Chapter X: Emperors Decius, Gallus, Æmilianus, Valerian And Gallienus—Part I. 第十章 德西乌斯、加卢斯、埃米利安努斯、瓦勒良与加里恩努斯诸帝——第一节
¶
The Emperors Decius, Gallus, Æmilianus, Valerian, And Gallienus.—The General Irruption Of The Barbari Ans.—The Thirty Tyrants.
德西乌斯(Decius)、加卢斯(Gallus)、埃米利安努斯、瓦勒良(Valerian)与加里恩努斯(Gallienus)诸帝——蛮族的全面入侵——三十僭主
¶
From the great secular games celebrated by Philip, to the death of the emperor Gallienus, there elapsed twenty years of shame and misfortune. During that calamitous period, every instant of time was marked, every province of the Roman world was afflicted, by barbarous invaders, and military tyrants, and the ruined empire seemed to approach the last and fatal moment of its dissolution. The confusion of the times, and the scarcity of authentic memorials, oppose equal difficulties to the historian, who attempts to preserve a clear and unbroken thread of narration. Surrounded with imperfect fragments, always concise, often obscure, and sometimes contradictory, he is reduced to collect, to compare, and to conjecture: and though he ought never to place his conjectures in the rank of facts, yet the knowledge of human nature, and of the sure operation of its fierce and unrestrained passions, might, on some occasions, supply the want of historical materials.
自腓力(Philip)主持那场盛大的百年赛会,到加里恩努斯皇帝驾崩,其间横亘着二十年的耻辱与不幸。这段岁月苦难深重:没有哪一刻不曾留下蛮族入侵与军人僭主的印记,罗马世界没有哪一个行省不曾遭其蹂躏;倾颓的帝国,仿佛正逼近土崩瓦解、无可挽回的最后关头。时局纷乱,信而有征的史料又寥寥无几,史家想要理出一条清晰连贯、首尾不断的叙述,这两重障碍同样棘手。他所能凭借的,不过是些残缺的断片,无不失之简略,往往晦涩,有时还彼此矛盾;他只得搜集、比对、推断。推断固然万不可与事实等量齐观,然而通晓人性、深知那些狂暴而无所羁勒的激情必将如何发作,有时倒也足以弥补史料之不足。
¶
There is not, for instance, any difficulty in conceiving, that the successive murders of so many emperors had loosened all the ties of allegiance between the prince and people; that all the generals of Philip were disposed to imitate the example of their master; and that the caprice of armies, long since habituated to frequent and violent revolutions, might every day raise to the throne the most obscure of their fellow-soldiers. History can only add, that the rebellion against the emperor Philip broke out in the summer of the year two hundred and forty-nine, among the legions of Mæsia; and that a subaltern officer, 1 named Marinus, was the object of their seditious choice. Philip was alarmed. He dreaded lest the treason of the Mæsian army should prove the first spark of a general conflagration. Distracted with the consciousness of his guilt and of his danger, he communicated the intelligence to the senate. A gloomy silence prevailed, the effect of fear, and perhaps of disaffection; till at length Decius, one of the assembly, assuming a spirit worthy of his noble extraction, ventured to discover more intrepidity than the emperor seemed to possess. He treated the whole business with contempt, as a hasty and inconsiderate tumult, and Philip’s rival as a phantom of royalty, who in a very few days would be destroyed by the same inconstancy that had created him. The speedy completion of the prophecy inspired Philip with a just esteem for so able a counsellor; and Decius appeared to him the only person capable of restoring peace and discipline to an army whose tumultuous spirit did not immediately subside after the murder of Marinus. Decius, 2 who long resisted his own nomination, seems to have insinuated the danger of presenting a leader of merit to the angry and apprehensive minds of the soldiers; and his prediction was again confirmed by the event. The legions of Mæsia forced their judge to become their accomplice. They left him only the alternative of death or the purple. His subsequent conduct, after that decisive measure, was unavoidable. He conducted, or followed, his army to the confines of Italy, whither Philip, collecting all his force to repel the formidable competitor whom he had raised up, advanced to meet him. The Imperial troops were superior in number; but the rebels formed an army of veterans, commanded by an able and experienced leader. Philip was either killed in the battle, or put to death a few days afterwards at Verona. His son and associate in the empire was massacred at Rome by the Prætorian guards; and the victorious Decius, with more favorable circumstances than the ambition of that age can usually plead, was universally acknowledged by the senate and provinces. It is reported, that, immediately after his reluctant acceptance of the title of Augustus, he had assured Philip, by a private message, of his innocence and loyalty, solemnly protesting, that, on his arrival on Italy, he would resign the Imperial ornaments, and return to the condition of an obedient subject. His professions might be sincere; but in the situation where fortune had placed him, it was scarcely possible that he could either forgive or be forgiven. 3
譬如说,有些事推想起来毫无难处:接连有那么多皇帝惨遭弑杀,君民之间的效忠纽带早已松弛殆尽;腓力麾下的将领,个个都想效法主上当年的榜样;军队久已习于频繁而暴烈的政变,一时兴之所至,随时都可能把同袍中最默默无闻的人拥上皇位。史家所能补充的,仅止于此:公元 249 年夏,默西亚(Mæsia)诸军团中爆发了反抗腓力皇帝的叛乱;被这群哗变者拥立为首的,是一名叫马里努斯(Marinus)的下级军官。1腓力大为惊慌,唯恐默西亚军团这一叛逆,竟成燎原大火的第一星火。他自知有罪,又深感处境凶险,心乱如麻,便把这消息通报给元老院。满座一片阴郁的沉默,这是出于恐惧,或许也含着几分离心。终于,在座的德西乌斯秉着无愧于高贵门第的气概挺身而出,所显露的胆魄,连皇帝本人似乎也有所不及。他对整桩事嗤之以鼻,说这不过是一场仓促而轻率的骚动,腓力的这个对手也只是个帝王的幻影:士兵们反复无常,既能把他捧出来,不出几日也照样会把他毁掉。预言应验之速,令腓力对这位能干的谋臣生出由衷的敬重;在他看来,马里努斯虽已被杀,那支军队的骚动之气却并未随即平息,而能使其重归安宁与纪律的,唯有德西乌斯一人。腓力要派他前去,德西乌斯2却再三推辞,似乎暗示:把一位素有才干的将领,交到这群又怒又惧的士兵手里,是件危险的事;后来的事态,再度印证了他的预见。默西亚诸军团硬是逼着这位前来问罪的人,做了他们的同谋:摆在他面前的只有两条路,要么死,要么披上紫袍。既走出这决定性的一步,他此后的举动便再无回旋余地。他率领大军,或者不如说是被大军裹挟着,开赴意大利边境;腓力则倾其全力,前来迎击这个由他一手捧起、如今却令人生畏的对手。皇帝一方兵力占优,叛军却是一支老兵劲旅,又有一位干练而富于经验的统帅指挥。腓力或是死于阵中,或是数日后在维罗纳(Verona)被处死。他的儿子与他同膺帝位,在罗马被禁卫军杀害。德西乌斯得胜之后,元老院与各行省一致承认他为皇帝;比起那个时代寻常的野心家,他有更充分的理由为自己辩解。据传,他勉强接受奥古斯都尊号之后,随即私下遣人向腓力表白自己的清白与忠忱,郑重声言:一旦抵达意大利,他便交还帝王的一切徽饰,重新做一名俯首听命的臣子。他这番表白或许出于至诚;然而,命运既已把他推到这般地步,无论是他宽恕别人,还是别人宽恕他,都几乎成了不可能的事。3
¶
The emperor Decius had employed a few months in the works of peace and the administration of justice, when he was summoned to the banks of the Danube by the invasion of the Goths. This is the first considerable occasion in which history mentions that great people, who afterwards broke the Roman power, sacked the Capitol, and reigned in Gaul, Spain, and Italy. So memorable was the part which they acted in the subversion of the Western empire, that the name of Goths is frequently but improperly used as a general appellation of rude and warlike barbarism.
德西乌斯皇帝忙于治平之政、料理司法,不过数月,哥特人入侵,他便被迫赶赴多瑙河畔。这是史书首次郑重提及这个伟大的民族。日后正是他们,摧折了罗马的国力,洗劫了卡皮托利山(Capitol),并先后称雄于高卢(Gaul)、西班牙与意大利。在西部帝国的倾覆中,他们的所作所为如此令人难忘,以致“哥特”之名常被人误用,泛指一切粗野好战的蛮风。
¶
In the beginning of the sixth century, and after the conquest of Italy, the Goths, in possession of present greatness, very naturally indulged themselves in the prospect of past and of future glory. They wished to preserve the memory of their ancestors, and to transmit to posterity their own achievements. The principal minister of the court of Ravenna, the learned Cassiodorus, gratified the inclination of the conquerors in a Gothic history, which consisted of twelve books, now reduced to the imperfect abridgment of Jornandes. 4 These writers passed with the most artful conciseness over the misfortunes of the nation, celebrated its successful valor, and adorned the triumph with many Asiatic trophies, that more properly belonged to the people of Scythia. On the faith of ancient songs, the uncertain, but the only memorials of barbarians, they deduced the first origin of the Goths from the vast island, or peninsula, of Scandinavia. 5 501 That extreme country of the North was not unknown to the conquerors of Italy: the ties of ancient consanguinity had been strengthened by recent offices of friendship; and a Scandinavian king had cheerfully abdicated his savage greatness, that he might pass the remainder of his days in the peaceful and polished court of Ravenna. 6 Many vestiges, which cannot be ascribed to the arts of popular vanity, attest the ancient residence of the Goths in the countries beyond the Rhine. From the time of the geographer Ptolemy, the southern part of Sweden seems to have continued in the possession of the less enterprising remnant of the nation, and a large territory is even at present divided into east and west Gothland. During the middle ages, (from the ninth to the twelfth century,) whilst Christianity was advancing with a slow progress into the North, the Goths and the Swedes composed two distinct and sometimes hostile members of the same monarchy. 7 The latter of these two names has prevailed without extinguishing the former. The Swedes, who might well be satisfied with their own fame in arms, have, in every age, claimed the kindred glory of the Goths. In a moment of discontent against the court of Rome, Charles the Twelfth insinuated, that his victorious troops were not degenerated from their brave ancestors, who had already subdued the mistress of the world. 8
六世纪之初,哥特人既已征服意大利,正当权势鼎盛之时,自然而然沉醉于对昔日与未来荣光的遐想。他们既想让祖先的事迹不致湮没,也想把自身的功业传诸后世。拉文纳(Ravenna)宫廷的首辅大臣、博学的卡西奥多鲁斯(Cassiodorus),撰成一部十二卷的哥特史,迎合了这些征服者的心意;此书如今只剩约达尼斯(Jornandes)那部残缺的节本传世。4这些著者以极其巧妙的简笔,一笔带过民族的种种不幸,却极力称颂其克敌制胜的英勇,还把许多本应归于斯基泰人(Scythians)的亚洲战功,拿来装点哥特人的凯旋。古老的歌谣虽不足凭信,却是蛮族仅有的记忆所系;二人便据此推断,哥特人最初起源于斯堪的纳维亚(Scandinavia)那片辽阔的岛屿——或者说半岛。5 501北方那片极远之地,对征服意大利的哥特人来说并不陌生:远古的血缘之亲,因近来友好的往来而愈加牢固;曾有一位斯堪的纳维亚国王,欣然抛下自己那份蛮荒的尊荣,只为在拉文纳这平和而文雅的宫廷中安度余生。6有许多遗迹可以证明,哥特人古时确曾居于莱茵河彼岸诸地;这些遗迹,绝不是民间出于虚荣所能伪造的。自地理学家托勒密的时代起,这个民族中进取心稍逊的一支遗民,似乎便一直据有瑞典南部;直到今日,那里仍有一大片地域分作东哥得兰与西哥得兰。中世纪时(九世纪至十二世纪),基督教正缓缓向北方推进;那时哥特人与瑞典人(Swedes)同属一个王国,却是各自独立的两部分,有时还彼此为敌。7两个名号之中,后者终占了上风,却也未能使前者之名湮灭。瑞典人本大可满足于自家的赫赫武名,却世世代代都要攀认哥特人那份同宗的荣耀。查理十二世(Charles the Twelfth)有一回对罗马教廷心怀不满,便意有所指地说:他麾下那支百战百胜的军队,比起英勇的先祖来丝毫不曾退化,而这些先祖早就征服过“世界的主宰”罗马。8
¶
Till the end of the eleventh century, a celebrated temple subsisted at Upsal, the most considerable town of the Swedes and Goths. It was enriched with the gold which the Scandinavians had acquired in their piratical adventures, and sanctified by the uncouth representations of the three principal deities, the god of war, the goddess of generation, and the god of thunder. In the general festival, that was solemnized every ninth year, nine animals of every species (without excepting the human) were sacrificed, and their bleeding bodies suspended in the sacred grove adjacent to the temple. 9 The only traces that now subsist of this barbaric superstition are contained in the Edda, 901 a system of mythology, compiled in Iceland about the thirteenth century, and studied by the learned of Denmark and Sweden, as the most valuable remains of their ancient traditions.
¶
Notwithstanding the mysterious obscurity of the Edda, we can easily distinguish two persons confounded under the name of Odin; the god of war, and the great legislator of Scandinavia. The latter, the Mahomet of the North, instituted a religion adapted to the climate and to the people. Numerous tribes on either side of the Baltic were subdued by the invincible valor of Odin, by his persuasive eloquence, and by the fame which he acquired of a most skilful magician. The faith that he had propagated, during a long and prosperous life, he confirmed by a voluntary death. Apprehensive of the ignominious approach of disease and infirmity, he resolved to expire as became a warrior. In a solemn assembly of the Swedes and Goths, he wounded himself in nine mortal places, hastening away (as he asserted with his dying voice) to prepare the feast of heroes in the palace of the God of war. 10
《埃达》虽神秘晦涩,我们仍不难辨出:混于“奥丁(Odin)”一名之下的,其实是两个人——一位是战神,一位则是斯堪的纳维亚伟大的立法者。后者堪称北方的穆罕默德,创立了一套与当地风土人情相宜的宗教。奥丁凭着所向无敌的勇武、动人的辩才,以及绝顶巫师的盛名,降服了波罗的海两岸无数部落。他一生长寿而显达,其间广布这套信仰;临终又以自戕之举,为这信仰再作印证。他唯恐疾病与衰朽缠身,死得不体面,便决意像一名战士那样死去。在瑞典人与哥特人的一次庄严集会上,他刺伤自己身上九处要害,临终时声言:他这是要赶往战神的殿堂,为英灵们备下盛宴。10
¶
The native and proper habitation of Odin is distinguished by the appellation of As-gard. The happy resemblance of that name with As-burg, or As-of, 11 words of a similar signification, has given rise to an historical system of so pleasing a contexture, that we could almost wish to persuade ourselves of its truth. It is supposed that Odin was the chief of a tribe of barbarians which dwelt on the banks of the Lake Mæotis, till the fall of Mithridates and the arms of Pompey menaced the North with servitude. That Odin, yielding with indignant fury to a power he was unable to resist, conducted his tribe from the frontiers of the Asiatic Sarmatia into Sweden, with the great design of forming, in that inaccessible retreat of freedom, a religion and a people which, in some remote age, might be subservient to his immortal revenge; when his invincible Goths, armed with martial fanaticism, should issue in numerous swarms from the neighborhood of the Polar circle, to chastise the oppressors of mankind. 12
奥丁真正的故乡,名叫阿斯加德(As-gard)。这个名字恰好与地名“As-burg”或“As-of”11相似,含义也相近;由此衍生出一套历史假说,编织得如此动人,我们几乎想说服自己信以为真。据这套说法,奥丁本是一支蛮族部落的首领,部落原居于迈奥提斯湖(Lake Mæotis)畔;后来米特拉达梯(Mithridates)败亡,庞培兵锋所向,北方眼看就要沦于奴役。奥丁自知无力抵挡这股势力,只得含愤屈服,率部众从亚洲萨尔马提亚的边地迁入瑞典。他胸怀一桩宏图:要在那片外人难以踏足、自由得以保全的隐僻之地,缔造出一种宗教、一个民族,好在遥远的将来替他报这永世难消的仇。到那时,他那所向无敌的哥特人将挟着尚武的狂热,从北极圈附近成群结队地涌出,去惩罚那些压迫天下的人。12
¶
If so many successive generations of Goths were capable of preserving a faint tradition of their Scandinavian origin, we must not expect, from such unlettered barbarians, any distinct account of the time and circumstances of their emigration. To cross the Baltic was an easy and natural attempt. The inhabitants of Sweden were masters of a sufficient number of large vessels, with oars, 13 and the distance is little more than one hundred miles from Carlscroon to the nearest ports of Pomerania and Prussia. Here, at length, we land on firm and historic ground. At least as early as the Christian æra, 14 and as late as the age of the Antonines, 15 the Goths were established towards the mouth of the Vistula, and in that fertile province where the commercial cities of Thorn, Elbing, Köningsberg, and Dantzick, were long afterwards founded. 16 Westward of the Goths, the numerous tribes of the Vandals were spread along the banks of the Oder, and the sea-coast of Pomerania and Mecklenburgh. A striking resemblance of manners, complexion, religion, and language, seemed to indicate that the Vandals and the Goths were originally one great people. 17 The latter appear to have been subdivided into Ostrogoths, Visigoths, and Gepidæ. 18 The distinction among the Vandals was more strongly marked by the independent names of Heruli, Burgundians, Lombards, and a variety of other petty states, many of which, in a future age, expanded themselves into powerful monarchies. 181
哥特人历经这许多世代,尚能依稀记得自己源出斯堪的纳维亚;但要指望这些目不识丁的蛮族,把迁徙的年代与情形讲得清清楚楚,那是万万不能的。渡过波罗的海,本是轻而易举、顺理成章之事。瑞典居民拥有足够多带桨的大船,13而从卡尔斯克鲁纳(Carlscroon)到波美拉尼亚(Pomerania)和普鲁士(Prussia)最近的港口,相距也不过一百英里出头。至此,我们总算踏上了坚实可靠、有史可稽的土地。至迟在基督纪元之初,14直到安敦尼诸帝(Antonines)的时代,15哥特人一直定居在维斯瓦河(Vistula)口一带那片富饶的土地上——日后托伦(Thorn)、埃尔宾(Elbing)、柯尼斯堡(Köningsberg)、但泽(Dantzick)这几座商业城市,便建立在那里。16哥特人以西,汪达尔人(Vandals)的众多部落散布在奥得河(Oder)两岸,以及波美拉尼亚和梅克伦堡(Mecklenburgh)的沿海一带。两族在习俗、肤色、宗教与语言上惊人地相似,这似乎表明汪达尔人与哥特人本是同一个伟大民族。17哥特人似乎又分作东哥特人(Ostrogoths)、西哥特人(Visigoths)与格皮德人三支。18汪达尔人内部的分野则更为鲜明,各支各有其名号,如赫鲁利人(Heruli)、勃艮第人(Burgundians)、伦巴第人(Lombards),此外还有形形色色的小邦;其中不少,日后都膨胀成了强大的王国。181
¶
In the age of the Antonines, the Goths were still seated in Prussia. About the reign of Alexander Severus, the Roman province of Dacia had already experienced their proximity by frequent and destructive inroads. 19 In this interval, therefore, of about seventy years we must place the second migration of the Goths from the Baltic to the Euxine; but the cause that produced it lies concealed among the various motives which actuate the conduct of unsettled barbarians. Either a pestilence or a famine, a victory or a defeat, an oracle of the gods or the eloquence of a daring leader, were sufficient to impel the Gothic arms on the milder climates of the south. Besides the influence of a martial religion, the numbers and spirit of the Goths were equal to the most dangerous adventures. The use of round bucklers and short swords rendered them formidable in a close engagement; the manly obedience which they yielded to hereditary kings, gave uncommon union and stability to their councils; 20 and the renowned Amala, the hero of that age, and the tenth ancestor of Theodoric, king of Italy, enforced, by the ascendant of personal merit, the prerogative of his birth, which he derived from the Anses, or demigods of the Gothic nation. 21
在安敦尼诸帝的时代,哥特人仍居于普鲁士。约在亚历山大·塞维鲁(Alexander Severus)在位期间,罗马的达契亚(Dacia)行省已屡遭他们侵扰,损毁惨重,领教了这个近邻的厉害。19由此推算,哥特人从波罗的海向黑海的第二次迁徙,必发生在这大约七十年之间;但居无定所的蛮族行事,动机本就多种多样,这次迁徙因何而起,便隐没其中,难以究诘。无论是一场瘟疫或饥荒,一次胜仗或败仗,一道神谕,抑或某位大胆首领的雄辩之辞,都足以驱使哥特人的兵锋,转向南方那气候较为温和的地带。哥特人除了有尚武宗教的鼓舞,论人数、论锐气,也都足以胜任最凶险的远征。他们惯用圆盾与短剑,近身搏战时令人生畏;他们服从世袭的君王,又不失男儿气概,因而议事异常齐心、稳固。20声名显赫的阿马拉(Amala),是他那个时代的英雄,也是意大利国王狄奥多里克(Theodoric)的第十代先祖。他生来便享有尊贵的特权,血统出自哥特民族的半神,即所谓安瑟斯(Anses)(Anses);而他又以个人才德的威望,巩固了这份与生俱来的特权。21
¶
The fame of a great enterprise excited the bravest warriors from all the Vandalic states of Germany, many of whom are seen a few years afterwards combating under the common standard of the Goths. 22 The first motions of the emigrants carried them to the banks of the Prypec, a river universally conceived by the ancients to be the southern branch of the Borysthenes. 23 The windings of that great stream through the plains of Poland and Russia gave a direction to their line of march, and a constant supply of fresh water and pasturage to their numerous herds of cattle. They followed the unknown course of the river, confident in their valor, and careless of whatever power might oppose their progress. The Bastarnæ and the Venedi were the first who presented themselves; and the flower of their youth, either from choice or compulsion, increased the Gothic army. The Bastarnæ dwelt on the northern side of the Carpathian Mountains: the immense tract of land that separated the Bastarnæ from the savages of Finland was possessed, or rather wasted, by the Venedi; 24 we have some reason to believe that the first of these nations, which distinguished itself in the Macedonian war, 25 and was afterwards divided into the formidable tribes of the Peucini, the Borani, the Carpi, &c., derived its origin from the Germans. 251 With better authority, a Sarmatian extraction may be assigned to the Venedi, who rendered themselves so famous in the middle ages. 26 But the confusion of blood and manners on that doubtful frontier often perplexed the most accurate observers. 27 As the Goths advanced near the Euxine Sea, they encountered a purer race of Sarmatians, the Jazyges, the Alani, 271 and the Roxolani; and they were probably the first Germans who saw the mouths of the Borysthenes, and of the Tanais. If we inquire into the characteristic marks of the people of Germany and of Sarmatia, we shall discover that those two great portions of human kind were principally distinguished by fixed huts or movable tents, by a close dress or flowing garments, by the marriage of one or of several wives, by a military force, consisting, for the most part, either of infantry or cavalry; and above all, by the use of the Teutonic, or of the Sclavonian language; the last of which has been diffused by conquest, from the confines of Italy to the neighborhood of Japan.
一场宏大征伐声名远播,日耳曼全境汪达尔诸邦最勇猛的战士都为之奋起;数年之后,便可见其中许多人聚在哥特人的旗帜之下,并肩作战。22这些迁徙者先是来到普里佩茨河(Prypec)畔;古人普遍认为,这条河是博里斯提尼斯河(Borysthenes)的南支。23这条大河蜿蜒流过波兰与俄罗斯的平原,既为他们的行军指明了方向,又为其成群的牛畜源源不断地供给淡水与草场。他们凭着一腔勇武,沿这条陌生的河道一路前行,全然不把任何可能阻挡他们的势力放在心上。最先与他们遭遇的,是巴斯塔尔奈人(Bastarnæ)与维内迪人(Venedi);这两族的青年精锐,或出于自愿,或迫于胁迫,加入哥特大军,使其愈发壮大。巴斯塔尔奈人居于喀尔巴阡山脉(Carpathian Mountains)的北麓;而在他们与芬兰(Finland)的野人之间,横亘着一大片辽阔的土地,为维内迪人所占据——或者不如说,是被他们糟蹋着。24两族之中,巴斯塔尔奈人曾在马其顿战争中崭露头角,25后来又分成佩夫基尼人(Peucini)、博拉尼人(Borani)、卡尔皮人(Carpi)等多个强悍的部落;我们不无理由相信,这个民族源出日耳曼人。251至于在中世纪声名大噪的维内迪人,把他们的血统追溯到萨尔马提亚人(Sarmatians),则更有根据。26然而,在那片界限暧昧的边地上,血统与习俗混杂难辨,纵是最精细的观察者,也每每为之困惑。27哥特人挺进到黑海附近,遇上了血统更为纯正的萨尔马提亚人——雅济格斯人(Jazyges)、阿兰人(Alani)271与罗克索拉尼人(Roxolani);而最早见到博里斯提尼斯河与塔奈斯河(Tanais)入海口的日耳曼人,大概也正是这些哥特人。若探究日耳曼人与萨尔马提亚人各自的特征,便会发现,人类这两大族类的区别主要在于:住的是固定的木屋还是可移动的帐篷,穿的是紧身衣还是宽袍,行的是一夫一妻还是一夫多妻,军队的主力是步兵还是骑兵;而尤其在于说的是条顿语还是斯拉夫语。斯拉夫语凭借征服广为流布,从意大利边境一直传到日本附近。
Notes 注释
1
↩
The expression used by Zosimus and Zonaras may signify that Marinus commanded a century, a cohort, or a legion.
佐西莫斯(Zosimus)与佐纳拉斯(Zonaras)所用的措辞,或可指马里努斯统领的是一个百人队、一个步兵大队,抑或一整个军团。
2
↩
His birth at Bubalia, a little village in Pannonia, (Eutrop. ix. Victor. in Cæsarib. et Epitom.,) seems to contradict, unless it was merely accidental, his supposed descent from the Decii. Six hundred years had bestowed nobility on the Decii: but at the commencement of that period, they were only plebeians of merit, and among the first who shared the consulship with the haughty patricians. Plebeine Deciorum animæ, &c. Juvenal, Sat. viii. 254. See the spirited speech of Decius, in Livy. x. 9, 10.
他生于潘诺尼亚(Pannonia)一座名叫布巴利亚(Bubalia)的小村(Eutrop. ix. Victor. in Cæsarib. et Epitom.);除非他只是碰巧生在那里,否则此事似乎与他出自德西乌斯家族的传说相抵牾。德西乌斯家族的显贵门第,是六百年岁月赋予的;而在这六百年之初,他们不过是些有德望的平民,是最早一批与高傲的贵族分享执政官之位的人。“Plebeiæ Deciorum animæ”(德西乌斯家族出身平民的魂灵,云云),语出尤维纳利斯(Juvenal)《讽刺诗集》第八首第 254 行(Juvenal, Sat. viii. 254)。另见李维笔下德西乌斯那篇慷慨激昂的演说(Livy. x. 9, 10)。
3
↩
Zosimus, l. i. p. 20, c. 22. Zonaras, l. xii. p. 624, edit. Louvre.
见 Zosimus, l. i. p. 20, c. 22;Zonaras, l. xii. p. 624, edit. Louvre。
4
↩
See the prefaces of Cassiodorus and Jornandes; it is surprising that the latter should be omitted in the excellent edition, published by Grotius, of the Gothic writers.
参见卡西奥多鲁斯与约达尼斯各自所作的序言;令人诧异的是,格劳秀斯(Grotius)所刊行的那部出色的哥特著者文集,竟把约达尼斯遗漏了。
5
↩
On the authority of Ablavius, Jornandes quotes some old Gothic chronicles in verse. De Reb. Geticis, c. 4.
约达尼斯依据阿布拉维乌斯(Ablavius)的记述,引用了几种古老的哥特韵文编年史。见 De Reb. Geticis, c. 4。
501
↩
The Goths have inhabited Scandinavia, but it was not their original habitation. This great nation was anciently of the Suevian race; it occupied, in the time of Tacitus, and long before, Mecklenburgh, Pomerania Southern Prussia and the north-west of Poland. A little before the birth of J. C., and in the first years of that century, they belonged to the kingdom of Marbod, king of the Marcomanni: but Cotwalda, a young Gothic prince, delivered them from that tyranny, and established his own power over the kingdom of the Marcomanni, already much weakened by the victories of Tiberius. The power of the Goths at that time must have been great: it was probably from them that the Sinus Codanus (the Baltic) took this name, as it was afterwards called Mare Suevicum, and Mare Venedicum, during the superiority of the proper Suevi and the Venedi. The epoch in which the Goths passed into Scandinavia is unknown. See Adelung, Hist. of Anc. Germany, p. 200. Gatterer, Hist. Univ. 458.—G. ——M. St. Martin observes, that the Scandinavian descent of the Goths rests on the authority of Jornandes, who professed to derive it from the traditions of the Goths. He is supported by Procopius and Paulus Diaconus. Yet the Goths are unquestionably the same with the Getæ of the earlier historians. St. Martin, note on Le Beau, Hist. du bas Empire, iii. 324. The identity of the Getæ and Goths is by no means generally admitted. On the whole, they seem to be one vast branch of the Indo-Teutonic race, who spread irregularly towards the north of Europe, and at different periods, and in different regions, came in contact with the more civilized nations of the south. At this period, there seems to have been a reflux of these Gothic tribes from the North. Malte Brun considers that there are strong grounds for receiving the Islandic traditions commented by the Danish Varro, M. Suhm. From these, and the voyage of Pytheas, which Malte Brun considers genuine, the Goths were in possession of Scandinavia, Ey-Gothland, 250 years before J. C., and of a tract on the continent (Reid-Gothland) between the mouths of the Vistula and the Oder. In their southern migration, they followed the course of the Vistula; afterwards, of the Dnieper. Malte Brun, Geogr. i. p. 387, edit. 1832. Geijer, the historian of Sweden, ably maintains the Scandinavian origin of the Goths. The Gothic language, according to Bopp, is the link between the Sanscrit and the modern Teutonic dialects: “I think that I am reading Sanscrit when I am reading Olphilas.” Bopp, Conjugations System der Sanscrit Sprache, preface, p. x—M.
哥特人确曾居于斯堪的纳维亚,但那并非其最初的居所。这个伟大的民族古时属于苏维汇族;在塔西佗的时代乃至更早,他们占据着梅克伦堡、波美拉尼亚、南普鲁士以及波兰的西北部。约在基督诞生前不久及公元最初的几年间,他们受马科曼尼人(Marcomanni)之王马尔博德(Marbod)统治;后来年轻的哥特王子卡特瓦尔达(Cotwalda)把他们从这一暴政下解救出来,又进而把马科曼尼(Marcomannic)王国置于自己的权势之下,而这个王国此前已因提比略(Tiberius)连战连捷,大为削弱。当时哥特人的势力想必十分强盛:Sinus Codanus(即波罗的海)之名,大概便得自他们;正如后来在苏维汇人(Suevi)本部与维内迪人各擅其势时,此海又相继被称作 Mare Suevicum 与 Mare Venedicum。哥特人迁入斯堪的纳维亚的确切年代,已不可考。参见 Adelung, Hist. of Anc. Germany, p. 200;Gatterer, Hist. Univ. 458。—G——圣马丁(St. Martin)先生指出,哥特人源出斯堪的纳维亚一说,实据约达尼斯之言,而约达尼斯自称此说本于哥特人的传统。普罗柯比(Procopius)与执事保罗(Paulus Diaconus)亦持此论。但圣马丁又认为,哥特人无疑就是早期史家笔下的格泰人(Getæ)。见圣马丁为勒博(Beau)《晚期帝国史》所作之注(Le Beau, Hist. du bas Empire, iii. 324)。格泰人与哥特人是否同族,绝非人人认可。大体而言,他们似乎同属印度-条顿(Indo-Teutonic)人种下一个庞大的分支;这一分支向欧洲北部扩散,并无定规,在不同时期、不同地域,与南方较为文明的民族有过接触。而在正文所述的这一时期,这些哥特部落似乎正从北方回流南下。马尔特-布伦(Malte Brun)认为,苏姆(Suhm)先生素有“丹麦的瓦罗(Varro)”之称,他所笺释的那些冰岛传说,有充分的理由可以采信。据这些传说,再加上皮西亚斯(Pytheas)的航行记录(马尔特-布伦视之为真实可信),早在公元前 250 年,哥特人便已占有斯堪的纳维亚(Ey-Gothland),以及大陆上维斯瓦河口与奥得河口之间的一片地带(Reid-Gothland)。他们南迁时,先是沿维斯瓦河而行,其后又循第聂伯河(Dnieper)南下。见 Malte Brun, Geogr. i. p. 387, edit. 1832。瑞典史家盖耶尔(Geijer)有力地论证了哥特人源出斯堪的纳维亚之说。据波普(Bopp)所言,哥特语是梵语与近代条顿诸方言之间的纽带:“每当读乌尔菲拉斯(Olphilas)的文字,我便觉得自己是在读梵语。”见 Bopp, Conjugations System der Sanscrit Sprache, preface, p. x。—M
6
↩
Jornandes, c. 3.
Jornandes, c. 3.
7
↩
See in the Prolegomena of Grotius some large extracts from Adam of Bremen, and Saxo-Grammaticus. The former wrote in the year 1077, the latter flourished about the year 1200.
参见格劳秀斯《绪论》中所辑不来梅的亚当(Adam of Bremen)与萨克索·格拉玛提库斯(Saxo-Grammaticus)的若干大段引文。前者写作于 1077 年,后者约活跃于 1200 年前后。
8
↩
Voltaire, Histoire de Charles XII. l. iii. When the Austrians desired the aid of the court of Rome against Gustavus Adolphus, they always represented that conqueror as the lineal successor of Alaric. Harte’s History of Gustavus, vol. ii. p. 123.
见伏尔泰《查理十二世史》第三卷(Voltaire, Histoire de Charles XII. l. iii.)。奥地利人请求罗马教廷助其对抗古斯塔夫·阿道夫(Gustavus Adolphus)时,总把这位征服者说成是阿拉里克(Alaric)的嫡系后裔。见 Harte's History of Gustavus, vol. ii. p. 123。
9
↩
See Adam of Bremen in Grotii Prolegomenis, p. 105. The temple of Upsal was destroyed by Ingo, king of Sweden, who began his reign in the year 1075, and about fourscore years afterwards, a Christian cathedral was erected on its ruins. See Dalin’s History of Sweden, in the Bibliotheque Raisonee.
参见格劳秀斯《绪论》中所引不来梅的亚当,p. 105。乌普萨拉的神庙毁于瑞典国王英戈(Ingo)之手(英戈于 1075 年即位);约八十年后,一座基督教座堂在神庙的废墟上拔地而起。见 Dalin's History of Sweden,载《Bibliotheque Raisonee》。
901
↩
The Eddas have at length been made accessible to European scholars by the completion of the publication of the Sæmundine Edda by the Arna Magnæan Commission, in 3 vols. 4to., with a copious lexicon of northern mythology.—M.
阿尔纳·马格努斯委员会(Arna Magnæan Commission)出齐了三卷四开本的《塞蒙德埃达(Sæmundine Edda)》,并附有一部详备的北欧神话辞典,欧洲学者至此终于得以一窥《埃达》诸篇。—M
10
↩
Mallet, Introduction a l’Histoire du Dannemarc.
Mallet, Introduction a l'Histoire du Dannemarc.
11
↩
Mallet, c. iv. p. 55, has collected from Strabo, Pliny, Ptolemy, and Stephanus Byzantinus, the vestiges of such a city and people.
马莱(Mallet)在其书第四章 p. 55,从斯特拉波(Strabo)、普林尼、托勒密与拜占庭的斯特凡努斯(Stephanus Byzantinus)诸家中,搜罗出这样一座城市与一个民族存在过的蛛丝马迹。
12
↩
This wonderful expedition of Odin, which, by deducting the enmity of the Goths and Romans from so memorable a cause, might supply the noble groundwork of an epic poem, cannot safely be received as authentic history. According to the obvious sense of the Edda, and the interpretation of the most skilful critics, As-gard, instead of denoting a real city of the Asiatic Sarmatia, is the fictitious appellation of the mystic abode of the gods, the Olympus of Scandinavia; from whence the prophet was supposed to descend, when he announced his new religion to the Gothic nations, who were already seated in the southern parts of Sweden. * Note: A curious letter may be consulted on this subject from the Swede, Ihre counsellor in the Chancery of Upsal, printed at Upsal by Edman, in 1772 and translated into German by M. Schlozer. Gottingen, printed for Dietericht, 1779.—G. ——Gibbon, at a later period of his work, recanted his opinion of the truth of this expedition of Odin. The Asiatic origin of the Goths is almost certain from the affinity of their language to the Sanscrit and Persian; but their northern writers, when all mythology was reduced to hero worship.—M.
奥丁这场奇异的远征,让哥特人与罗马人的世仇有了如此一段令人难忘的缘起,本可为一部史诗提供高贵的底本;当作信史,却断不可轻信。按《埃达》显而易见的文义,并据最高明的评家所释,阿斯加德所指并非亚洲萨尔马提亚(Sarmatia)一座实有的城市,而是众神神秘居所的虚构名称,即斯堪的纳维亚的奥林匹斯;据说那位先知便是从那里降临,向早已定居瑞典南部的哥特诸族宣示他新创的宗教。* 编者按:关于此题,可参见一封饶有趣味的信,出自瑞典人伊勒(Ihre)——乌普萨拉文书院的参事——之手,1772 年由埃德曼印行于乌普萨拉,后经施勒策尔(Schlozer)先生译成德文,1779 年于哥廷根(Gottingen)由迪特里希印行。—G——吉本在其著作的较晚部分,收回了自己关于奥丁此次远征确有其事的看法。哥特人源出亚洲,由其语言与梵语、波斯语的亲缘关系看来,几乎可以断定;然而他们的北方著者,当一切神话都被归结为对英雄的崇拜之时……—M
13
↩
Tacit. Germania, c. 44.
Tacit. Germania, c. 44.
14
↩
Tacit. Annal. ii. 62. If we could yield a firm assent to the navigations of Pytheas of Marseilles, we must allow that the Goths had passed the Baltic at least three hundred years before Christ.
Tacit. Annal. ii. 62。倘若我们能确信马赛(Marseilles)的皮西亚斯的航行属实,便不得不承认:哥特人至迟在公元前 300 年便已渡过波罗的海。
15
↩
Ptolemy, l. ii.
Ptolemy, l. ii.
16
↩
By the German colonies who followed the arms of the Teutonic knights. The conquest and conversion of Prussia were completed by those adventurers in the thirteenth century.
这些城市,是随条顿骑士(Teutonic knights)团武力而来的德意志移民所建。正是这些冒险者,在十三世纪最终征服了普鲁士,并使之皈依基督教。
17
↩
Pliny (Hist. Natur. iv. 14) and Procopius (in Bell. Vandal. l. i. c. l) agree in this opinion. They lived in distant ages, and possessed different means of investigating the truth.
普林尼(Hist. Natur. iv. 14)与普罗柯比(in Bell. Vandal. l. i. c. l)在此看法上一致。二人相隔的年代甚远,探求真相所凭借的手段也各不相同。
18
↩
The Ostro and Visi, the eastern and western Goths, obtained those denominations from their original seats in Scandinavia. In all their future marches and settlements they preserved, with their names, the same relative situation. When they first departed from Sweden, the infant colony was contained in three vessels. The third, being a heavy sailer, lagged behind, and the crew, which afterwards swelled into a nation, received from that circumstance the appellation of Gepidæ or Loiterers. Jornandes, c. 17. * Note: It was not in Scandinavia that the Goths were divided into Ostrogoths and Visigoths; that division took place after their irruption into Dacia in the third century: those who came from Mecklenburgh and Pomerania were called Visigoths; those who came from the south of Prussia, and the northwest of Poland, called themselves Ostrogoths. Adelung, Hist. All. p. 202 Gatterer, Hist. Univ. 431.—G.
“Ostro”与“Visi”,即东哥特人与西哥特人,这两个名号得自他们在斯堪的纳维亚最初的居地。此后无论迁往何处、在哪里定居,他们都保留着原来的名号,彼此的相对方位也始终不变。当年他们初离瑞典时,这支尚在襁褓中的移民队伍只装了三条船。第三条船航速迟缓,落在了后面;船上那批人便因此得名格皮德人(Gepidæ),意为“迟缓者”,日后繁衍成了一个民族。见约达尼斯 c. 17。* 编者按:哥特人分为东哥特人与西哥特人,并不是在斯堪的纳维亚,而是在三世纪他们侵入达契亚之后:由梅克伦堡、波美拉尼亚而来者,称西哥特人;由普鲁士南部、波兰西北部而来者,则自称东哥特人。见 Adelung, Hist. All. p. 202;Gatterer, Hist. Univ. 431。—G
181
↩
This opinion is by no means probable. The Vandals and the Goths equally belonged to the great division of the Suevi, but the two tribes were very different. Those who have treated on this part of history, appear to me to have neglected to remark that the ancients almost always gave the name of the dominant and conquering people to all the weaker and conquered races. So Pliny calls Vindeli, Vandals, all the people of the north-east of Europe, because at that epoch the Vandals were doubtless the conquering tribe. Cæsar, on the contrary, ranges under the name of Suevi, many of the tribes whom Pliny reckons as Vandals, because the Suevi, properly so called, were then the most powerful tribe in Germany. When the Goths, become in their turn conquerors, had subjugated the nations whom they encountered on their way, these nations lost their name with their liberty, and became of Gothic origin. The Vandals themselves were then considered as Goths; the Heruli, the Gepidæ, &c., suffered the same fate. A common origin was thus attributed to tribes who had only been united by the conquests of some dominant nation, and this confusion has given rise to a number of historical errors.—G. ——M. St. Martin has a learned note (to Le Beau, v. 261) on the origin of the Vandals. The difficulty appears to be in rejecting the close analogy of the name with the Vend or Wendish race, who were of Sclavonian, not of Suevian or German, origin. M. St. Martin supposes that the different races spread from the head of the Adriatic to the Baltic, and even the Veneti, on the shores of the Adriatic, the Vindelici, the tribes which gave their name to Vindobena, Vindoduna, Vindonissa, were branches of the same stock with the Sclavonian Venedi, who at one time gave their name to the Baltic; that they all spoke dialects of the Wendish language, which still prevails in Carinthia, Carniola, part of Bohemia, and Lusatia, and is hardly extinct in Mecklenburgh and Pomerania. The Vandal race, once so fearfully celebrated in the annals of mankind, has so utterly perished from the face of the earth, that we are not aware that any vestiges of their language can be traced, so as to throw light on the disputed question of their German, their Sclavonian, or independent origin. The weight of ancient authority seems against M. St. Martin’s opinion. Compare, on the Vandals, Malte Brun. 394. Also Gibbon’s note, c. xli. n. 38.—M.
此说绝无可能。汪达尔人与哥特人同属苏维汇这一大支,但两个部族其实大不相同。凡论及这段历史的人,在我看来都忽略了一点:古人几乎总是把占统治地位、征服他人的那个民族之名,加诸一切较弱的、被征服的族类之上。故而普林尼把欧洲东北部的所有民族统称为温迪利人(Vindeli)(即汪达尔人),只因那个时代汪达尔人无疑是征服者的部落。恺撒则反其道而行,把许多被普林尼算作汪达尔人的部族归入苏维汇人名下,只因当时严格意义上的苏维汇人才是日耳曼最强盛的部族。及至哥特人转而成为征服者,把沿途所遇的各族一一制服,这些民族便连同自由一并失去了自己的名号,摇身变作哥特族裔。于是汪达尔人自己也被视为哥特人;赫鲁利人、格皮德人等等,也都遭遇同样的命运。这样一来,本不过因某个统治民族的征服而聚合到一起的诸部族,竟被硬安上一个共同的起源,由此混淆,遂酿成史书上许多讹误。—G——圣马丁先生为汪达尔人的起源写有一条博学的注(见勒博书 v. 261)。其难处似乎在于:汪达尔(Vandal)之名与文德(Vend)或文德族之名极为相近,令人难以断然否认二者的关联,而文德族属斯拉夫血统,并非苏维汇或日耳曼血统。圣马丁先生推想,从亚得里亚海顶端到波罗的海一带的各族,都与斯拉夫的维内迪人同出一源,其中甚至包括亚得里亚海沿岸的威尼提人(Veneti)、温德利基人,以及温多博纳、温多杜纳(Vindoduna)、温多尼萨(Vindonissa)等地因之得名的那些部落;波罗的海也曾一度以维内迪人为名。他还推想,这些部族说的都是文德语的各种方言,这种语言至今仍通行于卡林西亚(Carinthia)、卡尼奥拉(Carniola)、波希米亚(Bohemia)的一部分以及卢萨蒂亚(Lusatia),在梅克伦堡和波美拉尼亚也尚未完全绝迹。汪达尔这个种族,昔日在人类史册上曾令人闻之色变,如今却已从世上消亡得如此彻底,据我们所知,连他们语言的一点遗迹也无从寻觅;他们究属日耳曼、斯拉夫,还是自成一系,这个聚讼纷纭的问题,也就无从借此得到澄清。古代权威的分量,似乎并不利于圣马丁先生之说。关于汪达尔人,可参较 Malte Brun. 394,另见吉本本书第四十一章注 38。—M
19
↩
See a fragment of Peter Patricius in the Excerpta Legationum and with regard to its probable date, see Tillemont, Hist, des Empereurs, tom. iii. p. 346.
参见贵族彼得(Peter Patricius)的一则残篇,载《Excerpta Legationum》;至于其大致年代,参见 Tillemont, Hist. des Empereurs, tom. iii. p. 346。
20
↩
Omnium harum gentium insigne, rotunda scuta, breves gladii, et erga rages obsequium. Tacit. Germania, c. 43. The Goths probably acquired their iron by the commerce of amber.
“Omnium harum gentium insigne, rotunda scuta, breves gladii, et erga reges obsequium.”(这一切民族的共同标志,便是圆盾、短剑,以及对君王的服从。)语出 Tacit. Germania, c. 43。哥特人的铁,大概是靠琥珀贸易换来的。
21
↩
Jornandes, c. 13, 14.
Jornandes, c. 13, 14.
22
↩
The Heruli, and the Uregundi or Burgundi, are particularly mentioned. See Mascou’s History of the Germans, l. v. A passage in the Augustan History, p. 28, seems to allude to this great emigration. The Marcomannic war was partly occasioned by the pressure of barbarous tribes, who fled before the arms of more northern barbarians.
文中特别提到了赫鲁利人以及乌雷贡迪人(Uregundi)(或作勃艮第人)。参见马斯科夫(Mascou)《日耳曼人史》第五卷。《奥古斯都史》(Augustan History)p. 28 有一段,似乎暗指这场大迁徙。马科曼尼战争的起因之一,在于蛮族部落带来的压力:这些部落为躲避更北方蛮族的兵锋,纷纷南逃。
23
↩
D’Anville, Geographie Ancienne, and the third part of his incomparable map of Europe.
见当维尔(Anville)《古代地理学》(Geographie Ancienne),以及他那幅无与伦比的欧洲地图的第三部分。
24
↩
Tacit. Germania, c. 46.
Tacit. Germania, c. 46.
25
↩
Cluver. Germ. Antiqua, l. iii. c. 43.
Cluver. Germ. Antiqua, l. iii. c. 43.
251
↩
The Bastarnæ cannot be considered original inhabitants of Germany Strabo and Tacitus appear to doubt it; Pliny alone calls them Germans: Ptolemy and Dion treat them as Scythians, a vague appellation at this period of history; Livy, Plutarch, and Diodorus Siculus, call them Gauls, and this is the most probable opinion. They descended from the Gauls who entered Germany under Signoesus. They are always found associated with other Gaulish tribes, such as the Boll, the Taurisci, &c., and not to the German tribes. The names of their chiefs or princes, Chlonix, Chlondicus. Deldon, are not German names. Those who were settled in the island of Peuce in the Danube, took the name of Peucini. The Carpi appear in 237 as a Suevian tribe who had made an irruption into Mæsia. Afterwards they reappear under the Ostrogoths, with whom they were probably blended. Adelung, p. 236, 278.—G.
巴斯塔尔奈人不能算作日耳曼的原住民:斯特拉波与塔西佗似乎对此存疑;唯独普林尼称他们为日耳曼人;托勒密与狄奥(Dion)则视之为斯基泰人——在这一历史时期,“斯基泰人”本是个笼统的称呼;李维、普鲁塔克与西西里的狄奥多罗斯(Diodorus Siculus)则称他们为高卢人(Gauls),这是最有可能的说法。他们乃是随西格诺埃苏斯(Signoesus)进入日耳曼的那批高卢人的后裔。人们总见他们与波伊人、陶里斯基人(Taurisci)等其他高卢部落为伍,而不与日耳曼诸部族相干。他们首领或王公的名字——Chlonix、Chlondicus、Deldon——都不是日耳曼名字。其中定居于多瑙河佩夫凯岛(Peuce)上的一支,得名佩夫基尼人。卡尔皮人在 237 年出现时,是一支侵入默西亚的苏维汇部落;其后又在东哥特人治下重新现身,大概已与东哥特人融为一体。见 Adelung, p. 236, 278。—G
26
↩
The Venedi, the Slavi, and the Antes, were the three great tribes of the same people. Jornandes, 24. * Note Dagger: They formed the great Sclavonian nation.—G.
维内迪人、斯拉维人(Slavi)与安特人(Antes),乃同一民族的三大部族。见 Jornandes, 24。* 编者按:他们构成了那个庞大的斯拉夫民族。—G
27
↩
Tacitus most assuredly deserves that title, and even his cautious suspense is a proof of his diligent inquiries.
塔西佗无疑当得起“最精细的观察者”这一称号;即便是他那审慎的存疑,也正是他勤于考究的明证。
271
↩
Jac. Reineggs supposed that he had found, in the mountains of Caucasus, some descendants of the Alani. The Tartars call them Edeki-Alan: they speak a peculiar dialect of the ancient language of the Tartars of Caucasus. See J. Reineggs’ Descr. of Caucasus, p. 11, 13.—G. According to Klaproth, they are the Ossetes of the present day in Mount Caucasus and were the same with the Albanians of antiquity. Klaproth, Hist. de l’Asie, p. 180.—M.
雅各·赖内格斯(Reineggs)自称在高加索山(Mount Caucasus)中寻得阿兰人的一些后裔。鞑靼人(Tartars)称他们为 Edeki-Alan;他们所操的,是高加索(Caucasus)鞑靼人古语的一种独特方言。参见 J. Reineggs' Descr. of Caucasus, p. 11, 13。—G 据克拉普罗特(Klaproth)之说,他们便是今日高加索山中的奥塞梯人(Ossetes),也就是古代的阿尔巴尼亚人(Albanians)。见克拉普罗特,Hist. de l'Asie, p. 180。—M