Chapter LVI: The Saracens, The Franks And The Normans.—Part III. 第五十六章 萨拉森人、法兰克人与诺曼人——第三节

Roger, the twelfth and last of the sons of Tancred, had been long detained in Normandy by his own and his father’s age. He accepted the welcome summons; hastened to the Apulian camp; and deserved at first the esteem, and afterwards the envy, of his elder brother. Their valor and ambition were equal; but the youth, the beauty, the elegant manners, of Roger engaged the disinterested love of the soldiers and people. So scanty was his allowance for himself and forty followers, that he descended from conquest to robbery, and from robbery to domestic theft; and so loose were the notions of property, that, by his own historian, at his special command, he is accused of stealing horses from a stable at Melphi. 52 His spirit emerged from poverty and disgrace: from these base practices he rose to the merit and glory of a holy war; and the invasion of Sicily was seconded by the zeal and policy of his brother Guiscard. After the retreat of the Greeks, the idolaters, a most audacious reproach of the Catholics, had retrieved their losses and possessions; but the deliverance of the island, so vainly undertaken by the forces of the Eastern empire, was achieved by a small and private band of adventurers. 53 In the first attempt, Roger braved, in an open boat, the real and fabulous dangers of Scylla and Charybdis; landed with only sixty soldiers on a hostile shore; drove the Saracens to the gates of Messina and safely returned with the spoils of the adjacent country. In the fortress of Trani, his active and patient courage were equally conspicuous. In his old age he related with pleasure, that, by the distress of the siege, himself, and the countess his wife, had been reduced to a single cloak or mantle, which they wore alternately; that in a sally his horse had been slain, and he was dragged away by the Saracens; but that he owed his rescue to his good sword, and had retreated with his saddle on his back, lest the meanest trophy might be left in the hands of the miscreants. In the siege of Trani, three hundred Normans withstood and repulsed the forces of the island. In the field of Ceramio, fifty thousand horse and foot were overthrown by one hundred and thirty-six Christian soldiers, without reckoning St. George, who fought on horseback in the foremost ranks. The captive banners, with four camels, were reserved for the successor of St. Peter; and had these barbaric spoils been exposed, not in the Vatican, but in the Capitol, they might have revived the memory of the Punic triumphs. These insufficient numbers of the Normans most probably denote their knights, the soldiers of honorable and equestrian rank, each of whom was attended by five or six followers in the field; 54 yet, with the aid of this interpretation, and after every fair allowance on the side of valor, arms, and reputation, the discomfiture of so many myriads will reduce the prudent reader to the alternative of a miracle or a fable. The Arabs of Sicily derived a frequent and powerful succor from their countrymen of Africa: in the siege of Palermo, the Norman cavalry was assisted by the galleys of Pisa; and, in the hour of action, the envy of the two brothers was sublimed to a generous and invincible emulation. After a war of thirty years, 55 Roger, with the title of great count, obtained the sovereignty of the largest and most fruitful island of the Mediterranean; and his administration displays a liberal and enlightened mind, above the limits of his age and education. The Moslems were maintained in the free enjoyment of their religion and property: 56 a philosopher and physician of Mazara, of the race of Mahomet, harangued the conqueror, and was invited to court; his geography of the seven climates was translated into Latin; and Roger, after a diligent perusal, preferred the work of the Arabian to the writings of the Grecian Ptolemy. 57 A remnant of Christian natives had promoted the success of the Normans: they were rewarded by the triumph of the cross. The island was restored to the jurisdiction of the Roman pontiff; new bishops were planted in the principal cities; and the clergy was satisfied by a liberal endowment of churches and monasteries. Yet the Catholic hero asserted the rights of the civil magistrate. Instead of resigning the investiture of benefices, he dexterously applied to his own profit the papal claims: the supremacy of the crown was secured and enlarged, by the singular bull, which declares the princes of Sicily hereditary and perpetual legates of the Holy See. 58
坦克雷德诸子共十二人,罗杰居末。因自己年幼、父亲年迈,他久留诺曼底未行。兄长相召,他欣然应命,匆匆赶往阿普利亚军营;起初博得兄长的敬重,其后却招致他的嫉妒。兄弟二人勇武与野心不相上下;然罗杰年轻俊美、举止优雅,赢得士卒与民众无所图报的爱戴。他供养自己与四十名随从的进项极为微薄,以致从征战之业沦为劫掠,再从劫掠沦为家中的偷窃;而当时人对财产的观念又极其松散,竟至他本人的史家——且是奉他亲口之命——记下他曾在梅尔菲的一处马厩里偷马。52 他的志气终究挣脱了贫困与耻辱:由这些卑下的行径,他一跃而登上圣战的功业与荣耀;他进攻西西里,又得到兄长吉斯卡尔的热忱与谋略相助。希腊人退走之后,那些拜偶像者——他们的存在对大公教徒而言乃是最放肆的羞辱——重新夺回了失地与产业;然而这场解放海岛之举,东帝国大军屡屡兴师、终归徒劳,最后竟由一小队私人的冒险者完成了。53 初次尝试时,罗杰乘一叶无篷小舟,冒着斯库拉与卡律布狄斯或真或传的凶险渡过海峡,仅率六十名士兵登上敌岸,把萨拉森人一直逐到墨西拿城门下,又满载邻近乡野的战利品安然而返。在特拉尼要塞,他既勇猛又能坚忍,二者同样引人瞩目。晚年时他乐于回忆:围城之困曾使他与身为伯爵夫人的妻子窘迫到只剩一件披风外袍,两人轮流披用;又说某次突围时坐骑被杀,他遭萨拉森人拖走,全靠一柄好剑才得脱身;撤退时他还把马鞍背在背上,唯恐哪怕最微不足道的战利品也落入异教徒之手。特拉尼围城战中,三百名诺曼人挡住并击退了全岛的兵力。在切拉米之野,五万名骑兵与步卒被一百三十六名基督徒士兵击溃——这还没算上圣乔治,他策马在最前列冲杀。缴获的军旗连同四头骆驼,留作进献圣彼得继承人之物;这些蛮族战利品倘若不是陈列在梵蒂冈,而是陈列在卡皮托利山,或许真能唤起人们对布匿战争凯旋的记忆。诺曼人这些少得不足信的数字,多半只是指他们的骑士,即身份高贵、拥有骑士位阶的战士,每人在战场上还带着五六名随从;54 然而,即便借助这一解释,即便在勇武、武备与威名各方面都作了充分的估量,这许多万大军竟遭击溃一事,仍会逼得审慎的读者只能在“奇迹”与“虚构”之间二选其一。西西里的阿拉伯人时常从非洲同胞那里得到强有力的增援;在巴勒莫围城战中,诺曼骑兵则有比萨的桨帆船相助;而临战之际,兄弟二人的相互嫉妒竟升华为一种慷慨无匹的争胜之心。历经三十年战争,55 罗杰以“大伯爵”的名号,取得了地中海上最大、最富饶海岛的主权;他的施政显示出一种开明豁达的胸怀,远远超越了他所处的时代与所受的教育。穆斯林得以继续自由地保有自己的信仰与财产;56 一位马扎拉的哲学家兼医生,出身穆罕默德的族裔,曾向这位征服者慷慨陈词,遂受邀入宫;他那部论述七大气候带的地理著作被译成拉丁文;罗杰细读之后,认为这位阿拉伯人的作品胜过希腊人托勒密的著述。57 岛上残存的一批基督徒土著曾助诺曼人成功,如今十字架的凯旋便是对他们的酬报。海岛重归罗马教宗的教权管辖;各主要城市新设主教;教会又获赠丰厚的堂产与修院,圣职人员由此心满意足。然而这位大公教会的英雄仍坚持世俗君长的权利。他非但没有放弃对圣职授予的掌控,反而巧妙地把教宗的种种主张化为己用:凭着那道非同寻常的教宗诏书——它宣布西西里的君主世代永为圣座的使节——王权的至高地位得到了确认与扩张。58
To Robert Guiscard, the conquest of Sicily was more glorious than beneficial: the possession of Apulia and Calabria was inadequate to his ambition; and he resolved to embrace or create the first occasion of invading, perhaps of subduing, the Roman empire of the East. 59 From his first wife, the partner of his humble fortune, he had been divorced under the pretence of consanguinity; and her son Bohemond was destined to imitate, rather than to succeed, his illustrious father. The second wife of Guiscard was the daughter of the princes of Salerno; the Lombards acquiesced in the lineal succession of their son Roger; their five daughters were given in honorable nuptials, 60 and one of them was betrothed, in a tender age, to Constantine, a beautiful youth, the son and heir of the emperor Michael. 61 But the throne of Constantinople was shaken by a revolution: the Imperial family of Ducas was confined to the palace or the cloister; and Robert deplored, and resented, the disgrace of his daughter and the expulsion of his ally. A Greek, who styled himself the father of Constantine, soon appeared at Salerno, and related the adventures of his fall and flight. That unfortunate friend was acknowledged by the duke, and adorned with the pomp and titles of Imperial dignity: in his triumphal progress through Apulia and Calabria, Michael 62 was saluted with the tears and acclamations of the people; and Pope Gregory the Seventh exhorted the bishops to preach, and the Catholics to fight, in the pious work of his restoration. His conversations with Robert were frequent and familiar; and their mutual promises were justified by the valor of the Normans and the treasures of the East. Yet this Michael, by the confession of the Greeks and Latins, was a pageant and an impostor; a monk who had fled from his convent, or a domestic who had served in the palace. The fraud had been contrived by the subtle Guiscard; and he trusted, that after this pretender had given a decent color to his arms, he would sink, at the nod of the conqueror, into his primitive obscurity. But victory was the only argument that could determine the belief of the Greeks; and the ardor of the Latins was much inferior to their credulity: the Norman veterans wished to enjoy the harvest of their toils, and the unwarlike Italians trembled at the known and unknown dangers of a transmarine expedition. In his new levies, Robert exerted the influence of gifts and promises, the terrors of civil and ecclesiastical authority; and some acts of violence might justify the reproach, that age and infancy were pressed without distinction into the service of their unrelenting prince. After two years’ incessant preparations the land and naval forces were assembled at Otranto, at the heel, or extreme promontory, of Italy; and Robert was accompanied by his wife, who fought by his side, his son Bohemond, and the representative of the emperor Michael. Thirteen hundred knights 63 of Norman race or discipline, formed the sinews of the army, which might be swelled to thirty thousand 64 followers of every denomination. The men, the horses, the arms, the engines, the wooden towers, covered with raw hides, were embarked on board one hundred and fifty vessels: the transports had been built in the ports of Italy, and the galleys were supplied by the alliance of the republic of Ragusa.
对罗伯特·吉斯卡尔而言,征服西西里带来的荣耀多于实利:仅据有阿普利亚与卡拉布里亚,远不足以餍足他的野心;于是他决意抓住、乃至制造头一个机会,去入侵——或许竟是征服——东方的罗马帝国。59 他的原配曾与他共度微贱岁月,后来他借口两人有血亲关系而与她离异;她所生的儿子博希蒙德,命中注定只能效法其显赫的父亲,却无从继承他的家业。吉斯卡尔的第二任妻子是萨莱诺君主的女儿;伦巴第人默认了他俩之子罗杰的嫡系继承权;他们的五个女儿都缔结了体面的婚姻,60 其中一个还在幼年便许配给了君士坦丁——那是位俊美的少年,皇帝米海尔的儿子兼继承人。61 然而君士坦丁堡的皇位却因一场政变而动摇:杜卡斯皇族被幽禁于宫中或囚于修院;罗伯特既为女儿蒙羞、盟友遭逐而痛惜,也为之愤懑。不久,一个自称是君士坦丁之父的希腊人来到萨莱诺,讲述了他兵败逃亡的种种经历。公爵承认了这位落难的“朋友”,为他备办帝王的排场与尊号;米海尔62 一路巡行阿普利亚与卡拉布里亚,所到之处民众含泪欢呼致敬;教宗格列高利七世更劝勉各主教登坛布道、号召大公教徒起而征战,共襄这一恢复其帝位的虔诚大业。他与罗伯特往来密切、言谈亲昵;两人相互许下的诺言,仿佛已有诺曼人的勇武和东方的财富为其担保。然而这个米海尔,据希腊人与拉丁人一致承认,不过是个摆出来的傀儡、一名冒名顶替之徒:要么是从修院逃出的僧侣,要么是在宫中当过差的仆役。这场骗局出自狡黠的吉斯卡尔之手;他料想,只等这个冒牌货为自己的出兵抹上一层体面的借口,此人便会在征服者一个眼色之下,重新沉回原先的默默无闻。可是唯有胜利才能让希腊人真心信服;而拉丁人虽然轻信,热忱却远不及其轻信之深:诺曼老兵一心想坐享辛劳换来的成果,而素不善战的意大利人则对一场跨海远征中已知与未知的种种凶险惶恐不安。在这次征兵中,罗伯特既动用赏赐与许诺加以笼络,又搬出世俗与教会两重权威加以威吓;某些强征的暴行,甚至坐实了这样的指责:不论老翁还是幼童,都被这位铁石心肠的君主一概抓去当兵。经过两年不停的筹备,水陆两军齐集奥特朗托——那是意大利“靴跟”所在、也即最南端的海角;随行在罗伯特身边的,有并肩作战的妻子、儿子博希蒙德,以及那位冒充皇帝米海尔的人。一千三百名骑士,63 或为诺曼血统、或受诺曼军法训练,构成了全军的中坚;连同形形色色的随从,总数或可膨胀至三万人。64 将士、马匹、兵器、攻城器械,以及蒙着生牛皮的木制攻城塔,尽数装上一百五十艘船只:运兵船是在意大利各港口打造的,桨帆船则由结盟的拉古萨共和国供给。
At the mouth of the Adriatic Gulf, the shores of Italy and Epirus incline towards each other. The space between Brundusium and Durazzo, the Roman passage, is no more than one hundred miles; 65 at the last station of Otranto, it is contracted to fifty; 66 and this narrow distance had suggested to Pyrrhus and Pompey the sublime or extravagant idea of a bridge. Before the general embarkation, the Norman duke despatched Bohemond with fifteen galleys to seize or threaten the Isle of Corfu, to survey the opposite coast, and to secure a harbor in the neighborhood of Vallona for the landing of the troops. They passed and landed without perceiving an enemy; and this successful experiment displayed the neglect and decay of the naval power of the Greeks. The islands of Epirus and the maritime towns were subdued by the arms or the name of Robert, who led his fleet and army from Corfu (I use the modern appellation) to the siege of Durazzo. That city, the western key of the empire, was guarded by ancient renown, and recent fortifications, by George Palaeologus, a patrician, victorious in the Oriental wars, and a numerous garrison of Albanians and Macedonians, who, in every age, have maintained the character of soldiers. In the prosecution of his enterprise, the courage of Guiscard was assailed by every form of danger and mischance. In the most propitious season of the year, as his fleet passed along the coast, a storm of wind and snow unexpectedly arose: the Adriatic was swelled by the raging blast of the south, and a new shipwreck confirmed the old infamy of the Acroceraunian rocks. 67 The sails, the masts, and the oars, were shattered or torn away; the sea and shore were covered with the fragments of vessels, with arms and dead bodies; and the greatest part of the provisions were either drowned or damaged. The ducal galley was laboriously rescued from the waves, and Robert halted seven days on the adjacent cape, to collect the relics of his loss, and revive the drooping spirits of his soldiers. The Normans were no longer the bold and experienced mariners who had explored the ocean from Greenland to Mount Atlas, and who smiled at the petty dangers of the Mediterranean. They had wept during the tempest; they were alarmed by the hostile approach of the Venetians, who had been solicited by the prayers and promises of the Byzantine court. The first day’s action was not disadvantageous to Bohemond, a beardless youth, 68 who led the naval powers of his father. All night the galleys of the republic lay on their anchors in the form of a crescent; and the victory of the second day was decided by the dexterity of their evolutions, the station of their archers, the weight of their javelins, and the borrowed aid of the Greek fire. The Apulian and Ragusian vessels fled to the shore, several were cut from their cables, and dragged away by the conqueror; and a sally from the town carried slaughter and dismay to the tents of the Norman duke. A seasonable relief was poured into Durazzo, and as soon as the besiegers had lost the command of the sea, the islands and maritime towns withdrew from the camp the supply of tribute and provision. That camp was soon afflicted with a pestilential disease; five hundred knights perished by an inglorious death; and the list of burials (if all could obtain a decent burial) amounted to ten thousand persons. Under these calamities, the mind of Guiscard alone was firm and invincible; and while he collected new forces from Apulia and Sicily, he battered, or scaled, or sapped, the walls of Durazzo. But his industry and valor were encountered by equal valor and more perfect industry. A movable turret, of a size and capacity to contain five hundred soldiers, had been rolled forwards to the foot of the rampart: but the descent of the door or drawbridge was checked by an enormous beam, and the wooden structure was constantly consumed by artificial flames.
在亚得里亚海湾口,意大利与伊庇鲁斯两岸彼此相向而趋。布伦迪西乌姆与都拉佐之间即古罗马人的渡海航路,相距不过一百英里;65 若从最靠外的奥特朗托起算,更缩至五十英里;66 正是这道狭窄的海面,曾令皮洛士与庞培生出架桥飞渡的宏图——或者说狂想。在大军全体登船之前,诺曼公爵先遣博希蒙德率十五艘桨帆船,前去夺取或威慑科孚岛,勘察对岸海滨,并在瓦罗纳附近觅得一处港口,以供部队登陆。他们一路渡海登岸,竟未遇一个敌人;这次顺利的试探,恰恰暴露出希腊人海上力量的废弛与衰败。伊庇鲁斯沿海诸岛与各海滨城镇,或慑于罗伯特的兵威、或慑于他的名声,纷纷降服;罗伯特遂率水陆大军从科孚(此处我采用今名)进抵都拉佐城下,展开围攻。这座城市乃帝国西面的门户,既有累世威名护持,又有新筑的工事防守,还有久经东方战阵、屡建战功的贵族乔治·帕莱奥洛戈斯坐镇,加之一支由阿尔巴尼亚人与马其顿人组成的庞大守军——这两族无论哪个时代都不失为骁勇的战士。推进这番事业时,形形色色的凶险与厄运轮番考验着吉斯卡尔的勇气。正当一年中最宜航行的时节,他的舰队沿岸行进时,一场夹雪的暴风骤然而起:南风狂啸,掀起亚得里亚海的怒涛,一场新的海难再次印证了阿克罗克劳尼亚礁石那由来已久的凶名。67 船帆、桅杆、船桨或被击碎、或被卷走;海面与岸边到处漂浮、堆积着船只的残骸、兵器和尸体;大半军需也不是沉没水底,便是损毁。公爵座乘的桨帆船好不容易才从浪涛中抢救出来;罗伯特在附近海角停留了七天,一面收拢劫余的人马物资,一面重新鼓起士卒低落的士气。此时的诺曼人,早已不复当年那批勇敢而老练的航海者——那些人曾从格陵兰一直探航到阿特拉斯山,对地中海上区区风浪只报以一笑。这一回他们却在风暴中落了泪;威尼斯人应拜占庭朝廷的恳求与许诺,正带着敌意逼近,更教他们惊惶。头一天的交战,对博希蒙德68 而言尚不算失利——这位统领其父海上舰队的少年,此时尚未蓄须。威尼斯共和国的桨帆船整夜下锚,排成一弯新月的阵形;次日的胜负,则取决于他们调度阵势的娴熟、弓弩手的部署、投枪的沉重,以及借来的希腊火之助。阿普利亚与拉古萨的船只纷纷逃向岸边,其中数艘被割断缆绳、由胜者拖走;城中守军又出击一次,把杀戮与惊恐一直带到了诺曼公爵的营帐。及时的援兵与补给源源涌入都拉佐;而围城一方一旦丧失制海权,沿海诸岛与各城镇便不再向其营中输送贡赋与粮草。不久,营中又爆发瘟疫;五百名骑士就此不光彩地死去;死者名册(假使人人都能得到像样的安葬的话)竟多达一万人。在这重重灾祸之下,唯有吉斯卡尔一人心志坚定、不可撼动;他一面从阿普利亚和西西里调集新的兵力,一面对都拉佐的城墙时而撞击、时而登城、时而掘壕挖墙。然而,他的勤勉与勇武,却遇上了同样的勇武和更为周密的勤勉。一座可容五百名士兵、体量惊人的活动攻城塔已推进到城垣脚下;可是塔上放板刚要落下,就被一根巨大的横梁顶住无法展开,而人为纵放的火焰,又不断吞噬着那木制的塔身。
While the Roman empire was attacked by the Turks in the East, east, and the Normans in the West, the aged successor of Michael surrendered the sceptre to the hands of Alexius, an illustrious captain, and the founder of the Comnenian dynasty. The princess Anne, his daughter and historian, observes, in her affected style, that even Hercules was unequal to a double combat; and, on this principle, she approves a hasty peace with the Turks, which allowed her father to undertake in person the relief of Durazzo. On his accession, Alexius found the camp without soldiers, and the treasury without money; yet such were the vigor and activity of his measures, that in six months he assembled an army of seventy thousand men, 69 and performed a march of five hundred miles. His troops were levied in Europe and Asia, from Peloponnesus to the Black Sea; his majesty was displayed in the silver arms and rich trappings of the companies of Horse-guards; and the emperor was attended by a train of nobles and princes, some of whom, in rapid succession, had been clothed with the purple, and were indulged by the lenity of the times in a life of affluence and dignity. Their youthful ardor might animate the multitude; but their love of pleasure and contempt of subordination were pregnant with disorder and mischief; and their importunate clamors for speedy and decisive action disconcerted the prudence of Alexius, who might have surrounded and starved the besieging army. The enumeration of provinces recalls a sad comparison of the past and present limits of the Roman world: the raw levies were drawn together in haste and terror; and the garrisons of Anatolia, or Asia Minor, had been purchased by the evacuation of the cities which were immediately occupied by the Turks. The strength of the Greek army consisted in the Varangians, the Scandinavian guards, whose numbers were recently augmented by a colony of exiles and volunteers from the British Island of Thule. Under the yoke of the Norman conqueror, the Danes and English were oppressed and united; a band of adventurous youths resolved to desert a land of slavery; the sea was open to their escape; and, in their long pilgrimage, they visited every coast that afforded any hope of liberty and revenge. They were entertained in the service of the Greek emperor; and their first station was in a new city on the Asiatic shore: but Alexius soon recalled them to the defence of his person and palace; and bequeathed to his successors the inheritance of their faith and valor. 70 The name of a Norman invader revived the memory of their wrongs: they marched with alacrity against the national foe, and panted to regain in Epirus the glory which they had lost in the battle of Hastings. The Varangians were supported by some companies of Franks or Latins; and the rebels, who had fled to Constantinople from the tyranny of Guiscard, were eager to signalize their zeal and gratify their revenge. In this emergency, the emperor had not disdained the impure aid of the Paulicians or Manichaeans of Thrace and Bulgaria; and these heretics united with the patience of martyrdom the spirit and discipline of active valor. 71 The treaty with the sultan had procured a supply of some thousand Turks; and the arrows of the Scythian horse were opposed to the lances of the Norman cavalry. On the report and distant prospect of these formidable numbers, Robert assembled a council of his principal officers. “You behold,” said he, “your danger: it is urgent and inevitable. The hills are covered with arms and standards; and the emperor of the Greeks is accustomed to wars and triumphs. Obedience and union are our only safety; and I am ready to yield the command to a more worthy leader.” The vote and acclamation even of his secret enemies, assured him, in that perilous moment, of their esteem and confidence; and the duke thus continued: “Let us trust in the rewards of victory, and deprive cowardice of the means of escape. Let us burn our vessels and our baggage, and give battle on this spot, as if it were the place of our nativity and our burial.” The resolution was unanimously approved; and, without confining himself to his lines, Guiscard awaited in battle-array the nearer approach of the enemy. His rear was covered by a small river; his right wing extended to the sea; his left to the hills: nor was he conscious, perhaps, that on the same ground Caesar and Pompey had formerly disputed the empire of the world. 72
当罗马帝国东有土耳其人进犯、西有诺曼人来袭之际,米海尔那位年迈的继任者把权柄交到了阿历克塞手中——此人是一员声名显赫的统帅,也是科穆宁王朝的奠基者。他的女儿兼史家安娜公主,以其一贯矫饰的笔调评论道:纵是赫拉克勒斯也难以同时应付两面之敌;据此她赞同匆匆与土耳其人媾和,好让父亲得以亲自出马,去解都拉佐之围。阿历克塞登基之初,但见军营里无兵、国库里无钱;然而他的举措雷厉风行,竟在半年之内便召集起一支七万人的大军,69 并完成了五百英里的行军。他的兵员征自欧、亚两洲,远及伯罗奔尼撒与黑海之滨;一队队骑兵卫士配着银亮的甲仗与华贵的鞍辔,衬托出他的威仪;皇帝身边还簇拥着一大批贵族与王公,其中有些人曾在皇位急速更迭之际一度身披紫袍,如今则借着这宽和的时世,仍安享富贵与尊荣。这些人年少气盛,本可鼓舞士气;无奈他们贪图享乐、又不甘居人之下,正是祸乱的温床;他们一味聒噪着要速战速决,扰乱了阿历克塞的持重之计——本来他大可把围城之敌反加包围、困而饿之。一一列数这些行省,不免令人黯然对比罗马世界今昔的疆界:这些未经训练的新兵是在仓皇惊惧中拼凑起来的;而安纳托利亚(即小亚细亚)的守军,更是以放弃诸城为代价才抽调而来,那些城池随即便被土耳其人占据。希腊军队的主力在于瓦兰吉人,即那支斯堪的纳维亚卫队;近来又有一批来自不列颠图勒岛的流亡者与志愿者加入,使其人数有所增添。在诺曼征服者的枷锁之下,丹麦人与英格兰人同受压迫,也因此同仇敌忾;一群敢于冒险的年轻人决意逃离这片沦为奴役的土地;大海为他们的出逃敞开着;在漫长的漂泊之旅中,凡有一线自由与复仇之望的海岸,他们都一一造访。希腊皇帝收纳了他们、供其驱使;他们最初驻防在亚洲一侧海岸的一座新城,但阿历克塞不久便把他们召回,用以护卫自身与宫廷,并把他们的忠诚与勇武作为一份遗产传给了后世诸帝。70 “诺曼入侵者”这个名号,重又唤起了他们对旧日冤仇的记忆:他们意气昂扬地开赴前线,去迎战这一民族的宿敌,一心要在伊庇鲁斯夺回当年黑斯廷斯一役所丧失的荣光。瓦兰吉人另有几队法兰克人(或曰拉丁人)相助;还有一些为躲避吉斯卡尔暴政而逃奔君士坦丁堡的叛离者,也急于一显其热忱、以泄心头之恨。值此危急之际,皇帝也不惜借重色雷斯与保加利亚一带保罗派(或曰摩尼教徒)那不洁之手;这些异端既有殉道者般的坚忍,又兼具骁勇善战的精神与纪律。71 与苏丹缔结的和约,为他换来了数千名土耳其援兵;于是斯基泰骑兵的箭矢,便与诺曼骑兵的长枪相抗。听闻敌军数目如此可畏,又远远望见其阵势,罗伯特便召集麾下主要将领举行军议。“你们都看到了自己身处的险境,”他说道,“它既迫在眉睫,又无从躲避。漫山遍野尽是刀兵旗帜,而希腊皇帝更是久经沙场、惯于奏凯。唯有服从与团结,才是我们保命的凭仗;我本人也甘愿把指挥权让给更配担此重任的人。”就在这生死攸关的一刻,连他暗中的仇敌也投票并高声表态,向他保证了敬重与信任;公爵于是接着说道:“让我们把希望寄托在胜利的酬报上,断绝怯懦者一切逃遁的退路。让我们烧掉自己的船只和辎重,就在这片土地上决一死战,仿佛此地便是我们生身之处、葬身之所。”这一决断获得众人一致赞同;吉斯卡尔并不固守自己的营垒防线,而是列开战阵,静候敌军逼近。他的后方有一条小河作屏障,右翼直抵海边,左翼倚着山丘;他或许并未意识到,当年恺撒与庞培正是在这同一片土地上争夺过天下的霸权。72
Against the advice of his wisest captains, Alexius resolved to risk the event of a general action, and exhorted the garrison of Durazzo to assist their own deliverance by a well-timed sally from the town. He marched in two columns to surprise the Normans before daybreak on two different sides: his light cavalry was scattered over the plain; the archers formed the second line; and the Varangians claimed the honors of the vanguard. In the first onset, the battle-axes of the strangers made a deep and bloody impression on the army of Guiscard, which was now reduced to fifteen thousand men. The Lombards and Calabrians ignominiously turned their backs; they fled towards the river and the sea; but the bridge had been broken down to check the sally of the garrison, and the coast was lined with the Venetian galleys, who played their engines among the disorderly throng. On the verge of ruin, they were saved by the spirit and conduct of their chiefs. Gaita, the wife of Robert, is painted by the Greeks as a warlike Amazon, a second Pallas; less skilful in arts, but not less terrible in arms, than the Athenian goddess: 73 though wounded by an arrow, she stood her ground, and strove, by her exhortation and example, to rally the flying troops. 74 Her female voice was seconded by the more powerful voice and arm of the Norman duke, as calm in action as he was magnanimous in council: “Whither,” he cried aloud, “whither do ye fly? Your enemy is implacable; and death is less grievous than servitude.” The moment was decisive: as the Varangians advanced before the line, they discovered the nakedness of their flanks: the main battle of the duke, of eight hundred knights, stood firm and entire; they couched their lances, and the Greeks bore the furious and irresistible shock of the French cavalry. 75 Alexius was not deficient in the duties of a soldier or a general; but he no sooner beheld the slaughter of the Varangians, and the flight of the Turks, than he despised his subjects, and despaired of his fortune. The princess Anne, who drops a tear on this melancholy event, is reduced to praise the strength and swiftness of her father’s horse, and his vigorous struggle when he was almost overthrown by the stroke of a lance, which had shivered the Imperial helmet. His desperate valor broke through a squadron of Franks who opposed his flight; and after wandering two days and as many nights in the mountains, he found some repose, of body, though not of mind, in the walls of Lychnidus. The victorious Robert reproached the tardy and feeble pursuit which had suffered the escape of so illustrious a prize: but he consoled his disappointment by the trophies and standards of the field, the wealth and luxury of the Byzantine camp, and the glory of defeating an army five times more numerous than his own. A multitude of Italians had been the victims of their own fears; but only thirty of his knights were slain in this memorable day. In the Roman host, the loss of Greeks, Turks, and English, amounted to five or six thousand: 76 the plain of Durazzo was stained with noble and royal blood; and the end of the impostor Michael was more honorable than his life.
阿历克塞不顾麾下最明智将领的劝阻,决意孤注一掷、寻求一场全面决战,并叮嘱都拉佐守军择准时机出城反击,为自身的解围出一份力。他分兵两路,打算趁天明之前从两个方向奇袭诺曼人:轻骑兵散布于平原之上,弓箭手列为第二阵,瓦兰吉人则争得了充当前锋的荣誉。初一交锋,这些异邦人的战斧便在吉斯卡尔军中砍出了一道深而血腥的缺口——此时他的兵力已锐减至一万五千人。伦巴第人和卡拉布里亚人可耻地掉头,朝着河流与海岸奔逃;无奈那座桥先前为阻止守军出击已被拆毁,海岸边又停满威尼斯人的桨帆船,只管把各式抛射器械对着乱作一团的人群猛烈施放。就在全军濒临覆灭之际,多亏几位首领的胆气与调度,才转危为安。罗伯特的妻子盖塔,在希腊人笔下被描绘成一位好战的亚马逊女杰、第二个帕拉斯:论技艺,她不及那位雅典女神,可论到临阵的威猛,却丝毫不逊于她。73 她虽中了一箭,却仍坚守原地,一面疾声鼓舞、一面以身作则,竭力收拢溃逃的士卒。74 她那女子的呼喊,又得到了诺曼公爵更为洪亮的声音与更为有力的臂膀相助——此人临阵时镇定自若,一如他议事时的宽宏大度:“你们往哪里逃?”他高声呼喊,“往哪里逃?敌人绝不会心慈手软;与其为奴,一死尚且没那么难堪。”这一刻成了胜负的关键:瓦兰吉人突进到本方阵线之前,两翼因而门户洞开;公爵的中军——八百名骑士——却岿然不动、阵形完整;他们平端长枪冲杀过去,希腊人硬生生承受了法兰西骑兵那狂猛而无可抵挡的冲击。75 无论作为士兵还是主帅,阿历克塞都未曾失职;然而,一见瓦兰吉人惨遭屠戮、土耳其人临阵脱逃,他顿时鄙弃起自己的臣民,也对自己的命运彻底绝望。安娜公主为这桩伤心之事洒下一掬泪水,到头来却只能转而称颂父亲坐骑的雄健与迅捷,以及他险些被一记长枪刺落马下时的奋力挣扎——那一枪已将御用的头盔击得粉碎。他凭着拼死的勇力,冲开一队拦阻其逃路的法兰克骑兵;在山中辗转流亡了两日两夜之后,总算在吕赫尼杜斯城墙之内让身体得到些许歇息——尽管心绪难宁。得胜的罗伯特责怪追击太过迟缓无力,竟让这样一位显赫的猎物脱逃;不过,凭着战场上缴获的战利品与军旗、拜占庭营中的财富与奢华物件,以及击败一支五倍于己之敌的荣耀,他这份失望也算得到了慰藉。成群的意大利人死于自己的恐惧之下;而在这值得铭记的一天里,他麾下的骑士却只战死了三十人。罗马一方,希腊人、土耳其人与英格兰人的伤亡合计达五六千之众;76 都拉佐平原染满了贵族与王室的鲜血;而那冒牌皇帝米海尔的结局,倒比他生前更为体面。
It is more than probable that Guiscard was not afflicted by the loss of a costly pageant, which had merited only the contempt and derision of the Greeks. After their defeat, they still persevered in the defence of Durazzo; and a Venetian commander supplied the place of George Palaeologus, who had been imprudently called away from his station. The tents of the besiegers were converted into barracks, to sustain the inclemency of the winter; and in answer to the defiance of the garrison, Robert insinuated, that his patience was at least equal to their obstinacy. 77 Perhaps he already trusted to his secret correspondence with a Venetian noble, who sold the city for a rich and honorable marriage. At the dead of night, several rope-ladders were dropped from the walls; the light Calabrians ascended in silence; and the Greeks were awakened by the name and trumpets of the conqueror. Yet they defended the streets three days against an enemy already master of the rampart; and near seven months elapsed between the first investment and the final surrender of the place. From Durazzo, the Norman duke advanced into the heart of Epirus or Albania; traversed the first mountains of Thessaly; surprised three hundred English in the city of Castoria; approached Thessalonica; and made Constantinople tremble. A more pressing duty suspended the prosecution of his ambitious designs. By shipwreck, pestilence, and the sword, his army was reduced to a third of the original numbers; and instead of being recruited from Italy, he was informed, by plaintive epistles, of the mischiefs and dangers which had been produced by his absence: the revolt of the cities and barons of Apulia; the distress of the pope; and the approach or invasion of Henry king of Germany. Highly presuming that his person was sufficient for the public safety, he repassed the sea in a single brigantine, and left the remains of the army under the command of his son and the Norman counts, exhorting Bohemond to respect the freedom of his peers, and the counts to obey the authority of their leader. The son of Guiscard trod in the footsteps of his father; and the two destroyers are compared, by the Greeks, to the caterpillar and the locust, the last of whom devours whatever has escaped the teeth of the former. 78 After winning two battles against the emperor, he descended into the plain of Thessaly, and besieged Larissa, the fabulous realm of Achilles, 79 which contained the treasure and magazines of the Byzantine camp. Yet a just praise must not be refused to the fortitude and prudence of Alexius, who bravely struggled with the calamities of the times. In the poverty of the state, he presumed to borrow the superfluous ornaments of the churches: the desertion of the Manichaeans was supplied by some tribes of Moldavia: a reenforcement of seven thousand Turks replaced and revenged the loss of their brethren; and the Greek soldiers were exercised to ride, to draw the bow, and to the daily practice of ambuscades and evolutions. Alexius had been taught by experience, that the formidable cavalry of the Franks on foot was unfit for action, and almost incapable of motion; 80 his archers were directed to aim their arrows at the horse rather than the man; and a variety of spikes and snares were scattered over the ground on which he might expect an attack. In the neighborhood of Larissa the events of war were protracted and balanced. The courage of Bohemond was always conspicuous, and often successful; but his camp was pillaged by a stratagem of the Greeks; the city was impregnable; and the venal or discontented counts deserted his standard, betrayed their trusts, and enlisted in the service of the emperor. Alexius returned to Constantinople with the advantage, rather than the honor, of victory. After evacuating the conquests which he could no longer defend, the son of Guiscard embarked for Italy, and was embraced by a father who esteemed his merit, and sympathized in his misfortune.
吉斯卡尔多半并不为失去这场耗资不菲的傀儡把戏而痛惜——那出戏本就只配换来希腊人的轻蔑与嘲笑。战败之后,希腊人依旧坚守都拉佐;乔治·帕莱奥洛戈斯先前被冒失地调离了防地,如今其位由一名威尼斯将领接替。围城者把营帐改建成营房,以熬过严冬的酷寒;面对守军的挑衅叫阵,罗伯特则含蓄地放话说:论耐性,他至少不输于他们的顽固。77 或许他此时已把指望寄托在与一名威尼斯贵族的暗中勾连上——此人为换取一桩既富且贵的婚姻,出卖了这座城池。深夜时分,几架绳梯从城墙上垂下;身手矫捷的卡拉布里亚人悄无声息地攀了上去;待希腊人惊醒时,迎接他们的已是征服者的名号与号角声。尽管城墙已尽落敌手,他们仍在街巷间抵抗了三天;而从最初合围到该城最终陷落,前后将近七个月。诺曼公爵从都拉佐挥师深入伊庇鲁斯(亦即阿尔巴尼亚)腹地,越过色萨利边缘的头几道山岭,在卡斯托里亚城出其不意地俘获三百名英格兰人,进逼塞萨洛尼卡,一时间连君士坦丁堡也为之震恐。一桩更为紧迫的要务,迫使他中止了这番野心勃勃的谋划。海难、瘟疫加上刀兵之祸,已使他的军队折损到只剩原先的三分之一;而意大利非但没有补来新兵,反倒有一封封哀诉的书信告知他:因他离境而生出的种种祸患与危险——阿普利亚各城市与男爵的叛乱、教宗的困厄,还有日耳曼国王亨利的进逼乃至入侵。他自信满满,以为单凭自己一人便足以保全公众安危,遂独乘一艘轻帆船渡海折返,把残余的军队交由儿子和几位诺曼伯爵统领,并嘱咐博希蒙德要尊重同侪的自主之权,又叮嘱众伯爵要服从主帅的号令。吉斯卡尔之子踏着父亲的足迹前行;希腊人把这一对祸害比作毛虫与蝗——凡是逃过前者齿间的东西,都被后者吞食殆尽。78 在两度击败皇帝之后,他挥师而下,进入色萨利平原,围攻拉里萨——传说中阿喀琉斯的王国,79 那里贮藏着拜占庭大营的财宝与军需。不过,对于阿历克塞的坚毅与审慎,也不应吝惜公允的赞誉——他勇敢地与时艰苦苦搏斗。国库空虚之下,他竟敢挪借教堂里多余的装饰之物;摩尼教徒的临阵脱离,则由摩尔达维亚的几个部落补上;七千名土耳其援兵开到,既填补了先前同族折损的缺额,也算为之报了仇;希腊士卒则日日操练骑术、拉弓,以及设伏与变阵之法。阿历克塞已从经验中懂得:法兰克人那令人生畏的骑兵,一旦下马徒步便难以作战,几乎寸步难行;80 于是他吩咐弓箭手把箭对准战马而非骑手,又在预料敌军可能来袭的地面上遍布各式尖桩与陷阱。在拉里萨一带,战事迁延日久,胜负相持不下。博希蒙德的勇武始终引人注目,且屡屡奏效;然而他的营寨却中了希腊人的计谋而遭洗劫;那座城又坚不可摧;而那些或贪财、或心怀不满的伯爵,纷纷弃他的旗号而去,辜负所托,转投皇帝麾下效力。阿历克塞班师君士坦丁堡,带回的与其说是胜利的荣耀,不如说是胜利的实利。既已无力再守住既得的疆土,吉斯卡尔之子便撤离占领地、登船返回意大利,投入一位父亲的怀抱——这位父亲既赏识他的才干,也同情他的不幸。

Notes 注释

52
Latrocinio armigerorum suorum in multis sustentabatur, quod quidem ad ejus ignominiam non dicimus; sed ipso ita praecipiente adhuc viliora et reprehensibiliora dicturi sumus ut pluribus patescat, quam laboriose et cum quanta angustia a profunda paupertate ad summum culmen divitiarum vel honoris attigerit. Such is the preface of Malaterra (l. i. c. 25) to the horse-stealing. From the moment (l. i. c. 19) that he has mentioned his patron Roger, the elder brother sinks into the second character. Something similar in Velleius Paterculus may be observed of Augustus and Tiberius.
Latrocinio armigerorum suorum in multis sustentabatur, quod quidem ad ejus ignominiam non dicimus; sed ipso ita praecipiente adhuc viliora et reprehensibiliora dicturi sumus ut pluribus patescat, quam laboriose et cum quanta angustia a profunda paupertate ad summum culmen divitiarum vel honoris attigerit.(大意:他多半靠部下的劫掠维持生计;我们说这些并非要羞辱他,恰恰相反,正是奉他本人之命,我们还要讲些更卑下、更可责的事,好让世人更清楚地看到,他是历经怎样的艰辛与困厄,才从赤贫的深渊攀上财富与荣誉的顶峰。)以上便是马拉泰拉(第一卷第25章)为盗马一事所作的开场白。自他(第一卷第19章)提到自己的恩主罗杰那一刻起,兄长便退居次要角色。韦莱乌斯·帕特尔库鲁斯笔下论奥古斯都与提比略,也可见到类似的情形。
53
Duo sibi proficua deputans animae scilicet et corporis si terran: Idolis deditam ad cultum divinum revocaret, (Galfrid Malaterra, l. ii. c. 1.) The conquest of Sicily is related in the three last books, and he himself has given an accurate summary of the chapters, (p. 544-546.)
Duo sibi proficua deputans animae scilicet et corporis si terram Idolis deditam ad cultum divinum revocaret(大意:他认为,若能把一片沉溺于偶像崇拜的土地重新引归对神的敬拜,于灵魂与肉体两方面都对自己有益)(Galfrid Malaterra, l. ii. c. 1.)。征服西西里一事记述于最后三卷之中,他本人还为各章作了一份准确的提要(p. 544-546)。
54
See the word Milites in the Latin Glossary of Ducange.
参看杜康热《拉丁语汇编》中“Milites”词条。
55
Of odd particulars, I learn from Malaterra, that the Arabs had introduced into Sicily the use of camels (l. i. c. 33) and of carrier-pigeons, (c. 42;) and that the bite of the tarantula provokes a windy disposition, quae per anum inhoneste crepitando emergit; a symptom most ridiculously felt by the whole Norman army in their camp near Palermo, (c. 36.) I shall add an etymology not unworthy of the xith century: Messana is divided from Messis, the place from whence the harvests of the isle were sent in tribute to Rome, (l. ii. c. 1.)
至于一些稀奇的细节,我从马拉泰拉那里得知:阿拉伯人把骆驼(第一卷第33章)与信鸽(第42章)的使用引入了西西里;又说被塔兰图拉毒蛛咬伤会激起一股胀气,quae per anum inhoneste crepitando emergit(意即“它会从肛门以不雅的爆响冒出”);诺曼全军在巴勒莫附近扎营时,就极其滑稽地集体尝到了这一症状(第36章)。我再补上一条颇合十一世纪水准的词源考据:Messana(墨西拿)一名派生自 Messis(收获),因为此地正是全岛谷物作为贡品运往罗马的出发地(第二卷第1章)。
56
See the capitulation of Palermo in Malaterra, l. ii. c. 45, and Giannone, who remarks the general toleration of the Saracens, (tom ii. p. 72.)
巴勒莫的受降条款见马拉泰拉第二卷第45章,以及詹诺内的记述——他特别提到对萨拉森人普遍采取了宽容政策(第二卷第72页)。
57
John Leo Afer, de Medicis et Philosophus Arabibus, c. 14, apud Fabric. Bibliot. Graec. tom. xiii. p. 278, 279. This philosopher is named Esseriph Essachalli, and he died in Africa, A. H. 516, A.D. 1122. Yet this story bears a strange resemblance to the Sherif al Edrissi, who presented his book (Geographia Nubiensis, see preface p. 88, 90, 170) to Roger, king of Sicily, A. H. 541, A.D. 1153, (D’Herbelot, Bibliotheque Orientale, p. 786. Prideaux’s Life of Mahomet, p. 188. Petit de la Croix, Hist. de Gengiscan, p. 535, 536. Casiri, Bibliot. Arab. Hispan. tom. ii. p. 9-13;) and I am afraid of some mistake.
John Leo Afer, de Medicis et Philosophus Arabibus, c. 14, apud Fabric. Bibliot. Graec. tom. xiii. p. 278, 279. 这位哲学家名叫埃塞里夫·埃萨查利,卒于非洲,回历516年、即公元1122年。不过,这个故事与谢里夫·伊德里西的事迹有着离奇的相似:后者曾把自己的著作(《努比亚地理志》,见序言 p. 88, 90, 170)献给西西里国王罗杰,时在回历541年、即公元1153年(D’Herbelot, Bibliotheque Orientale, p. 786. Prideaux’s Life of Mahomet, p. 188. Petit de la Croix, Hist. de Gengiscan, p. 535, 536. Casiri, Bibliot. Arab. Hispan. tom. ii. p. 9-13.);因此我担心此处恐有讹误。
58
Malaterra remarks the foundation of the bishoprics, (l. iv. c. 7,) and produces the original of the bull, (l. iv. c. 29.) Giannone gives a rational idea of this privilege, and the tribunal of the monarchy of Sicily, (tom. ii. p. 95-102;) and St. Marc (Abrege, tom. iii. p. 217-301, 1st column) labors the case with the diligence of a Sicilian lawyer.
马拉泰拉记述了这些主教区的设立(第四卷第7章),并录出了那道诏书的原文(第四卷第29章)。詹诺内对这一特权以及“西西里君权裁判所”作了合乎情理的说明(第二卷第95-102页);圣马克(《纲要》,第三卷第217-301页,第一栏)则以西西里律师般的勤谨反复钻研此案。
59
In the first expedition of Robert against the Greeks, I follow Anna Comnena, (the ist, iiid, ivth, and vth books of the Alexiad,) William Appulus, (l. ivth and vth, p. 270-275,) and Jeffrey Malaterra, (l. iii. c. 13, 14, 24-29, 39.) Their information is contemporary and authentic, but none of them were eye-witnesses of the war.
关于罗伯特首次征讨希腊人的经过,我依据的是安娜·科穆宁娜(《阿莱克修斯传》第一、第三、第四、第五卷)、阿普利亚的威廉(第四、五卷,p. 270-275)和杰弗里·马拉泰拉(第三卷第13、14、24-29、39章)。他们的记载都出自当时之人、真实可信,只是无人亲眼目睹这场战争。
60
One of them was married to Hugh, the son of Azzo, or Axo, a marquis of Lombardy, rich, powerful, and noble, (Gulielm. Appul. l. iii. p. 267,) in the xith century, and whose ancestors in the xth and ixth are explored by the critical industry of Leibnitz and Muratori. From the two elder sons of the marquis Azzo are derived the illustrious lines of Brunswick and Este. See Muratori, Antichita Estense.
她们中有一位嫁给了休——伦巴第侯爵阿佐(或作阿克索)之子;此人于十一世纪时富有、显贵而有权势(Gulielm. Appul. l. iii. p. 267),其九、十世纪的先祖,则经莱布尼茨与穆拉托里的精审考订而得以厘清。布伦瑞克与埃斯特两大名门,皆源出阿佐侯爵的两个长子。参看穆拉托里《埃斯特古史》。
61
Anna Comnena, somewhat too wantonly, praises and bewails that handsome boy, who, after the rupture of his barbaric nuptials, (l. i. p. 23,) was betrothed as her husband. (p. 27.) Elsewhere she describes the red and white of his skin, his hawk’s eyes, &c., l. iii. p. 71.
安娜·科穆宁娜以未免过于放纵的笔调,既盛赞又惋惜那位俊美的少年;在他那门蛮族婚约破裂之后(第一卷第23页),此人又被许配给她做丈夫(第27页)。她在别处还描摹了他红白相间的肤色、鹰隼般的眼睛等等(第三卷第71页)。
62
Anna Comnena, l. i. p. 28, 29. Gulielm. Appul. l. iv p. 271. Galfrid Malaterra, l. iii. c. 13, p. 579, 580. Malaterra is more cautious in his style; but the Apulian is bold and positive.—Mentitus se Michaelem Venerata Danais quidam seductor ad illum. As Gregory VII had believed, Baronius almost alone, recognizes the emperor Michael. (A.D. No. 44.)
Anna Comnena, l. i. p. 28, 29. Gulielm. Appul. l. iv p. 271. Galfrid Malaterra, l. iii. c. 13, p. 579, 580. 马拉泰拉的措辞较为审慎,阿普利亚诗人却大胆而笃定—Mentitus se Michaelem Venerata Danais quidam seductor ad illum(意即:某个骗子谎称自己是米海尔,前来投奔他,博取希腊人的敬奉)。既然当年格列高利七世都曾信以为真,如今也就几乎只剩巴罗尼乌斯一人还承认那位皇帝米海尔(见其《教会编年史》相应年份,第44条)。
63
Ipse armatae militiae non plusquam MCCC milites secum habuisse, ab eis qui eidem negotio interfuerunt attestatur, (Malaterra, l. iii. c. 24, p. 583.) These are the same whom the Apulian (l. iv. p. 273) styles the equestris gens ducis, equites de gente ducis.
Ipse armatae militiae non plusquam MCCC milites secum habuisse, ab eis qui eidem negotio interfuerunt attestatur(大意:据亲历其事者作证,他随身带去的披甲战士不过一千三百人)(Malaterra, l. iii. c. 24, p. 583.)。这些人正是阿普利亚诗人(第四卷第273页)所称的 equestris gens ducis、equites de gente ducis(“公爵的骑士之族”“出自公爵族裔的骑兵”)。
64
Anna Comnena (Alexias, l. i. p. 37;) and her account tallies with the number and lading of the ships. Ivit in Dyrrachium cum xv. millibus hominum, says the Chronicon Breve Normannicum, (Muratori, Scriptores, tom. v. p. 278.) I have endeavored to reconcile these reckonings.
见安娜·科穆宁娜(《阿莱克修斯传》第一卷第37页);她的记述与船只的数目及载运量相吻合。《诺曼简明编年史》则称 Ivit in Dyrrachium cum xv. millibus hominum(“他率一万五千人开赴迪拉基乌姆”,即都拉佐)(Muratori, Scriptores, tom. v. p. 278.)。我已尽力把这几种算法调和一致。
65
The Itinerary of Jerusalem (p. 609, edit. Wesseling) gives a true and reasonable space of a thousand stadia or one hundred miles which is strangely doubled by Strabo (l. vi. p. 433) and Pliny, (Hist. Natur. iii. 16.)
《耶路撒冷行程记》(p. 609,韦塞林校订本)给出的距离真实而合理,为一千斯塔迪亚、即一百英里;斯特拉波(第六卷第433页)与普林尼(《自然史》第三卷第16节)却离奇地把这一数字翻了一倍。
66
Pliny (Hist. Nat. iii. 6, 16) allows quinquaginta millia for this brevissimus cursus, and agrees with the real distance from Otranto to La Vallona, or Aulon, (D’Anville, Analyse de sa Carte des Cotes de la Grece, &c., p. 3-6.) Hermolaus Barbarus, who substitutes centum. (Harduin, Not. lxvi. in Plin. l. iii.,) might have been corrected by every Venetian pilot who had sailed out of the gulf.
普林尼(《自然史》第三卷第6、16节)为这段“最短航程”(brevissimus cursus)定为 quinquaginta millia(五万步,即五十英里),与奥特朗托到拉瓦罗纳(亦即奥隆)的实际距离相符(当维尔《希腊海岸地图分析》等,p. 3-6)。赫尔莫劳斯·巴尔巴鲁斯改作 centum(一百)(Harduin, Not. lxvi. in Plin. l. iii.),而但凡驶出过这海湾的威尼斯领航员,都能纠正他这一说法。
67
Infames scopulos Acroceraunia, Horat. carm. i. 3. The praecipitem Africum decertantem Aquilonibus, et rabiem Noti and the monstra natantia of the Adriatic, are somewhat enlarged; but Horace trembling for the life of Virgil, is an interesting moment in the history of poetry and friendship.
Infames scopulos Acroceraunia(“阿克罗克劳尼亚那声名狼藉的礁石”),语出贺拉斯《颂歌集》第一卷第3首。诗中那“与北风相搏的疾猛非洲风”(praecipitem Africum decertantem Aquilonibus)、“南风的狂暴”(et rabiem Noti)以及亚得里亚海中“泅游的巨怪”(monstra natantia),未免有些夸大;不过贺拉斯为维吉尔的性命而战栗,在诗歌史与友谊史上都堪称一个动人的瞬间。
68
(Alexias, l. iv. p. 106.) Yet the Normans shaved, and the Venetians wore, their beards: they must have derided the no beard of Bohemond; a harsh interpretation. (Duncanga ad Alexiad. p. 283.)
(《阿莱克修斯传》第四卷第106页。)然而诺曼人剃须,威尼斯人蓄须:他们想必曾嘲笑博希蒙德不长胡子——这是一种苛刻的解读(Duncanga ad Alexiad. p. 283)。
69
Muratori (Annali d’ Italia, tom. ix. p. 136, 137) observes, that some authors (Petrus Diacon. Chron. Casinen. l. iii. c. 49) compose the Greek army of 170,000 men, but that the hundred may be struck off, and that Malaterra reckons only 70,000; a slight inattention. The passage to which he alludes is in the Chronicle of Lupus Protospata, (Script. Ital. tom. v. p. 45.) Malaterra (l. iv. c. 27) speaks in high, but indefinite terms of the emperor, cum copiisinnumerabilbus: like the Apulian poet, (l. iv. p. 272:) —More locustarum montes et pianna teguntur.
穆拉托里(《意大利编年史》第九卷第136、137页)指出:有些作者(Petrus Diacon. Chron. Casinen. l. iii. c. 49)把希腊军队算作十七万人,但那多出的“十万”大可勾去,而马拉泰拉只算作七万——这只是一处小小的疏忽。他所影射的那段文字,见于卢普斯·普罗托斯帕塔的编年史(Script. Ital. tom. v. p. 45)。马拉泰拉(第四卷第27章)以夸张而含糊的口吻谈及皇帝,说他 cum copiis innumerabilibus(“率领着不计其数的大军”);这与阿普利亚诗人(第四卷第272页)如出一辙—More locustarum montes et plana teguntur(“群山与平原尽为蝗群般的大军所覆盖”)。
70
See William of Malmsbury, de Gestis Anglorum, l. ii. p. 92. Alexius fidem Anglorum suspiciens praecipuis familiaritatibus suis eos applicabat, amorem eorum filio transcribens. Odericus Vitalis (Hist. Eccles. l. iv. p. 508, l. vii. p. 641) relates their emigration from England, and their service in Greece.
参看马姆斯伯里的威廉《英吉利人事迹》第二卷第92页。Alexius fidem Anglorum suspiciens praecipuis familiaritatibus suis eos applicabat, amorem eorum filio transcribens(大意:阿历克塞看重英格兰人的忠诚,把他们收为亲近心腹,并将对他们的这份宠信一并传给了儿子)。奥德里克·维塔利斯(《教会史》第四卷第508页、第七卷第641页)记述了他们从英格兰的迁出,以及在希腊的效力。
71
See the Apulian, (l. i. p. 256.) The character and the story of these Manichaeans has been the subject of the livth chapter.
参看阿普利亚诗人(第一卷第256页)。这些摩尼教徒的品性与来历,已在第五十四章中详述。
72
See the simple and masterly narrative of Caesar himself, (Comment. de Bell. Civil. iii. 41-75.) It is a pity that Quintus Icilius (M. Guichard) did not live to analyze these operations, as he has done the campaigns of Africa and Spain.
参看恺撒本人那朴实而精湛的叙述(《内战记》第三卷第41-75节)。可惜昆图斯·伊基利乌斯(即吉夏尔先生)未能活着分析这些军事行动,一如他分析过非洲与西班牙的历次战役那样。
73
It is very properly translated by the President Cousin, (Hist. de Constantinople, tom. iv. p. 131, in 12mo.,) qui combattoit comme une Pallas, quoiqu’elle ne fut pas aussi savante que celle d’Athenes. The Grecian goddess was composed of two discordant characters, of Neith, the workwoman of Sais in Egypt, and of a virgin Amazon of the Tritonian lake in Libya, (Banier, Mythologie, tom. iv. p. 1-31, in 12mo.)
库赞院长的译文十分贴切(《君士坦丁堡史》第四卷第131页,12开本):qui combattoit comme une Pallas, quoiqu’elle ne fut pas aussi savante que celle d’Athenes(“她像帕拉斯一般作战,尽管不及雅典那位女神博学”)。这位希腊女神本由两种彼此扞格的形象糅合而成:一是埃及塞易斯城的女工匠奈特,二是利比亚特里托尼斯湖畔的一位处女亚马逊(Banier, Mythologie, tom. iv. p. 1-31,12开本)。
74
Anna Comnena (l. iv. p. 116) admires, with some degree of terror, her masculine virtues. They were more familiar to the Latins and though the Apulian (l. iv. p. 273) mentions her presence and her wound, he represents her as far less intrepid. Uxor in hoc bello Roberti forte sagitta
Quadam laesa fuit: quo vulnere territa nullam.
Dum sperabat opem, se poene subegerat hosti.
The last is an unlucky word for a female prisoner.
安娜·科穆宁娜(第四卷第116页)带着几分惊惧,钦佩她那男子般的品性。拉丁人对她则更为熟悉;不过阿普利亚诗人(第四卷第273页)虽提到她的在场与所受的箭伤,却把她写得远没有那般无所畏惧。Uxor in hoc bello Roberti forte sagitta(“罗伯特之妻在此役中偶为一箭所伤……”)
Quadam laesa fuit: quo vulnere territa nullam. Dum sperabat opem, se poene subegerat hosti.(大意:她中箭负伤;为那创伤所骇,正当自忖再无救援时,几乎向敌人俯首屈服。)末尾这个词(“屈服于敌”)用在一名女俘身上,实在是不吉之语。
75
(Anna, l. v. p. 133;) and elsewhere, (p. 140.) The pedantry of the princess in the choice of classic appellations encouraged Ducange to apply to his countrymen the characters of the ancient Gauls.
(安娜,第五卷第133页;另见第140页。)这位公主在选用古典称谓上的迂腐炫学,促使杜康热把古高卢人的性格套用到自己的同胞身上。
76
Lupus Protospata (tom. iii. p. 45) says 6000: William the Apulian more than 5000, (l. iv. p. 273.) Their modesty is singular and laudable: they might with so little trouble have slain two or three myriads of schismatics and infidels!
卢普斯·普罗托斯帕塔(第三卷第45页)记作六千,阿普利亚的威廉(第四卷第273页)则记为五千余。他们的克制实在难得而可嘉:本来他们大可不费吹灰之力,就宰掉两三万名分裂派与异教徒呢!
77
The Romans had changed the inauspicious name of Epidamnus to Dyrrachium, (Plin. iii. 26;) and the vulgar corruption of Duracium (see Malaterra) bore some affinity to hardness. One of Robert’s names was Durand, a durando: poor wit! (Alberic. Monach. in Chron. apud Muratori, Annali d’Italia, tom. ix. p. 137.)
罗马人曾把“埃皮丹努斯”这个不吉的名字改成了“迪拉基乌姆”(Plin. iii. 26);而民间讹传的“杜拉基乌姆”(Duracium,见马拉泰拉)一名,则与“坚硬”(hardness)略有牵连。罗伯特的名号之一是“杜兰德”(Durand),据说取自 durando(“坚忍持久”):真是拙劣的俏皮话!(Alberic. Monach. in Chron. apud Muratori, Annali d’Italia, tom. ix. p. 137.)
78
(Anna, l. i. p. 35.) By these similes, so different from those of Homer she wishes to inspire contempt as well as horror for the little noxious animal, a conqueror. Most unfortunately, the common sense, or common nonsense, of mankind, resists her laudable design.
(安娜,第一卷第35页。)她用这些与荷马笔下截然不同的比喻,意在让人对征服者这“为害的小动物”既生鄙夷、又怀恐惧。可惜得很,人类的常识——或者说通常的胡涂——偏偏抵消了她这番用心良苦的意图。
79
Prodiit hac auctor Trojanae cladis Achilles. The supposition of the Apulian (l. v. p. 275) may be excused by the more classic poetry of Virgil, (Aeneid. ii. 197,) Larissaeus Achilles, but it is not justified by the geography of Homer.
Prodiit hac auctor Trojanae cladis Achilles(“特洛伊之祸的祸首阿喀琉斯便出自此地”)。阿普利亚诗人(第五卷第275页)的这一臆断,或可借维吉尔更为古典的诗句(《埃涅阿斯纪》第二卷第197行)中的 Larissaeus Achilles(“拉里萨的阿喀琉斯”)来开脱,却得不到荷马地理记载的支持。
80
The items which encumbered the knights on foot, have been ignorantly translated spurs, (Anna Comnena, Alexias, l. v. p. 140.) Ducange has explained the true sense by a ridiculous and inconvenient fashion, which lasted from the xith to the xvth century. These peaks, in the form of a scorpion, were sometimes two feet and fastened to the knee with a silver chain.
那些累赘、妨碍徒步骑士行动的物件,被人无知地译成了“马刺”(安娜·科穆宁娜,《阿莱克修斯传》第五卷第140页)。杜康热则以一种从十一世纪一直流行到十五世纪的可笑而不便的时尚风气,道破了其真正含义:这些形似蝎尾的尖头(鞋尖),有时长达两英尺,还用一条银链系在膝上。