Chapter LII: More Conquests By The Arabs.—Part V. 第五十二章 阿拉伯人的进一步征服——第五节
¶
The third and most obvious cause was the weight and magnitude of the empire itself. The caliph Almamon might proudly assert, that it was easier for him to rule the East and the West, than to manage a chess-board of two feet square: 102 yet I suspect that in both those games he was guilty of many fatal mistakes; and I perceive, that in the distant provinces the authority of the first and most powerful of the Abbassides was already impaired. The analogy of despotism invests the representative with the full majesty of the prince; the division and balance of powers might relax the habits of obedience, might encourage the passive subject to inquire into the origin and administration of civil government. He who is born in the purple is seldom worthy to reign; but the elevation of a private man, of a peasant, perhaps, or a slave, affords a strong presumption of his courage and capacity. The viceroy of a remote kingdom aspires to secure the property and inheritance of his precarious trust; the nations must rejoice in the presence of their sovereign; and the command of armies and treasures are at once the object and the instrument of his ambition. A change was scarcely visible as long as the lieutenants of the caliph were content with their vicarious title; while they solicited for themselves or their sons a renewal of the Imperial grant, and still maintained on the coin and in the public prayers the name and prerogative of the commander of the faithful. But in the long and hereditary exercise of power, they assumed the pride and attributes of royalty; the alternative of peace or war, of reward or punishment, depended solely on their will; and the revenues of their government were reserved for local services or private magnificence. Instead of a regular supply of men and money, the successors of the prophet were flattered with the ostentatious gift of an elephant, or a cast of hawks, a suit of silk hangings, or some pounds of musk and amber. 103
第三个、也是最显而易见的原因,便是帝国本身的分量与规模。哈里发马蒙曾不无得意地宣称,治理东西方两大天下,反倒比摆弄一副两英尺见方的棋盘更为省心;102 然而我却怀疑,在这两盘棋局里,他都犯下了不少致命的失误;而且我看得出,在遥远的各行省,这位阿拔斯王朝最早、也最强大的君主,其权威其实早已受损。依照专制政体的通例,代行君权者往往一身尽揽君主的全部威严;而权力一旦分割、相互制衡,服从的习性便可能随之松弛,甚至怂恿本来逆来顺受的臣民去追问:民政究竟从何而来,又如何运作。生于帝王紫室之人,鲜少配得上君临天下;而一介平民——或许本是农夫,或许本是奴隶——竟能飞黄腾达,这本身就有力地印证了他的胆识与才干。一位远方王国的总督,总想把自己那朝不保夕的受命之职,变作可以世代承袭的产业;各族百姓自会因君主近在眼前而欢欣;而对军队与府库的掌控,既是他野心的目标,也是实现野心的工具。只要哈里发的这些代镇之臣还安于其代行的名号,变化便几乎无从察觉;只要他们还为自己或子嗣去请求续颁帝国的敕封,还在钱币上、在公众礼拜的祷词中,保留着信士统帅的名号与特权,一切便如常。然而权力既已长久世袭,他们便渐渐摆出王者的骄矜与做派;战与和的抉择、赏与罚的裁断,全凭一己之意;治下的赋税,也尽数留作本地之用,或供一己奢靡。先知的继承者们,非但收不到按例上缴的兵员与钱财,反倒只落得几样徒具排场的贡礼来敷衍:一头大象,一队猎鹰,一套丝绸帷幔,或是几磅麝香与龙涎香。103
¶
After the revolt of Spain from the temporal and spiritual supremacy of the Abbassides, the first symptoms of disobedience broke forth in the province of Africa. Ibrahim, the son of Aglab, the lieutenant of the vigilant and rigid Harun, bequeathed to the dynasty of the Aglabites the inheritance of his name and power. The indolence or policy of the caliphs dissembled the injury and loss, and pursued only with poison the founder of the Edrisites, 104 who erected the kingdom and city of Fez on the shores of the Western ocean. 105 In the East, the first dynasty was that of the Taherites; 106 the posterity of the valiant Taher, who, in the civil wars of the sons of Harun, had served with too much zeal and success the cause of Almamon, the younger brother. He was sent into honorable exile, to command on the banks of the Oxus; and the independence of his successors, who reigned in Chorasan till the fourth generation, was palliated by their modest and respectful demeanor, the happiness of their subjects and the security of their frontier. They were supplanted by one of those adventures so frequent in the annals of the East, who left his trade of a brazier (from whence the name of Soffarides) for the profession of a robber. In a nocturnal visit to the treasure of the prince of Sistan, Jacob, the son of Leith, stumbled over a lump of salt, which he unwarily tasted with his tongue. Salt, among the Orientals, is the symbol of hospitality, and the pious robber immediately retired without spoil or damage. The discovery of this honorable behavior recommended Jacob to pardon and trust; he led an army at first for his benefactor, at last for himself, subdued Persia, and threatened the residence of the Abbassides. On his march towards Bagdad, the conqueror was arrested by a fever. He gave audience in bed to the ambassador of the caliph; and beside him on a table were exposed a naked cimeter, a crust of brown bread, and a bunch of onions. “If I die,” said he, “your master is delivered from his fears. If I live, this must determine between us. If I am vanquished, I can return without reluctance to the homely fare of my youth.” From the height where he stood, the descent would not have been so soft or harmless: a timely death secured his own repose and that of the caliph, who paid with the most lavish concessions the retreat of his brother Amrou to the palaces of Shiraz and Ispahan. The Abbassides were too feeble to contend, too proud to forgive: they invited the powerful dynasty of the Samanides, who passed the Oxus with ten thousand horse so poor, that their stirrups were of wood: so brave, that they vanquished the Soffarian army, eight times more numerous than their own. The captive Amrou was sent in chains, a grateful offering to the court of Bagdad; and as the victor was content with the inheritance of Transoxiana and Chorasan, the realms of Persia returned for a while to the allegiance of the caliphs. The provinces of Syria and Egypt were twice dismembered by their Turkish slaves of the race of Toulon and Ilkshid. 107 These Barbarians, in religion and manners the countrymen of Mahomet, emerged from the bloody factions of the palace to a provincial command and an independent throne: their names became famous and formidable in their time; but the founders of these two potent dynasties confessed, either in words or actions, the vanity of ambition. The first on his death-bed implored the mercy of God to a sinner, ignorant of the limits of his own power: the second, in the midst of four hundred thousand soldiers and eight thousand slaves, concealed from every human eye the chamber where he attempted to sleep. Their sons were educated in the vices of kings; and both Egypt and Syria were recovered and possessed by the Abbassides during an interval of thirty years. In the decline of their empire, Mesopotamia, with the important cities of Mosul and Aleppo, was occupied by the Arabian princes of the tribe of Hamadan. The poets of their court could repeat without a blush, that nature had formed their countenances for beauty, their tongues for eloquence, and their hands for liberality and valor: but the genuine tale of the elevation and reign of the Hamadanites exhibits a scene of treachery, murder, and parricide.
继西班牙脱离阿拔斯王朝的世俗与宗教双重统治之后,最早的悖逆征兆便在阿非利加行省显现。阿格拉布之子易卜拉欣,本是那位警觉而严苛的哈伦所委派的镇守之臣,却把自己的名号与权势当作遗产,传给了阿格拉布王朝。历代哈里发或因怠惰、或出于权谋,对这般损害与失土佯作不见,只暗中以毒药追杀伊德里斯王朝的奠基者;104 此人曾在西方大洋之滨建起非斯这座城市与王国。105 在东方,头一个自立的王朝是塔希尔王朝,106 即骁勇的塔希尔的后裔;当年哈伦诸子内战之际,塔希尔为幼弟马蒙一方效力,未免过于卖力,又过于成功。于是他被体面地放逐,去镇守阿姆河畔;其后裔在呼罗珊一直统治到第四代,而他们那份独立的姿态,因举止谦恭、治下百姓安乐、边陲稳固,才显得不那么刺眼。取而代之的,是东方史册上屡见不鲜的那类冒险家:此人本以铜匠为业(萨法尔王朝之名即由此而来),后来弃业为盗。一天夜里,莱斯之子雅库布潜入锡斯坦君主的宝库,脚下绊到一块盐块,竟不经意地用舌尖尝了一口。在东方人心目中,盐乃待客之谊的象征,于是这位虔敬的盗贼当即抽身退去,既未取走一物,也未损毁分毫。这一义举日后被人发觉,反倒为雅库布赢得了宽恕与信任;他起初为恩主统兵,最终则为自己而战,征服了波斯,进而威胁到阿拔斯王朝的都城。就在向巴格达进军途中,这位征服者被一场热病所困。他卧于病榻,接见哈里发的使者;身旁的桌上,摆着一柄出鞘的弯刀、一块粗黑面包和一把洋葱。“我若死去,”他说,“你家主上便可去了心头之患;我若活着,眼前这几样东西就将决定你我之间的胜负;我若战败,也甘愿毫无怨言地回到少年时那粗茶淡饭的日子。”然而以他当时所处的高位,那一跌绝不会那般轻柔无伤:一场适时的病死,既保全了他自身的安宁,也保全了哈里发的安宁——后者以极其慷慨的让步为代价,才换得其弟阿慕尔退居设拉子与伊斯法罕的宫殿。阿拔斯王朝既太过孱弱、无力抗争,又太过骄矜、不肯宽宥,于是招来了势力雄厚的萨曼王朝。萨曼人率一万骑兵渡过阿姆河,穷得连马镫都是木头做的,却又勇猛得竟击溃了兵力八倍于己的萨法尔大军。阿慕尔被俘,戴着镣铐押往巴格达,成了献给朝廷的一份称心贡礼;而胜利者既满足于承袭河中地区与呼罗珊,波斯诸地便暂时重归哈里发麾下。叙利亚与埃及两行省,则曾两度被出身图伦、伊赫什德两系的突厥奴隶割据肢解。107 这些蛮族在宗教与习俗上已与穆罕默德同其族类;他们从宫廷的血腥党争中脱颖而出,先攫得一省的军权,进而登上独立的王座:他们的名字在当时既显赫又可畏;然而这两大强盛王朝的开创者,无论以言语还是以行动,都道出了野心之虚妄。前一位临终时祈求真主怜悯他这个罪人,坦言自己竟不知权力的边界何在;后一位虽有四十万士兵、八千奴隶环卫,却仍要对世人隐瞒自己就寝的居室所在。他们的子嗣自幼便沾染帝王的种种恶习;埃及与叙利亚遂在三十年间又被阿拔斯王朝收复并占据。及至阿拔斯帝国衰落,美索不达米亚连同摩苏尔、阿勒颇两座重镇,落入哈姆丹部族的阿拉伯君主之手。他们宫中的诗人可以毫不脸红地反复吟诵:造化生就了他们俊美的容颜、雄辩的口舌,以及既慷慨又勇武的双手;可是哈姆丹王朝崛起与统治的真实故事,展现的却是一幕幕背信、谋杀与弑亲的丑剧。
¶
At the same fatal period, the Persian kingdom was again usurped by the dynasty of the Bowides, by the sword of three brothers, who, under various names, were styled the support and columns of the state, and who, from the Caspian Sea to the ocean, would suffer no tyrants but themselves. Under their reign, the language and genius of Persia revived, and the Arabs, three hundred and four years after the death of Mahomet, were deprived of the sceptre of the East.
就在这一劫难当头的时期,波斯王国再度被布韦希王朝篡夺——凭的是三兄弟手中的刀剑;他们各有名号,皆被尊为国家的支柱与栋梁,从里海一直到大洋,除自己之外绝不容第二个暴君存在。在他们治下,波斯的语言与才智重又复兴;而在穆罕默德辞世三百零四年之后,阿拉伯人便丧失了对东方的权柄。
¶
Rahadi, the twentieth of the Abbassides, and the thirty-ninth of the successors of Mahomet, was the last who deserved the title of commander of the faithful; 108 the last (says Abulfeda) who spoke to the people, or conversed with the learned; the last who, in the expense of his household, represented the wealth and magnificence of the ancient caliphs. After him, the lords of the Eastern world were reduced to the most abject misery, and exposed to the blows and insults of a servile condition. The revolt of the provinces circumscribed their dominions within the walls of Bagdad: but that capital still contained an innumerable multitude, vain of their past fortune, discontented with their present state, and oppressed by the demands of a treasury which had formerly been replenished by the spoil and tribute of nations. Their idleness was exercised by faction and controversy. Under the mask of piety, the rigid followers of Hanbal 109 invaded the pleasures of domestic life, burst into the houses of plebeians and princes, the wine, broke the instruments, beat the musicians, and dishonored, with infamous suspicions, the associates of every handsome youth. In each profession, which allowed room for two persons, the one was a votary, the other an antagonist, of Ali; and the Abbassides were awakened by the clamorous grief of the sectaries, who denied their title, and cursed their progenitors. A turbulent people could only be repressed by a military force; but who could satisfy the avarice or assert the discipline of the mercenaries themselves? The African and the Turkish guards drew their swords against each other, and the chief commanders, the emirs al Omra, 110 imprisoned or deposed their sovereigns, and violated the sanctuary of the mosch and harem. If the caliphs escaped to the camp or court of any neighboring prince, their deliverance was a change of servitude, till they were prompted by despair to invite the Bowides, the sultans of Persia, who silenced the factions of Bagdad by their irresistible arms. The civil and military powers were assumed by Moezaldowlat, the second of the three brothers, and a stipend of sixty thousand pounds sterling was assigned by his generosity for the private expense of the commander of the faithful. But on the fortieth day, at the audience of the ambassadors of Chorasan, and in the presence of a trembling multitude, the caliph was dragged from his throne to a dungeon, by the command of the stranger, and the rude hands of his Dilamites. His palace was pillaged, his eyes were put out, and the mean ambition of the Abbassides aspired to the vacant station of danger and disgrace. In the school of adversity, the luxurious caliphs resumed the grave and abstemious virtues of the primitive times. Despoiled of their armor and silken robes, they fasted, they prayed, they studied the Koran and the tradition of the Sonnites: they performed, with zeal and knowledge, the functions of their ecclesiastical character. The respect of nations still waited on the successors of the apostle, the oracles of the law and conscience of the faithful; and the weakness or division of their tyrants sometimes restored the Abbassides to the sovereignty of Bagdad. But their misfortunes had been imbittered by the triumph of the Fatimites, the real or spurious progeny of Ali. Arising from the extremity of Africa, these successful rivals extinguished, in Egypt and Syria, both the spiritual and temporal authority of the Abbassides; and the monarch of the Nile insulted the humble pontiff on the banks of the Tigris.
拉迪是阿拔斯王朝的第二十位哈里发,也是穆罕默德的第三十九位继承者,他是最后一个无愧于“信士统帅”称号的人;108 据阿布尔费达说,他是最后一个向民众发表演说、与学者往来交谈的哈里发,也是最后一个在宫廷用度上仍能彰显古代哈里发那份富庶与豪奢的人。自他以后,这些东方世界的君主便沦落到最卑贱的悲惨境地,如同奴仆一般,任人殴打、任人凌辱。各行省相继叛离,把他们的疆土压缩到了巴格达城墙之内;然而这座都城仍聚居着数不清的民众:他们既为昔日的荣华自负,又对眼下的处境不满,还饱受国库征敛之苦——那国库从前本是靠各族的战利品与贡赋充盈起来的。他们闲极无聊,便以结党与论争来打发时日。罕百勒那些严苛的信徒 109 打着虔诚的幌子,侵扰起百姓的居家之乐来:他们闯入平民与显贵的宅邸,泼掉美酒,砸毁乐器,殴打乐师,还以种种不堪的猜疑,去羞辱每一个俊美少年身边的伴侣。凡是容得下两个人的行当,其中一人必是阿里的信徒,另一人则是阿里的死敌;各派信众吵嚷不休、悲愤填膺,既否认阿拔斯诸君的名位,又诅咒他们的先祖,闹得阿拔斯王朝寝食难安。如此骚动的民众,唯有靠武力才能弹压;可这些雇佣兵本身贪得无厌,又难以约束,谁又能填满他们的贪欲、整肃他们的军纪呢?阿非利加卫队与突厥卫队彼此拔刀相向;而那些位居统帅之首的大埃米尔(emir al Omra),110 更是任意囚禁或废黜自己的君主,肆意亵渎清真寺与后宫这两处圣地。哈里发即便逃到某个邻邦君主的营帐或朝廷,所谓获救也不过是换一个主子受奴役罢了;直到走投无路,他们才不得不去招引波斯的苏丹——布韦希王朝,后者遂以势不可挡的武力,压服了巴格达的各方党争。军政大权尽归三兄弟中的老二穆伊兹·道莱掌握;他慷慨地拨出六万英镑的年俸,充作信士统帅的私人用度。然而到了第四十天,正当哈里发接见呼罗珊使节、群臣战栗环立之际,那外来者一声令下,他麾下的代拉姆兵便伸出粗暴之手,把哈里发从御座上拖下,投入地牢。宫殿遭到洗劫,他本人被剜去双眼;而阿拔斯家族卑微的野心,竟仍争相觊觎这个既危险又屈辱的空位。在逆境这所学堂的磨砺下,这些一向奢靡的哈里发,重又拾起了早期先人那种庄重而克己的德行。铠甲与丝袍尽被剥去,他们便斋戒、祈祷,钻研《古兰经》与逊尼派的圣训;以满腔热忱和渊博学识,履行其宗教领袖的种种职分。各族对使者继承者的敬重依然不减——他们仍是律法的权威、众信士良心的所寄;而压制他们的强权一旦衰弱或分裂,有时又会使阿拔斯王朝重掌巴格达的主权。然而阿拔斯诸君的不幸,又因法蒂玛王朝的得势而更添苦涩——那是一支自称阿里后裔、真伪难辨的家族。这些得胜的对手从阿非利加极远之地崛起,在埃及与叙利亚一举扑灭了阿拔斯王朝的宗教权威与世俗权威;尼罗河畔的君主,公然羞辱底格里斯河畔那位卑微的教长。
¶
In the declining age of the caliphs, in the century which elapsed after the war of Theophilus and Motassem, the hostile transactions of the two nations were confined to some inroads by sea and land, the fruits of their close vicinity and indelible hatred. But when the Eastern world was convulsed and broken, the Greeks were roused from their lethargy by the hopes of conquest and revenge. The Byzantine empire, since the accession of the Basilian race, had reposed in peace and dignity; and they might encounter with their entire strength the front of some petty emir, whose rear was assaulted and threatened by his national foes of the Mahometan faith. The lofty titles of the morning star, and the death of the Saracens, 111 were applied in the public acclamations to Nicephorus Phocas, a prince as renowned in the camp, as he was unpopular in the city. In the subordinate station of great domestic, or general of the East, he reduced the Island of Crete, and extirpated the nest of pirates who had so long defied, with impunity, the majesty of the empire. 112 His military genius was displayed in the conduct and success of the enterprise, which had so often failed with loss and dishonor. The Saracens were confounded by the landing of his troops on safe and level bridges, which he cast from the vessels to the shore. Seven months were consumed in the siege of Candia; the despair of the native Cretans was stimulated by the frequent aid of their brethren of Africa and Spain; and after the massy wall and double ditch had been stormed by the Greeks a hopeless conflict was still maintained in the streets and houses of the city. 1121 The whole island was subdued in the capital, and a submissive people accepted, without resistance, the baptism of the conqueror. 113 Constantinople applauded the long-forgotten pomp of a triumph; but the Imperial diadem was the sole reward that could repay the services, or satisfy the ambition, of Nicephorus.
在哈里发衰微的年代,也就是塞奥菲鲁斯与穆塔西姆之战以后的整整一个世纪里,两国之间的敌对往来,仅限于海上与陆上的几次侵扰——这不过是两国比邻而居、积怨难消所结的果子罢了。然而当东方世界陷入剧烈动荡、支离破碎之际,征服与复仇的希望便把希腊人从麻木中唤醒。自巴西尔王朝登基以来,拜占庭帝国一直在太平与尊严中休养生息;如今他们可以倾全力,从正面迎击某个小埃米尔,而这埃米尔的背后,又正遭与他同为穆斯林的本族仇敌袭扰、威胁。“晨星”与“萨拉森人的死神” 111 这等高华的尊号,在公众的欢呼声中被冠于尼基弗鲁斯·福卡斯——这位君主在军营中声名赫赫,在都城里却不得人心。他在大将军(亦即东方主帅)这一从属职位上,攻取了克里特岛,铲除了那个长久以来一直肆无忌惮、蔑视帝国威严的海盗巢穴。112 此役从前屡屡以损兵折将、蒙受耻辱而告终,如今却在他的指挥下大获成功,尽显其军事天才。他从战船向岸边架起一道道平稳的浮桥,让部队循桥登陆,令萨拉森人措手不及。围攻坎迪亚耗去了七个月;克里特土著虽已陷入绝望,却因阿非利加与西班牙同胞的频频接济而斗志复燃;待希腊人强攻破了那厚重的城墙与双重壕沟之后,城中街巷与屋舍之间仍在进行一场毫无希望的鏖战。1121 首府一破,全岛随即平定;顺服的居民也毫不抵抗地接受了征服者施予的洗礼。113 君士坦丁堡为这久违的凯旋盛典而喝彩;然而唯有帝国的皇冠,才配得上尼基弗鲁斯的功勋,也才能填满他的野心。
¶
After the death of the younger Romanus, the fourth in lineal descent of the Basilian race, his widow Theophania successively married Nicephorus Phocas and his assassin John Zimisces, the two heroes of the age. They reigned as the guardians and colleagues of her infant sons; and the twelve years of their military command form the most splendid period of the Byzantine annals. The subjects and confederates, whom they led to war, appeared, at least in the eyes of an enemy, two hundred thousand strong; and of these about thirty thousand were armed with cuirasses: 114 a train of four thousand mules attended their march; and their evening camp was regularly fortified with an enclosure of iron spikes. A series of bloody and undecisive combats is nothing more than an anticipation of what would have been effected in a few years by the course of nature; but I shall briefly prosecute the conquests of the two emperors from the hills of Cappadocia to the desert of Bagdad. The sieges of Mopsuestia and Tarsus, in Cilicia, first exercised the skill and perseverance of their troops, on whom, at this moment, I shall not hesitate to bestow the name of Romans. In the double city of Mopsuestia, which is divided by the River Sarus, two hundred thousand Moslems were predestined to death or slavery, 115 a surprising degree of population, which must at least include the inhabitants of the dependent districts. They were surrounded and taken by assault; but Tarsus was reduced by the slow progress of famine; and no sooner had the Saracens yielded on honorable terms than they were mortified by the distant and unprofitable view of the naval succors of Egypt. They were dismissed with a safe-conduct to the confines of Syria: a part of the old Christians had quietly lived under their dominion; and the vacant habitations were replenished by a new colony. But the mosch was converted into a stable; the pulpit was delivered to the flames; many rich crosses of gold and gems, the spoils of Asiatic churches, were made a grateful offering to the piety or avarice of the emperor; and he transported the gates of Mopsuestia and Tarsus, which were fixed in the walls of Constantinople, an eternal monument of his victory. After they had forced and secured the narrow passes of Mount Amanus, the two Roman princes repeatedly carried their arms into the heart of Syria. Yet, instead of assaulting the walls of Antioch, the humanity or superstition of Nicephorus appeared to respect the ancient metropolis of the East: he contented himself with drawing round the city a line of circumvallation; left a stationary army; and instructed his lieutenant to expect, without impatience, the return of spring. But in the depth of winter, in a dark and rainy night, an adventurous subaltern, with three hundred soldiers, approached the rampart, applied his scaling-ladders, occupied two adjacent towers, stood firm against the pressure of multitudes, and bravely maintained his post till he was relieved by the tardy, though effectual, support of his reluctant chief. The first tumult of slaughter and rapine subsided; the reign of Caesar and of Christ was restored; and the efforts of a hundred thousand Saracens, of the armies of Syria and the fleets of Africa, were consumed without effect before the walls of Antioch. The royal city of Aleppo was subject to Seifeddowlat, of the dynasty of Hamadan, who clouded his past glory by the precipitate retreat which abandoned his kingdom and capital to the Roman invaders. In his stately palace, that stood without the walls of Aleppo, they joyfully seized a well-furnished magazine of arms, a stable of fourteen hundred mules, and three hundred bags of silver and gold. But the walls of the city withstood the strokes of their battering-rams: and the besiegers pitched their tents on the neighboring mountain of Jaushan. Their retreat exasperated the quarrel of the townsmen and mercenaries; the guard of the gates and ramparts was deserted; and while they furiously charged each other in the market-place, they were surprised and destroyed by the sword of a common enemy. The male sex was exterminated by the sword; ten thousand youths were led into captivity; the weight of the precious spoil exceeded the strength and number of the beasts of burden; the superfluous remainder was burnt; and, after a licentious possession of ten days, the Romans marched away from the naked and bleeding city. In their Syrian inroads they commanded the husbandmen to cultivate their lands, that they themselves, in the ensuing season, might reap the benefit; more than a hundred cities were reduced to obedience; and eighteen pulpits of the principal moschs were committed to the flames to expiate the sacrilege of the disciples of Mahomet. The classic names of Hierapolis, Apamea, and Emesa, revive for a moment in the list of conquest: the emperor Zimisces encamped in the paradise of Damascus, and accepted the ransom of a submissive people; and the torrent was only stopped by the impregnable fortress of Tripoli, on the sea-coast of Phoenicia. Since the days of Heraclius, the Euphrates, below the passage of Mount Taurus, had been impervious, and almost invisible, to the Greeks.
巴西尔王朝直系第四代君主小罗曼努斯死后,其遗孀塞奥法诺先后嫁给了当世两位英雄——尼基弗鲁斯·福卡斯,以及刺杀福卡斯的凶手约翰·齐米斯基斯。二人以幼主的监护人兼共治者身份执政;他们统军的这十二年,构成了拜占庭编年史上最辉煌的一段。他们率往战场的臣民与盟军,至少在敌人眼中多达二十万;其中约三万身披胸甲;114 随军有四千头骡子相伴而行;每到傍晚扎营,必以一圈铁蒺藜环护营地。一连串血腥而未见分晓的战斗,无非是提前实现了几年之内自然演变本会带来的结果;不过,我仍要简略追述这两位皇帝从卡帕多西亚山地一直打到巴格达荒漠的征服历程。对奇里乞亚境内摩普绥提亚与塔尔苏斯两城的围攻,最先考验了他们麾下将士的本领与韧性;此刻,我不妨径直称这些人为罗马人。摩普绥提亚是一座被萨鲁斯河一分为二的双子城,城中二十万穆斯林注定难逃一死,或沦为奴隶;115 如此惊人的人口,至少应把附属地区的居民也一并算入。此城被团团围住,终遭强攻而下;塔尔苏斯则因饥荒缓缓逼近而降;萨拉森人刚以体面的条件投降,就沮丧地远远望见埃及的海上援兵姗姗来迟,已然无济于事。守军获准在通行护照的保护下撤往叙利亚边境;从前本有一部分基督徒一直安分地生活在萨拉森人治下;腾空的居所,则由新迁来的移民填补。清真寺被改作马厩,讲坛付之一炬;许多镶金嵌宝的贵重十字架——都是从亚细亚各教堂掠来的战利品——被当作贡品,献给皇帝的虔诚,或者说是他的贪欲;他还把摩普绥提亚与塔尔苏斯的城门运走,嵌进君士坦丁堡的城墙,充作其胜利的永久丰碑。两位罗马君主强行夺取并扼守了阿马努斯山的狭隘关口之后,一再挥师深入叙利亚腹地。然而尼基弗鲁斯并未强攻安条克的城墙——不知是出于仁慈,还是出于迷信,他似乎对这座东方古都心存敬意:他只绕城修筑了一道封锁工事,留下一支驻军,并叮嘱副将耐心守候,不必焦躁,只待春回。不料就在隆冬时节的一个漆黑雨夜,一名胆大的下级军官率三百士兵摸近城墙,架起云梯,攻占了相邻的两座塔楼,顶住蜂拥而上的人潮,死守据点,直到那位本不情愿的主帅迟迟才发来援兵——援兵虽姗姗来迟,却终究奏了效。屠戮与劫掠的初番骚乱平息之后,恺撒与基督的统治重又确立;十万萨拉森人、叙利亚的各路大军与阿非利加的舰队,在安条克城下枉费气力,一无所获。王城阿勒颇当时臣属于哈姆丹王朝的赛福·道莱;他仓皇撤退,把自己的王国与都城拱手让给罗马入侵者,从而玷污了往昔的荣光。在阿勒颇城外那座巍峨的宫殿里,他们欣然缴获了一座军械充盈的武库、一处养着一千四百头骡子的马厩,以及三百袋金银。然而城墙经受住了撞城槌的轮番猛击;围攻者只得在邻近的焦善山上扎营。罗马军后撤上山,反倒激化了城中市民与雇佣兵之间的争斗;城门与城垛的守卫弃岗而去;正当双方在市集上厮杀正酣之际,却被那共同的敌人出其不意地一举歼灭。城中男子尽遭屠戮,一万名青年被掳为俘;珍贵的战利品堆积如山,驮兽无论力气还是数目都不敷承载,多余的部分只好付之一炬;罗马人纵情劫掠、占据此城十日之后,才从这座被洗劫一空、鲜血淋漓的城市扬长而去。在历次侵入叙利亚时,他们勒令农夫照旧耕作田地,好让自己在来年收获时坐享其成;一百多座城市被迫归顺;十八座主要清真寺的讲坛被付之一炬,以清偿穆罕默德门徒所犯的亵渎之罪。希拉波利斯、阿帕米亚、埃梅萨这些古典的名字,在征服的清单上一时又重现光彩:齐米斯基斯皇帝在大马士革那片乐园般的土地上扎营,接受了顺服民众缴纳的赎金;而这股洪流般的攻势,唯有腓尼基海岸上固若金汤的的黎波里要塞才得以遏止。自希拉克略在世的年代以来,托罗斯山口以下的幼发拉底河,对希腊人来说一直是无从逾越、几乎从未得见的。
¶
The river yielded a free passage to the victorious Zimisces; and the historian may imitate the speed with which he overran the once famous cities of Samosata, Edessa, Martyropolis, Amida, 116 and Nisibis, the ancient limit of the empire in the neighborhood of the Tigris. His ardor was quickened by the desire of grasping the virgin treasures of Ecbatana, 117 a well-known name, under which the Byzantine writer has concealed the capital of the Abbassides. The consternation of the fugitives had already diffused the terror of his name; but the fancied riches of Bagdad had already been dissipated by the avarice and prodigality of domestic tyrants. The prayers of the people, and the stern demands of the lieutenant of the Bowides, required the caliph to provide for the defence of the city. The helpless Mothi replied, that his arms, his revenues, and his provinces, had been torn from his hands, and that he was ready to abdicate a dignity which he was unable to support. The emir was inexorable; the furniture of the palace was sold; and the paltry price of forty thousand pieces of gold was instantly consumed in private luxury. But the apprehensions of Bagdad were relieved by the retreat of the Greeks: thirst and hunger guarded the desert of Mesopotamia; and the emperor, satiated with glory, and laden with Oriental spoils, returned to Constantinople, and displayed, in his triumph, the silk, the aromatics, and three hundred myriads of gold and silver. Yet the powers of the East had been bent, not broken, by this transient hurricane. After the departure of the Greeks, the fugitive princes returned to their capitals; the subjects disclaimed their involuntary oaths of allegiance; the Moslems again purified their temples, and overturned the idols of the saints and martyrs; the Nestorians and Jacobites preferred a Saracen to an orthodox master; and the numbers and spirit of the Melchites were inadequate to the support of the church and state.
如今这条河却任凭得胜的齐米斯基斯自由通行;史家或可效仿他那份神速,一笔带过他如何席卷萨莫萨塔、埃德萨、马蒂罗波利斯、阿米达 116 与尼西比斯这些昔日名城——尼西比斯正是底格里斯河一带帝国旧日的边界。对埃克巴塔纳那尚未被人染指之财宝的觊觎,更激起了他的热望;117 埃克巴塔纳虽是个尽人皆知的名字,那位拜占庭作家却借它来隐指阿拔斯王朝的都城。四散奔逃的人们惊惶失措,早已把他名字所带来的恐怖传扬开去;然而巴格达那想象中的财富,其实早被本地暴君们的贪婪与挥霍耗散殆尽。民众的祈求,加上布韦希王朝那位统帅的严厉勒令,都要求哈里发出资筹办守城之事。无能为力的穆提答道,他的军队、财赋与行省早已被人从手中夺走,如今这一尊位,他既已无力支撑,甘愿拱手让出。那埃米尔却毫不通融;宫中陈设尽数变卖,换来区区四万枚金币,转眼便被挥霍在私人的奢靡之中。所幸希腊人的撤退解除了巴格达的忧惧:饥与渴替美索不达米亚的沙漠把守着门户;而这位皇帝既已尽享荣耀,又满载东方的战利品,遂班师返回君士坦丁堡,在凯旋式上展示丝绸、香料,以及三百万金银。然而东方列强在这场转瞬即逝的飓风中,不过是被压弯,并未被摧折。希腊人一撤走,出逃的诸君主便纷纷返回都城;臣民们则一口否认那些被迫立下的效忠誓言;穆斯林重又净洗自己的圣殿,推倒圣徒与殉道者的偶像;聂斯脱利派与雅各派宁可要一个萨拉森主子,也不愿要一个正统教派的主子;而麦尔基派无论人数还是气势,都不足以支撑起教会与国家。
¶
Of these extensive conquests, Antioch, with the cities of Cilicia and the Isle of Cyprus, was alone restored, a permanent and useful accession to the Roman empire. 118
在这一系列广泛的征服之中,唯有安条克连同奇里乞亚诸城与塞浦路斯岛得以长久收复,成为罗马帝国一笔持久而有用的疆土。118
Notes 注释
102
↩
Hyde, Syntagma Dissertat. tom. ii. p. 57, in Hist. Shahiludii.
Hyde, Syntagma Dissertat. tom. ii. p. 57, in Hist. Shahiludii.
103
↩
The dynasties of the Arabian empire may be studied in the Annals of Elmacin, Abulpharagius, and Abulfeda, under the proper years, in the dictionary of D’Herbelot, under the proper names. The tables of M. de Guignes (Hist. des Huns, tom. i.) exhibit a general chronology of the East, interspersed with some historical anecdotes; but his attachment to national blood has sometimes confounded the order of time and place.
阿拉伯帝国的历代王朝,可查阅埃尔马金、阿布·法拉杰与阿布尔费达三家《编年史》的相应年份,以及埃尔布洛《东方文库》中相应的词条。德经的年表(Hist. des Huns, tom. i.)列出了东方的一份通用纪年,其间还穿插着若干史事逸闻;不过他对本族血统的偏爱,有时混淆了时间与地点的先后次序。
104
↩
The Aglabites and Edrisites are the professed subject of M. de Cardonne, (Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne sous la Domination des Arabes, tom. ii. p. 1-63.)
阿格拉布王朝与伊德里斯王朝,正是卡尔多纳专论的对象(Hist. de l’Afrique et de l’Espagne sous la Domination des Arabes, tom. ii. p. 1-63)。
105
↩
To escape the reproach of error, I must criticize the inaccuracies of M. de Guignes (tom. i. p. 359) concerning the Edrisites. 1. The dynasty and city of Fez could not be founded in the year of the Hegira 173, since the founder was a posthumous child of a descendant of Ali, who fled from Mecca in the year 168. 2. This founder, Edris, the son of Edris, instead of living to the improbable age of 120 years, A. H. 313, died A. H. 214, in the prime of manhood. 3. The dynasty ended A. H. 307, twenty-three years sooner than it is fixed by the historian of the Huns. See the accurate Annals of Abulfeda p. 158, 159, 185, 238.
为免被人指为讹误,我必须指出德经(tom. i. p. 359)在伊德里斯王朝一事上的种种失实。其一,非斯这个王朝及其都城不可能创建于希吉拉173年,因为其奠基者乃阿里某位后裔的遗腹子,而此人是在希吉拉168年从麦加出逃的。其二,这位奠基者伊德里斯(伊德里斯之子),并未如所传那样活到 120 岁(希吉拉313年)这般不合情理的高寿,而是于希吉拉214年壮年之际便已辞世。其三,该王朝终于希吉拉307年,比那位匈奴史家所定的年份早了二十三年。参见阿布尔费达那部精确的《编年史》,第158、159、185、238页。
106
↩
The dynasties of the Taherites and Soffarides, with the rise of that of the Samanines, are described in the original history and Latin version of Mirchond: yet the most interesting facts had already been drained by the diligence of M. D’Herbelot.
塔希尔王朝与萨法尔王朝的历代世系,连同萨曼王朝的兴起,在米尔洪德的原文史著及其拉丁译本中均有记载;不过其中最耐人寻味的史实,早已被埃尔布洛的勤勉搜罗殆尽。
107
↩
M. de Guignes (Hist. des Huns, tom. iii. p. 124-154) has exhausted the Toulunides and Ikshidites of Egypt, and thrown some light on the Carmathians and Hamadanites.
德经(Hist. des Huns, tom. iii. p. 124-154)已对埃及的图伦王朝与伊赫什德王朝作了详尽论述,并对卡尔马特派与哈姆丹王朝略有阐发。
108
↩
Hic est ultimus chalifah qui multum atque saepius pro concione peroraret.... Fuit etiam ultimus qui otium cum eruditis et facetis hominibus fallere hilariterque agere soleret. Ultimus tandem chalifarum cui sumtus, stipendia, reditus, et thesauri, culinae, caeteraque omnis aulica pompa priorum chalifarum ad instar comparata fuerint. Videbimus enim paullo post quam indignis et servilibius ludibriis exagitati, quam ad humilem fortunam altimumque contemptum abjecti fuerint hi quondam potentissimi totius terrarum Orientalium orbis domini. Abulfed. Annal. Moslem. p. 261. I have given this passage as the manner and tone of Abulfeda, but the cast of Latin eloquence belongs more properly to Reiske. The Arabian historian (p. 255, 257, 261-269, 283, &c.) has supplied me with the most interesting facts of this paragraph.
Hic est ultimus chalifah qui multum atque saepius pro concione peroraret.... Fuit etiam ultimus qui otium cum eruditis et facetis hominibus fallere hilariterque agere soleret. Ultimus tandem chalifarum cui sumtus, stipendia, reditus, et thesauri, culinae, caeteraque omnis aulica pompa priorum chalifarum ad instar comparata fuerint. Videbimus enim paullo post quam indignis et servilibius ludibriis exagitati, quam ad humilem fortunam altimumque contemptum abjecti fuerint hi quondam potentissimi totius terrarum Orientalium orbis domini. Abulfed. Annal. Moslem. p. 261.(大意:拉迪乃末一位常在集会上滔滔演说的哈里发,也是末一位惯以博学诙谐之士为伴、于闲暇中欢然度日的哈里发,更是末一位在用度、俸禄、收入、府库、膳食及一切宫廷排场上仍仿效前代哈里发的哈里发;我们不久便会看到,这些昔日东方世界最强大的君主,如何被卑劣而屈辱的戏弄所折磨,沦落到何等卑微的境地、遭受何等极端的鄙夷。)我照录这段文字,以传阿布尔费达的笔法与语气;不过这般拉丁文的雄辩色彩,其实更应归功于赖斯克。这位阿拉伯史家(p. 255, 257, 261-269, 283 等页)为本段提供了最耐人寻味的诸般史实。
109
↩
Their master, on a similar occasion, showed himself of a more indulgent and tolerating spirit. Ahmed Ebn Hanbal, the head of one of the four orthodox sects, was born at Bagdad A. H. 164, and died there A. H. 241. He fought and suffered in the dispute concerning the creation of the Koran.
他们的宗师在类似情形下,倒显出更为宽容、更能容人的胸怀。艾哈迈德·本·罕百勒是四大正统教派之一的领袖,希吉拉164年生于巴格达,希吉拉241年也卒于此地。他曾在关于《古兰经》是否受造的那场争论中奋力抗辩,并为此蒙难。
110
↩
The office of vizier was superseded by the emir al Omra, Imperator Imperatorum, a title first instituted by Radhi, and which merged at length in the Bowides and Seljukides: vectigalibus, et tributis, et curiis per omnes regiones praefecit, jussitque in omnibus suggestis nominis ejus in concionibus mentionem fieri, (Abulpharagius, Dynart. p 199.) It is likewise mentioned by Elmacin, (p. 254, 255.)
维齐尔一职被“大埃米尔”(emir al Omra,即 Imperator Imperatorum,众统帅之统帅)所取代;这一头衔由拉迪首创,最终为布韦希王朝与塞尔柱王朝所承袭:vectigalibus, et tributis, et curiis per omnes regiones praefecit, jussitque in omnibus suggestis nominis ejus in concionibus mentionem fieri(大意:他总揽各地的赋税、贡品与官署,并下令各处讲坛在集会宣讲时都要提及其名,Abulpharagius, Dynart. p 199)。埃尔马金亦提及此事(p. 254, 255)。
111
↩
Liutprand, whose choleric temper was imbittered by his uneasy situation, suggests the names of reproach and contempt more applicable to Nicephorus than the vain titles of the Greeks, Ecce venit stella matutina, surgit Eous, reverberat obtutu solis radios, pallida Saracenorum mors, Nicephorus.
柳特普兰德因处境窘迫,脾气愈发暴躁;他所献上的,是一串更配得上尼基弗鲁斯的辱骂与轻蔑之词,而非希腊人那些虚浮的尊号:Ecce venit stella matutina, surgit Eous, reverberat obtutu solis radios, pallida Saracenorum mors, Nicephorus.(大意:看哪,晨星升起,曙光东现,其光反射日辉——萨拉森人苍白的死神,尼基弗鲁斯来也。)
112
↩
Notwithstanding the insinuation of Zonaras, &c., (tom. ii. l. xvi. p. 197,) it is an undoubted fact, that Crete was completely and finally subdued by Nicephorus Phocas, (Pagi, Critica, tom. iii. p. 873-875. Meursius, Creta, l. iii. c. 7, tom. iii. p. 464, 465.)
尽管佐纳拉斯等人(tom. ii. l. xvi. p. 197)有所暗示,但克里特确系尼基弗鲁斯·福卡斯彻底而最终地征服,此乃无可置疑的事实(Pagi, Critica, tom. iii. p. 873-875. Meursius, Creta, l. iii. c. 7, tom. iii. p. 464, 465)。
1121
↩
The Acroases of Theodorus, de expugnatione Cretae, miserable iambics, relate the whole campaign. Whoever would fairly estimate the merit of the poetic deacon, may read the description of the slinging a jackass into the famishing city. The poet is in a transport at the wit of the general, and revels in the luxury of antithesis. Theodori Acroases, lib. iii. 172, in Niebuhr’s Byzant. Hist.—M.
狄奥多鲁斯的《宣讲集》(de expugnatione Cretae,《克里特陷落记》)以一堆拙劣的抑扬格诗句,叙述了整场战役。谁若想公允地评判这位诗人执事的才具,不妨读一读他描写把一头蠢驴抛掷进那座饥城的段落。诗人对将军的机智大为倾倒,尽情陶醉于对偶铺陈之乐。Theodori Acroases, lib. iii. 172,见尼布尔《拜占庭史》。—M
113
↩
A Greek Life of St. Nicon the Armenian was found in the Sforza library, and translated into Latin by the Jesuit Sirmond, for the use of Cardinal Baronius. This contemporary legend casts a ray of light on Crete and Peloponnesus in the 10th century. He found the newly-recovered island, foedis detestandae Agarenorum superstitionis vestigiis adhuc plenam ac refertam.... but the victorious missionary, perhaps with some carnal aid, ad baptismum omnes veraeque fidei disciplinam pepulit. Ecclesiis per totam insulam aedificatis, &c., (Annal. Eccles. A.D. 961.)
一部记述亚美尼亚人圣尼孔生平的希腊文传记,在斯福尔扎图书馆中被发现,由耶稣会士西尔蒙译成拉丁文,供巴罗尼乌斯枢机使用。这部同时代的圣徒传,为十世纪的克里特与伯罗奔尼撒投下了一线亮光。他发现这座刚刚收复的岛屿 foedis detestandae Agarenorum superstitionis vestigiis adhuc plenam ac refertam(仍到处充斥着阿加雷尼人可憎迷信的污秽遗迹)……但这位得胜的传教士,或许还借助了几分世俗武力,ad baptismum omnes veraeque fidei disciplinam pepulit(把所有人都驱入洗礼、纳入真信仰的规训之下)。Ecclesiis per totam insulam aedificatis(全岛遍建教堂),云云(Annal. Eccles. A.D. 961)。
114
↩
Elmacin, Hist. Saracen. p. 278, 279. Liutprand was disposed to depreciate the Greek power, yet he owns that Nicephorus led against Assyria an army of eighty thousand men.
Elmacin, Hist. Saracen. p. 278, 279。柳特普兰德虽有意贬低希腊的国力,却也承认尼基弗鲁斯曾率一支八万人的大军进攻亚述。
115
↩
Ducenta fere millia hominum numerabat urbs (Abulfeda, Annal. Moslem. p. 231) of Mopsuestia, or Masifa, Mampsysta, Mansista, Mamista, as it is corruptly, or perhaps more correctly, styled in the middle ages, (Wesseling, Itinerar. p. 580.) Yet I cannot credit this extreme populousness a few years after the testimony of the emperor Leo, (Tactica, c. xviii. in Meursii Oper. tom. vi. p. 817.)
Ducenta fere millia hominum numerabat urbs(该城约有二十万居民,Abulfeda, Annal. Moslem. p. 231),此即摩普绥提亚——中世纪时它又被讹称(或许反倒更为准确)为 Masifa、Mampsysta、Mansista、Mamista(Wesseling, Itinerar. p. 580)。不过,距利奥皇帝作证仅数年之后(Tactica, c. xviii. in Meursii Oper. tom. vi. p. 817),我实在难以相信此城会有如此稠密的人口。
116
↩
The text of Leo the deacon, in the corrupt names of Emeta and Myctarsim, reveals the cities of Amida and Martyropolis, (Mia farekin. See Abulfeda, Geograph. p. 245, vers. Reiske.) Of the former, Leo observes, urbus munita et illustris; of the latter, clara atque conspicua opibusque et pecore, reliquis ejus provinciis urbibus atque oppidis longe praestans.
执事利奥的文本,以 Emeta 与 Myctarsim 这两个讹误的名称,实指阿米达与马蒂罗波利斯两城(后者即 Mia farekin。参见 Abulfeda, Geograph. p. 245, vers. Reiske)。论前者,利奥称其为 urbus munita et illustris(一座设防坚固、声名显赫的城市);论后者,则称 clara atque conspicua opibusque et pecore, reliquis ejus provinciis urbibus atque oppidis longe praestans(其城光耀夺目,财富牲畜之丰远胜该省其余城镇)。
117
↩
Ut et Ecbatana pergeret Agarenorumque regiam everteret.... aiunt enim urbium quae usquam sunt ac toto orbe existunt felicissimam esse auroque ditissimam, (Leo Diacon. apud Pagium, tom. iv. p. 34.) This splendid description suits only with Bagdad, and cannot possibly apply either to Hamadan, the true Ecbatana, (D’Anville, Geog. Ancienne, tom. ii. p. 237,) or Tauris, which has been commonly mistaken for that city. The name of Ecbatana, in the same indefinite sense, is transferred by a more classic authority (Cicero pro Lego Manilia, c. 4) to the royal seat of Mithridates, king of Pontus.
Ut et Ecbatana pergeret Agarenorumque regiam everteret……(他要进军埃克巴塔纳,推翻阿加雷尼人的王庭)……aiunt enim urbium quae usquam sunt ac toto orbe existunt felicissimam esse auroque ditissimam(据说此城乃普天之下、举世所有城市中最为富庶、黄金最多者,Leo Diacon. apud Pagium, tom. iv. p. 34)。这般华美的描述只配得上巴格达,绝不可能指哈马丹——那才是真正的埃克巴塔纳(D’Anville, Geog. Ancienne, tom. ii. p. 237)——也不可能指大不里士,尽管后者常被误认作该城。埃克巴塔纳这一名称,在同样含混的意义上,还被一位更为古典的权威(Cicero pro Lego Manilia, c. 4)用来指称本都国王米特拉达梯的王都。
118
↩
See the Annals of Elmacin, Abulpharagius, and Abulfeda, from A. H. 351 to A. H. 361; and the reigns of Nicephorus Phocas and John Zimisces, in the Chronicles of Zonaras (tom. ii. l. xvi. p. 199—l. xvii. 215) and Cedrenus, (Compend. p. 649-684.) Their manifold defects are partly supplied by the Ms. history of Leo the deacon, which Pagi obtained from the Benedictines, and has inserted almost entire, in a Latin version, (Critica, tom. iii. p. 873, tom. iv. 37.) * Note: The whole original work of Leo the Deacon has been published by Hase, and is inserted in the new edition of the Byzantine historians. M Lassen has added to the Arabian authorities of this period some extracts from Kemaleddin’s account of the treaty for the surrender of Aleppo.—M.
参见埃尔马金、阿布·法拉杰与阿布尔费达的《编年史》,希吉拉351年至361年部分;以及佐纳拉斯《编年史》(tom. ii. l. xvi. p. 199—l. xvii. 215)与塞德雷努斯(Compend. p. 649-684)中关于尼基弗鲁斯·福卡斯与约翰·齐米斯基斯两朝的记述。这些著作的种种缺漏,部分可由执事利奥的史著手稿补足——帕吉从本笃会士处得到这份手稿,几乎全文以拉丁译本收入其著作之中(Critica, tom. iii. p. 873, tom. iv. 37)。* 补注:执事利奥的全部原作已由哈泽刊行,并收入拜占庭史家丛书的新版之中。拉森(M. Lassen)为这一时期的阿拉伯文献增补了若干摘录,取自卡玛尔丁关于阿勒颇献城和约的记述。—M