Chapter XLVI: Troubles In Persia.—Part I. 第四十六章 波斯的动乱——第一节
¶
Revolutions On Persia After The Death Of Chosroes On Nushirvan.—His Son Hormouz, A Tyrant, Is Deposed.—Usurpation Of Baharam.—Flight And Restoration Of Chosroes II.—His Gratitude To The Romans.—The Chagan Of The Avars.—Revolt Of The Army Against Maurice.—His Death.—Tyranny Of Phocas.—Elevation Of Heraclius.—The Persian War.—Chosroes Subdues Syria, Egypt, And Asia Minor.—Siege Of Constantinople By The Persians And Avars.—Persian Expeditions.—Victories And Triumph Of Heraclius.
库思老·努希尔万死后波斯的政局动荡——其子霍尔米兹德暴虐无道,遭到废黜——巴赫拉姆篡位——库思老二世出逃与复位——他对罗马人的感激——阿瓦尔人的可汗——军队反叛莫里斯——莫里斯之死——福卡斯的暴政——希拉克略登位——波斯战争——库思老征服叙利亚、埃及与小亚细亚——波斯人与阿瓦尔人围攻君士坦丁堡——波斯的远征——希拉克略的胜利与凯旋。
¶
The conflict of Rome and Persia was prolonged from the death of Craesus to the reign of Heraclius. An experience of seven hundred years might convince the rival nations of the impossibility of maintaining their conquests beyond the fatal limits of the Tigris and Euphrates. Yet the emulation of Trajan and Julian was awakened by the trophies of Alexander, and the sovereigns of Persia indulged the ambitious hope of restoring the empire of Cyrus. 1 Such extraordinary efforts of power and courage will always command the attention of posterity; but the events by which the fate of nations is not materially changed, leave a faint impression on the page of history, and the patience of the reader would be exhausted by the repetition of the same hostilities, undertaken without cause, prosecuted without glory, and terminated without effect. The arts of negotiation, unknown to the simple greatness of the senate and the Caesars, were assiduously cultivated by the Byzantine princes; and the memorials of their perpetual embassies 2 repeat, with the same uniform prolixity, the language of falsehood and declamation, the insolence of the Barbarians, and the servile temper of the tributary Greeks. Lamenting the barren superfluity of materials, I have studied to compress the narrative of these uninteresting transactions: but the just Nushirvan is still applauded as the model of Oriental kings, and the ambition of his grandson Chosroes prepared the revolution of the East, which was speedily accomplished by the arms and the religion of the successors of Mahomet.
罗马与波斯之间的争斗,自克拉苏之死一直延续到希拉克略在位之时。七百年的经历,本足以使这两个宿敌明白:要把征服所得守在底格里斯河与幼发拉底河这道致命的界线之外,是断无可能的。然而,亚历山大昔日的赫赫战功,仍激起图拉真与尤利安的争胜之心;波斯的历代君主,也始终怀着重建居鲁士帝国的野心。1 如此非凡的武力与勇气,后世自然会为之瞩目;但那些无关国运的战事,在史册上留下的痕迹本就浅淡;何况这类征伐兴师无名、鏖战无功、收场无果,一再重演,恐怕连读者的耐心也要消磨殆尽。昔日元老院与诸恺撒气象质朴而恢弘,本不谙纵横捭阖之术;拜占庭的君主们却对这套外交伎俩钻研不辍,他们频繁往来的使节所留下的记录,2 千篇一律、冗长乏味,无非是虚饰浮夸的辞令、蛮族的骄横,以及纳贡的希腊人那副卑躬屈膝的做派。史料虽多,却贫瘠无用,令人叹惋;故我力求简述这些乏味的交涉。然而公正的努希尔万,至今仍被奉为东方君主的典范;而他的孙子库思老,其勃勃野心则为东方的剧变埋下伏笔——这场剧变,终由穆罕默德的后继者,凭其刀剑与信仰迅速完成。
¶
In the useless altercations, that precede and justify the quarrels of princes, the Greeks and the Barbarians accused each other of violating the peace which had been concluded between the two empires about four years before the death of Justinian. The sovereign of Persia and India aspired to reduce under his obedience the province of Yemen or Arabia 3 Felix; the distant land of myrrh and frankincense, which had escaped, rather than opposed, the conquerors of the East. After the defeat of Abrahah under the walls of Mecca, the discord of his sons and brothers gave an easy entrance to the Persians: they chased the strangers of Abyssinia beyond the Red Sea; and a native prince of the ancient Homerites was restored to the throne as the vassal or viceroy of the great Nushirvan. 4 But the nephew of Justinian declared his resolution to avenge the injuries of his Christian ally the prince of Abyssinia, as they suggested a decent pretence to discontinue the annual tribute, which was poorly disguised by the name of pension. The churches of Persarmenia were oppressed by the intolerant spirit of the Magi; 411 they secretly invoked the protector of the Christians, and, after the pious murder of their satraps, the rebels were avowed and supported as the brethren and subjects of the Roman emperor. The complaints of Nushirvan were disregarded by the Byzantine court; Justin yielded to the importunities of the Turks, who offered an alliance against the common enemy; and the Persian monarchy was threatened at the same instant by the united forces of Europe, of Aethiopia, and of Scythia. At the age of fourscore the sovereign of the East would perhaps have chosen the peaceful enjoyment of his glory and greatness; but as soon as war became inevitable, he took the field with the alacrity of youth, whilst the aggressor trembled in the palace of Constantinople. Nushirvan, or Chosroes, conducted in person the siege of Dara; and although that important fortress had been left destitute of troops and magazines, the valor of the inhabitants resisted above five months the archers, the elephants, and the military engines of the Great King. In the mean while his general Adarman advanced from Babylon, traversed the desert, passed the Euphrates, insulted the suburbs of Antioch, reduced to ashes the city of Apamea, and laid the spoils of Syria at the feet of his master, whose perseverance in the midst of winter at length subverted the bulwark of the East. But these losses, which astonished the provinces and the court, produced a salutary effect in the repentance and abdication of the emperor Justin: a new spirit arose in the Byzantine councils; and a truce of three years was obtained by the prudence of Tiberius. That seasonable interval was employed in the preparations of war; and the voice of rumor proclaimed to the world, that from the distant countries of the Alps and the Rhine, from Scythia, Maesia, Pannonia, Illyricum, and Isauria, the strength of the Imperial cavalry was reenforced with one hundred and fifty thousand soldiers. Yet the king of Persia, without fear, or without faith, resolved to prevent the attack of the enemy; again passed the Euphrates, and dismissing the ambassadors of Tiberius, arrogantly commanded them to await his arrival at Caesarea, the metropolis of the Cappadocian provinces. The two armies encountered each other in the battle of Melitene: 412 the Barbarians, who darkened the air with a cloud of arrows, prolonged their line, and extended their wings across the plain; while the Romans, in deep and solid bodies, expected to prevail in closer action, by the weight of their swords and lances. A Scythian chief, who commanded their right wing, suddenly turned the flank of the enemy, attacked their rear-guard in the presence of Chosroes, penetrated to the midst of the camp, pillaged the royal tent, profaned the eternal fire, loaded a train of camels with the spoils of Asia, cut his way through the Persian host, and returned with songs of victory to his friends, who had consumed the day in single combats, or ineffectual skirmishes. The darkness of the night, and the separation of the Romans, afforded the Persian monarch an opportunity of revenge; and one of their camps was swept away by a rapid and impetuous assault. But the review of his loss, and the consciousness of his danger, determined Chosroes to a speedy retreat: he burnt, in his passage, the vacant town of Melitene; and, without consulting the safety of his troops, boldly swam the Euphrates on the back of an elephant. After this unsuccessful campaign, the want of magazines, and perhaps some inroad of the Turks, obliged him to disband or divide his forces; the Romans were left masters of the field, and their general Justinian, advancing to the relief of the Persarmenian rebels, erected his standard on the banks of the Araxes. The great Pompey had formerly halted within three days’ march of the Caspian: 5 that inland sea was explored, for the first time, by a hostile fleet, 6 and seventy thousand captives were transplanted from Hyrcania to the Isle of Cyprus. On the return of spring, Justinian descended into the fertile plains of Assyria; the flames of war approached the residence of Nushirvan; the indignant monarch sunk into the grave; and his last edict restrained his successors from exposing their person in battle against the Romans. 611 Yet the memory of this transient affront was lost in the glories of a long reign; and his formidable enemies, after indulging their dream of conquest, again solicited a short respite from the calamities of war. 7
君王们开战之前,总要有一番无谓的口舌之争,为争端寻个由头。此番希腊人与蛮族便互相指责,说对方破坏了两大帝国之间的和约——那和约缔结于查士丁尼去世前约四年。波斯与印度之主一心要将也门(即阿拉伯福地)纳入治下,3 这片盛产没药与乳香的遥远土地,与其说曾抗拒东方的征服者,不如说是侥幸避开了他们。阿布拉哈在麦加城下败北之后,其子嗣与兄弟之间纷争不断,波斯人遂得以轻易插足:他们把来自阿比西尼亚的外邦人逐过红海,扶植一位古希米亚尔王室的本地王子重登王位,充当伟大的努希尔万的附庸或藩臣。4 然而查士丁尼的外甥却声言,要为他的基督徒盟友、那位阿比西尼亚君主所受的欺凌复仇——因为这正好给了他一个体面的借口,去中止每年的进贡;那笔贡赋,勉强以“年金”之名加以遮掩。波斯亚美尼亚的各处教会,饱受麻葛褊狭偏执之苦;411 他们暗中求告基督徒的庇护者。及至他们“虔诚地”杀掉本地的总督之后,罗马皇帝便公开承认、扶持这些叛乱者,俨然视之为自己的兄弟与臣民。拜占庭朝廷对努希尔万的抗议置之不理;查士丁经不住突厥人的再三怂恿,接受了他们联手对付共同敌人的提议;于是波斯王朝一时之间,同时受到来自欧洲、埃塞俄比亚与斯基泰三方联军的威胁。这位东方之主已届八十高龄,本或愿安享其荣耀与尊荣;可一旦战事势不可免,他便如青年般奋然出征,反倒是挑起战端的一方,在君士坦丁堡的宫中瑟瑟发抖。努希尔万——又称库思老——亲自督师围攻达拉;那座要塞地位虽重,却既无守军也无粮秣储备;然而城中居民奋勇抵抗,硬是顶住了这位大王的弓箭手、战象与攻城器械,坚守了五个多月。与此同时,他麾下的大将阿达尔曼从巴比伦出发,穿越沙漠,渡过幼发拉底河,兵临安条克近郊肆意劫掠,将阿帕米亚城化为灰烬,把从叙利亚掳来的战利品堆在主君脚下;而这位主君隆冬之中锲而不舍,终于攻陷了这座东方的堡垒。这一连串损失震动了各行省与朝廷,却也带来一个有益的结果:查士丁皇帝幡然悔悟,退位让贤。拜占庭的议政厅中气象一新;提比略以其审慎,为帝国争得了三年的休战。这段来得及时的间隙,正好用来筹备战事;传言四起,向天下宣扬:帝国的骑兵已从阿尔卑斯山与莱茵河一带的远方,从斯基泰、默西亚、潘诺尼亚、伊利里库姆与伊苏里亚,增补了十五万之众。然而波斯王或是无所畏惧,或是不守信义,决意抢在敌军动手之前先发制人;他再度渡过幼发拉底河,打发走提比略的使节,还傲慢地命他们到卡帕多西亚诸省的首府凯撒里亚去恭候他的驾临。两军在梅利泰内一战相遇:412 蛮族万箭齐发,遮天蔽日,把阵线拉长,两翼铺展开去,横贯整片平原;罗马人则结成纵深严整的密集队形,指望凭刀剑长矛的分量,在近身肉搏中取胜。一位统领罗马右翼的斯基泰酋长,突然绕到敌军侧翼,当着库思老的面猛攻其后卫,直插营垒中央,洗劫王帐,亵渎了那不灭的圣火,用一队骆驼驮满从亚细亚掠得的珍宝,杀开一条血路穿过波斯大军,唱着凯歌返回己方;而他的同袍们,这一整天却都消磨在单打独斗或无谓的小规模冲突里。入夜的黑暗,加上罗马各部彼此散处,给了波斯王报复的机会:他以迅猛的突袭,一举荡平了罗马人的一座营垒。但清点损失、深知处境凶险之后,库思老还是决意迅速撤退:他在途中焚毁了已成空城的梅利泰内,也顾不上麾下将士的安危,径自伏在象背上,泅渡幼发拉底河而去。这一仗劳而无功。此后因粮秣匮乏,或许还有突厥人的入侵,他不得不遣散或分散兵力;战场遂为罗马人所掌控。他们的大将查士丁尼挥师前进,去接应波斯亚美尼亚的叛军,把军旗插上了阿拉克塞斯河畔。昔日威名赫赫的庞培,也曾进兵到离里海仅三日路程之处便就此止步;5 如今这片内海头一回有敌国舰队前来探航,6 并将七万名俘虏从许尔卡尼亚迁往塞浦路斯岛。翌年春回,查士丁尼挥军南下,进入亚述的沃野平原;战火逼近努希尔万的居所,这位悲愤交加的君主就此长眠;临终前他颁下最后一道敕令,禁止后继者亲身上阵与罗马人交锋。611 不过,这一时的挫辱,早已湮没在他漫长治世的荣光之中;而他那些可畏的敌人,在做了一场征服的美梦之后,又转而恳求,暂时从战祸中得一喘息。7
¶
The throne of Chosroes Nushirvan was filled by Hormouz, or Hormisdas, the eldest or the most favored of his sons. With the kingdoms of Persia and India, he inherited the reputation and example of his father, the service, in every rank, of his wise and valiant officers, and a general system of administration, harmonized by time and political wisdom to promote the happiness of the prince and people. But the royal youth enjoyed a still more valuable blessing, the friendship of a sage who had presided over his education, and who always preferred the honor to the interest of his pupil, his interest to his inclination. In a dispute with the Greek and Indian philosophers, Buzurg 8 had once maintained, that the most grievous misfortune of life is old age without the remembrance of virtue; and our candor will presume that the same principle compelled him, during three years, to direct the councils of the Persian empire. His zeal was rewarded by the gratitude and docility of Hormouz, who acknowledged himself more indebted to his preceptor than to his parent: but when age and labor had impaired the strength, and perhaps the faculties, of this prudent counsellor, he retired from court, and abandoned the youthful monarch to his own passions and those of his favorites. By the fatal vicissitude of human affairs, the same scenes were renewed at Ctesiphon, which had been exhibited at Rome after the death of Marcus Antoninus. The ministers of flattery and corruption, who had been banished by his father, were recalled and cherished by the son; the disgrace and exile of the friends of Nushirvan established their tyranny; and virtue was driven by degrees from the mind of Hormouz, from his palace, and from the government of the state. The faithful agents, the eyes and ears of the king, informed him of the progress of disorder, that the provincial governors flew to their prey with the fierceness of lions and eagles, and that their rapine and injustice would teach the most loyal of his subjects to abhor the name and authority of their sovereign. The sincerity of this advice was punished with death; the murmurs of the cities were despised, their tumults were quelled by military execution: the intermediate powers between the throne and the people were abolished; and the childish vanity of Hormouz, who affected the daily use of the tiara, was fond of declaring, that he alone would be the judge as well as the master of his kingdom.
库思老·努希尔万的王座,由霍尔米兹德(又作霍尔米斯达斯)继承——他是努希尔万诸子中最年长、或者说最受宠爱的一个。他所承继的,不止波斯与印度两大王国,还有父亲的威名与表率、各级贤能勇武之臣的效力,以及一整套行政体制——这套体制经岁月与政治智慧的调和,本为增进君民双方的福祉而设。但这位年轻的君主还享有一件更为宝贵的福分:一位贤者的情谊。此人曾主持他的教育,凡事总把学生的荣誉置于其利益之上,又把学生的利益置于其一时的喜好之上。在一场与希腊和印度哲人的辩论中,布祖尔格8曾断言:人生最深重的不幸,莫过于年届暮年却无德行可供追忆;出于厚道,我们不妨假定,正是这一信念,促使他在长达三年的时间里主掌波斯帝国的朝政。霍尔米兹德以感激与顺从回报他的一片热忱,还自认为受师傅的恩惠更甚于受父母的恩惠;但当年岁与操劳损及这位睿智谋臣的体力、或许还有心智之时,他便退出朝廷,任由这年轻的君主听凭自己的情欲与宠臣的摆布。人事变迁,其势常令人扼腕;当年马可·奥勒留死后在罗马上演的那一幕,如今又在泰西封重演。那些阿谀逢迎、贪赃枉法之徒,本为父亲所逐,如今却被儿子召回、重加宠信;努希尔万旧友的失势与放逐,成全了这帮人的专横跋扈;德行遂一步步被逐出霍尔米兹德的心灵、他的宫廷,乃至整个国政。那些充当国王耳目的忠实臣属禀报他说:乱象正日益蔓延,各省长官如狮鹰扑食般凶猛地攫取民脂民膏,其巧取豪夺与横行不法,终将使他最忠顺的臣民也憎恶起君主的名号与权威。这番忠言换来的,却是杀身之祸;他对各城的怨言不屑一顾,一有骚动便以军队处决弹压;王座与百姓之间那些居间缓冲的权力,尽遭裁撤;霍尔米兹德虚荣得像个孩子,惯常终日戴着王冠招摇,还动辄宣称:在自己的王国里,唯有他一人既是主宰,也是裁断者。
¶
In every word, and in every action, the son of Nushirvan degenerated from the virtues of his father. His avarice defrauded the troops; his jealous caprice degraded the satraps; the palace, the tribunals, the waters of the Tigris, were stained with the blood of the innocent, and the tyrant exulted in the sufferings and execution of thirteen thousand victims. As the excuse of his cruelty, he sometimes condescended to observe, that the fears of the Persians would be productive of hatred, and that their hatred must terminate in rebellion but he forgot that his own guilt and folly had inspired the sentiments which he deplored, and prepared the event which he so justly apprehended. Exasperated by long and hopeless oppression, the provinces of Babylon, Susa, and Carmania, erected the standard of revolt; and the princes of Arabia, India, and Scythia, refused the customary tribute to the unworthy successor of Nushirvan. The arms of the Romans, in slow sieges and frequent inroads, afflicted the frontiers of Mesopotamia and Assyria: one of their generals professed himself the disciple of Scipio; and the soldiers were animated by a miraculous image of Christ, whose mild aspect should never have been displayed in the front of battle. 9 At the same time, the eastern provinces of Persia were invaded by the great khan, who passed the Oxus at the head of three or four hundred thousand Turks. The imprudent Hormouz accepted their perfidious and formidable aid; the cities of Khorassan or Bactriana were commanded to open their gates; the march of the Barbarians towards the mountains of Hyrcania revealed the correspondence of the Turkish and Roman arms; and their union must have subverted the throne of the house of Sassan.
无论一言一行,努希尔万这个儿子都背离了父亲的德行,一步步堕落下去。他贪婪成性,克扣军饷;猜忌无常,随意贬黜众总督;宫廷、法庭乃至底格里斯河水,无不染满无辜者的鲜血,而这暴君竟以一万三千名受害者的苦难与处决为乐。为自己的残暴辩解时,他有时也肯屈尊议论说:波斯人的畏惧终将滋生仇恨,而仇恨必以叛乱收场;却忘了正是他自己的罪愆与愚行,激起了他所哀叹的那种情绪,也铺就了他料想得分毫不差的那桩结局。巴比伦、苏萨与卡尔马尼亚等行省,在长期而无望的压迫下忍无可忍,终于举起了反旗;阿拉伯、印度与斯基泰的诸侯,也拒绝向努希尔万这个不肖的继任者缴纳惯常的贡赋。罗马人的兵锋以迟缓的围城与频繁的侵袭,不断骚扰美索不达米亚与亚述的边境:其麾下一员大将自称是西庇阿的门徒,士兵们则因一幅显灵的基督圣像而斗志高昂——然而那副温和的面容,本就不该抬到阵前去示众。9 与此同时,波斯东部各省又遭大可汗入侵,他率领三四十万突厥人渡过阿姆河。轻率的霍尔米兹德竟接受了这帮人既凶险又可畏的“相助”;呼罗珊(即巴克特里亚)诸城奉命大开城门;蛮族朝许尔卡尼亚山进军,暴露出突厥与罗马两军暗中勾连、彼此呼应;两下若真联起手来,萨珊王室的王座势必倾覆。
¶
Persia had been lost by a king; it was saved by a hero. After his revolt, Varanes or Bahram is stigmatized by the son of Hormouz as an ungrateful slave; the proud and ambiguous reproach of despotism, since he was truly descended from the ancient princes of Rei, 10 one of the seven families whose splendid, as well as substantial, prerogatives exalted them above the heads of the Persian nobility. 11 At the siege of Dara, the valor of Bahram was signalized under the eyes of Nushirvan, and both the father and son successively promoted him to the command of armies, the government of Media, and the superintendence of the palace. The popular prediction which marked him as the deliverer of Persia, might be inspired by his past victories and extraordinary figure: the epithet Giubin 1111 is expressive of the quality of dry wood: he had the strength and stature of a giant; and his savage countenance was fancifully compared to that of a wild cat. While the nation trembled, while Hormouz disguised his terror by the name of suspicion, and his servants concealed their disloyalty under the mask of fear, Bahram alone displayed his undaunted courage and apparent fidelity: and as soon as he found that no more than twelve thousand soldiers would follow him against the enemy; he prudently declared, that to this fatal number Heaven had reserved the honors of the triumph. 1112 The steep and narrow descent of the Pule Rudbar, 12 or Hyrcanian rock, is the only pass through which an army can penetrate into the territory of Rei and the plains of Media. From the commanding heights, a band of resolute men might overwhelm with stones and darts the myriads of the Turkish host: their emperor and his son were transpierced with arrows; and the fugitives were left, without counsel or provisions, to the revenge of an injured people. The patriotism of the Persian general was stimulated by his affection for the city of his forefathers: in the hour of victory, every peasant became a soldier, and every soldier a hero; and their ardor was kindled by the gorgeous spectacle of beds, and thrones, and tables of massy gold, the spoils of Asia, and the luxury of the hostile camp. A prince of a less malignant temper could not easily have forgiven his benefactor; and the secret hatred of Hormouz was envenomed by a malicious report, that Bahram had privately retained the most precious fruits of his Turkish victory. But the approach of a Roman army on the side of the Araxes compelled the implacable tyrant to smile and to applaud; and the toils of Bahram were rewarded with the permission of encountering a new enemy, by their skill and discipline more formidable than a Scythian multitude. Elated by his recent success, he despatched a herald with a bold defiance to the camp of the Romans, requesting them to fix a day of battle, and to choose whether they would pass the river themselves, or allow a free passage to the arms of the great king. The lieutenant of the emperor Maurice preferred the safer alternative; and this local circumstance, which would have enhanced the victory of the Persians, rendered their defeat more bloody and their escape more difficult. But the loss of his subjects, and the danger of his kingdom, were overbalanced in the mind of Hormouz by the disgrace of his personal enemy; and no sooner had Bahram collected and reviewed his forces, than he received from a royal messenger the insulting gift of a distaff, a spinning-wheel, and a complete suit of female apparel. Obedient to the will of his sovereign he showed himself to the soldiers in this unworthy disguise: they resented his ignominy and their own; a shout of rebellion ran through the ranks; and the general accepted their oath of fidelity and vows of revenge. A second messenger, who had been commanded to bring the rebel in chains, was trampled under the feet of an elephant, and manifestos were diligently circulated, exhorting the Persians to assert their freedom against an odious and contemptible tyrant. The defection was rapid and universal; his loyal slaves were sacrificed to the public fury; the troops deserted to the standard of Bahram; and the provinces again saluted the deliverer of his country.
波斯险些亡于一位国君之手,却得一位英雄相救。瓦拉内斯(即巴赫拉姆)起兵之后,被霍尔米兹德之子斥为忘恩负义的奴仆;这却是专制君权那种傲慢而含混的指摘——因为巴赫拉姆其实出自雷伊的古老王室,10 乃波斯七大世家之一的后裔;这七家所享的特权,既显赫又实在,令他们凌驾于波斯群贵之上。11 围攻达拉之役,巴赫拉姆的勇武在努希尔万眼前大放异彩;父子两代君主先后提拔他,让他统率大军、治理米底、执掌宫务。民间有预言说他将是波斯的拯救者,这或许出自他昔日的战功与非凡的相貌:“楚宾”这一绰号,1111 意指枯木一般的质地——他有巨人般的力气与身材,那张凶悍的脸,被人异想天开地比作野猫。举国战栗之际,霍尔米兹德以“猜疑”之名掩饰内心的恐惧,臣仆们则以“畏惧”为面具遮藏各自的异心;唯有巴赫拉姆一人,既显出无畏的勇气,又表现得忠心耿耿。及至他发现愿随他迎敌的不过一万二千人,便机敏地宣称:上天早已把凯旋的荣耀,留给了这个注定的数目。1112 普勒鲁德巴尔12——又称许尔卡尼亚岩——那道又陡又窄的坡口,是大军得以进入雷伊之境与米底平原的唯一通道。只要占据这居高临下的高地,一小队意志坚决的人,便能用滚石与投枪压倒突厥的千军万马:突厥的君主与其子皆被乱箭射穿,溃逃的残众既无人谋划、又断了粮草,只能任凭这个饱受欺凌的民族去报复。这位波斯将领对祖先故城的眷恋,更激起了他的报国之心:胜利在望之时,每个农夫都成了战士,每个战士都成了英雄;敌营中那奢华的景象——纯金的卧榻、宝座与几案,尽是从亚细亚掠来的战利品——更把他们的斗志熊熊点燃。纵是天性不那么狠毒的君主,也难以轻易饶恕自己的恩人;何况又有恶意的流言,说巴赫拉姆私自扣下了那场突厥大捷中最珍贵的战果,霍尔米兹德暗藏的恨意遂愈发歹毒。可是一支罗马军队正从阿拉克塞斯河一侧逼近,这不共戴天的暴君只得强作笑颜,佯加赞许;对巴赫拉姆的辛劳,他的赏赐便是准许他去迎击一个新敌——这敌人凭其武艺与纪律,比斯基泰的乌合之众更为可畏。新胜之余,他意气昂扬,遣一名传令官带着傲然的战书前往罗马营地,请对方定下交战之日,并任其抉择:是自行渡河过来,还是让大王的军队从容渡过。莫里斯皇帝的这位副将,选了较为稳妥的一途;这一地形上的因素,本可为波斯人的胜利添彩,如今却使他们败得更惨、逃得更难。然而在霍尔米兹德心里,臣民的伤亡、王国的危难,都抵不过私敌蒙羞来得快意;巴赫拉姆刚集结、检阅完部众,就收到一名王使送来的侮辱性“礼物”:一支纺纱杆、一架纺车,外加一整套女装。他遵从君主的旨意,竟以这般不堪的装束现身于将士之前:将士们既为他、也为自己蒙受的耻辱而愤慨,反叛的呼声传遍行伍,这位主将便接受了他们效忠的誓言与复仇的誓愿。第二名奉命把这“叛贼”锁拿归案的使者,被大象踏死;一份份檄文四处传布,力劝波斯人起来反抗这个可憎可鄙的暴君,争取自己的自由。倒戈之势迅疾而遍及全境;仍效忠于王的奴仆,成了民众怒火下的牺牲品;军队纷纷投奔巴赫拉姆的旗下;各行省再一次向这位祖国的拯救者欢呼致敬。
¶
As the passes were faithfully guarded, Hormouz could only compute the number of his enemies by the testimony of a guilty conscience, and the daily defection of those who, in the hour of his distress, avenged their wrongs, or forgot their obligations. He proudly displayed the ensigns of royalty; but the city and palace of Modain had already escaped from the hand of the tyrant. Among the victims of his cruelty, Bindoes, a Sassanian prince, had been cast into a dungeon; his fetters were broken by the zeal and courage of a brother; and he stood before the king at the head of those trusty guards, who had been chosen as the ministers of his confinement, and perhaps of his death. Alarmed by the hasty intrusion and bold reproaches of the captive, Hormouz looked round, but in vain, for advice or assistance; discovered that his strength consisted in the obedience of others; and patiently yielded to the single arm of Bindoes, who dragged him from the throne to the same dungeon in which he himself had been so lately confined. At the first tumult, Chosroes, the eldest of the sons of Hormouz, escaped from the city; he was persuaded to return by the pressing and friendly invitation of Bindoes, who promised to seat him on his father’s throne, and who expected to reign under the name of an inexperienced youth. In the just assurance, that his accomplices could neither forgive nor hope to be forgiven, and that every Persian might be trusted as the judge and enemy of the tyrant, he instituted a public trial without a precedent and without a copy in the annals of the East. The son of Nushirvan, who had requested to plead in his own defence, was introduced as a criminal into the full assembly of the nobles and satraps. 13 He was heard with decent attention as long as he expatiated on the advantages of order and obedience, the danger of innovation, and the inevitable discord of those who had encouraged each other to trample on their lawful and hereditary sovereign. By a pathetic appeal to their humanity, he extorted that pity which is seldom refused to the fallen fortunes of a king; and while they beheld the abject posture and squalid appearance of the prisoner, his tears, his chains, and the marks of ignominious stripes, it was impossible to forget how recently they had adored the divine splendor of his diadem and purple. But an angry murmur arose in the assembly as soon as he presumed to vindicate his conduct, and to applaud the victories of his reign. He defined the duties of a king, and the Persian nobles listened with a smile of contempt; they were fired with indignation when he dared to vilify the character of Chosroes; and by the indiscreet offer of resigning the sceptre to the second of his sons, he subscribed his own condemnation, and sacrificed the life of his own innocent favorite. The mangled bodies of the boy and his mother were exposed to the people; the eyes of Hormouz were pierced with a hot needle; and the punishment of the father was succeeded by the coronation of his eldest son. Chosroes had ascended the throne without guilt, and his piety strove to alleviate the misery of the abdicated monarch; from the dungeon he removed Hormouz to an apartment of the palace, supplied with liberality the consolations of sensual enjoyment, and patiently endured the furious sallies of his resentment and despair. He might despise the resentment of a blind and unpopular tyrant, but the tiara was trembling on his head, till he could subvert the power, or acquire the friendship, of the great Bahram, who sternly denied the justice of a revolution, in which himself and his soldiers, the true representatives of Persia, had never been consulted. The offer of a general amnesty, and of the second rank in his kingdom, was answered by an epistle from Bahram, friend of the gods, conqueror of men, and enemy of tyrants, the satrap of satraps, general of the Persian armies, and a prince adorned with the title of eleven virtues. 14 He commands Chosroes, the son of Hormouz, to shun the example and fate of his father, to confine the traitors who had been released from their chains, to deposit in some holy place the diadem which he had usurped, and to accept from his gracious benefactor the pardon of his faults and the government of a province. The rebel might not be proud, and the king most assuredly was not humble; but the one was conscious of his strength, the other was sensible of his weakness; and even the modest language of his reply still left room for treaty and reconciliation. Chosroes led into the field the slaves of the palace and the populace of the capital: they beheld with terror the banners of a veteran army; they were encompassed and surprised by the evolutions of the general; and the satraps who had deposed Hormouz, received the punishment of their revolt, or expiated their first treason by a second and more criminal act of disloyalty. The life and liberty of Chosroes were saved, but he was reduced to the necessity of imploring aid or refuge in some foreign land; and the implacable Bindoes, anxious to secure an unquestionable title, hastily returned to the palace, and ended, with a bowstring, the wretched existence of the son of Nushirvan. 15
既然各处隘口都有人忠实把守,霍尔米兹德也只能凭着一颗有愧的良心,以及那些人日复一日的倒戈——他们或趁他落难报复宿怨,或干脆忘却了对他的恩义——去揣度敌人的数目。他仍神气十足地摆出王家的仪仗,可马达因的城池与宫殿,早已脱出这暴君的掌握。萨珊王子宾多伊斯也曾是他残暴的受害者之一,被投入地牢;如今其弟凭一腔热忱与勇气砸开了他的镣铐,他便率领那些原被指派看管他、或许还要取他性命的亲信卫士,径直站到了国王面前。这囚徒贸然闯入、厉声斥责,霍尔米兹德大惊失色,环顾四周,想寻个主意或帮手,却是徒然;他这才发觉,自己的权力全系于旁人的服从,只得乖乖听凭宾多伊斯只手将他从王座拖下,投入那座不久前才关押过宾多伊斯本人的地牢。乱起之初,霍尔米兹德的长子库思老便逃出了城;后来经不住宾多伊斯恳切而友善的再三相邀,终于回转——宾多伊斯许诺扶他登上父亲的王座,实则打算借这乳臭未干的年轻人之名,自己号令天下。宾多伊斯心中有数:他那些同谋既不能宽恕别人,也别指望被人宽恕,而每个波斯人都可放心地视作这暴君的审判者与仇敌;于是他一手操办了一场审判——这在东方的史册上,既无前例,也无仿本。努希尔万之子曾请求当庭为自己申辩,此刻却被当作罪犯,押到贵族与众总督齐集的大会上。13 当他大谈秩序与服从的好处、革故鼎新的危险,以及那些互相怂恿、践踏合法世袭君主的人必然反目成仇之时,众人还算体面地静听。他又凄然诉诸他们的恻隐之心,硬是逼出了那份人们对失势之君鲜少吝惜的怜悯;望着这囚徒卑屈的姿态、褴褛的模样,望着他的眼泪、他的锁链、他身上那可耻的鞭痕,众人实在无法忘记:不久之前,他们还曾对他冠冕与紫袍所焕发的神圣光彩顶礼膜拜。可是他一旦竟敢为自己的所作所为辩白、并夸耀其治下的种种武功,会场上便腾起一片愤懑的低语。他给君王的职责下起定义,波斯贵族只报以轻蔑的冷笑;待他竟敢诋毁库思老的品性,众人更是怒不可遏;而他又冒失地提出愿把王杖让与次子,等于亲手签下了自己的判决书,也葬送了那个无辜爱子的性命。那男孩连同其母的残尸被示众;霍尔米兹德的双目被烧红的针刺瞎;对父亲的惩处过后,随之而来的便是长子的加冕。库思老登上王位并无罪愆,他还怀着一片孝心,力图减轻这位退位君主的痛苦:他把霍尔米兹德从地牢移到宫中一处居室,慷慨供给声色之娱以为慰藉,又耐着性子忍受他因怨恨与绝望而发的阵阵狂躁。一个又瞎又不得人心的暴君,纵然心怀怨恨,他也尽可置之不理,可他头上的王冠依旧摇摇欲坠,除非他能扳倒或结交伟大的巴赫拉姆——这位将领严词否认这场变革的正当性,声称他与麾下将士才是波斯真正的代表,而这场变革自始至终从未征询过他们的意见。库思老提出大赦天下、并许以王国中的次席,巴赫拉姆的答复却是一封书信,署名为:诸神之友、众人的征服者、暴君的仇敌、总督中的总督、波斯诸军的统帅、以“十一种美德”称号为饰的君主。14 他命令霍尔米兹德之子库思老:切莫重蹈其父的覆辙、招致同样的下场;把那些刚获释放的叛徒重新囚禁;将他僭据的冠冕交存于某处圣所;并从他这位仁厚恩主手中,领受对其过错的宽赦,以及一省的治权。叛臣或许算不得倨傲,国王却断然算不得谦卑;只是前者深知自身之强,后者也自觉其弱;而库思老回信措辞虽谦,仍给磋商与和解留了余地。库思老率宫中的奴仆与都城的市井之众出征:他们一望见那支百战之师的旗号便惊惶失措,又中了这位将领的巧妙调度,遭其包抄突袭;而那些废黜霍尔米兹德的总督,或为叛乱受罚,或以第二桩更为罪恶的背信之举,来抵偿他们头一回的叛逆。库思老虽保住了性命与自由,却也落到只能向异邦乞援求庇的地步;那不肯罢休的宾多伊斯,一心要谋一个无可争议的名分,便匆匆赶回宫中,用一根弓弦,结果了努希尔万之子那可悲的性命。15
¶
While Chosroes despatched the preparations of his retreat, he deliberated with his remaining friends, 16 whether he should lurk in the valleys of Mount Caucasus, or fly to the tents of the Turks, or solicit the protection of the emperor. The long emulation of the successors of Artaxerxes and Constantine increased his reluctance to appear as a suppliant in a rival court; but he weighed the forces of the Romans, and prudently considered that the neighborhood of Syria would render his escape more easy and their succors more effectual. Attended only by his concubines, and a troop of thirty guards, he secretly departed from the capital, followed the banks of the Euphrates, traversed the desert, and halted at the distance of ten miles from Circesium. About the third watch of the night, the Roman præfect was informed of his approach, and he introduced the royal stranger to the fortress at the dawn of day. From thence the king of Persia was conducted to the more honorable residence of Hierapolis; and Maurice dissembled his pride, and displayed his benevolence, at the reception of the letters and ambassadors of the grandson of Nushirvan. They humbly represented the vicissitudes of fortune and the common interest of princes, exaggerated the ingratitude of Bahram, the agent of the evil principle, and urged, with specious argument, that it was for the advantage of the Romans themselves to support the two monarchies which balance the world, the two great luminaries by whose salutary influence it is vivified and adorned. The anxiety of Chosroes was soon relieved by the assurance, that the emperor had espoused the cause of justice and royalty; but Maurice prudently declined the expense and delay of his useless visit to Constantinople. In the name of his generous benefactor, a rich diadem was presented to the fugitive prince, with an inestimable gift of jewels and gold; a powerful army was assembled on the frontiers of Syria and Armenia, under the command of the valiant and faithful Narses, 17 and this general, of his own nation, and his own choice, was directed to pass the Tigris, and never to sheathe his sword till he had restored Chosroes to the throne of his ancestors. 1711 The enterprise, however splendid, was less arduous than it might appear. Persia had already repented of her fatal rashness, which betrayed the heir of the house of Sassan to the ambition of a rebellious subject: and the bold refusal of the Magi to consecrate his usurpation, compelled Bahram to assume the sceptre, regardless of the laws and prejudices of the nation. The palace was soon distracted with conspiracy, the city with tumult, the provinces with insurrection; and the cruel execution of the guilty and the suspected served to irritate rather than subdue the public discontent. No sooner did the grandson of Nushirvan display his own and the Roman banners beyond the Tigris, than he was joined, each day, by the increasing multitudes of the nobility and people; and as he advanced, he received from every side the grateful offerings of the keys of his cities and the heads of his enemies. As soon as Modain was freed from the presence of the usurper, the loyal inhabitants obeyed the first summons of Mebodes at the head of only two thousand horse, and Chosroes accepted the sacred and precious ornaments of the palace as the pledge of their truth and the presage of his approaching success. After the junction of the Imperial troops, which Bahram vainly struggled to prevent, the contest was decided by two battles on the banks of the Zab, and the confines of Media. The Romans, with the faithful subjects of Persia, amounted to sixty thousand, while the whole force of the usurper did not exceed forty thousand men: the two generals signalized their valor and ability; but the victory was finally determined by the prevalence of numbers and discipline. With the remnant of a broken army, Bahram fled towards the eastern provinces of the Oxus: the enmity of Persia reconciled him to the Turks; but his days were shortened by poison, perhaps the most incurable of poisons; the stings of remorse and despair, and the bitter remembrance of lost glory. Yet the modern Persians still commemorate the exploits of Bahram; and some excellent laws have prolonged the duration of his troubled and transitory reign.
库思老一面加紧筹备退路,一面与尚存的几位亲信商议:16 是该藏身于高加索山的谷地,还是逃往突厥人的营帐,抑或去恳求罗马皇帝的庇护。阿尔达希尔与君士坦丁两家后裔长久以来的争胜宿怨,令他愈发不愿以乞援者的身份,现身于宿敌的朝廷;但他权衡了罗马人的实力,审慎地想到:叙利亚近在咫尺,既便于自己脱身,也利于对方更有力地施援。他只带着几名姬妾和一队三十人的卫士,悄然离开都城,沿幼发拉底河而行,穿过沙漠,在离基尔克西乌姆十英里处停下。约莫三更时分,罗马长官得报他将至,天一破晓便把这位落难的王室客人迎入要塞。波斯王随后被护送到更为体面的居所希拉波利斯;莫里斯在接见努希尔万之孙的书信与使节时,收敛起自己的骄矜,一味展露善意。使节谦卑地陈说命运的无常与君主之间休戚相关的共同利害,极力渲染巴赫拉姆——那“恶”之化身——如何忘恩负义,并以貌似有理的说辞力陈:扶持这两个维系天下均势的王朝,本就于罗马人自身有利;这两大王朝正如两轮巨光,以其有益的照拂使世界得以生机盎然、增色生辉。不久便有确讯传来:皇帝已决意维护正义、扶助王统。库思老的焦虑遂得纾解;不过莫里斯审慎地谢绝了他前往君士坦丁堡的打算——那趟出访既费钱又费时,并无实益。这位慷慨的恩主以自己的名义,赠予这落难王子一顶华贵的王冠,外加珠宝与黄金,价值无可估量;一支劲旅在叙利亚与亚美尼亚边境集结,由英勇忠贞的纳尔塞斯统领,17 这位将领乃皇帝本国之人,又经皇帝亲自选定,奉命渡过底格里斯河,不把库思老重新扶上其祖先的王座,便决不收剑入鞘。1711 这番事业虽显赫,其艰难却不及表面看去那般。波斯已然悔恨自己那致命的鲁莽——竟把萨珊王室的继承人,断送给一个叛臣的野心;而麻葛断然拒绝为其篡位加冕祝圣,逼得巴赫拉姆只能不顾国法民情,径自执起王权。不久,宫中阴谋四起,城内骚乱不止,各行省揭竿而反;而对罪人与嫌疑者的残酷处决,非但未能压服民怨,反倒火上浇油。努希尔万之孙刚在底格里斯河对岸打出自己与罗马的旗号,前来归附的贵族与百姓便日益增多;他每前进一步,四面八方便纷纷献上城池的钥匙与仇敌的首级,聊表感戴之忱。篡位者一离开马达因,忠心的居民便应梅博德斯的头一声号召而起——此人只率两千骑兵;库思老受下了王宫中那些神圣而珍贵的饰物,既视之为百姓忠诚的凭证,也当作自己即将成功的先兆。巴赫拉姆枉费气力,未能阻止帝国援军会合;两军会师之后,胜负便在扎布河畔与米底边境的两场会战中见了分晓。罗马人连同忠于王室的波斯臣民共计六万,而篡位者的全部兵力不过四万:两军主将都尽显其勇武与才干,但最终决定胜局的,还是人数与纪律上的优势。巴赫拉姆带着一支溃军的残部,向阿姆河以东的行省逃去:与波斯为敌这一点,使他同突厥人重归于好;然而一种毒药却缩短了他的性命——那或许是最无药可解的一种毒:悔恨与绝望的锥心之痛,以及对失落荣光的苦涩追忆。即便如此,今日的波斯人仍在追念巴赫拉姆的功业;他那动荡而短暂的治世,也因几部优良的法律而延续了影响。
¶
The restoration of Chosroes was celebrated with feasts and executions; and the music of the royal banquet was often disturbed by the groans of dying or mutilated criminals. A general pardon might have diffused comfort and tranquillity through a country which had been shaken by the late revolutions; yet, before the sanguinary temper of Chosroes is blamed, we should learn whether the Persians had not been accustomed either to dread the rigor, or to despise the weakness, of their sovereign. The revolt of Bahram, and the conspiracy of the satraps, were impartially punished by the revenge or justice of the conqueror; the merits of Bindoes himself could not purify his hand from the guilt of royal blood: and the son of Hormouz was desirous to assert his own innocence, and to vindicate the sanctity of kings. During the vigor of the Roman power, several princes were seated on the throne of Persia by the arms and the authority of the first Caesars. But their new subjects were soon disgusted with the vices or virtues which they had imbibed in a foreign land; the instability of their dominion gave birth to a vulgar observation, that the choice of Rome was solicited and rejected with equal ardor by the capricious levity of Oriental slaves. But the glory of Maurice was conspicuous in the long and fortunate reign of his son and his ally. A band of a thousand Romans, who continued to guard the person of Chosroes, proclaimed his confidence in the fidelity of the strangers; his growing strength enabled him to dismiss this unpopular aid, but he steadily professed the same gratitude and reverence to his adopted father; and till the death of Maurice, the peace and alliance of the two empires were faithfully maintained. 18 Yet the mercenary friendship of the Roman prince had been purchased with costly and important gifts; the strong cities of Martyropolis and Dara 1811 were restored, and the Persarmenians became the willing subjects of an empire, whose eastern limit was extended, beyond the example of former times, as far as the banks of the Araxes, and the neighborhood of the Caspian. A pious hope was indulged, that the church as well as the state might triumph in this revolution: but if Chosroes had sincerely listened to the Christian bishops, the impression was erased by the zeal and eloquence of the Magi: if he was armed with philosophic indifference, he accommodated his belief, or rather his professions, to the various circumstances of an exile and a sovereign. The imaginary conversion of the king of Persia was reduced to a local and superstitious veneration for Sergius, 19 one of the saints of Antioch, who heard his prayers and appeared to him in dreams; he enriched the shrine with offerings of gold and silver, and ascribed to this invisible patron the success of his arms, and the pregnancy of Sira, a devout Christian and the best beloved of his wives. 20 The beauty of Sira, or Schirin, 21 her wit, her musical talents, are still famous in the history, or rather in the romances, of the East: her own name is expressive, in the Persian tongue, of sweetness and grace; and the epithet of Parviz alludes to the charms of her royal lover. Yet Sira never shared the passions which she inspired, and the bliss of Chosroes was tortured by a jealous doubt, that while he possessed her person, she had bestowed her affections on a meaner favorite. 22
库思老的复位,是以宴饮与处决来庆贺的;王家宴席上的丝竹之声,屡屡被垂死或受肢刑者的呻吟所搅扰。一纸大赦,本可为这个刚经历动乱、饱受震荡的国度带来慰藉与安宁;然而在责备库思老嗜杀成性之前,我们应先弄清:波斯人是否早已习惯——对自己的君主,要么畏其严酷,要么鄙其软弱,二者必居其一。这位胜利者一视同仁地惩处了巴赫拉姆的叛乱与众总督的阴谋——或出于报复,或出于公道;纵有种种功劳,宾多伊斯本人也洗不净手上那弑君的血罪;何况霍尔米兹德之子一心要表白自己的清白,并维护君王之尊不可侵犯。当年罗马国势鼎盛之时,好几位王子都是靠早期诸恺撒的武力与威权,才得以登上波斯王座的。但这些人在异邦所沾染的恶习或美德,很快便令其新臣民生厌;他们统治的动荡不稳,催生出一句俗谚:东方那些反复无常、轻浮善变的奴才,对罗马所立之君,求之也急切,弃之也同样急切。不过,莫里斯的光荣,却在他这位义子兼盟友漫长而昌顺的治世中显露无遗。一支千人的罗马卫队持续护卫着库思老,昭示出他对这些外邦人忠诚的信赖;待自身势力日渐壮大,他本可遣散这支不得民心的助力,却始终对义父表示如一的感激与敬重;直到莫里斯去世,两大帝国间的和平与同盟都得到忠实的维系。18 然而这位罗马君主唯利是图的友谊,是用一份份贵重而紧要的馈赠换来的;马蒂罗波利斯与达拉这两座坚城1811复归罗马,波斯亚美尼亚人也心甘情愿地成了罗马的臣民;帝国的东界由此向外拓展,一直推到阿拉克塞斯河畔与里海近旁,为前代所未有。人们怀着一个虔诚的期望,盼在这场剧变中,不仅国家、连教会也能一同凯旋:可是,即便库思老当真听过基督教主教们的规劝,那点印象也早被麻葛的热忱与口才抹去;若说他抱持的是哲人般的淡漠,那么他的信仰——或者不如说他口头的表白——便随流亡者与君主这两种不同的处境而变通。所谓波斯王皈依基督教,其实无非是对安条克圣徒塞尔吉乌斯19的一种局限而迷信的崇奉;相传这位圣徒听见了他的祈祷,还在梦中向他显现。他以金银供品充实圣龛,并把自己的武运,连同虔诚信主、最受他宠爱的爱妃西拉的身孕,都归功于这位无形的守护者。20 西拉(又名希琳)21的美貌、她的机智、她的音乐才华,至今仍在东方的史册——或者不如说传奇——中脍炙人口:她的名字在波斯语中本就有甜美与优雅之意;而“帕尔维兹”这一称号,则暗指她那位帝王情郎的迷人风采。然而西拉对她所激起的情爱始终无动于衷;库思老的欢愉,也为一桩妒忌的疑虑所折磨:他虽占有了她的人,她却把芳心许给了一个更卑微的宠幸之人。22
Notes 注释
1
↩
Missis qui... reposcerent... veteres Persarum ac Macedonum terminos, seque invasurum possessa Cyro et post Alexandro, per vaniloquentiam ac minas jaciebat. Tacit. Annal. vi. 31. Such was the language of the Arsacides. I have repeatedly marked the lofty claims of the Sassanians.
Missis qui... reposcerent... veteres Persarum ac Macedonum terminos, seque invasurum possessa Cyro et post Alexandro, per vaniloquentiam ac minas jaciebat. Tacit. Annal. vi. 31. 这正是阿尔撒息王朝的口吻。萨珊王朝那些自负的主张,我已一再点出。
2
↩
See the embassies of Menander, extracted and preserved in the tenth century by the order of Constantine Porphyrogenitus.
参见米南德所记的历次出使;这些内容于十世纪奉君士坦丁·波菲罗格尼图斯之命辑录保存。
3
↩
The general independence of the Arabs, which cannot be admitted without many limitations, is blindly asserted in a separate dissertation of the authors of the Universal History, vol. xx. p. 196—250. A perpetual miracle is supposed to have guarded the prophecy in favor of the posterity of Ishmael; and these learned bigots are not afraid to risk the truth of Christianity on this frail and slippery foundation. * Note: It certainly appears difficult to extract a prediction of the perpetual independence of the Arabs from the text in Genesis, which would have received an ample fulfilment during centuries of uninvaded freedom. But the disputants appear to forget the inseparable connection in the prediction between the wild, the Bedoween habits of the Ismaelites, with their national independence. The stationary and civilized descendant of Ismael forfeited, as it were, his birthright, and ceased to be a genuine son of the “wild man” The phrase, “dwelling in the presence of his brethren,” is interpreted by Rosenmüller (in loc.) and others, according to the Hebrew geography, “to the East” of his brethren, the legitimate race of Abraham—M.
关于阿拉伯人普遍不受外族统治这一说法——它若不加诸多限定便难以成立——《世界通史》的作者们在一篇专论中盲目予以断言(vol. xx. p. 196—250)。他们设想有一场恒久的神迹,护佑着那关乎以实玛利后裔的预言得以应验;这些博学的偏执之徒,竟不惮于把基督教的真理,押在如此脆弱而靠不住的根基之上。* 编者按:诚然,要从《创世记》的经文中引出“阿拉伯人将永享独立”这一预言,似乎颇为牵强——须知在此前数百年不曾遭外族侵入的自由岁月里,这预言早已充分应验。然而争论者们似乎忘了:预言中那以实玛利后裔的野性、贝都因式的习俗,与其民族的独立本是密不可分的。以实玛利那定居而开化的后裔,可以说已然放弃了自己的长子名分,不再是那“野人”的真正子孙。至于“住在众弟兄面前”一语,罗森米勒(见该处注释)等人依照希伯来的地理观念,将其解作居于其众弟兄——即亚伯拉罕嫡系一脉——的“东方”。—M
4
↩
D’Herbelot, Biblioth. Orient. p. 477. Pocock, Specimen Hist. Arabum, p. 64, 65. Father Pagi (Critica, tom. ii. p. 646) has proved that, after ten years’ peace, the Persian war, which continued twenty years, was renewed A.D. 571. Mahomet was born A.D. 569, in the year of the elephant, or the defeat of Abrahah, (Gagnier, Vie de Mahomet, tom. i. p. 89, 90, 98;) and this account allows two years for the conquest of Yemen. * Note: Abrahah, according to some accounts, was succeeded by his son Taksoum, who reigned seventeen years; his brother Mascouh, who was slain in battle against the Persians, twelve. But this chronology is irreconcilable with the Arabian conquests of Nushirvan the Great. Either Seif, or his son Maadi Karb, was the native prince placed on the throne by the Persians. St. Martin, vol. x. p. 78. See likewise Johannsen, Hist. Yemanae.—M.
埃尔布洛,Biblioth. Orient. p. 477。波科克,Specimen Hist. Arabum, p. 64, 65。帕吉神父(Critica, tom. ii. p. 646)已证明:在十年和平之后,那场持续二十年的波斯战争,于公元571年重启。穆罕默德生于公元569年,即“象年”,也就是阿布拉哈战败之年(加尼耶,Vie de Mahomet, tom. i. p. 89, 90, 98);照此推算,征服也门用了两年。* 编者按:据某些记载,阿布拉哈死后由其子塔克苏姆继位,在位十七年;其弟马斯库赫在与波斯人交战中阵亡,在位十二年。但这一纪年,与伟大的努希尔万征服阿拉伯之事无法调和。被波斯人扶上王位的本地君主,若非赛义夫,便是其子马阿迪·卡里布。圣马丁,vol. x. p. 78。另见约翰森,Hist. Yemanae。—M
411
↩
Persarmenia was long maintained in peace by the tolerant administration of Mejej, prince of the Gnounians. On his death he was succeeded by a persecutor, a Persian, named Ten-Schahpour, who attempted to propagate Zoroastrianism by violence. Nushirvan, on an appeal to the throne by the Armenian clergy, replaced Ten-Schahpour, in 552, by Veschnas-Vahram. The new marzban, or governor, was instructed to repress the bigoted Magi in their persecutions of the Armenians, but the Persian converts to Christianity were still exposed to cruel sufferings. The most distinguished of them, Izdbouzid, was crucified at Dovin in the presence of a vast multitude. The fame of this martyr spread to the West. Menander, the historian, not only, as appears by a fragment published by Mai, related this event in his history, but, according to M. St. Martin, wrote a tragedy on the subject. This, however, is an unwarrantable inference from the phrase which merely means that he related the tragic event in his history. An epigram on the same subject, preserved in the Anthology, Jacob’s Anth. Palat. i. 27, belongs to the historian. Yet Armenia remained in peace under the government of Veschnas-Vahram and his successor Varazdat. The tyranny of his successor Surena led to the insurrection under Vartan, the Mamigonian, who revenged the death of his brother on the marzban Surena, surprised Dovin, and put to the sword the governor, the soldiers, and the Magians. From St. Martin, vol x. p. 79—89.—M.
波斯亚美尼亚在格努尼家族的君主梅杰宽厚的治理下,长久保持安宁。梅杰死后,继任者是个波斯人、名叫滕沙赫普尔的迫害者,此人企图以暴力推行琐罗亚斯德教。亚美尼亚教士向王廷上诉,努希尔万遂于552年以韦什纳斯-瓦赫拉姆取代滕沙赫普尔。这位新任马兹班(即总督)奉命约束那些偏执的麻葛,不许他们迫害亚美尼亚人;然而皈依基督教的波斯人,仍难免遭受酷刑折磨。其中最著名的伊兹德布兹德,当着大批民众的面在德温被钉上十字架。这位殉道者的名声传到了西方。史家米南德不仅(据迈刊布的一则残篇所示)在其史著中记述了此事,据圣马丁说,还就此题材写了一出悲剧。不过,这一推断实属牵强,因为那句话不过是说他在史著中记述了这一悲惨事件而已。另有一首以此为题的铭辞,收录于《希腊诗选》(Jacob's Anth. Palat. i. 27),亦出自这位史家之手。在韦什纳斯-瓦赫拉姆及其继任者瓦拉兹达特治下,亚美尼亚始终太平。及至再一位继任者苏雷纳暴虐无道,终于激起马米科尼扬人瓦尔坦领导的起义;瓦尔坦为弟报仇,杀了马兹班苏雷纳,奇袭德温,把总督、士兵与麻葛尽数处死。据圣马丁,vol x. p. 79—89。—M
412
↩
Malathiah. It was in the lesser Armenia.—M.
即马拉蒂亚(Malathiah)。此地在小亚美尼亚。—M
5
↩
He had vanquished the Albanians, who brought into the field 12,000 horse and 60,000 foot; but he dreaded the multitude of venomous reptiles, whose existence may admit of some doubt, as well as that of the neighboring Amazons. Plutarch, in Pompeio, tom. ii. p. 1165, 1166.
他(庞培)曾击败阿尔巴尼亚人——这些人出动了一万二千骑兵和六万步兵;但他忌惮那里成群的毒蛇,其存在或可存疑,一如附近的亚马逊人是否存在亦难确证。普鲁塔克,in Pompeio, tom. ii. p. 1165, 1166。
6
↩
In the history of the world I can only perceive two navies on the Caspian: 1. Of the Macedonians, when Patrocles, the admiral of the kings of Syria, Seleucus and Antiochus, descended most probably the River Oxus, from the confines of India, (Plin. Hist. Natur. vi. 21.) 2. Of the Russians, when Peter the First conducted a fleet and army from the neighborhood of Moscow to the coast of Persia, (Bell’s Travels, vol. ii. p. 325—352.) He justly observes, that such martial pomp had never been displayed on the Volga.
纵观世界历史,我所能查见的里海舰队仅有两支:其一属马其顿人,其时叙利亚二王塞琉古与安条克麾下的舰队司令帕特罗克利斯,很可能是从印度边境顺阿姆河而下(Plin. Hist. Natur. vi. 21)。其二属俄罗斯人,其时彼得一世率领一支舰队与军队,从莫斯科近郊开赴波斯海岸(Bell's Travels, vol. ii. p. 325—352)。他说得不错:如此赫赫军威,伏尔加河上从未有过。
611
↩
This circumstance rests on the statements of Evagrius and Theophylaci Simocatta. They are not of sufficient authority to establish a fact so improbable. St. Martin, vol. x. p. 140.—M.
此事仅据埃瓦格里乌斯与塞奥菲拉克特·西摩卡塔之说。二人分量不足,不足以坐实如此难以置信之事。圣马丁,vol. x. p. 140。—M
7
↩
For these Persian wars and treaties, see Menander, in Excerpt. Legat. p. 113—125. Theophanes Byzant. apud Photium, cod. lxiv p. 77, 80, 81. Evagrius, l. v. c. 7—15. Theophylact, l. iii. c. 9—16 Agathias, l. iv. p. 140.
关于这些波斯战争与和约,参见米南德,in Excerpt. Legat. p. 113—125。塞奥法尼斯·拜占庭(Theophanes Byzant.),见佛提乌辑本,cod. lxiv p. 77, 80, 81。埃瓦格里乌斯,l. v. c. 7—15。塞奥菲拉克特,l. iii. c. 9—16。阿加提亚斯,l. iv. p. 140。
8
↩
Buzurg Mihir may be considered, in his character and station, as the Seneca of the East; but his virtues, and perhaps his faults, are less known than those of the Roman, who appears to have been much more loquacious. The Persian sage was the person who imported from India the game of chess and the fables of Pilpay. Such has been the fame of his wisdom and virtues, that the Christians claim him as a believer in the gospel; and the Mahometans revere Buzurg as a premature Mussulman. D’Herbelot, Bibliotheque Orientale, p. 218.
布祖尔格·米赫尔就其品格与地位而言,堪称东方的塞涅卡;只是他的德行——或许还有他的过失——远不如那位罗马人(塞涅卡)为世人所知,因为塞涅卡似乎话要多得多。正是这位波斯贤者,把国际象棋与比德拜的寓言从印度引入波斯。他智慧与德行的名声之大,以致基督徒把他说成福音的信徒,穆斯林则把布祖尔格奉为一位早生的穆斯林。埃尔布洛,Bibliotheque Orientale, p. 218。
9
↩
See the imitation of Scipio in Theophylact, l. i. c. 14; the image of Christ, l. ii. c. 3. Hereafter I shall speak more amply of the Christian images—I had almost said idols. This, if I am not mistaken, is the oldest of divine manufacture; but in the next thousand years, many others issued from the same workshop.
关于效法西庇阿之事,见塞奥菲拉克特,l. i. c. 14;关于基督圣像,见 l. ii. c. 3。此类基督教圣像——我几乎要说是“偶像”了——我留待日后详加论述。倘若我没弄错,这是最早的一件“神造”之物;但在此后一千年里,同一间作坊又出产了许许多多。
10
↩
Ragae, or Rei, is mentioned in the Apocryphal book of Tobit as already flourishing, 700 years before Christ, under the Assyrian empire. Under the foreign names of Europus and Arsacia, this city, 500 stadia to the south of the Caspian gates, was successively embellished by the Macedonians and Parthians, (Strabo, l. xi. p. 796.) Its grandeur and populousness in the ixth century are exaggerated beyond the bounds of credibility; but Rei has been since ruined by wars and the unwholesomeness of the air. Chardin, Voyage en Perse, tom. i. p. 279, 280. D’Herbelot, Biblioth. Oriental. p. 714.
拉加(又称雷伊)在次经《托比特书》中已有提及,说它早在基督前七百年、亚述帝国治下便已繁盛。此城位于里海门户以南五百斯塔迪亚,曾先后以欧罗普斯和阿尔萨基亚这两个外来名字为人所知,经马其顿人与帕提亚人相继修饰美化(斯特拉波,l. xi. p. 796)。九世纪时其宏伟与人口之盛,被夸张得难以令人置信;此后雷伊却因战乱与空气恶劣而沦为废墟。夏尔丹,Voyage en Perse, tom. i. p. 279, 280。埃尔布洛,Biblioth. Oriental. p. 714。
11
↩
Theophylact. l. iii. c. 18. The story of the seven Persians is told in the third book of Herodotus; and their noble descendants are often mentioned, especially in the fragments of Ctesias. Yet the independence of Otanes (Herodot. l. iii. c. 83, 84) is hostile to the spirit of despotism, and it may not seem probable that the seven families could survive the revolutions of eleven hundred years. They might, however, be represented by the seven ministers, (Brisson, de Regno Persico, l. i. p. 190;) and some Persian nobles, like the kings of Pontus (Polyb l. v. p. 540) and Cappadocia, (Diodor. Sicul. l. xxxi. tom. ii. p. 517,) might claim their descent from the bold companions of Darius.
塞奥菲拉克特,l. iii. c. 18。七位波斯贵人的故事,见希罗多德第三卷;他们高贵的后裔屡见记载,尤其散见于克特西亚斯的残篇。不过,奥塔涅斯不受君权约束的独立地位(希罗多德,l. iii. c. 83, 84),与专制精神格格不入;而要说这七大世家竟能历经一千一百年的沧桑变革而存续,恐怕也未必可信。然而,这七家或许可由那七位大臣来代表(布里松,de Regno Persico, l. i. p. 190);某些波斯贵族,一如本都诸王(波利比乌斯,l. v. p. 540)与卡帕多西亚诸王(西西里的狄奥多罗斯,l. xxxi. tom. ii. p. 517),也可能自称是大流士那些勇敢伙伴的后裔。
1111
↩
He is generally called Baharam Choubeen, Baharam, the stick-like, probably from his appearance. Malcolm, vol. i. p. 120.—M.
他一般被称作巴赫拉姆·楚宾,意为“棍子似的巴赫拉姆”,大约是就其体貌而言。马尔科姆,vol. i. p. 120。—M
1112
↩
The Persian historians say, that Hormouz entreated his general to increase his numbers; but Baharam replied, that experience had taught him that it was the quality, not the number of soldiers, which gave success. * * * No man in his army was under forty years, and none above fifty. Malcolm, vol. i. p. 121—M.
波斯史家称,霍尔米兹德曾恳请这位将领增添兵员,巴赫拉姆却答道:经验告诉他,制胜的是士兵的素质而非数量。……他军中无一人小于四十岁,也无一人大于五十岁。马尔科姆,vol. i. p. 121。—M
12
↩
See an accurate description of this mountain by Olearius, (Voyage en Perse, p. 997, 998,) who ascended it with much difficulty and danger in his return from Ispahan to the Caspian Sea.
关于这座山的准确描述,见奥莱亚里乌斯(Voyage en Perse, p. 997, 998);他从伊斯法罕返回里海途中,历尽艰险登上此山。
13
↩
The Orientals suppose that Bahram convened this assembly and proclaimed Chosroes; but Theophylact is, in this instance, more distinct and credible. * Note: Yet Theophylact seems to have seized the opportunity to indulge his propensity for writing orations; and the orations read rather like those of a Grecian sophist than of an Eastern assembly.—M.
东方作者以为是巴赫拉姆召集了这次集会并拥立库思老为王;但在这件事上,塞奥菲拉克特的记述更为清晰可信。* 编者按:不过,塞奥菲拉克特似乎借此机会,纵情施展他撰写演说辞的癖好;那些演说辞读来,倒更像出自一位希腊诡辩家之口,而非东方的一场集会。—M
14
↩
See the words of Theophylact, l. iv. c. 7., &c. In answer, Chosroes styles himself in genuine Oriental bombast.
塞奥菲拉克特的原话见 l. iv. c. 7. 等处。作答时,库思老以地道的东方式浮夸口吻自称一番。
15
↩
Theophylact (l. iv. c. 7) imputes the death of Hormouz to his son, by whose command he was beaten to death with clubs. I have followed the milder account of Khondemir and Eutychius, and shall always be content with the slightest evidence to extenuate the crime of parricide. Note: Malcolm concurs in ascribing his death to Bundawee, (Bindoes,) vol. i. p. 123. The Eastern writers generally impute the crime to the uncle St. Martin, vol. x. p. 300.—M.
塞奥菲拉克特(l. iv. c. 7)把霍尔米兹德之死归咎于其子,说他是奉子命被乱棍打死的。我则采信洪德米尔与欧提基乌斯较为温和的说法;但凡有一丝证据可为弑父之罪开脱,我总乐于采纳。编者按:马尔科姆也认为其死出自邦达维(即宾多伊斯)之手,vol. i. p. 123。东方作者则大多把这桩罪行归咎于其舅父。圣马丁,vol. x. p. 300。—M
16
↩
After the battle of Pharsalia, the Pompey of Lucan (l. viii. 256—455) holds a similar debate. He was himself desirous of seeking the Parthians: but his companions abhorred the unnatural alliance and the adverse prejudices might operate as forcibly on Chosroes and his companions, who could describe, with the same vehemence, the contrast of laws, religion, and manners, between the East and West.
法尔萨利亚一战之后,卢坎笔下的庞培(l. viii. 256—455)也有过一番类似的商议。庞培本人有意投奔帕提亚人,随行者却厌恶这种有悖常理的结盟;同样的抵触成见,或许也会同样强烈地作用于库思老及其同伴——他们尽可以同样激切地历数东方与西方在法律、宗教与风俗上的种种对立。
17
↩
In this age there were three warriors of the name of Narses, who have been often confounded, (Pagi, Critica, tom. ii. p. 640:) 1. A Persarmenian, the brother of Isaac and Armatius, who, after a successful action against Belisarius, deserted from his Persian sovereign, and afterwards served in the Italian war.—2. The eunuch who conquered Italy.—3. The restorer of Chosroes, who is celebrated in the poem of Corippus (l. iii. 220—327) as excelsus super omnia vertico agmina.... habitu modestus.... morum probitate placens, virtute verendus; fulmineus, cautus, vigilans, &c.
这个时代有三位名叫纳尔塞斯的武将,常被人混为一谈(帕吉,Critica, tom. ii. p. 640):其一是波斯亚美尼亚人,伊萨克与阿尔马提乌斯之兄,曾对贝利撒留打了一场胜仗,后来背弃波斯君主,转而效力于意大利战争。其二是征服意大利的那位宦官。其三便是扶助库思老复位的这一位,科里普斯的诗篇(l. iii. 220—327)曾颂扬他:excelsus super omnia vertice agmina.... habitu modestus.... morum probitate placens, virtute verendus; fulmineus, cautus, vigilans(超群拔萃,凌驾三军……仪态谦和……以德行之端正而得人心,以武勇之凛然而受敬畏;迅捷如雷,谨慎,机警),云云。
1711
↩
The Armenians adhered to Chosroes. St. Martin, vol. x. p. 312.—M. ——According to Mivkhond and the Oriental writers, Bahram received the daughter of the Khakan in marriage, and commanded a body of Turks in an invasion of Persia. Some say that he was assassinated; Malcolm adopts the opinion that he was poisoned. His sister Gourdieh, the companion of his flight, is celebrated in the Shah Nameh. She was afterwards one of the wives of Chosroes. St. Martin. vol. x. p. 331.—M.
亚美尼亚人始终追随库思老。圣马丁,vol. x. p. 312。—M ——据米尔洪德及东方诸作者所言,巴赫拉姆娶了可汗之女为妻,并统率一支突厥军队入侵波斯。有人说他是被暗杀的;马尔科姆则采信他是被毒死的说法。他的妹妹古尔迪耶一路伴他出逃,在《列王纪》中广受传颂;她后来成了库思老的妻子之一。圣马丁,vol. x. p. 331。—M
18
↩
Experimentis cognitum est Barbaros malle Roma petere reges quam habere. These experiments are admirably represented in the invitation and expulsion of Vonones, (Annal. ii. 1—3,) Tiridates, (Annal. vi. 32-44,) and Meherdates, (Annal. xi. 10, xii. 10-14.) The eye of Tacitus seems to have transpierced the camp of the Parthians and the walls of the harem.
Experimentis cognitum est Barbaros malle Roma petere reges quam habere(经验表明,蛮族宁愿向罗马求取君主,而不愿真让罗马来统治)。这类实例,在沃诺涅斯(Annal. ii. 1—3)、提里达特斯(Annal. vi. 32-44)与梅赫尔达特斯(Annal. xi. 10, xii. 10-14)被迎立又被逐这几桩事上,都有绝妙的呈现。塔西佗的目光,似乎穿透了帕提亚人的营帐与后宫的宫墙。
1811
↩
Concerning Nisibis, see St. Martin and his Armenian authorities, vol. x p. 332, and Memoires sur l’Armenie, tom. i. p. 25.—M.
关于尼西比斯,见圣马丁及其所据的亚美尼亚史料,vol. x p. 332,以及 Memoires sur l'Armenie, tom. i. p. 25。—M
19
↩
Sergius and his companion Bacchus, who are said to have suffered in the persecution of Maximian, obtained divine honor in France, Italy, Constantinople, and the East. Their tomb at Rasaphe was famous for miracles, and that Syrian town acquired the more honorable name of Sergiopolis. Tillemont, Mem. Eccles. tom. v. p. 481—496. Butler’s Saints, vol. x. p. 155.
塞尔吉乌斯与其同伴巴克斯,据说是在马克西米安的迫害中殉道的,后来在法国、意大利、君士坦丁堡与东方各地都受到神圣的尊崇。他们在拉萨费的陵墓以显灵神迹闻名,那座叙利亚小城遂得了“塞尔吉奥波利斯”这一更为荣耀的名字。蒂耶蒙,Mem. Eccles. tom. v. p. 481—496。巴特勒《圣徒传》,vol. x. p. 155。
20
↩
Evagrius (l. vi. c. 21) and Theophylact (l. v. c. 13, 14) have preserved the original letters of Chosroes, written in Greek, signed with his own hand, and afterwards inscribed on crosses and tables of gold, which were deposited in the church of Sergiopolis. They had been sent to the bishop of Antioch, as primate of Syria. * Note: St. Martin thinks that they were first written in Syriac, and then translated into the bad Greek in which they appear, vol. x. p. 334.—M.
埃瓦格里乌斯(l. vi. c. 21)与塞奥菲拉克特(l. v. c. 13, 14)保存了库思老书信的原文;这些信以希腊文写成,由他亲笔签署,后来被镌刻在十字架与金板之上,存放于塞尔吉奥波利斯的教堂里。信原是寄给安条克主教——即叙利亚首席主教——的。* 编者按:圣马丁认为,这些信最初是用叙利亚文写的,后来才被译成如今所见的那种蹩脚希腊文,vol. x. p. 334。—M
21
↩
The Greeks only describe her as a Roman by birth, a Christian by religion: but she is represented as the daughter of the emperor Maurice in the Persian and Turkish romances which celebrate the love of Khosrou for Schirin, of Schirin for Ferhad, the most beautiful youth of the East, D’Herbelot, Biblioth. Orient. p. 789, 997, 998. * Note: Compare M. von Hammer’s preface to, and poem of, Schirin in which he gives an account of the various Persian poems, of which he has endeavored to extract the essence in his own work.—M.
希腊作者只说她生为罗马人、信奉基督教;但在传颂库思老爱恋希琳、希琳又爱恋东方第一美少年法尔哈德的波斯与土耳其传奇里,她却被说成是莫里斯皇帝的女儿。埃尔布洛,Biblioth. Orient. p. 789, 997, 998。* 编者按:可参看冯·哈默为《希琳》所作的序言及其诗作,他在其中介绍了各种波斯诗篇,并力图在自己的作品中提炼出其精华。—M
22
↩
The whole series of the tyranny of Hormouz, the revolt of Bahram, and the flight and restoration of Chosroes, is related by two contemporary Greeks—more concisely by Evagrius, (l. vi. c. 16, 17, 18, 19,) and most diffusely by Theophylact Simocatta, (l. iii. c. 6—18, l. iv. c. 1—16, l. v. c. 1-15:) succeeding compilers, Zonaras and Cedrenus, can only transcribe and abridge. The Christian Arabs, Eutychius (Annal. tom. ii. p. 200—208) and Abulpharagius (Dynast. p. 96—98) appear to have consulted some particular memoirs. The great Persian historians of the xvth century, Mirkhond and Khondemir, are only known to me by the imperfect extracts of Schikard, (Tarikh, p. 150—155,) Texeira, or rather Stevens, (Hist. of Persia, p. 182—186,) a Turkish Ms. translated by the Abbe Fourmount, (Hist. de l’Academie des Inscriptions, tom. vii. p. 325—334,) and D’Herbelot, (aux mots Hormouz, p. 457—459. Bahram, p. 174. Khosrou Parviz, p. 996.) Were I perfectly satisfied of their authority, I could wish these Oriental materials had been more copious.
霍尔米兹德的暴政、巴赫拉姆的叛乱,以及库思老出逃与复位这一连串事件,由两位同时代的希腊作者加以记述——埃瓦格里乌斯(l. vi. c. 16, 17, 18, 19)叙来较为简略,塞奥菲拉克特·西摩卡塔(l. iii. c. 6—18, l. iv. c. 1—16, l. v. c. 1-15)则最为详尽;后来的编纂者佐纳拉斯与塞德雷努斯,不过是转录与节略而已。信奉基督教的阿拉伯人欧提基乌斯(Annal. tom. ii. p. 200—208)与阿布·法拉杰(Dynast. p. 96—98),看来查阅过某些特别的回忆录。至于十五世纪那两位伟大的波斯史家米尔洪德与洪德米尔,我所知的仅限于几家残缺的辑录:席卡尔德(Tarikh, p. 150—155)、特谢拉(或者不如说史蒂文斯,Hist. of Persia, p. 182—186)、一部由富尔蒙神父翻译的土耳其文抄本(Hist. de l'Academie des Inscriptions, tom. vii. p. 325—334),以及埃尔布洛(Hormouz 条,p. 457—459;Bahram 条,p. 174;Khosrou Parviz 条,p. 996)。倘若我对这些史料的可靠性完全放心,真愿它们能更为丰赡才好。