienne Gaule, p. 96—99) at twenty-three Gallic leagues, or thirty-four and a half Roman miles to the south of Strasburg. From its ruins the adjacent town of Colmar has arisen. Note: It is rather Horburg, on the right bank of the River Ill, opposite to Colmar. From Schoepflin, Alsatia Illustrata. St. Martin, iv. 121.—M.
战场之所在,即 Argentaria(又作 Argentovaria),经当维尔先生(Notice de l’Ancienne Gaule, p. 96—99)精确考订,位于斯特拉斯堡以南二十三高卢里格,合三十四罗马里半。邻近的科尔马城,便是在其废墟之上兴起的。编者按:此地毋宁说是霍尔堡,位于伊尔河右岸,与科尔马隔河相望。据舍普夫林,Alsatia Illustrata。圣马丁,iv. 121。—M
87
↩
The full and impartial narrative of Ammianus (xxxi. 10) may derive some additional light from the Epitome of Victor, the Chronicle of Jerom, and the History of Orosius, (l. vii. c. 33, p. 552, edit. Havercamp.)
阿米阿努斯(xxxi. 10)那翔实而公允的记述,还可从维克托的《概要》、哲罗姆的《编年史》以及奥罗修斯的《历史》(l. vii. c. 33, p. 552,哈弗坎普版)中得到若干补充的印证。
88
↩
Moratus paucissimos dies, seditione popularium levium pulsus Ammian. xxxi. 11. Socrates (l. iv. c. 38) supplies the dates and some circumstances. * Note: Compare fragment of Eunapius. Mai, 272, in Niebuhr, p. 77.—M
Moratus paucissimos dies, seditione popularium levium pulsus(他在都城只逗留了寥寥数日,便被轻浮民众的骚乱逼迫出兵)。阿米阿努斯,xxxi. 11。苏格拉底(l. iv. c. 38)提供了日期及若干情节。编者按:可比对欧纳皮乌斯的残篇。迈,272,见尼布尔,p. 77。—M
89
↩
Vivosque omnes circa Mutinam, Regiumque, et Parmam, Italica oppida, rura culturos exterminavit. Ammianus, xxxi. 9. Those cities and districts, about ten years after the colony of the Taifalæ, appear in a very desolate state. See Muratori, Dissertazioni sopra le Antichità Italiane, tom. i. Dissertat. xxi. p. 354.
Vivosque omnes circa Mutinam, Regiumque, et Parmam, Italica oppida, rura culturos exterminavit.(他把所有生者尽数流放到意大利的穆蒂纳、雷吉乌姆和帕尔马诸城周边,去耕种田地。)阿米阿努斯,xxxi. 9。这些城市与地区,在泰伐利人被安置为屯垦者约十年之后,呈现出一派极其荒凉的景象。参看穆拉托里,Dissertazioni sopra le Antichità Italiane, tom. i. Dissertat. xxi. p. 354。
90
↩
Ammian. xxxi. 11. Zosimus, l. iv. p. 228—230. The latter expatiates on the desultory exploits of Sebastian, and despatches, in a few lines, the important battle of Hadrianople. According to the ecclesiastical critics, who hate Sebastian, the praise of Zosimus is disgrace, (Tillemont, Hist. des Empereurs, tom. v. p. 121.) His prejudice and ignorance undoubtedly render him a very questionable judge of merit.
阿米阿努斯,xxxi. 11。佐西莫斯,l. iv. p. 228—230。后者对塞巴斯蒂安那些零散的战功大加铺陈,却用寥寥数行便草草打发了阿德里安堡这场重要战役。在那些憎恶塞巴斯蒂安的教会评家看来,佐西莫斯的褒扬反倒成了羞辱(蒂耶蒙,Hist. des Empereurs, tom. v. p. 121)。佐西莫斯的偏见与无知,无疑使他成了一个极不可靠的功过裁断者。
91
↩
Ammianus (xxxi. 12, 13) almost alone describes the councils and actions which were terminated by the fatal battle of Hadrianople. We might censure the vices of his style, the disorder and perplexity of his narrative: but we must now take leave of this impartial historian; and reproach is silenced by our regret for such an irreparable loss.
阿米阿努斯(xxxi. 12, 13)几乎是唯一记述了那些以阿德里安堡致命一役告终的谋议与行动的人。我们尽可挑剔他文笔上的种种毛病、叙事的杂乱与晦涩;然而此刻,我们不得不与这位公正的史家诀别了——想到这般无可弥补的损失,满腹的责难也只得化作惋惜、就此缄默。
92
↩
The difference of the eight miles of Ammianus, and the twelve of Idatius, can only embarrass those critics (Valesius ad loc.,) who suppose a great army to be a mathematical point, without space or dimensions.
阿米阿努斯所说的八英里,与伊达提乌斯所说的十二英里,两者之差,只会难倒这样一些评家(瓦莱修斯注此处):他们竟把一支大军想象成一个没有大小、没有广延的数学上的点。
93
↩
Nec ulla annalibus, præter Cannensem pugnam, ita ad internecionem res legitur gesta. Ammian. xxxi. 13. According to the grave Polybius, no more than 370 horse, and 3,000 foot, escaped from the field of Cannæ: 10,000 were made prisoners; and the number of the slain amounted to 5,630 horse, and 70,000 foot, (Polyb. l. iii. p 371, edit. Casaubon, 8vo.) Livy (xxii. 49) is somewhat less bloody: he slaughters only 2,700 horse, and 40,000 foot. The Roman army was supposed to consist of 87,200 effective men, (xxii. 36.)
Nec ulla annalibus, præter Cannensem pugnam, ita ad internecionem res legitur gesta.(史册之中,除坎尼一役外,再没有哪一场战事记载得如此惨烈、近乎全军覆没。)阿米阿努斯,xxxi. 13。据严谨的波利比乌斯记载,从坎尼战场逃生的,骑兵不过三百七十、步兵不过三千;被俘者一万;阵亡者则达骑兵五千六百三十、步兵七万(Polyb. l. iii. p 371,卡索邦版,8vo)。李维(xxii. 49)所记稍轻些:他笔下只杀了骑兵两千七百、步兵四万。据称罗马军队计有可作战之士八万七千二百人(xxii. 36)。
94
↩
We have gained some faint light from Jerom, (tom. i. p. 26 and in Chron. p. 188,) Victor, (in Epitome,) Orosius, (l. vii. c. 33, p. 554,) Jornandes, (c. 27,) Zosimus, (l. iv. p. 230,) Socrates, (l. iv. c. 38,) Sozomen, (l. vi. c. 40,) Idatius, (in Chron.) But their united evidence, if weighed against Ammianus alone, is light and unsubstantial.
我们从哲罗姆(tom. i. p. 26,又见 in Chron. p. 188)、维克托(见《概要》)、奥罗修斯(l. vii. c. 33, p. 554)、约达尼斯(c. 27)、佐西莫斯(l. iv. p. 230)、苏格拉底(l. iv. c. 38)、索佐门(l. vi. c. 40)、伊达提乌斯(见《编年史》)等人那里得到了些许微弱的启示。可他们这些人证合在一起,若拿来与阿米阿努斯一人相较,也显得单薄而无甚分量。
95
↩
Libanius de ulciscend. Julian. nece, c. 3, in Fabricius, Bibliot Græc. tom. vii. p. 146—148.
利巴尼乌斯,de ulciscend. Julian. nece, c. 3,见法布里丘斯,Bibliot. Græc. tom. vii. p. 146—148。
96
↩
Valens had gained, or rather purchased, the friendship of the Saracens, whose vexatious inroads were felt on the borders of Phœnicia, Palestine, and Egypt. The Christian faith had been lately introduced among a people, reserved, in a future age, to propagate another religion, (Tillemont, Hist. des Empereurs, tom. v. p. 104, 106, 141. Mém. Eccles. tom. vii. p. 593.)
瓦伦斯赢得了——或不如说是收买了——萨拉森人的友谊;这些人恼人的劫掠,腓尼基、巴勒斯坦与埃及的边境都深有体会。基督信仰新近才传入这个民族之中,而在将来的某个时代,他们注定要去传播另一种宗教(蒂耶蒙,Hist. des Empereurs, tom. v. p. 104, 106, 141。Mém. Eccles. tom. vii. p. 593)。
97
↩
Crinitus quidam, nudus omnia præter pubem, subraunum et ugubre strepens. Ammian. xxxi. 16, and Vales. ad loc. The Arabs often fought naked; a custom which may be ascribed to their sultry climate, and ostentatious bravery. The description of this unknown savage is the lively portrait of Derar, a name so dreadful to the Christians of Syria. See Ockley’s Hist. of the Saracens, vol. i. p. 72, 84, 87.
Crinitus quidam, nudus omnia præter pubem, subraunum et ugubre strepens.(有一个长发之人,除下体外浑身赤裸,发出一种低沉而凄厉的吼声。)阿米阿努斯,xxxi. 16,并瓦莱修斯注此处。阿拉伯人常常赤身作战,这一习俗或可归因于他们那闷热的气候,以及好逞勇武的炫耀之心。这个来历不明的野人,其形貌活脱脱便是达拉尔的写照——这名字令叙利亚的基督徒闻之丧胆。参看奥克利《萨拉森人史》,vol. i. p. 72, 84, 87。
98
↩
The series of events may still be traced in the last pages of Ammianus, (xxxi. 15, 16.) Zosimus, (l. iv. p. 227, 231,) whom we are now reduced to cherish, misplaces the sally of the Arabs before the death of Valens. Eunapius (in Excerpt. Legat. p. 20) praises the fertility of Thrace, Macedonia, &c.
这一连串事件的经过,仍可在阿米阿努斯著作的最后几页(xxxi. 15, 16)中查考。佐西莫斯(l. iv. p. 227, 231)——如今我们竟落到要珍视此人的地步——把阿拉伯人的那次突袭错置于瓦伦斯之死以前。欧纳皮乌斯(in Excerpt. Legat. p. 20)盛赞色雷斯、马其顿等地的富饶。
99
↩
Observe with how much indifference Cæsar relates, in the Commentaries of the Gallic war, that he put to death the whole senate of the Veneti, who had yielded to his mercy, (iii. 16;) that he labored to extirpate the whole nation of the Eburones, (vi. 31;) that forty thousand persons were massacred at Bourges by the just revenge of his soldiers, who spared neither age nor sex, (vii. 27,) &c.
请看恺撒在《高卢战记》中叙述以下诸事时是何等的漠然:他如何把已经俯首乞怜的威尼提人的整个元老院尽行处死(iii. 16);他如何竭力要把厄布罗内斯人整族斩尽杀绝(vi. 31);他的士兵又如何出于所谓义愤的复仇,在布尔日不分老幼、不论男女地屠戮了四万人(vii. 27),等等。
100
↩
Such are the accounts of the sack of Magdeburgh, by the ecclesiastic and the fisherman, which Mr. Harte has transcribed, (Hist. of Gustavus Adolphus, vol. i. p. 313—320,) with some apprehension of violating the dignity of history.
关于马格德堡遭劫一事,那位教士与那位渔夫的记述便是如此;哈特先生曾将其转录下来(Hist. of Gustavus Adolphus, vol. i. p. 313—320),却又不无顾虑,唯恐有损历史的尊严。
101
↩
Et vastatis urbibus, hominibusque interfectis, solitudinem et raritatem bestiarum quoque fieri, et volatilium, pisciumque: testis Illyricum est, testis Thracia, testis in quo ortus sum solum, (Pannonia;) ubi præter cœlum et terram, et crescentes vepres, et condensa sylvarum cuncta perierunt. Tom. vii. p. 250, l, Cap. Sophonias and tom. i. p. 26.
Et vastatis urbibus, hominibusque interfectis, solitudinem et raritatem bestiarum quoque fieri, et volatilium, pisciumque: testis Illyricum est, testis Thracia, testis in quo ortus sum solum, (Pannonia;) ubi præter cœlum et terram, et crescentes vepres, et condensa sylvarum cuncta perierunt.(城市既已荒废、人烟既已灭绝,于是走兽也变得稀少,飞禽与鱼类亦复如是:伊利里库姆可为见证,色雷斯可为见证,我出生的那片土地——潘诺尼亚——也可为见证;那里除了天空、大地、丛生的荆棘和茂密的林莽之外,万物尽皆凋亡。)见 Tom. vii. p. 250,《西番雅书》注(Cap. Sophonias),又 tom. i. p. 26。